Christophe Boulay

Three-dimensional study of pelvic asymmetry on anatomical specimens and its clinical perspectives

The aim of this study was to assess pelvic asymmetry (i.e. to determine whether the right iliac bone and the right part of the sacrum are mirror images of the left), both quantitatively and qualitatively, using three‐dimensional measurements. Pelvic symmetry was described osteologically using a common reference coordinate system for a large sample of pelvises. Landmarks were established on 12 anatomical specimens with an electromagnetic Fastrak system. Seventy‐one paired variables were tested with a paired t‐test and a non‐parametric test (Wilcoxon). A Pearson correlation matrix between the right and left values of the same variable was applied exclusively to values that were significantly asymmetric in order to calculate a dimensionless asymmetry index, ABGi, for each variable. Fifteen variables were significantly asymmetric and correlated with the right vs. left sides for the following anatomical regions: sacrum, iliac blades, iliac width, acetabulum and the superior lunate surface of the acetabulum. ABGi values above a threshold of ± 4.8% were considered significantly asymmetric in seven variables of the pelvic area. Total asymmetry involving the right and the left pelvis seems to follow a spiral path in the pelvis; in the upper part, the iliac blades rotate clockwise, and in the lower part, the pubic symphysis rotates anticlockwise. Thus, pelvic asymmetry may be evaluated in clinical examinations by measuring iliac crest orientation.

How is sagittal balance acquired during bipedal gait acquisition? Comparison of neonatal and adult pelves in three dimensions. Evolutionary implications

We compare adult and intact neonatal pelves, using a pelvic sagittal variable, the angle of sacral incidence, which presents significant correlations with vertebral curvature in adults and plays an important role in sagittal balance of the trunk on the lower limbs. Since the lumbar curvature develops in the child in association with gait acquisition, we expect a change in this angle during growth which could contribute to the acquisition of sagittal balance. To understand the mechanisms underlying the sagittal balance in the evolution of human bipedalism, we also measure the angle of incidence of hominid fossils. Fourty-seven landmarks were digitized on 50 adult and 19 intact neonatal pelves. We used a three-dimensional model of the pelvis (DE-VISU program) which calculates the angle of sacral incidence and related functional variables. Cross-sectional data from newborns and adults show that the angle of sacral incidence increases and becomes negatively correlated with the sacro-acetabular distance. During ontogeny the sacrum becomes curved, tends to sink down between the iliac blades as a wedge and moves backward in the sagittal plane relative to the acetabula, thus contributing to the backwards displacement of the center of gravity of the trunk. A chain of correlations links the degree of the sacral slope and of the angle of incidence, which is tightly linked with the lumbar lordosis. We sketch a model showing the coordinated changes occurring in the pelvis and vertebral column during the acquisition of bipedalism in infancy. In the australopithecine pelves, Sts 14 and AL 288-1, and in the Homo erectus Gona pelvis the angle of sacral incidence reaches the mean values of humans. Discussing the incomplete pelves of Ardipithecus ramidus, Australopithecus sediba and the Nariokotome Boy, we suggest how the functional linkage between pelvis and spine, observed in humans, could have emerged during hominid evolution.

Pelvic incidence: a predictive factor for three-dimensional acetabular orientation-a preliminary study.

Acetabular cup orientation (inclination and anteversion) is a fundamental topic in orthopaedics and depends on pelvis tilt (positional parameter) emphasising the notion of a safe range of pelvis tilt. The hypothesis was that pelvic incidence (morphologic parameter) could yield a more accurate and reliable assessment than pelvis tilt. The aim was to find out a predictive equation of acetabular 3D orientation parameters which were determined by pelvic incidence to include in the model. The second aim was to consider the asymmetry between the right and left acetabulae. Twelve pelvic anatomic specimens were measured with an electromagnetic Fastrak system (Polhemus Society) providing 3D position of anatomical landmarks to allow measurement of acetabular and pelvic parameters. Acetabulum and pelvis data were correlated by a Spearman matrix. A robust linear regression analysis provided prediction of acetabulum axes. The orientation of each acetabulum could be predicted by the incidence. The incidence is correlated with the morphology of acetabula. The asymmetry of the acetabular roof was correlated with pelvic incidence. This study allowed analysis of relationships of acetabular orientation and pelvic incidence. Pelvic incidence (morphologic parameter) could determine the safe range of pelvis tilt (positional parameter) for an individual and not a group.

