Charles R. Mace

Paper-Based ELISA†

This paper describes enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) performed in a 96-microzone plate fabricated in paper (paper-based ELISA, or P-ELISA). ELISA is widely used in biochemical analyses; these assays are typically carried out in microtiter plates or small vials. 2] ELISA combines the specificity of antibodies with high-turnover catalysis by enzymes to provide specificity and sensitivity. We have recently described a 96-microzone paper plate— fabricated by patterning hydrophobic polymer in hydrophilic paper—as a platform for biochemical analysis. Although microfluidic paper-based analytical devices (mPADs) were designed primarily to provide analytical capability at low cost in developing countries, we expect that they will also be useful in applications such as point-of-care clinical analysis, military and humanitarian aid field operations, and others where high throughput, low volumes of sample, low cost, and robustness are important. These devices have so far been prototyped using analyses of simple analytes: glucose, total protein, and certain enzymes. P-ELISA combines the sensitivity and specificity of ELISA with the convenience, low cost and ease-of-use of paper-based platforms; P-ELISA (at it current state of development) is faster and less expensive than conventional ELISA, but somewhat less sensitive. Porous membranes, including nitrocellulose and filter paper, have been used for decades in dot-immunobinding assays (DIA). Though DIAs are the simplest form of immunoassays on paper, they typically require one piece of nitrocellulose for each assay; the pieces of nitrocellulose have to be processed individually in Petri dishes, and the assays take several hours to complete. Quantitative DIAs have been reported, but DIAs are typically qualitative, and provide only “yes/no” results. Conventional ELISA, usually performed in 96-well plates (fabricated by injection molding in plastic), is quantitative and well-suited for highthroughput assays, but each assay requires large volumes (ca. 20–200 mL) of analyte and reagents, the time required for incubation and blocking steps are long ( 1 h per step, because the reagents must diffuse to the surface of the wells), and the results are usually quantified using a plate reader, typically a

Separation of Nanoparticles in Aqueous Multiphase Systems through Centrifugation

20 000 instrument. Paper microzone plates for ELISA can have the same layout as plastic 96-well plates, but each test zone requires only about 3 mL of sample, and the results can be measured using a desktop scanner, typically a

Magnetic Levitation in the Analysis of Foods and Water

100 instrument. In addition, an entire P-ELISA can be completed in less than one hour. The ease of fabrication of paper microzone plates also opens opportunities for a wide range of non-standard formats, and customized connections to carry reagents between zones. To evaluate the feasibility of P-ELISA, and the potential advantages and disadvantages of P-ELISA and 96-well-plate-based ELISA, we adapted a standard procedure to our format and then demonstrated an indirect P-ELISA using rabbit IgG as a model analyte. We also established that P-ELISA can be used to detect and quantify antibodies to the HIV-1 envelope antigen gp41 in human serum using an anti-human IgG antibody conjugated to alkaline phosphatase (ALP) to produce a colorimetric readout. We used a 96-microzone paper plate with an array (12 8) of circular test zones for running multiple P-ELISAs in parallel (Figure 1A); the Supporting Information describes the details. The array was designed to have the same layout and dimensions as a standard plastic 96-well plate, so that it would be compatible with existing microanalytical infrastructure (eightor twelve-channel pipettes and plate readers). Each test zone was 5 mm in diameter and required 3 mL of solution to fill (e.g., to wet completely with fluid); this design was a good compromise between convenience and conservation of reagents, as it reduced the amount of reagents and sample required for the assay but ensured accurate distribution of fluids when using a manual pipette. We also examined smaller test zones, with the smallest test zone requiring 0.5 mL of solution to fill (e.g., to wet completely). This size is similar to that required in a 384-well plate format. The top and bottom faces of the test zones in papermicrozone plates are open to atmosphere. The advantage of this configuration is that the zones can be washed by adding a washing buffer to the top of the zone while pressing the bottom of the zone against a piece of blotting paper. The washing buffer goes through the test zone vertically and into [*] Dr. C.-M. Cheng, Dr. A. W. Martinez, Dr. J. Gong, Dr. C. R. Mace, Prof. S. T. Phillips, Prof. E. Carrilho, K. A. Mirica, Prof. G. M. Whitesides Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology Harvard University Cambridge, MA 02138 (USA) E-mail: gwhitesides@gmwgroup.harvard.edu Homepage: http://gmwgroup.harvard.edu

