Cécile Braudeau

Development of a cross-platform biomarker signature to detect renal transplant tolerance in humans.

Identifying transplant recipients in whom immunological tolerance is established or is developing would allow an individually tailored approach to their posttransplantation management. In this study, we aimed to develop reliable and reproducible in vitro assays capable of detecting tolerance in renal transplant recipients. Several biomarkers and bioassays were screened on a training set that included 11 operationally tolerant renal transplant recipients, recipient groups following different immunosuppressive regimes, recipients undergoing chronic rejection, and healthy controls. Highly predictive assays were repeated on an independent test set that included 24 tolerant renal transplant recipients. Tolerant patients displayed an expansion of peripheral blood B and NK lymphocytes, fewer activated CD4+ T cells, a lack of donor-specific antibodies, donor-specific hyporesponsiveness of CD4+ T cells, and a high ratio of forkhead box P3 to alpha-1,2-mannosidase gene expression. Microarray analysis further revealed in tolerant recipients a bias toward differential expression of B cell-related genes and their associated molecular pathways. By combining these indices of tolerance as a cross-platform biomarker signature, we were able to identify tolerant recipients in both the training set and the test set. This study provides an immunological profile of the tolerant state that, with further validation, should inform and shape drug-weaning protocols in renal transplant recipients.

Identification of a peripheral blood transcriptional biomarker panel associated with operational renal allograft tolerance

Long-term allograft survival generally requires lifelong immunosuppression (IS). Rarely, recipients display spontaneous “operational tolerance” with stable graft function in the absence of IS. The lack of biological markers of this phenomenon precludes identification of potentially tolerant patients in which IS could be tapered and hinders the development of new tolerance-inducing strategies. The objective of this study was to identify minimally invasive blood biomarkers for operational tolerance and use these biomarkers to determine the frequency of this state in immunosuppressed patients with stable graft function. Blood gene expression profiles from 75 renal-transplant patient cohorts (operational tolerance/acute and chronic rejection/stable graft function on IS) and 16 healthy individuals were analyzed. A subset of samples was used for microarray analysis where three-class comparison of the different groups of patients identified a “tolerant footprint” of 49 genes. These biomarkers were applied for prediction of operational tolerance by microarray and real-time PCR in independent test groups. Thirty-three of 49 genes correctly segregated tolerance and chronic rejection phenotypes with 99% and 86% specificity. The signature is shared with 1 of 12 and 5 of 10 stable patients on triple IS and low-dose steroid monotherapy, respectively. The gene signature suggests a pattern of reduced costimulatory signaling, immune quiescence, apoptosis, and memory T cell responses. This study identifies in the blood of kidney recipients a set of genes associated with operational tolerance that may have utility as a minimally invasive monitoring tool for guiding IS titration. Further validation of this tool for safe IS minimization in prospective clinical trials is warranted.

Patients with drug-free long-term graft function display increased numbers of peripheral B cells with a memory and inhibitory phenotype

Several transplant patients maintain stable kidney graft function in the absence of immunosuppression. Here we compared the characteristics of their peripheral B cells to that of others who had stable graft function but were under pharmacologic immunosuppression, to patients with chronic rejection and to healthy volunteers. In drug-free long-term graft function (DF) there was a significant increase in both absolute cell number and frequency of total B cells; particularly activated, memory and early memory B cells. These increased B-cell numbers were associated with a significantly enriched transcriptional B-cell profile. Costimulatory/migratory molecules (B7-2/CD80, CD40, and CD62L) were upregulated in B cells; particularly in memory CD19(+)IgD(-)CD38(+/-)CD27(+) B cells in these patients. Their purified B cells, however, responded normally to a polyclonal stimulation and did not have cytokine polarization. This phenotype was associated with the following specific characteristics which include an inhibitory signal (decreased FcgammaRIIA/FcgammaRIIB ratio); a preventive signal of hyperactive B-cell response (an increase in BANK1, which negatively modulates CD40-mediated AKT activation); an increased number of B cells expressing CD1d and CD5; an increased BAFF-R/BAFF ratio that could explain why these patients have more peripheral B cells; and a specific autoantibody profile. Thus, our findings show that patients with DF have a particular blood B-cell phenotype that may contribute to the maintenance of long-term graft function.