Perineal descent predicted by a pelvic bone factor: the pelvic incidence angle.

PURPOSE: By measuring the pelvic incidence angle, we assessed the relationship between pelvic floor disorders and pelvic morphology, which allowed us to document for the first time the hypothesis that pelvic incidence may be a predictive factor of perineal descent. METHODS: In a retrospective study of 197 women, the perineal descent at rest and during straining was assessed by defecography. The pelvic incidence angle (53° ± 9°, independent of the subject position) was defined as the angle between the line perpendicular to the sacral plate at its midpoint and the line connecting this point to the middle of the femoral heads axis. The pelvic incidence angle was correlated with the incidence of pelvic floor descent. RESULTS: In those with pelvic floor descent at rest compared with those without, pelvic incidence angle was significantly larger (64° vs. 53°, P < 10E-06). As a predictive factor of perineal descent at rest, a great pelvic incidence (>62°) had a sensitivity (73 percent), specificity (82 percent), positive predictive value (81 percent), and negative predictive value (75 percent). CONCLUSIONS: A large pelvic incidence (>62°) may be a predictive factor of perineal descent at rest before the apparition of other acquired factors. With pelvic incidence >62°, a large overhang between the insertions increases the strains on the perineum, which is rather horizontal.

Clinical and allelic heterogeneity in a pediatric cohort of 11 patients carrying MFN2 mutation

INTRODUCTION The Mitofusin 2 gene (MFN2), which encodes a mitochondrial membrane protein, is known to be the first cause of autosomal dominant Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 2 (CMT2) with early onset. This gene is involved in typical CMT2A and in more atypical phenotypes as optic atrophy or spastic paraplegia. CMT2 refers to inherited axonal polyneuropathy, which associates progressive peripheral motor and sensory neuropathy, a family history consistent mainly with autosomal dominant inheritance, and normal nerve conduction velocities. SUBJECTS Between 1999 and 2012, the genetic diagnosis of MFN2 mutation was made in 11 children who were treated in our department for different neurological symptoms. All data including family and personal history data, results of standardized clinical and electrophysiology testing, brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), neuro-ophthalmic evaluation, muscle biopsy histopathology and molecular diagnosis were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS Five different mutations were found in 6 unrelated families. Three of them have previously been described; the two remaining are new mutations: one of them related a new phenotype. Clinical signs appeared before the age of 6 years in more than half of the patients (54%). The motor deficit was predominant in 8 patients (72%). Two children presented an acute onset of disease that stabilized afterwards; the other children showed a more progressive deterioration that was managed symptomatically. CONCLUSION This large pediatric study describes a great interfamilial and intrafamilial phenotypic variability. We recommend screening this gene in pediatric patient with chronic neurologic symptoms such as motor deficit or optic atrophy but also in acute neurologic deficiencies such as subacute polyradiculoneuritis.

[Two key describers of the sacro-acetabular relationships: the angles of sacral and acetabular incidence].