Aqueous Multiphase Systems of Polymers and Surfactants Provide Self-Assembling Step-Gradients in Density

This paper demonstrates the use of aqueous multiphase systems (MuPSs) as media for rate-zonal centrifugation to separate nanoparticles of different shapes and sizes. The properties of MuPSs do not change with time or during centrifugation; this stability facilitates sample collection after separation. A three-phase system demonstrates the separation of the reaction products (nanorods, nanospheres, and large particles) of a synthesis of gold nanorods, and enriches the nanorods from 48 to 99% in less than ten minutes using a benchtop centrifuge.

Measuring Binding of Protein to Gel-Bound Ligands Using Magnetic Levitation

This paper describes a method and a sensor that use magnetic levitation (MagLev) to characterize samples of food and water on the basis of measurements of density. The sensor comprises two permanent NdFeB magnets positioned on top of each other in a configuration with like poles facing and a container filled with a solution of paramagnetic ions. Measurements of density are obtained by suspending a diamagnetic object in the container filled with the paramagnetic fluid, placing the container between the magnets, and measuring the vertical position of the suspended object. MagLev was used to estimate the salinity of water, to compare a variety of vegetable oils on the basis of the ratio of polyunsaturated fat to monounsaturated fat, to compare the contents of fat in milk, cheese, and peanut butter, and to determine the density of grains.

Denaturation of Proteins by SDS and Tetraalkylammonium Dodecyl Sulfates

This Communication demonstrates the generation of over 300 phase-separated systems-ranging from two to six phases-from mixtures of aqueous solutions of polymers and surfactants. These aqueous multiphase systems (MuPSs) form self-assembling, thermodynamically stable step-gradients in density using a common solvent, water. The steps in density between phases of a MuPS can be very small (Δρ ≈ 0.001 g/cm(3)), do not change over time, and can be tuned by the addition of co-solutes. We use two sets of similar objects, glass beads and pellets of different formulations of Nylon, to demonstrate the ability of MuPSs to separate mixtures of objects by differences in density. The stable interfaces between phases facilitate the convenient collection of species after separation. These results suggest that the stable, sharp step-gradients in density provided by MuPSs can enable new classes of fractionations and separations based on density.

Detection of human proteins using arrayed imaging reflectometry

This paper describes the use of magnetic levitation (MagLev) to measure the association of proteins and ligands. The method starts with diamagnetic gel beads that are functionalized covalently with small molecules (putative ligands). Binding of protein to the ligands within the bead causes a change in the density of the bead. When these beads are suspended in a paramagnetic aqueous buffer and placed between the poles of two NbFeB magnets with like poles facing, the changes in the density of the bead on binding of protein result in changes in the levitation height of the bead that can be used to quantify the amount of protein bound. This paper uses a reaction-diffusion model to examine the physical principles that determine the values of rate and equilibrium constants measured by this system, using the well-defined model system of carbonic anhydrase and aryl sulfonamides. By tuning the experimental protocol, the method is capable of quantifying either the concentration of protein in a solution, or the binding affinities of a protein to several resin-bound small molecules simultaneously. Since this method requires no electricity and only a single piece of inexpensive equipment, it may find use in situations where portability and low cost are important, such as in bioanalysis in resource-limited settings, point-of-care diagnosis, veterinary medicine, and plant pathology. It still has several practical disadvantages. Most notably, the method requires relatively long assay times and cannot be applied to large proteins (>70 kDa), including antibodies. The design and synthesis of beads with improved characteristics (e.g., larger pore size) has the potential to resolve these problems.

