Chirag K Patel

Review of Estrone Sulfatase and its Inhibitors - An Important New Target Against Hormone Dependent Breast Cancer

A high proportion (approximately 40%) of breast cancers are hormone dependent. The female hormones estradiol and androstenediol are believed to play a key role in the initiation and promotion of this disease. In the fight against hormone dependent breast cancers, extensive research has been undertaken to produce compounds which are potent inhibitors against the cytochrome P-450 enzyme aromatase (AR), which converts the C19 androgens to the C18 estrogens. However, the administration of AR inhibitors alone has failed to produce the expected decrease in plasma levels of estrone. The major impetus to the development of steroid sulfatase inhibitors has therefore been the realisation that in order to improve therapeutic response for women with hormone-dependent breast cancer, not only must the AR enzyme be inhibited, but also the synthesis of estrogens via alternative routes. The steroid sulfatase enzyme regulates the formation of estrone (which can subsequently be converted to the potent estrogen estradiol) from estrone sulfate, a steroid conjugate present in high concentrations in tissue and blood in women with breast cancer. The sulfatase enzyme system also controls the formation of dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) from the DHEA-sulfate. This is important since DHEA can be converted to 5-androstene-3 beta,17 beta-diol, which possesses estrogenic properties capable of stimulating the growth of breast cancer cells in vitro and in vivo. Considerable progress has been made in recent years in the development of a number of potent steroid/estrone sulfatase inhibitors, as such both steroidal and non-steroidal compounds have been considered and a number of highly potent inhibitors have been produced and evaluated against what is now considered a crucial enzyme in the fight against hormone dependent breast cancer. The review therefore considers the work that has been undertaken to date, as well as possible future development with respect to dual inhibitors of both estrone sulfatase and AR.

Novel inhibitors of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES)

We report the initial results of our study into a series of simple 4-sulfamated phenyl alkyl ketones as potential inhibitors of the enzyme estrone sulfatase. The results of the study show that these compounds are potent inhibitors, possessing greater inhibitory activity than COUMATE, but weaker activity than EMATE. Furthermore, the compounds are observed to be irreversible inhibitors.

Hydrophobicity, a physicochemical factor in the inhibition of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES)

We report the initial structure-activity relationship study (SAR) (in particular logP) of a series of compounds based upon 4-sulfamated phenyl ketones as potent inhibitors of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES). The results of the study show that these compounds are irreversible inhibitors of ES and that they are more potent than COUMATE, but weaker than EMATE. Analysis of the SAR data shows a strong correlation between IC(50) and logP but also supports our previous study, which suggests a very strong relationship between pK(a) and IC(50).

Acid dissociation constant, a potential physicochemical factor in the inhibition of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES)

We report the initial results of the synthesis and biochemical evaluation of a series of aminosulfonate based compounds of phenol and the determination of the pKa of the parent phenol in an attempt to investigate the role of this physicochemical factor in the irreversible inhibition of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES). The results of the study show that there is a strong correlation between the observed pKa and inhibitory activity. We postulate that the stability of the phenoxide ion, as indicated by the acid dissociation constant, is an important factor in the irreversible inhibition of this enzyme.

Evidence for the mechanism of the irreversible inhibition of oestrone sulphatase (ES) by aminosulphonate based compounds.

In our search for the mechanism of the enzyme oestrone sulphatase (ES) we have synthesised and evaluated a number of compounds that were predicted to possess some inhibitory activity. Some of these compounds were indeed found to be inhibitors of ES, whilst other compounds were not. From a consideration of the structure-activity relationship (SAR) of the inhibitors and non-inhibitors of this enzyme, we discovered a factor which we now believe is the main inhibitory moiety within the aminosulphonated inhibitors. We therefore report the results of our study into a series of phenyl and alkyl sulphamated compounds as inhibitors of ES. The results of the study show that the substituted phenyl sulphamates are potent inhibitors, whereas the alkyl compounds are, in general, non-inhibitors. Using the results of our SAR study, we postulate the probable mechanism for the irreversible and reversible inhibition of ES, and rationalise the role of the different physicochemical factors in the inhibition of this crucial enzyme.