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Implantation of total hip arthroplasties raises several important questions concerning the relationship between the orientation of the lumbosacral joint and the acetabular-femoral joint; in other words, between the position of the patients trunk and the orientation of the acetabula. To elucidate better these complex relationships, we conducted a morphometry study on a sample of 51 dry pelves: pelv 26 female and 25 male specimens. MATERIAL AND METHODS Three-dimensional coordinates of 47 homologous points were recorded for each pelvis. Data were then processed with De-Visu, a graphic visualization software. Seven parameters were compared: sacral slope, sacral incidence, and five parameters quantifying the three-dimensional orientation of the acetabula. RESULTS The graphic modelization enabled an integral 3-D visualization of each pelvis. The sagittal view enabled simultaneous visualization of the sacrum, the sacroiliac joints, the acetabula, and their alignments, as well as the variability of their spatial relation. The position reference chosen to simulate the upright position aligned the anterior iliac spines and the superior pubic point. This position was found pertinent because the mean value of the sacral slope (41.8) and the sacral incidence (54) were not different from published series. The sacral slope was the most strongly correlated with the acetabular parameters. It exhibited a positive correlation with sagittal acetabular slope (r=0.59) and acetabular inclination (r=0.59). It exhibited a negative correlation with acetabular anteversion (R=0.45). The correlation with the sagittal acetabular slope was very strong for anteversion (r=0.92), and rose with acetabular inclination (r=-0.66). The angle formed by the two acetabular axes was highly variable (37). The correlation between this angle and inclination was very high in males (r=-0.88) and non-significant in females. There was however a very strong correlation with anteversion in females (r=-0.74) which was non-significant in males. This contrasting finding was related to the wide spread of the inclination values in males and anteversion values in females. DISCUSSION We demonstrated a new sagittal parameter: the acetabular incidence. The summit of this angle is the center of the acetabulum. The sides are the pelvic thickness and the acetabular axes. This parameter was negatively correlated with the sacral incidence. It account simultaneously for the sagittal position of the sacrum in relation to the acetabula and for the degree of acetabular anteversion and inclination. We have demonstrated that the geometric sum of these two angles, sacral incidence and acetabular incidence, is equivalent to the sacro-acetabular angle demonstrated by Lazennec and Saillant. These authors showed that the sacro-acetabular angle is the sum of two positional parameters, the sacral slope and the sagittal acetabular tilt (or slope). The three angles -- sacral incidence, acetabular incidence, sacro-acetabular angle -- are anatomic angles which do not vary with the pelvic position.

P.276 La descente périnéale est prédite par la biométrie osseuse du pelvis

But Definir une relation entre la descente perineale et la morphologie osseuse du pelvis en calculant l’angle d’incidence pelvienne (AIP). Materiels et Methodes Lors d’une etude retrospective portant sur 197 patientes, la descente perineale au repos et a l’effort a ete evaluee sur la defecographie. L’AIP etait mesure entre la perpendiculaire passant par le centre du plateau de la 1 ere vertebre sacree et la droite reliant ce centre aux tetes femorales. L’AIP a ete correle a l’incidence de la descente perineale. Resultats L’AIP etait significativement plus eleve quand le perinee etait descendu (64° vs 59°). Comme facteur predictif de perinee descendu, un AIP > 62° avait une sensibilite de 73,2 %, une specificite de 82 %, une valeur predictive positive de 80,7 % et une valeur predictive negative de 75 %. Discussion Un AIP eleve temoigne d’une horizontalisation et d’une ouverture du pelvis favorisant des troubles de la statique pelvienne. La morphologie osseuse du bassin determine l’orientation des fascias et des muscles pelviens et perineaux, expliquant la possibile survenue de troubles de la statique pelvienne. Conclusion L’angle d’incidence pelvienne est predictif de la descente perineale.

Deux descripteurs clé des relations sacro-cotyloïdiennes : les angles d’incidence sacrée et cotyloïdeMise en évidence par le logiciel De-Visu