Multiplexed, Patterned-Paper Immunoassay for Detection of Malaria and Dengue Fever

This article describes the use of capillary electrophoresis (CE) to examine the influence of different cations (C(+); C(+) = Na(+) and tetra-n-alkylammonium, NR(4)(+), where R = Me, Et, Pr, and Bu) on the rates of denaturation of bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCA) in the presence of anionic surfactant dodecylsulfate (DS(-)). An analysis of the denaturation of BCA in solutions of Na(+)DS(-) and NR(4)(+)DS(-) (in Tris-Gly buffer) indicated that the rates of formation of complexes of denatured BCA with DS(-) (BCA(D)-DS(-)(n,sat)) are indistinguishable and independent of the cation below the critical micellar concentration (cmc) and independent of the total concentration of DS(-) above the cmc. At concentrations of C(+)DS(-) above the cmc, BCA denatured at rates that depended on the cation; the rates decreased by a factor >10(4) in the order of Na(+) ≈ NMe(4)(+) > NEt(4)(+) > NPr(4)(+) > NBu(4)(+), which is the same order as the values of the cmc (which decrease from 4.0 mM for Na(+)DS(-) to 0.9 mM for NBu(4)(+)DS(-) in Tris-Gly buffer). The relationship between the cmc values and the rates of formation of BCA(D)-DS(-)(n,sat()) suggested that the kinetics of denaturation of BCA involve the association of this protein with monomeric DS(-) rather than with micelles of (C(+)DS(-))(n). A less-detailed survey of seven other proteins (α-lactalbumin, β-lactoglobulin A, β-lactoglobulin B, carboxypeptidase B, creatine phosphokinase, myoglobin, and ubiquitin) showed that the difference between Na(+)DS(-) and NR(4)(+)DS(-) observed with BCA was not general. Instead, the influence of NR(4)(+) on the association of DS(-) with these proteins depended on the protein. The selection of the cation contributed to the properties (including the composition, electrophoretic mobility, and partitioning behavior in aqueous two-phase systems) of aggregates of denatured protein and DS(-). These results suggest that the variation in the behavior of NR(4)(+)DS(-) with changes in R may be exploited in methods used to analyze and separate mixtures of proteins.

Enabling the Development and Deployment of Next Generation Point-of-Care Diagnostics

Assays built upon protein arrays are critical tools in determining the basic nature of biology, and have considerable promise in diagnosing human disease. These protein arrays aid in the elucidation of mapping pathway interactions, disease biomarker discovery, and regulatory processes. The solutions used in these experiments, including cellular lysate and serum, are inherently complex mixtures and are high in total protein content. Therefore, array-based assays must be robust and maintain a high level of selectivity and sensitivity. We report herein that arrayed imaging reflectometry (AIR), a label-free biosensing platform we have previously disclosed, is highly suitable for the detection of human proteins in complex solutions. In particular, we demonstrate array-based detection of cytokines in buffered solutions, and in undiluted human serum.

Enrichment of reticulocytes from whole blood using aqueous multiphase systems of polymers

Multiplex assays detect the presence of more than one analyte in a sample. For diagnostic applications, multiplexed tests save healthcare providers time and resources by performing many assays in parallel, minimizing the amount of sample needed and improving the quality of information acquired regarding the health status of a patient. These advantages are of particular importance for those diseases that present with general, overlapping symptoms, which makes presumptive treatments inaccurate and may put the patient at risk. For example, malaria and dengue fever are febrile illnesses transmitted through mosquito bites, and these common features make it difficult to obtain an accurate diagnosis by symptoms alone. In this manuscript, we describe the development of a multiplexed, patterned paper immunoassay for the detection of biomarkers of malaria and dengue fever: malaria HRP2, malaria pLDH, and dengue NS1 type 2. In areas coendemic for malaria and dengue fever, this assay could be used as a rapid, point-of-care diagnostic to determine the cause of a fever of unknown origin. The reagents required for each paper-based immunoassay are separated spatially within a three-dimensional device architecture, which allows the experimental conditions to be adjusted independently for each assay. We demonstrate the analytical performances of paper-based assays for each biomarker and we show that there is no significant difference in performance between the multiplexed immunoassay and those immunoassays performed in singleplex. Additionally, we spiked individual analytes into lysed human blood to demonstrate specificity in a clinically relevant sample matrix. Our results suggest multiplex paper-based devices can be an essential component of diagnostic assays used at the point-of-care.