Clay W Scott

Label-free whole-cell assays: expanding the scope of GPCR screening.

A new class of instruments offers an unprecedented combination of label-free detection with exquisite sensitivity to live-cell responses. These instruments can quantify G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) signaling through G(s), G(i) and G(q) pathways and in some cases distinguish G-protein coupling, with sensitivity high enough to detect endogenous receptors. Here, we review emerging data evaluating impedance- and optical-based label-free instruments for GPCR drug discovery. In comparison with traditional GPCR assays, we highlight strengths, weaknesses and future opportunities for label-free biosensors. The ability to qualitatively distinguish G-protein coupling has groundbreaking potential for assessing functional selectivity, a concept that is changing the way GPCR pharmacology is defined and screening strategies are designed.

Human induced pluripotent stem cells and their use in drug discovery for toxicity testing

Predicting human safety risks of novel xenobiotics remains a major challenge, partly due to the limited availability of human cells to evaluate tissue-specific toxicity. Recent progress in the production of human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) may fill this gap. hiPSCs can be continuously expanded in culture in an undifferentiated state and then differentiated to form most cell types. Thus, it is becoming technically feasible to generate large quantities of human cell types and, in combination with relatively new detection methods, to develop higher-throughput in vitro assays that quantify tissue-specific biological properties. Indeed, the first wave of large scale hiSC-differentiated cell types including patient-derived hiPSCS are now commercially available. However, significant improvements in hiPSC production and differentiation processes are required before cell-based toxicity assays that accurately reflect mature tissue phenotypes can be delivered and implemented in a cost-effective manner. In this review, we discuss the promising alignment of hiPSCs and recently emerging technologies to quantify tissue-specific functions. We emphasize liver, cardiovascular, and CNS safety risks and highlight limitations that must be overcome before routine screening for toxicity pathways in hiSC-derived cells can be established.

Evaluating Cellular Impedance Assays for Detection of GPCR Pleiotropic Signaling and Functional Selectivity

G-protein—coupled receptors can couple to different signal transduction pathways in different cell types (termed cell-specific signaling) and can activate different signaling pathways depending on the receptor conformation(s) stabilized by the activating ligand (functional selectivity). These concepts offer potential for developing pathway-specific drugs that increase efficacy and reduce side effects. Despite significant interest, functional selectivity has been difficult to exploit in drug discovery, in part due to the burden of multiple assays. Cellular impedance assays use an emerging technology that can qualitatively distinguish Gs, Gi/o, and Gq signaling in a single assay and is thereby suited for studying these pharmacological concepts. Cellular impedance confirmed cell-specific Gs and Gq coupling for the melanocortin-4 receptor and dual Gi and Gs signaling with the cannabinoid-1 (CB1) receptor. The balance of Gi versus Gs signaling depended on the cell line. In CB1-HEKs, Giand Gs-like responses combined to yield a novel impedance profile demonstrating the dynamic nature of these traces. Cellspecific signaling was observed with endogenous D1 receptor in U-2 cells and SK-N-MC cells, yet the pharmacological profile of partial and full agonists was similar in both cell lines. We conclude that the dynamic impedance profile encodes valuable relative signaling information and is sufficiently robust to help evaluate cell-specific signaling and functional selectivity. (Journal of Biomolecular Screening 2009:246-255)

Evaluation of cellular dielectric spectroscopy, a whole-cell, label-free technology for drug discovery on Gi-coupled GPCRs.

Cellular dielectric spectroscopy (CDS) is an emerging technology capable of detecting a range of whole-cell responses in a label-free manner. A new CDS-based instrument, CellKey, has been developed that is optimized for G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) detection and has automated liquid handling in microplate format, thereby making CDS accessible to lead generation/optimization drug discovery. In addition to having sufficient throughput, new assay technologies must pass rigorous standards for assay development, signal window, dynamic range, and reproducibility to effectively support drug discovery SAR studies. Here, the authors evaluated CellKey with 3 different Gi-coupled GPCRs for suitability in supporting SAR studies. Optimized assay conditions compatible with the precision, reproducibility, and throughput required for routine screening were quickly achieved for each target. Across a 1000-fold range in compound potencies, CellKey results correlated with agonist and antagonist data obtained using classical methods ([ 35S]GTPγS binding and cAMP production). For partial agonists, relative efficacy measurements also correlated with GTPγS data. CellKey detection of positive allosteric modulators appeared superior to GTPγS methodology. Agonist and antagonist activity could be accurately quantified under conditions of low receptor expression. CellKey is a new technology platform that uses label-free detection in a homogeneous assay that is unaffected by color quenching and is easily integrated into existing microtiter-based compound testing and data analysis procedures for drug discovery. (Journal of Biomolecular Screening 2007:312-319)

