Chantale Roy

Resources and Costs Associated with Disabilities of Elderly People Living at Home and in Institutions

This study was carried out on a representative sample of elderly people living at home ( n = 300), in intermediate faculties ( n = 271) and nursing homes ( n = 774) from metropolitan, urban and rural areas in the Province of Quebec (Canada) in order to: 1) determine the level of disabilities and resources involved in the care of elderly people living at home or in institutional settings; 2) estimate the costs (public, private, voluntary) of these resources; 3) compare the costs according to the level of disability; and 4) predict the costs associated with disabilities. Results show that there were significant differences but large overlap in the disability level, cognitive status and nursing care needed and received between participants from the three settings. The disability score explained 85 per cent of the variance in nursing care time and 55 per cent (home), 15 per cent (intermediate facilities) and 68 per cent (nursing homes) of the variance in the cost. Nursing care was responsible for most of the cost in all settings. The total societal cost of home care was greater than the cost of intermediate facilities for elderly participants with a disability score over 7.4 and greater even than the cost of nursing homes for a score over 38.7.

A preventive program for community-dwelling elderly at risk of functional decline: a pilot study

A program has been designed to assess and survey community-dwelling elderly over 75, identified at risk of functional decline by a postal questionnaire. The objectives were to verify the acceptability and the feasability of the program and to explore its impact, mainly on the functional status. A randomized controlled study took place in an urban community where 99 participants were drawn from those having responded positively to two or more of the six questions asked in the postal questionnaire, previously studied in Sherbrooke, in 1992. The program consisted in a home visit by a nurse who administered a standardized assessment battery on risk factors identified specifically for functional decline. When problems were identified, experimental subjects were referred to their general practitioner or to other health professionals for diagnosis and interventions. The control subjects received the usual health services. Both process and outcome measures were utilized in the study. The process measures allowed to know whether the program was acceptable or not to subjects and if it was feasible when using the existing health care services. The outcome measures included the number of eliminated risk factors, the functional autonomy level, the general well-being, the perceived state of health and the social support. The results showed that the program was feasible to implement and acceptable by the subjects and by health professionals. After 6 months, study subjects did not loose autonomy whereas the control ones significantly declined (P<0.001). If preventive programs could be effective in reducing the loss of autonomy, the use and cost of health care services could also be reduced and the other health and wellfare problems could be also prevented.

Does the Planetree patient-centered approach to care pay off?: a cost-benefit analysis.

Although the Planetree patient-centered approach to care is being implemented in many institutions around the world, its impact is still the subject of some debate. On the one hand, it is viewed as the most cost-effective way to provide care and create a positive work environment that reduces staff burnout. On the other hand, it is argued that it requires higher staffing ratios and a substantial infusion of financial resources and is time consuming, which in turn results in more work. The present study addresses the economic agenda of the Planetree patient-centered approach to care and has been designed to answer the following question: do the advantages of the Planetree patient-centered approach outweigh its costs? This question is of considerable interest for health care administrators and managers because the relevant authorities the world over have limited resources to allocate to health care organizations. Using a trend analysis approach to cost-benefit in a rehabilitation center, this study shows that the revenues the model generates are greater than the costs of implementing it. Fewer grievances and vacant positions, an improved employee retention rate, a better working atmosphere, and a high level of employee satisfaction (higher than in similar establishments) were also noted.

Can we associate the hours of clinical services at the rehabilitation outcomes? The case of the visual impairment rehabilitation program.

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects on the elderly of clinical interventions by professionals from a visual impairment rehabilitation program, more specifically, the effects on their daily life and the extent to which such interventions encourage social participation. In accordance with the conceptual framework of the Disability Creation Process, the clinical results of a population study group of 100 persons with various types of visual impairment enrolled in a rehabilitation program were analyzed as per the intensity of the clinical interventions (eg, hours of clinical services provided and dispensed by professionals). The results of the study tend to show that the hours of services accorded to a patient positively contribute to the progression of his or her Functional Global Profile as per the rehabilitation outcomes progression measures. In contrast, age and the spreading of services negatively contribute. The contributions of the study are innovative for assessing clinical effectiveness. For instance, the understanding of the relationship between the measurement of a patient’s clinical results and the services that he or she has received should help us improve the practices and methods used in visual impairment rehabilitation.