Claude Delatour

Phytophthora pseudosyringae sp. nov., a new species causing root and collar rot of deciduous tree species in Europe

In several studies of oak decline in Europe, a semi-papillate homothallic Phytophthora taxon was consistently isolated, together with other Phytophthora species, from rhizosphere soil samples. It was also found associated with necrotic fine roots and stem necroses of Fagus sylvatica and Alnus glutinosa. Due to morphological and physiological similarities, the semi-papillate isolates were previously identified as P. syringae by various authors. The morphology, physiology and pathogenicity against fine roots of Quercus robur, Q. petraea and F. sylvatica, bark of A. glutinosa, leaves of Ilex aquifolium and apple fruits of this Phytophthora species are described and compared with those of related and similar Phytophthora species, namely P. ilicis, P. psychrophila, P. quercina, P. citricola and P. syringae. The phylogenetic placement on the basis of ITS and mtDNA sequence data was also examined. Isolates of this taxon produce colonies with stellate to rosaceous growth patterns and limited aerial mycelium on various agar media. Antheridia are predominantly paragynous. In water culture catenulate hyphal swellings and semi-papillate caducous sporangia, that are usually limoniform, ellipsoid or ovoid, are formed abundandly, mostly in lax or dense sympodia. This taxon is a moderately slow growing, low temperature species with optimum and maximum temperatures around 20 and 25 degrees C, respectively. Tested isolates are moderately aggressive to fine roots of oaks and beech, highly aggressive to holly leaves and apple fruits, and slightly pathogenic to alder bark. Thirteen tested isolates had an identical and distinct ITS sequence which was more similar to that of P. ilicis and P. psychrophila than any other known taxa. On the basis of their unique combination of morphological characters, colony growth patterns, cardinal temperatures for growth, growth rates, pathogenicity to oaks, beech, alder, apple and holly, their host range, and ITS and mtDNA sequences the semi-papillate caducous Phytophthora isolates from oaks, beech and alder are clearly separated from related and similar Phytophthora spp., and described as a new species, P. pseudosyringae sp. nov.

Three new species of Phytophthora from European oak forests

In several studies of oak decline in Europe, one semi-papillate ( Phytophthora psychrophila sp. nov.) and two non-papillate homothallic Phytophthora species ( P. europaea and P. uliginosa spp. nov.) were isolated, together with other Phytophthora species, from rhizosphere soil samples which could not be assigned to existing taxa. P. psychrophila differs from other semi-papillate species of Waterhouses morphological Group IV, like P. ilicis and P. hibernalis , by its uniform, dome-shaped and cottonwool-like colony growth pattern on V8 juice agar and malt extract agar, the occurrence of sympodially branched primary hyphae, the high variation in size and shape of the sporangia, shorter pedicels, lower optimum temperature for growth, and ITS sequences. P. europaea is distinguished from related non-papillate Group V and VI species, namely P. fragariae, P. cambivora , and the ‘alder phytophthora’, by producing oogonia with tapered bases, irregular walls and exclusively paragynous antheridia, its cardinal temperatures for growth, and ITS sequences. P. uliginosa differs from related Group V and VI species by its large oogonia with exclusively paragynous antheridia, the predominant occurrence of ellipsoid sporangia with markedly wide exit pores, its slow growth, low cardinal temperatures, its colony growth patterns, and ITS sequences. P. uliginosa is separated from P. europaea by its larger oogonia without tapering bases, lower cardinal temperatures and growth rates, different colony growth patterns, and greater aggressiveness on Q. robur.

Structure of Collybia fusipes populations in two infected oak stands

Collybia fusipes is the cause of a root rot of oak trees. We studied the structure of C. fusipes populations in two infected oak stands by using somatic incompatibility and DNA amplification. Isolates were obtained from different oak root systems or from within the same root system and somatic incompatibility groups (SIG) were identified. Many small SIGs that seldom encompassed more than one root system were present in both stands. More than one SIG was usually present on an individual root system: there were 3·1 ± 1·3 SIGs on the pedunculate oaks and 2·2 ± 0·6 on the red oaks. The largest SIG contained more than 70% of the isolates obtained from the root system of 14 of the 20 trees studied. Isolates that belonged to the same SIG usually had the same ribosomal intergenic spacer. It is concluded that C. fusipes spreads poorly from tree to tree by vegetative means.

Genetics of somatic incompatibility in Collybia fusipes

The genetics of somatic incompatibility in tetrapolar Collybia fusipes was studied using eight dikaryotic isolates collected from the wild and their experimentally derived progeny. Monokaryons from each isolate were all paired with the same unrelated monokaryon and also paired together in all combinations. The somatic compatibility of the two resulting sets of dikaryons was studied. Two different types of somatic incompatible interaction were observed, lightly or heavily pigmented lines developing between the two isolates. The dikaryons that had one nuclear type in common and one coming from sibling monokaryons were compatible in 7–27% of the cases, incompatible with a lightly pigmented interaction in 30–93% and incompatible with a heavily pigmented interaction in 0–53%. The results suggest that at least three to four loci control the somatic incompatibility in C. fusipes, one of them alone controlling the heavily pigmented interaction.

Responses of the root rot fungus Collybia fusipes to soil waterlogging and oxygen availability.

Collybia fusipes is a common root rot fungus in mature pedunculate oak forest, that causes drastic destruction of the tree root systems, especially in dry or mildly waterlogged soils. We wanted to check, under controlled conditions or in forest ecosystems, whether reduced O2 during saturation of the soil by water could interact with disease evolution. Susceptibility of waterlogged oak seedlings to C. fusipes was tested in a greenhouse and the survival of the pathogen in woody substrates was assessed in hydromorphic soils in a forest. A direct and detrimental effect of soil waterlogging on C. fusipes survival was evidenced both under controlled conditions and in forest stands. Growth of C. fusipes mycelium on agar media was monitored under low O2 mole fraction and compared to that of Armillaria mellea and Heterobasidion annosum. A drastic reduction in mycelial growth was evidenced in C. fusipes and H. annosum but not in A. mellea.

Inoculation of Mature Pedunculate Oaks (Quercus robur) with the Root Rot Fungus Collybia fusipes: Relationships with Tree Vigour and Soil Factors

The severity of natural infections induced by the root rot fungus Collybia fusipes depends on soil factors. Severely infected trees usually show reduced vigour, as evidenced by poor growth. However, it is not known whether reduced vigour could be a cause of the severe infection. The objective was to clarify the relationships between soil factors, tree vigour and susceptibility of Quercus robur to C. fusipes by artificially inoculating mature trees. Two experiments compared oak trees of different ages and dominance class and oak trees growing on different type of soils. The inoculum survival and the infection success were poor in both experiments when waterlogging was severe. Inoculum survival was better in soil with increasing sand/clay ratio, carbon/nitrogen ratio and decreasing pH and calcium, magnesium and phosphorus availability. The relationships between oak vigour and success of infection or surface area of lesions were inconsistent, with a slightly higher infection success on co-dominant/suppressed oaks in one experiment and a higher surface area of successful infection on dominant oaks in the second.