Claudio Bettini

A survey of context modelling and reasoning techniques

Development of context-aware applications is inherently complex. These applications adapt to changing context information: physical context, computational context, and user context/tasks. Context information is gathered from a variety of sources that differ in the quality of information they produce and that are often failure prone. The pervasive computing community increasingly understands that developing context-aware applications should be supported by adequate context information modelling and reasoning techniques. These techniques reduce the complexity of context-aware applications and improve their maintainability and evolvability. In this paper we discuss the requirements that context modelling and reasoning techniques should meet, including the modelling of a variety of context information types and their relationships, of situations as abstractions of context information facts, of histories of context information, and of uncertainty of context information. This discussion is followed by a description and comparison of current context modelling and reasoning techniques.

Protecting privacy against location-based personal identification

This paper presents a preliminary investigation on the privacy issues involved in the use of location-based services. It is argued that even if the user identity is not explicitly released to the service provider, the geo-localized history of user-requests can act as a quasi-identifier and may be used to access sensitive information about specific individuals. The paper formally defines a framework to evaluate the risk in revealing a user identity via location information and presents preliminary ideas about algorithms to prevent this to happen.

An access control model supporting periodicity constraints and temporal reasoning

Access control models, such as the ones supported by commercial DBMSs, are not yet able to fully meet many application needs. An important requirement derives from the temporal dimension that permissions have in many real-world situations. Permissions are often limited in time or may hold only for specific periods of time. In this article, we present an access control model in which periodic temporal intervals are associated with authorizations. An authorization is automatically granted in the specified intervals and revoked when such intervals expire. Deductive temporal rules with periodicity and order constraints are provided to derive new authorizations based on the presence or absence of other authorizations in specific periods of time. We provide a solution to the problem of ensuring the uniqueness of the global set of valid authorizations derivable at each instant, and we propose an algorithm to compute this set. Moreover, we address issues related to the efficiency of access control by adopting a materialization approach. The resulting model provides a high degree of flexibility and supports the specification of several protection requirements that cannot be expressed in traditional access control models.

COSAR: hybrid reasoning for context-aware activity recognition

Human activity recognition is a challenging problem for context-aware systems and applications. Research in this field has mainly adopted techniques based on supervised learning algorithms, but these systems suffer from scalability issues with respect to the number of considered activities and contextual data. In this paper, we propose a solution based on the use of ontologies and ontological reasoning combined with statistical inferencing. Structured symbolic knowledge about the environment surrounding the user allows the recognition system to infer which activities among the candidates identified by statistical methods are more likely to be the actual activity that the user is performing. Ontological reasoning is also integrated with statistical methods to recognize complex activities that cannot be derived by statistical methods alone. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is supported by experiments with a complete implementation of the system using commercially available sensors and an Android-based handheld device as the host for the main activity recognition module.

Discovering frequent event patterns with multiple granularities in time sequences

An important usage of time sequences is to discover temporal patterns. The discovery process usually starts with a user specified skeleton, called an event structure, which consists of a number of variables representing events and temporal constraints among these variables; the goal of the discovery is to find temporal patterns, i.e., instantiations of the variables in the structure that appear frequently in the time sequence. The paper introduces event structures that have temporal constraints with multiple granularities, defines the pattern discovery problem with these structures, and studies effective algorithms to solve it. The basic components of the algorithms include timed automata with granularities (TAGs) and a number of heuristics. The TAGs are for testing whether a specific temporal pattern, called a candidate complex event type, appears frequently in a time sequence. Since there are often a huge number of candidate event types for a usual event structure, heuristics are presented aiming at reducing the number of candidate event types and reducing the time spent by the TAGs testing whether a candidate type does appear frequently in the sequence. These heuristics exploit the information provided by explicit and implicit temporal constraints with granularity in the given event structure. The paper also gives the results of an experiment to show the effectiveness of the heuristics on a real data set.