Comparing Label-Free Biosensors for Pharmacological Screening With Cell-Based Functional Assays

The diversity and impact of label-free technologies continues to expand in drug discovery. Two classes of label-free instruments, using either an electrical impedance-based or an optical-based biosensor, are now available for investigating the effects of ligands on cellular targets. Studies of GPCR function have been especially prominent with these instruments due to the importance of this target class in drug discovery. Although both classes of biosensors share similar high sensitivity to changes in cell shape and structure, it is unknown whether these biosensors yield similar results when comparing the same GPCR response. Furthermore, since cell morphology changes induced by GPCRs differ depending on which G-protein is activated, there is potential for these instruments to have differential sensitivities to G-protein signaling. Here 1 impedance (CellKey)- and 2 optical-based instruments (BIND and Epic) are compared using Gi-coupled (ACh M2), Gq-coupled (ACh M1), and Gs-coupled (CRF1) receptors. All 3 instruments were robust in agonist and antagonist modes yielding comparable potencies and assay variance. Both the impedance and optical biosensors showed similar high sensitivity for detecting an endogenous D1/D5 receptor response and a melanocortin-4 receptor inverse agonist (agouti-related protein). The impedance-based biosensor was uniquely able to qualitatively distinguish G-protein coupling and reveal dual signaling by CRF1. Finally, responses with a ligand-gated ion channel, TRPV1, were similarly detectable in each instrument. Thus, despite some differences, both impedance- and optical-based platforms offer robust live-cell, label-free assays well suited to drug discovery and typically yield similar pharmacological profiles for GPCR ligands.

Human Stem Cell-Derived Cardiomyocytes in Cellular Impedance Assays: Bringing Cardiotoxicity Screening to the Front Line

Abstract Cardiovascular (CV) toxicity is a leading cause of drug attrition and withdrawal. Introducing in vitro assays with higher throughput should permit earlier CV hazard identification and enable medicinal chemists to design-out liabilities. Heretofore, development of in vitro CV assays has been limited by the challenge of replicating integrated cardiovascular physiology while achieving the throughput and consistency required for screening. These challenges appear to be met with a combination of human stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (CM) which beat spontaneously and monitoring the response with technology that can assess drug-induced changes in voltage dependent contraction such as cellular impedance which has been validated with excellent predictivity for drug-induced arrhythmia and contractility. Here, we review advances in cardiomyocyte impedance with emphasis on stem cell-derived cardiomyocyte models for toxicity screening. Key perspectives include: the electrical principles of impedance technology, impedance detection of cardiomyocyte beating, beat parameter selection/analysis, validation in toxicity and drug discovery, and future directions. As a conclusion, an in vitro screening cascade is proffered using the downstream, inclusive detection of CM impedance assays as a primary screen followed by complementary CM assays chosen to enable mechanism-appropriate follow-up. The combined approach will enhance testing for CV liabilities prior to traditional in vivo models.

An impedance-based cellular assay using human iPSC-derived cardiomyocytes to quantify modulators of cardiac contractility.

Cardiovascular toxicity, a prominent reason for late-stage failures in drug development, has resulted in a demand for in vitro assays that can predict this liability in early drug discovery. Current in vitro cardiovascular safety testing primarily focuses on ion channel modulation and low throughput cardiomyocyte (CM) contractility measurements. We evaluated both human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived CMs (hiPSC-CMs) and rat neonatal CMs (rat CMs) on the xCELLigence Cardio system which uses impedance technology to quantify CM beating properties in a 96-well format. Forty-nine compounds were tested in concentration-response mode to determine potency for modulation of CM beating, a surrogate biomarker for contractility. These compounds had previously been tested in vivo and in a low throughput in vitro optical-based contractility assay that measures sarcomere shortening in electrically paced dog CMs. In comparison with in vivo contractility effects, hiPSC-CM impedance had assay sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy values of 90%, 74%, and 82%, respectively. These values compared favorably to values reported for the dog CM optical assay (83%, 84%, and 82%) and were slightly better than impedance using rat CMs (77%, 74%, and 74%). The potency values from the hiPSC-CM and rat CM assays spanned four orders of magnitude and correlated with values from the dog CM optical assay (r(2 )= 0.76 and 0.70, respectively). The Cardio system assay has >5× higher throughput than the optical assay. Thus, hiPSC-CM impedance testing can help detect the human cardiotoxic potential of novel therapeutics early in drug discovery, and if a hazard is identified, has sufficient throughput to support the design-make-test-analyze cycle to mitigate this liability.

