Carolyn A. Keever

Evaluation of HLA‐Haplotype Disparate Parental Marrow Grafts Depleted of T Lymphocytes by Differential Agglutination with a Soybean Lectin and E‐Rosette Depletion for the Treatment of Severe Combined Immunodeficiency

Abstract. The factors that impact upon successful bone marrow transplantation leading to immunologic reconstitution in severe combined immune deficiency (SCID), Wiskott‐Aldrich syndrome, and in other lethal congenital immunodeficiencies are reviewed. Evidence is presented that graft‐versus‐host disease (GVHD) can be abrogated by the depletion of T cells, even from histoincompatible marrow grafts. However, graft resistance or restricted immune reconstitution has been observed with significant frequency. The bases for T cell reconstitution and limitations in B cell humoral immune recovery in the postgrafting period are reviewed, together with emerging evidence that pretransplant cytoreduction might obviate some of these problems.

Characterization of B cells in severe combined immunodeficiency disease

The circulating lymphoid cells of eight consecutive untreated infants with severe combined immunodeficiency disease (SCID) with B cells were analyzed for surface marker expression and function. The B cells of these children expressed sIg, HLA-DR, CD19 (B4), CD20 (B1), CD21 (B2), Leu-8, and lacked expression of CD10 (CALLA), as do normal peripheral blood B lymphocytes. SCID B cells also expressed antigens that are normally absent or present on only a minor subset of circulating adult B lymphocytes, including CD1c (M241), CD38 (OKT10), CD23 (PL13), with or without concomitant CD5 (Leu-1) expression. The B cells of these children were capable of proliferating in vitro when stimulated with Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I. However, in the presence of pokeweed mitogen, S. aureus Cowan I, and normal T cells, the sIg+ cells of these children produced only IgM. Studies performed on normal B cells obtained from cord blood, young children, and adults reveal that whereas cord blood B cells are predominantly CD1c, CD38, and CD23 positive, B-cell expression of these antigens decreases with age. Cord blood B cells, similar to SCID B cells, produce only IgM when stimulated in vitro with pokeweed mitogen and S. aureus Cowan I. Based on these observations, we hypothesize that SCID B cells represent a population of B cells present during normal B-cell ontogeny which becomes a minor subset when an individual develops full immunologic competence.

Tolerance of engrafted donor T cells following bone marrow transplantation for severe combined immunodeficiency

Patients transplanted for the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) frequently develop a unique state of split lymphoid chimerism. Such patients have T cells of donor origin, and non-T cells which are predominantly or exclusively of host origin. We have studied the reactivity of engrafted donor T cells to host and/or donor antigens in 12 patients transplanted for SCID, focusing on the characteristics of the tolerance to host and/or donor MHC antigens observed in nine of these patients who were recipients of T-cell-depleted, haploidentical parental bone marrow. In both proliferative and cytolytic assays, engrafted, donor-derived T cells were shown to be selectively nonreactive to histoincompatible host cells. This tolerance could not be ascribed to cells with suppressive activity in the engrafted T-cell population. T cells from a subset of patients, however, exhibited proliferative but not cytolytic reactivity to donor peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The responding cells were shown to be donor-derived CD3+ cells and were predominantly reactive to B-cell fractions from the donor. Two patients who received transplants from each parent in sequence engrafted T cells from one parent and had non-T cells of host, paternal, and maternal origin. The engrafted T cells proliferated weakly to B cells from the other parent, but were tolerant in cytolytic assays. Donor anti-donor reactivity was seen only in haploidentical split chimeras who had not been treated with cytotoxic drugs prior to T-cell engraftment. This proliferative reactivity toward donor may be due to an absence of donor derived Ia+ antigen presenting cells resident in the thymus of SCID patients at the time when the T-cell repertoire is being shaped.

NK and LAK activities from human marrow progenitors: I. The effects of interleukin-2 and interleukin-1

We have investigated the role of interleukin-2 (IL2) as a differentiation factor for human marrow-derived NK cell progenitors and have assessed the effects of interleukin-1 (IL1) on this activity. The effects of these cytokines on early NK cell precursors was determined by testing marrow which had been depleted of mature cells and of CD2+ cells by treatment with soybean agglutinin and sheep erythrocytes (SBA-E-BM). The cytolytic activities of the SBA-E-BM were tested in 51Cr release assays following 7-8 days of liquid culture. K562 targets were used to assess NK activity and NK-resistant Daudi targets were used to measure lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell activity. Neither NK nor LAK activity were measurable in marrow incubated in medium without cytokines, or in medium containing IL1 alone. In contrast, culture in medium containing IL2 resulted in a dose-dependent development of lytic activity. NK and LAK activities could be differentiated by the percentage of cultures in which the activity developed, the dose of IL2 required, the time kinetics of induction, and the effect of depletion of residual cells with NK phenotype prior to culture. The most lytically active effectors of both activities, however, were CD56+. Immunofluorescence analyses before and after culture with IL2 revealed that Leu19+ (CD56) cells increased from less than 2% to as much as 17% of the total marrow cells and showed the appearance of a population of CD56+CD16- cells. The addition of IL1 to the marrow cultures increased NK activity when suboptimal amounts of IL2 were used (less than or equal to 100 U/ml), but did not increase LAK activity at any concentration of IL2. A higher number of NK cells, as well as MY7+(CD13+) myeloid cells were recovered from cultures containing IL1 plus IL2, indicating that NK cells as well as myeloid cells had a growth advantage in the presence of IL1. IL2 receptor (CD25) expression was low in all cultures but was consistently higher in cultures containing IL1 and IL2, however, CD25 was not coexpressed on NK cells. These studies indicate that early NK cell precursors can grow and differentiate in response to IL2 and that NK and LAK lytic activities may be acquired at different developmental stages. IL1 may serve to promote the responsiveness of NK cell progenitors to low concentration of IL2 by a mechanism which may not require expression of CD25.