Gene Transfer of Heme Oxygenase‐1 and Carbon Monoxide Delivery Inhibit Chronic Rejection

The hallmark of chronic rejection is the occlusion of the artery lumen by intima hyperplasia as a consequence of leukocyte infiltration and vascular smooth muscle cell (VSMC) migration and proliferation. Heme oxygenase‐1 (HO‐1) is a tissue protective molecule which degrades heme into carbon monoxide (CO), free iron and biliverdin. We analyzed the effects of HO‐1 gene transfer into the vessel wall using an adenoviral vector (AdHO‐1) and of CO delivery in a model of chronic allogeneic aorta rejection in rats. Carbon monoxide treatment was achieved by a new pharmacological approach in transplantation using methylene chloride (MC), which releases CO after degradation. AdHO‐1‐mediated gene transfer into aorta endothelial cells (ECs) or CO delivery resulted in a significant reduction in intimal thickness compared to untreated or noncoding adenovirus‐treated controls. Aortas transduced with AdHO‐1 or treated with CO showed a reduction in the number of leukocytes as well as in the expression of adhesion molecules, costimulatory molecules and cytokines, with the gene transfer treatment displaying a more pronounced effect than the CO treatment. Conversely, CO inhibited VSMC accumulation in the intima more efficiently than AdHO‐1 treatment. Gene transfer of HO‐1 and pharmacological manipulation of CO are novel approaches to the analysis and treatment of chronic rejection.

Patients with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis have normal Treg function when cells expressing IL-7 receptor α-chain are excluded from the analysis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory disease that results in demyelination in the central nervous system, and a defect in the regulatory function of CD4+CD25high T cells has been implicated in the pathogenesis of the disease. Here, we reanalyzed the function of this T cell subset in patients with MS, but we depleted cells expressing IL-7 receptor alpha-chain (CD127), a marker recently described as present on activated T cells but not Tregs. Similar to other studies, we observed a marked defect in the suppressive function of unseparated CD4+CD25high T cells isolated from MS patients. However, when CD127(high) cells were removed from the CD4+CD25high population, patient and control cells inhibited T cell proliferation and cytokine production equally. Likewise, when the CD25 gate used to sort the cells was stringent enough to eliminate CD127high cells, CD4+CD25high T cells from patients with MS and healthy individuals had similar regulatory function. Additional analysis indicated that the CD127high cells within the CD4+CD25high T cell population from patients with MS appeared more proliferative and secreted more IFN-gamma and IL-2 than the same cells from healthy individuals. Taken together, we conclude that CD4+CD25highCD127low Tregs from MS patients and healthy individuals exhibit similar suppressive functions. The decreased inhibitory function of unfractioned CD4+CD25high cells previously observed might be due to abnormal activation of CD127high T cells in patients with MS.

Variation in numbers of CD4+CD25highFOXP3+ T cells with normal immuno-regulatory properties in long-term graft outcome

Chronic rejection (CR) is a major cause of long‐term graft loss that would be avoided by the induction of tolerance. We previously showed that renal transplant patients with CR have lower numbers of peripheral CD4+CD25high T cells than operationally tolerant patients, patients with stable graft function and healthy volunteers (HV). We explored here the profile of CD4+CD25high blood T cells in these patients focusing on their expression of the regulatory T cells (Treg) gene Forkhead Box P3 (FOXP3) and their suppressive function. We show that CR is associated with a decreased number of CD4+CD25highFOXP3+T cells with normal regulatory profile, whereas graft acceptance is associated with CD4+CD25highFOXP3+T cell numbers similar to HVs. These data suggest that Treg numbers, rather than their intrinsic suppressive capacity, may contribute to determining the long‐term fate of renal transplants.

Prolonged Blockade of CD40-CD40 Ligand Interactions by Gene Transfer of CD40Ig Results in Long-Term Heart Allograft Survival and Donor-Specific Hyporesponsiveness, But Does Not Prevent Chronic Rejection

Previous work on blockade of CD40-CD40 ligand interaction in mice and primates with anti-CD40 ligand mAbs has resulted in a moderate prolongation of allograft survival without the development of true allograft tolerance. In this study, we show in rats that adenovirus-mediated gene transfer of CD40Ig sequences into the graft resulted in prolonged (>200 days) expression of CD40Ig and in long-term (>300 days) survival. Recipients expressing CD40Ig displayed strongly (>90%) inhibited mixed leukocyte reactions and alloantibody production at early (days 5 and 17) and late time points (>100 day) after transplantation, but showed limited inhibition of leukocyte infiltration and cytokine production as evaluated by immunohistology at early time points (day 5). Recipients of long-surviving hearts showed donor-specific hyporesponsiveness since acceptance of second cardiac allografts was donor specific. Nevertheless, long-term allografts (>100 days) displayed signs of chronic rejection vasculopathy. Occluded vessels showed leukocyte infiltration, mainly composed of CD4+ and CD8+ cells, macrophages, and mast cells. These recipients also showed antidonor CTL activity. Recipients expressing CD40Ig did not show nonspecific immunosuppression, as they were able to mount anticognate immune responses that were partially inhibited at early time points and were normal thereafter. We conclude that gene transfer-mediated expression of CD40Ig resulted in a highly efficient inhibition of acute heart allograft rejection in rats. This treatment induced donor-specific inhibition of certain alloreactive mechanisms in the short-, but not the long-term, which resulted in long-term survival of allografts concomitant with the development of chronic rejection.