C3 activation is inhibited by analogs of compstatin but not by serine protease inhibitors or peptidyl α-ketoheterocycles

C3 convertase is a key enzyme in the complement cascade and is an attractive therapeutic target for drug design. Recent studies have demonstrated that this enzyme is inhibited by compstatin (Morikis, D. , Assa-Munt, N., Sahu, A., Lambris, J.D., 1998. Solution structure of Compstatin, a potent complement inhibitor. Protein Sci. (7) 619-627; Sahu, A., Kay, B.K., Lambris, J.D., 1996. Inhibition of human complement by a C3-binding peptide isolated from a phage-displayed random peptide library. J. Immunol. (157) 884-891), a 13 amino acid cyclic peptide that binds to C3. Since the enzyme exhibits some homology to serine proteases, substrate-based design could be another avenue for drug design. In this study, we confirm the activity of compstatin using different sources of enzyme and different assay systems. We also tested the activity of substituted compstatin analogs and compared the selectivity and toxicity of these compounds to peptidyl alpha-ketoheterocyclic compounds. Our work confirms the activity of compstatin in both alternative and classical complement pathways, describes 11 new active analogs of this cyclic peptide, and provides evidence for key segments of the peptide for activity. Compstatin and related active analogs showed little or no inhibition of clotting or key enzymes in the clotting cascade nor did they appear to have significant cytotoxicity. The characteristics of compstatin suggest that this peptide and its analogs could be attractive candidates for further clinical development. By contrast, known serine protease inhibitors, including peptidyl alpha-ketoheterocycles, did not inhibit C3 convertase illustrating the atypical nature of this enzyme.

A medium-throughput functional assay of KCNQ2 potassium channels using rubidium efflux and atomic absorption spectrometry.

Heterologous expression of KCNQ2 (Kv7.2) results in the formation of a slowly activating, noninactivating, voltage-gated potassium channel. Using a cell line that stably expresses KCNQ2, we developed a rubidium flux assay to measure the functional activity and pharmacological modulation of this ion channel. Rubidium flux was performed in a 96-well microtiter plate format; rubidium was quantified using an automated atomic absorption spectrometer to enable screening of 1000 data points/day. Cells accumulated rubidium at 37 degrees C in a monoexponential manner with t(1/2)=40min. Treating cells with elevated extracellular potassium caused membrane depolarization and stimulation of rubidium efflux through KCNQ2. The rate of rubidium efflux increased with increasing extracellular potassium: the t(1/2) at 50mM potassium was 5.1 min. Potassium-stimulated efflux was potentiated by the anticonvulsant drug retigabine (EC(50)=0.5 microM). Both potassium-induced and retigabine-facilitated efflux were blocked by TEA (IC(50)s=0.4 and 0.3mM, respectively) and the neurotransmitter release enhancers and putative cognition enhancers linopirdine (IC(50)s=2.3 and 7.1 microM, respectively) and XE991 (IC(50)s=0.3 and 0.9 microM, respectively). Screening a collection of ion channel modulators revealed additional inhibitors including clofilium (IC(50) = 27 microM). These studies extend the pharmacological profile of KCNQ2 and demonstrate the feasibility of using this assay system to rapidly screen for compounds that modulate the function of KCNQ2.

Synthesis and enzymatic evaluation of a P1 arginine aminocoumarin substrate library for trypsin-like serine proteases

A method for the solid-phase synthesis of P1 arginine containing peptides via attachment of the arginine side-chain guanidine group is described. This procedure is applied to the preparation of a tetrapeptide, P1 arginine aminocoumarin PS-SCL. This library was validated by using it to determine the P4-P2 specificity for thrombin and comparing the results to the known thrombin subsite specificity. This is the first reported example of a PS-SCL library containing a P1 arginine.