Bruce Seligmann

Gene expression predicts overall survival in paraffin-embedded tissues of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma treated with R-CHOP

Gene expression profiling (GEP) on frozen tissues has identified genes predicting outcome in patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL). Confirmation of results in current patients is limited by availability of frozen samples and addition of monoclonal antibodies to treatment regimens. We used a quantitative nuclease protection assay (qNPA) to analyze formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue blocks for 36 previously identified genes (N = 209, 93 chemotherapy; 116 rituximab + chemotherapy). By qNPA, 208 cases were successfully analyzed (99.5%). In addition, 15 of 36 and 11 of 36 genes, representing each functional group previously identified by GEP, were associated with survival (P < .05) in the 2 treatment groups, respectively. In addition, 30 of 36 hazard ratios of death trended in the same direction versus the original studies. Multivariate and variable cut-off point analysis identified low levels of HLA-DRB (< 20%) and high levels of MYC (> 80%) as independent indicators of survival, together distinguishing cases with the worst prognosis. Our results solve a clinical research problem by demonstrating that prognostic genes can be meaningfully quantified using qNPA technology on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues; previous GEP findings in DLBCL are relevant with current treatments; and 2 genes, representing immune escape and proliferation, are the common features of the most aggressive DLBCL.

Quantitative nuclease protection assay in paraffin-embedded tissue replicates prognostic microarray gene expression in diffuse large-B-cell lymphoma

Gene expression profiling (GEP) has identified genes whose expression levels predict patient survival in diffuse large-B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL). Such discovery techniques generally require frozen samples unavailable for most patients. We developed a quantitative nuclease protection assay to measure expression levels of prognostic DLBCL genes using formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue. FFPE tissue was sectioned, permeabilized, denatured in the presence of specific probes, and hybridized to mRNA in situ. Nuclease subsequently destroyed non-hybridized probe. Alkaline hydrolysis freed mRNA-bound probes from tissue, which were transferred to ArrayPlates for probe capture and chemiluminescent quantification. We validated assay performance using frozen, fresh, and FFPE DLBCL samples, then used 39 archived DLBCL, previously microarray analyzed, to correlate GEP and ArrayPlate results. We compared old (>18 years) with new (<2 months) paraffin blocks made from previously frozen tissue from the original biopsy. ArrayPlate gene expression results were confirmed with immunohistochemistry for BCL2, BCL6, and HLA-DR, showing agreement between mRNA species and the proteins they encode. Assay performance was linear to ∼1 mg sample/well. RNase and DNase treatments demonstrated assay specificity for RNA detection, both fixed and soluble RNA detection. Comparisons were excellent for lysate vs snap-frozen vs FFPE (R2>0.98 for all comparisons). Coefficients of variation for quadruplicates on FFPE were generally <20%. Correlation between new and old paraffin blocks from the same biopsy was good (R2=0.71). Comparison of ArrayPlate to Affymetrix and cDNA microarrays showed reasonable correlations. Insufficient power from small sample size prevented successfully correlating results with patient survival, although hazard ratios trended the expected directions. We developed an assay to quantify expression levels of survival prediction genes in DLBCL using FFPE, fresh, or frozen tissue. While this technique cannot replace GEP for discovery, it indicates that expression differences identified by GEP can be replicated on a platform applicable to archived FFPE samples.