Radiosensitivity of NK lytic activities and NK-mediated hematopoietic colony inhibition: effect of activation with IL-2 and blocking of the T-200 molecule.

NK cells are capable of a variety of effector functions including the unprimed lysis of certain tumor cell targets and the nonspecific suppression of hematopoietic colony formation. In this study we have evaluated in parallel the radiosensitivity of lytic and colony inhibitory activity (CIA) by peripheral blood lymphocytes and large granular lymphocytes before and after activation by 72-96 hr of culture in medium containing interleukin 2 (IL-2). Our results show that (1) cells exhibiting CIA and lytic activities have almost identical patterns of radioresistance both before and following activation by IL-2; (2) the amount of preculture irradiation which completely blocks IL-2-stimulated cell proliferation only minimally affects CIA and lytic activities; (3) lysis of K562 and inhibition of CFU-GM are more resistant to preculture irradiation than is the killing of NK insensitive targets; (4) both the CIA and the lytic activities of PBL, but not of LGL, can be increased by 500-1000 rad of gamma-irradiation; and (5) NK lytic activity and CIA both before and following activation by IL-2 are primarily mediated by cells bearing the NKH1A antigen. Evidence that suggests NK cells mediate both the lysis of K562 and the inhibition of myeloid cells by a common mechanism came from experiments which showed that a monoclonal antibody to the T-200 molecule (13.3) could block both activities.

Loss of tolerance associated with disappearance of B cells in a patient sequentially transplanted with paternal and maternal bone marrow for the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency disease

We have studied the tolerance of engrafted T cells from a severe combined immunodeficiency disease patient sequentially transplanted with T-cell-depleted bone marrow from both HLA haploidentical parents. The T cells from this patient were shown by HLA typing and cytogenetic analysis to be of material origin (donor of the second graft) while HLA typing of peripheral E--populations and of an Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B-cell line established 2 1/2 years after transplantation revealed the presence of host, maternal, and paternal (donor of the first graft) HLA antigens. When tested at 30 and 60 months after the last transplant, engrafted T cells from this patient had only weak mixed lymphocyte culture reactivity to paternal cells which could be inhibited by monoclonal antibodies to HLA-DQ and DR but not by anti-DP. T cells obtained 60 months after transplant were stimulated with paternal cells in both bulk and limiting dilution cultures and failed to generate typical allocytotoxic cells to paternal T- or B-cell targets. Mixed lymphocyte cultures performed at 71 months revealed an increased proliferative response by patient cells to paternal antigens; however, the engrafted T cells remained tolerant to maternal and host antigens. Limiting dilution analysis performed at this time revealed the presence of cytolytic cells directed to paternal antigens. There were no detectable B cells (only identified source of paternal antigen) as measured by immunofluorescent analysis of peripheral blood, nor any evidence of B-cell function as assessed by in vitro assays (proliferation to staphylococcus aureus Cowen strain A and mitogen-stimulated immunoglobulin production) or in vivo production of serum immunoglobulin at 60 and 71 months. The appearance of alloreactivity associated with the loss of B cells in this patient further supports the conclusion that the maintenance of tolerance to major histocompatibility complex disparate cells requires the continued in vivo presence of cells bearing the tolerizing antigens.

Cytotoxic and proliferative T-cell clones with antidonor reactivity from a patient transplanted for severe combined immunodeficiency disease.

Patients who have become split lymphoid chimeras (T cells of donor origin, B cells and monocytes of host origin) following transplantation of HLA-haploidentical marrow for the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency disease provide a unique model for the study of tolerance. One such patient, UPN 345, was transplanted with maternal marrow and was found to have antidonor proliferative reactivity without detectable donor-directed cytotoxicity when tested at 18, 23, and 66 mos following bone marrow transplantation. In bulk culture, the proliferation to donor cells could be blocked by monoclonal antibodies to HLA-DR and -DQ. Nine clones with antidonor reactivity were established by limiting dilution techniques from a mixed lymphocyte culture between engrafted T cells and irradiated donor E rosette-negative cells. All of the clones were of maternal donor origin, and all were CD3+CD4+CD8-. The clones were tested for proliferative and cytotoxic activity toward donor, host, and paternal B-lymphoblastoid cell lines (B-LCL). Six clones proliferated strongly to maternal B-LCL but not to host B-LCL. Six clones were found to exclusively lyse maternal B-LCL. Four of the clones had both antidonor cytotoxic and antidonor proliferative reactivity. Monoclonal antibody blocking studies were performed on five of the six clones with cytotoxic activity. The antidonor cytotoxicity was not inhibited by monoclonal antibodies to class I determinants; however, three clones were inhibited in the presence of monoclonal antibody to DR, one clone was inhibited by anti-DQ monoclonal antibody, and one clone was inhibited by anti-DP monoclonal antibody. The cytotoxicity of all five clones was inhibited by monoclonal antibody to CD4. These data indicate that antidonor reactivity may also include a cytotoxic component which is not apparent in bulk cultures and which, based on our limiting dilution studies, is probably controlled by regulatory cells. Both the antidonor cytotoxicity and the antidonor proliferation appear to be directed primarily toward donor HLA class II antigens that are not shared with the patient.