A temporal access control mechanism for database systems

The paper presents a discretionary access control model in which authorizations contain temporal intervals of validity. An authorization is automatically revoked when the associated temporal interval expires. The proposed model provides rules for the automatic derivation of new authorizations from those explicitly specified. Both positive and negative authorizations are supported. A formal definition of those concepts is presented, together with the semantic interpretation of authorizations and derivation rules as clauses of a general logic program. Issues deriving from the presence of negative authorizations are discussed. We also allow negation in rules: it is possible to derive new authorizations on the basis of the absence of other authorizations. The presence of this type of rule may lead to the generation of different sets of authorizations, depending on the evaluation order. An approach is presented, based on establishing an ordering among authorizations and derivation rules, which guarantees a unique set of valid authorizations. Moreover, we give an algorithm detecting whether such an ordering can be established for a given set of authorizations and rules. Administrative operations for adding, removing, or modifying authorizations and derivation rules are presented and efficiency issues related to these operations are also tackled in the paper. A materialization approach is proposed, allowing to efficiently perform access control.

Privacy in geo-social networks: proximity notification with untrusted service providers and curious buddies

A major feature of the emerging geo-social networks is the ability to notify a user when any of his friends (also called buddies) happens to be geographically in proximity. This proximity service is usually offered by the network itself or by a third party service provider (SP) using location data acquired from the users. This paper provides a rigorous theoretical and experimental analysis of the existing solutions for the location privacy problem in proximity services. This is a serious problem for users who do not trust the SP to handle their location data and would only like to release their location information in a generalized form to participating buddies. The paper presents two new protocols providing complete privacy with respect to the SP and controllable privacy with respect to the buddies. The analytical and experimental analysis of the protocols takes into account privacy, service precision, and computation and communication costs, showing the superiority of the new protocols compared to those appeared in the literature to date. The proposed protocols have also been tested in a full system implementation of the proximity service.

Obligation monitoring in policy management

Policies are widely used in modern systems and applications. Recently, it has been recognized that simple decisions are just not enough for many systems and applications. Many policies require actions to be performed after a decision is made in accordance with the policy. To address this need, this paper studies the notion of obligations, which are those conditions or actions that must be fulfilled by either the users or the system after the decision. This paper formalizes the obligations and investigates mechanisms for monitoring obligations. In particular, the paper discusses various aspects of how the system may compensate for unfulfilled obligations.

OWL 2 modeling and reasoning with complex human activities

In recent years, there has been a growing interest in the adoption of ontologies and ontological reasoning to automatically recognize complex context data such as human activities. In particular, the Web Ontology Language (OWL) emerged as the language of choice, being a standard for the Semantic Web, and supported by a number of tools for knowledge engineering and reasoning. However, the limitations of OWL 1 in terms of expressiveness have been recognized in various fields, and important research efforts have been made to extend the language while preserving decidability of its OWL 1 DL fragment. The result of such work is OWL 2. In this paper we investigate the use of OWL 2 for modeling complex activities and reasoning with them. We show that the new language constructors of OWL 2 overcome the main limitations of OWL 1 for the representation of activities; OWL 2 axioms can be used to represent certain rules and rule-based reasoning previously demanded to hybrid approaches, with the advantage of having a unique semantics, avoiding potential inconsistencies. Then, we propose a system architecture showing the integration of a novel OWL 2 activity ontology and reasoning modules with distributed modules for sensor data aggregation and reasoning. The feasibility of our solution is shown by an extensive experimental evaluation with simulations of different intelligent environments.

A general framework for time granularity and its application to temporal reasoning

This paper presents a general framework to define time granularity systems. We identify the main dimensions along which different systems can be characterized, and investigate the formal relationships among granularities in these systems. The paper also introduces the notion of a network of temporal constraints with (multiple) granularities emphasizing the semantic and computational differences from constraint networks with a single granularity. Consistency of networks with multiple granularities is shown to beNP‐hard in general and approximate solutions for this problem and for the minimal network problem are proposed.