Multiplexed Screening Assay for mRNA Combining Nuclease Protection with Luminescent Array Detection

The principles and performance are described for the ArrayPlate mRNA assay, a multiplexed mRNA assay for high-throughput and high-content screening and drug development. THP-1 monocytes grown and subjected to compound treatments in 96-well plates were subjected to a multiplexed nuclease protection assay in situ. The nuclease protection assay destroyed all cell-derived mRNA, but left intact stoichiometric amounts of 16 target-specific oligonucleotide probes. Upon transfer of processed cell lysates to a microplate that contained a 16-element oligonucleotide array at the bottom of each well, the various probe species were separated by immobilization at predefined elements of the array. Quantitative detection of array-bound probes was by enzyme-mediated chemiluminescence. A high-resolution charge-coupled device imager was used for the simultaneous readout of all 1536 array elements in a 96-well plate. For the measurement of 16 genes in samples of 25000 cells, the average standard deviation from well to well within a plate was 8.6% of signal intensity and was 10.8% from plate to plate. Assay response was linear and reproducibility was constant for all detected genes in samples ranging from 1000 to 50000 cells. When THP-1 monocytes were differentiated with phorbol ester and subsequently activated with bacterial lipopolysaccharide that contained different concentrations of dexamethasone, dose-dependent effects of dexamethasone on the mRNA levels of several genes were observed.

Transcriptional analysis of intracytoplasmically stained, FACS-purified cells by high-throughput, quantitative nuclease protection

Exploring the pathophysiology underlying diabetes mellitus requires characterizing the cellular constituents of pancreatic islets, primarily insulin-producing β-cells. Such efforts have been limited by inadequate techniques for purifying islet cellular subsets for further biochemical and gene-expression studies. Using intracytoplasmic staining and fluorescence-activated cell-sorting (FACS) followed by quantitative nuclease protection assay (qNPA™) technology, we examined 30 relevant genes expressed by islet subpopulations. Purified islet cell subsets expressed all four tested “housekeeping” genes with a surprising variability, dependent on both cell lineage and developmental stage, suggesting caution when interpreting housekeeping gene-normalized mRNA quantifications. Our new approach confirmed expected islet cell lineage-specific gene expression patterns at the transcriptional level, but also detected new phenotypes, including mRNA-profiles (supported by immunohistology) demonstrating that during pregnancy, some β-cells express Mafb, previously found only in immature β-cells during embryonic development. Overall, qNPA™ gene expression analysis using intracellular-stained then FACS-sorted cells has broad applications beyond islet cell biology.

A high-density quantitative nuclease protection microarray platform for high throughput analysis of gene expression

The quantitative nuclease protection assay (qNPA) is a very simple and highly sensitive method for measuring mRNA transcripts, can be used on a variety of sample types, and is amenable to high-throughput sample processing. We have combined the power of the qNPA assay with the density of a DNA microarray to create a qNPA Microarray platform. This platform is compatible with common laboratory equipment: it uses fluorescence-based detection, can be analyzed with common microarray scanners, and is in an SBS footprint with 96-well layout for high-throughput applications. Here, we demonstrate the characteristics of a qNPA Microarray slide that contains up to 1700 gene elements per well. We show that the new platform can reliably detect transcripts at levels as low as 10fM with median CVs below 12%. On a standardized set of samples, the qNPA Microarray detected the same trends in gene expression as the original qNPA technology, real time qPCR, and Affymetrix GeneChip DNA Microarrays. Given its ease of use, compatibility with multiple sample types, high-throughput capabilities, and its integration with standard laboratory equipment, the qNPA Microarray is a powerful new platform for gene expression research.

High-Throughput, High-Sensitivity Analysis of Gene Expression in Arabidopsis

High-throughput gene expression analysis of genes expressed during salt stress was performed using a novel multiplexed quantitative nuclease protection assay that involves customized DNA microarrays printed within the individual wells of 96-well plates. The levels of expression of the transcripts from 16 different genes were quantified within crude homogenates prepared from Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) plants also grown in a 96-well plate format. Examples are provided of the high degree of reproducibility of quantitative dose-response data and of the sensitivity of detection of changes in gene expression within limiting amounts of tissue. The lack of requirement for RNA purification renders the assay particularly suited for high-throughput gene expression analysis and for the discovery of novel chemical compounds that specifically modulate the expression of endogenous target genes.