The mechanism of the irreversible inhibition of estrone sulfatase (ES) through the consideration of a range of methane- and amino-sulfonate-based compounds

We report the results of our study into a series of simple phenyl and alkyl sulfamates and alkyl methanesulfonates as potential inhibitors of the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES). The results of the study show that the substituted phenyl sulfamates are good irreversible inhibitors; the alkyl sulfamate compounds were found to lack inhibitory activity; whilst the large alkyl chain containing methanesulfonate-based compounds were found to possess weak reversible inhibitory activity. Using the results of the inhibition study, we postulate the probable mechanism for ES and suggest that an attack by the gem-diol is a major requirement prior to the hydrolysis of the sulfamate group, following which, attack on the active site C=O occurs and which therefore leads to the production of an imine type functionality, resulting in irreversible inhibition.

The design, synthesis, and in vitro biochemical evaluation of a series of esters of 4-[(aminosulfonyl)oxy]benzoate as novel and highly potent inhibitors of estrone sulfatase

We report the initial results of our study into the use of a potential transition-state (TS) of the reaction catalysed by the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES) in the design of a series of cyclic esters of 4-[(aminosulfonyl)oxy]benzoate as novel inhibitors of ES. The results of the study show that these compounds are some of the most potent inhibitors known todate, possessing greater inhibitory activity than the three standard compounds: 4-methylcoumarin-7-O-sulfamate (COUMATE); the tricyclic derivative of COUMATE, namely 667-COUMATE (which is in Phase I of clinical trials) and; the steroidal inhibitor estrone-3-O-sulfamate (EMATE).

Synthesis and biochemical evaluation of novel and potent inhibitors of the enzyme oestrone sulphatase (ES)

In an effort to investigate the structural requirements for the inhibition of the enzyme oestrone sulphatase (ES), we have previously undertaken extensive structure-activity relationship studies. Using the data from molecular modelling and structure-activity relationship determination studies, we have designed a number of compounds based upon 4-sulphamated phenyl ketones. Here, we report the results of our study into a series of these compounds as potential inhibitors of ES. The results of the study show that these compounds are potent inhibitors the possessing greater inhibitory activity than 4-methylcoumarin-7-O-sulphamate derivative (COUMATE) (a potent non-steroidal inhibitor), but are weaker than oestrone-3-sulphamate (EMATE) and the recently reported 667- and 669-COUMATE, however, they provide good lead compounds in the search for potent inhibitors of ES. Furthermore, the compounds are observed to be irreversible inhibitors. From the consideration of the structure-activity relationship of these novel compounds, we have attempted to rationalise the significance of the log P factor in the inhibition of ES and suggest that a log P requirement of approximately 3.5 aids the inhibition through the rapid expulsion of the carbon backbone from the active site. We also propose that the same factor is responsible for the hydrolysis of oestrone sulphate reaction, appearing to be an irreversible process.

Determination and use of a transition state for the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES) from a proposed reaction mechanism

Using the postulated mechanism for the enzyme estrone sulfatase (ES), we have determined a possible transition state for the reaction catalysed by ES as a representation of the active site. Using the derived structure, we have undertaken the molecular modelling of several steroidal and non-steroidal inhibitors in an attempt to rationalise the inhibitory activity of a number of potent inhibitors.

Structure-activity relationship determination within a group of substituted phenyl sulfamate based compounds against the enzyme oestrone sulfatase

The enzyme oestrone sulfatase (ES) is responsible for the conversion of the stored (sulfated) form of oestrogens to the active form, namely oestrone. In our continuing quest to synthesize potent inhibitors of oestrone sulfatase and to determine the structural requirements for such inhibition, we have synthesized and evaluated several derivatives of phenyl sulfamate. We report the results of the synthesis and biochemical evaluation of a series of 3‐ and 4‐aminosulfonated derivatives of phenol in an effort to investigate the role of the acid dissociation constant (pKa), and therefore the stability of the phenoxide ion, on the inhibitory activity of compounds against this enzyme. The results showed that there was a strong correlation between the observed pKa and inhibitory activity within the aminosulfonated compounds considered. This suggested that in the inhibition of oestrone sulfatase by these compounds, pKa was an important physicochemical property, and as such, the stability of the O− ion was a crucial factor in the inhibition, and therefore the drug design process.