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Implantation of total hip arthroplasties raises several important questions concerning the relationship between the orientation of the lumbosacral joint and the acetabular-femoral joint; in other words, between the position of the patients trunk and the orientation of the acetabula. To elucidate better these complex relationships, we conducted a morphometry study on a sample of 51 dry pelves: pelv 26 female and 25 male specimens. MATERIAL AND METHODS Three-dimensional coordinates of 47 homologous points were recorded for each pelvis. Data were then processed with De-Visu, a graphic visualization software. Seven parameters were compared: sacral slope, sacral incidence, and five parameters quantifying the three-dimensional orientation of the acetabula. RESULTS The graphic modelization enabled an integral 3-D visualization of each pelvis. The sagittal view enabled simultaneous visualization of the sacrum, the sacroiliac joints, the acetabula, and their alignments, as well as the variability of their spatial relation. The position reference chosen to simulate the upright position aligned the anterior iliac spines and the superior pubic point. This position was found pertinent because the mean value of the sacral slope (41.8) and the sacral incidence (54) were not different from published series. The sacral slope was the most strongly correlated with the acetabular parameters. It exhibited a positive correlation with sagittal acetabular slope (r=0.59) and acetabular inclination (r=0.59). It exhibited a negative correlation with acetabular anteversion (R=0.45). The correlation with the sagittal acetabular slope was very strong for anteversion (r=0.92), and rose with acetabular inclination (r=-0.66). The angle formed by the two acetabular axes was highly variable (37). The correlation between this angle and inclination was very high in males (r=-0.88) and non-significant in females. There was however a very strong correlation with anteversion in females (r=-0.74) which was non-significant in males. This contrasting finding was related to the wide spread of the inclination values in males and anteversion values in females. DISCUSSION We demonstrated a new sagittal parameter: the acetabular incidence. The summit of this angle is the center of the acetabulum. The sides are the pelvic thickness and the acetabular axes. This parameter was negatively correlated with the sacral incidence. It account simultaneously for the sagittal position of the sacrum in relation to the acetabula and for the degree of acetabular anteversion and inclination. We have demonstrated that the geometric sum of these two angles, sacral incidence and acetabular incidence, is equivalent to the sacro-acetabular angle demonstrated by Lazennec and Saillant. These authors showed that the sacro-acetabular angle is the sum of two positional parameters, the sacral slope and the sagittal acetabular tilt (or slope). The three angles -- sacral incidence, acetabular incidence, sacro-acetabular angle -- are anatomic angles which do not vary with the pelvic position.

Deux descripteurs clé des relations sacro-cotyloïdiennes : les angles d’incidence sacrée et cotyloïde

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Implantation of total hip arthroplasties raises several important questions concerning the relationship between the orientation of the lumbosacral joint and the acetabular-femoral joint; in other words, between the position of the patients trunk and the orientation of the acetabula. To elucidate better these complex relationships, we conducted a morphometry study on a sample of 51 dry pelves: pelv 26 female and 25 male specimens. MATERIAL AND METHODS Three-dimensional coordinates of 47 homologous points were recorded for each pelvis. Data were then processed with De-Visu, a graphic visualization software. Seven parameters were compared: sacral slope, sacral incidence, and five parameters quantifying the three-dimensional orientation of the acetabula. RESULTS The graphic modelization enabled an integral 3-D visualization of each pelvis. The sagittal view enabled simultaneous visualization of the sacrum, the sacroiliac joints, the acetabula, and their alignments, as well as the variability of their spatial relation. The position reference chosen to simulate the upright position aligned the anterior iliac spines and the superior pubic point. This position was found pertinent because the mean value of the sacral slope (41.8) and the sacral incidence (54) were not different from published series. The sacral slope was the most strongly correlated with the acetabular parameters. It exhibited a positive correlation with sagittal acetabular slope (r=0.59) and acetabular inclination (r=0.59). It exhibited a negative correlation with acetabular anteversion (R=0.45). The correlation with the sagittal acetabular slope was very strong for anteversion (r=0.92), and rose with acetabular inclination (r=-0.66). The angle formed by the two acetabular axes was highly variable (37). The correlation between this angle and inclination was very high in males (r=-0.88) and non-significant in females. There was however a very strong correlation with anteversion in females (r=-0.74) which was non-significant in males. This contrasting finding was related to the wide spread of the inclination values in males and anteversion values in females. DISCUSSION We demonstrated a new sagittal parameter: the acetabular incidence. The summit of this angle is the center of the acetabulum. The sides are the pelvic thickness and the acetabular axes. This parameter was negatively correlated with the sacral incidence. It account simultaneously for the sagittal position of the sacrum in relation to the acetabula and for the degree of acetabular anteversion and inclination. We have demonstrated that the geometric sum of these two angles, sacral incidence and acetabular incidence, is equivalent to the sacro-acetabular angle demonstrated by Lazennec and Saillant. These authors showed that the sacro-acetabular angle is the sum of two positional parameters, the sacral slope and the sagittal acetabular tilt (or slope). The three angles -- sacral incidence, acetabular incidence, sacro-acetabular angle -- are anatomic angles which do not vary with the pelvic position.