A trichostatin A expression signature identified by TempO-Seq targeted whole transcriptome profiling

The use of gene expression signatures to classify compounds, identify efficacy or toxicity, and differentiate close analogs relies on the sensitivity of the method to identify modulated genes. We used a novel ligation-based targeted whole transcriptome expression profiling assay, TempO-Seq®, to determine whether previously unreported compound-responsive genes could be identified and incorporated into a broad but specific compound signature. TempO-Seq exhibits 99.6% specificity, single cell sensitivity, and excellent correlation with fold differences measured by RNA-Seq (R2 = 0.9) for 20,629 targets. Unlike many expression assays, TempO-Seq does not require RNA purification, cDNA synthesis, or capture of targeted RNA, and lacks a 3′ end bias. To investigate the sensitivity of the TempO-Seq assay to identify significantly modulated compound-responsive genes, we derived whole transcriptome profiles from MCF-7 cells treated with the histone deacetylase inhibitor Trichostatin A (TSA) and identified more than 9,000 differentially expressed genes. The TSA profile for MCF-7 cells overlapped those for HL-60 and PC-3 cells in the Connectivity Map (cMAP) database, suggesting a common TSA-specific expression profile independent of baseline gene expression. A 43-gene cell-independent TSA signature was extracted from cMAP and confirmed in TempO-Seq MCF-7 data. Additional genes that were not previously reported to be TSA responsive in the cMAP database were also identified. TSA treatment of 5 cell types revealed 1,136 differentially expressed genes in common, including 785 genes not previously reported to be TSA responsive. We conclude that TSA induces a specific expression signature that is consistent across widely different cell types, that this signature contains genes not previously associated with TSA responses, and that TempO-Seq provides the sensitive differential expression detection needed to define such compound-specific, cell-independent, changes in expression.

Multiplexed chemiluminescent assays in ArrayPlates for high-throughput measurement of gene expression

Multiplexed Molecular Profiling (MMP) assays for drug discovery are performed in ArrayPlates. ArrayPlates are 96- well microtiter plates that contain a 16-element array at the bottom of each well. Each element within an array measures one analyte in a sample. A CCD imager records the quantitative chemiluminescent readout of all 1,536 elements in a 96-well plate simultaneously. Since array elements are reagent modifiable by the end-user, ArrayPlates can be adapted to a broad range of nucleic acid- and protein-based assays. Such multiplexed assays are rapidly established, flexible, robust, automation-friendly and cost-effective. Nucleic acid assays in ArrayPlates can detect DNA and RNA, including SNPs and ESTs. A multiplexed mRNA assay to measure the expression of 16 genes is described. The assay combines a homogeneous nuclease protection assay with subsequent probe immobilization to the array by means of a sandwich hybridization followed with chemiluminescent detection. This assay was used to examine cells grown and treated in microplates and avoided cloning, transfection, RNA insolation, reverse transcription, amplification and fluorochrome labeling. Standard deviations for the measurement of 16 genes ranged from 3 percent to 13 percent in samples of 30,000 cells. Such ArrayPlates transcription assays are useful in drug discovery and development for target validation, screening, lead optimization, metabolism and toxicity profiling. Chemiluminescent detection provides ArrayPlates assays with high signal-to-noise readout and simplifies imager requirements. Imaging a 2D surface that contains arrays simplifies lens requirements relative to imaging columns of liquid in microtiter plate wells. The Omix imager for ArrayPlates is described.

Abstract 4146: Targeted gene expression sequencing from FFPE: NPSeq™.