Operationally tolerant and minimally immunosuppressed kidney recipients display strongly altered blood T-cell clonal regulation.

Most kidney transplant recipients who discontinue immunosuppression reject their graft. Nevertheless, a small number do not, suggesting that allogeneic tolerance state (referred to operational tolerance) is achievable in humans. So far, however, the rarity of such patients has limited their study. Because operational tolerance could be linked to anergy, ignorance or to an active regulatory mechanism, we analyzed the blood T‐cell repertoire usage of these patients. We report on comparison of T‐cell selection in drug‐free operationally tolerant kidney recipients (or with minimal immunosuppression), recipients with stable graft function, chronic rejection and healthy individuals. The blood T cells of operationally tolerant patients display two major characteristics: an unexpected strongly altered T‐cell receptor (TCR) Vβ usage and high TCR transcript accumulation in selected T cells. The cytokine transcriptional patterns of sorted T cells with altered TCR usage show no accumulation of cytokine transcripts (IL10, IL2, IL13, IFN‐γ), suggesting a state of hyporesponsiveness in these patients. Identification of such a potential surrogate pattern of operational tolerance in transplant recipients under life‐long immunosuppression may provide a new basis and rationale for exploration of tolerance state. However, these data obtained in a limited number of patients require further confirmation on larger series.

Human blood mDC subsets exhibit distinct TLR repertoire and responsiveness

Human blood DCs encompass pDCs and two subsets of mDCs: CD1c+ mDCs and CD141+ mDCs. The rare CD141+ DC population is thought to be the equivalent of mouse CD8α+ cDCs that play a significant role in antigen cross‐presentation. Here, we analyzed by Q‐PCR TLR1–10 expression in blood DC subsets. Whereas CD1c+ DCs express all TLR except TLR9, CD141+ DCs present a more restricted pattern with high expression of TLR3 and ‐10, expression of TLR1,‐2, ‐6, and ‐8, and lack of TLR4, ‐5, ‐7, and ‐9. The in vitro analysis of isolated mDC subset reponsiveness to an extensive panel of TLR ligands confirmed these results, with CD141+ DCs responding only to TLR1/2, ‐3, and ‐7/8. The cytokine/chemokine production profile of isolated CD141+ DCs was also more restricted, as they produced mainly proinflammatory cytokines but no IL‐12 and to a lower level, in comparison with CD1c+ DCs, except for CXCL10, CCL5, and IFN‐β. In contrast, with the use of a whole blood assay, we found that CD141+ DCs produce IL‐12 in response to TLR1/2, ‐3, and more surprisingly, ‐9. Finally, both mDC subsets are potent inducers of Th1 response, particularly after TLR3 triggering. Taken together, these data confirmed functional differences between blood mDC subsets. The major response of CD141+ mDCs to TLR3 ligand and their cytokine production pattern suggest a role for these cells in antiviral immunity.

Phenotypically and Functionally Distinct CD8+ Lymphocyte Populations in Long-Term Drug-Free Tolerance and Chronic Rejection in Human Kidney Graft Recipients

A substantial proportion of long-term kidney graft recipients, including those with a stable renal function in the absence of immunosuppressive therapy, present a skewed T cell receptor (TCR) Vbeta chain usage, essentially in the CD8+ subset. This study analyzed in more detail phenotypical and functional alterations of CD8+ lymphocytes in drug-free tolerant patients (DF-Tol) compared with recipients with chronic rejection (CR). Phenotyping revealed a significant increase in central memory and a decrease in effector CD8+ lymphocytes in DF-Tol versus CR. The expression of CD28+ and CD27+ on these effector cells was significantly decreased in CR. These profiles were stable over time and independent of treatment. Functionally, the CD8+CD28- lymphocytes were less sensitive to apoptosis than their CD8+CD28+ counterparts, without differences in polyclonal proliferation. The CD8+CD28- cells did not express GITR and FoxP3 but were characterized by high levels of preformed perforin and granzyme A, pointing toward a cytotoxic rather than a suppressor function. CD8+CD28- lymphocytes did not show antigen-specific degranulation when co-cultured with targets that bear donor HLA class I antigens, suggesting that the cytotoxicity is directed either to other determinants of the graft or to nongraft epitopes. Of interest, CD8+ cells from DF-Tol displayed the same profile as healthy individuals, indicating an increase in CD8+CD28- effector lymphocytes in CR rather than a decrease in DF-Tol. CD8+ lymphocytes from stable kidney recipients under conventional maintenance immunosuppression displayed a mixed profile, independent of treatment and time of sampling. Taken collectively, these data show a strong cytotoxicity-associated CD8+CD28- signature in CR and suggest a suppression of pathologic cytotoxicity in DF-Tol. Further prospective studies should assess whether serial CD8+ phenotyping may help to identify patients who are at risk for CR when immunosuppression is tapered.