A robust targeted sequencing assay with simple, automated set up that provides accurate and sensitive measurement of gene expression from FFPE has been developed, referred to as NPSeq™. This assay is based on HTG9s nuclease protection array-based qNPA™ assay, which has been launched as a diagnostic and translational research platform automated on the HTG EDGE System. Briefly, FFPE is lysed and processed through the standard qNPA protocol on EDGE, then unique barcodes, adaptors and primer seqeuences are added for sequencing. Samples are pooled, concentrated, and run on a gel for QC and clean-up before submitting for colony formation and sequencing. NPSeq retains S1 hydrolysis for specificity, while eliminating the array and hybridization capture/detection specificity steps from the qNPA protocol, replacing them with direct sequencing and counting of each nuclease protection probe. NPSeq measurement from FFPE is accurate, sensitive, and quantitatively reproducible. Performance has been evaluated using a focused assay measuring gene expression. Accuracy, defined as the correlation of measurements from frozen sample to matched FFPE, is R2 > 0.95. Compared to the qNPA ArrayPlate diagnostic assay, measuring clinical FFPE and using in each case 0.25 cm2 area of a 5 micron thick breast cancer section, the correlation of measurements was R2 = 0.93. The NPSeq assay conserves sample, with high sensitivity to routinely use small amounts of FFPE (less than 0.25 cm2 area of a 5 micron section). NPSeq was quantitative and highly reproducibility, with avg CV9s of 3%. NPSeq is a true universal assay because it can measure sets of a few genes to sets of 1,000 or more genes without any change in protocol or platform. Thus, it can be used for biomarker discovery and then those biomarkers can be focused into a drug discovery or diagnostic assay without any change in reagents, protocol or platform, while delivering the same quantitative and ultra-high quality data. Since NPSeq samples can be tagged and pooled before sequencing the sequencing cost/sample can be reduced substantially, making both biomarker discovery and targeted diagnostic sequencing assays cost efficient. NPSeq exploits the qNPA advantage of a lysis only, extraction-free protocol to simultaneously measure mRNA and miRNA dependably from FFPE even where the mRNA is degraded. Additional application results from retrospective studies of clinical FFPE will be presented that validate the performance of the NPSeq assays, including an NPSeq assay containing content of the miRBase version 19 of ∼2000 miRNA and mRNA housekeeper genes that is in development and being used for miRNA biomarker identification from FFPE. Citation Format: Debrah Thompson, Ihab Botros, Bruce Seligmann. Targeted gene expression sequencing from FFPE: NPSeq™. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 104th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2013 Apr 6-10; Washington, DC. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2013;73(8 Suppl):Abstract nr 4146. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2013-4146

Extraction-Free Whole Transcriptome Gene Expression Analysis of FFPE Sections and Histology-Directed Subareas of Tissue

We describe the use of a ligation-based targeted whole transcriptome expression profiling assay, TempO-Seq™, to profile formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue, including H&E stained FFPE tissue, by directly lysing tissue scraped from slides without extracting RNA or converting the RNA to cDNA. The correlation of measured gene expression changes in unfixed and fixed samples using blocks prepared from a pellet of a single cell type was R2 = 0.97, demonstrating that no significant artifacts were introduced by fixation. Fixed and fresh samples prepared in an equivalent manner produced comparable sequencing depth results (+/-20%), with similar %CV (11.5 and 12.7%, respectively), indicating no significant loss of measurable RNA due to fixation. The sensitivity of the TempO-Seq assay was the same whether the tissue section was fixed or not. The assay performance was equivalent for human, mouse, or rat whole transcriptome. The results from 10 mm2 and 2 mm2 areas of tissue obtained from 5 μm thick sections were equivalent, thus demonstrating high sensitivity and ability to profile focal areas of histology within a section. Replicate reproducibility of separate areas of tissue ranged from R2 = 0.83 (lung) to 0.96 (liver) depending on the tissue type, with an average correlation of R2 = 0.90 across nine tissue types. The average %CVs were 16.8% for genes expressed at greater than 200 counts, and 20.3% for genes greater than 50 counts. Tissue specific differences in gene expression were identified and agreed with the literature. There was negligible impact on assay performance using FFPE tissues that had been archived for up to 30 years. Similarly, there was negligible impact of H&E staining, facilitating accurate visualization for scraping and assay of small focal areas of specific histology within a section.