Clément Brandel

Impact of molecular flexibility on double polymorphism, solid solutions and chiral discrimination during crystallization of diprophylline enantiomers.

The polymorphic behavior of racemic and enantiopure diprophylline (DPL), a chiral derivative of theophylline marketed as a racemic solid, has been investigated by combining differential scanning calorimetry, powder X-ray diffraction, hot-stage microscopy and single-crystal X-ray experiments. The pure enantiomers were obtained by a chemical synthesis route, and additionally an enantioselective crystallization procedure was developed. The binary phase diagram between the DPL enantiomers was constructed and revealed a double polymorphism (i.e., polymorphism both of the racemic mixture and of the pure enantiomer). The study of the various equilibria in this highly unusual phase diagram revealed a complex situation since mixtures of DPL enantiomers can crystallize either as a stable racemic compound, a metastable conglomerate, or two distinct metastable solid solutions. Crystal structure analysis revealed that the DPL molecules adopt different conformations in the crystal forms suggesting that the conformational degrees of freedom of the substituent that carries the only two H-bond donor groups might be related to the versatile crystallization behavior of DPL. The control of these equilibria and the use of a suitable solvent allowed the design of an efficient protocol for the preparative resolution of racemic DPL via preferential crystallization. Therefore, the resolution of DPL enantiomers despite the existence of a racemic compound stable at any temperature demonstrates that the detection of a stable conglomerate is not mandatory for the implementation of preferential crystallization.

Structural Aspects of Solid Solutions of Enantiomers

A mixture of two enantiomers can crystallize according to three types of heterogeneous equilibria: a racemic compound (a 1:1 stoichiometric compound), a conglomerate (a physical mixture of particles with opposite chirality) or, more rarely, as a solid solution (a crystalline architecture exhibiting a lack of chiral discrimination with respect to the two enantiomers). Due to the scarce occurrence of solid solutions, only a few examples of such behavior are known, and even fewer systems have been investigated by means of single crystal X-ray diffraction. Yet, preliminary work performed in the 1970s by several research teams revealed that structural investigations of solid solutions could provide valuable insights into chiral discrimination mechanisms at the crystal lattice scale. In the present paper, our aim is to review published cases of enantiomeric solid solutions for which both melting phase diagrams and crystal structures are available in order to analyze the lack of chiral discrimination associated to these phases. Our methodology consists in considering both the molecular and crystallographic aspects of stereoselectivity with the final aim of identifying structural criteria responsible for the occurrence of solid solutions. The experimental conditions allowing access to solid solutions will also be considered in light of these structural criteria.

Prenucleation self-assembly and chiral discrimination mechanisms during solution crystallisation of racemic diprophylline

The crystallisation behaviour of (RS)-diprophylline (DPL) in two different solvents is investigated to assess the incidence of solvated pre-associations on nucleation, crystal growth and chiral discrimination. In the solvated state, Raman spectroscopy shows that dimeric associations similar to those depicted in the crystalline solid solution (ssRII) predominate in isopropanol (IPA), which may account for the systematic spontaneous nucleation of this crystal form from this solvent. By contrast, spontaneous nucleation in DMF yields the stable racemic compound RI, consistently with the distinct features of the Raman spectrum collected in this solvent. A crystal growth study of ssRII in IPA reveals that the crystal habitus is impacted by the solution enantiomeric excess; this is explained by increased competition between homo- and heterochiral pre-associations. This is supported by a molecular modelling study on the enantiomeric selectivity of the DPL crystal lattices. The combination of assessment methods on solution chemistry, nucleation and chiral discrimination provides methodological tools from which the occurrence of solid solutions can be rationalised.

Inhibition of the Vapor-Mediated Phase Transition of the High Temperature Form of Pyrazinamide

Tailor-made additives can prove an effective method to prolong the lifetime of metastable forms of pharmaceutical compounds by surface stabilization. Pyrazinamide (PZA) is a pharmaceutical compound with four polymorphic forms. The high temperature γ form, which can be produced by spray drying or sublimation growth, is metastable at room temperature and transforms within days when produced by spray drying, and within several months up to years for single crystals produced by sublimation. However, when PZA is cospray dried with 1,3-dimethylurea (DMU), it has been reported to remain in its γ form for several years. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images reveal that the phase transition from γ-PZA to the low temperature forms involves a vapor-mediated recrystallization, while the reverse phase transition upon heating is a nucleation-and-growth solid–solid phase transition. The lifetime-extending effect of DMU on spray-dried PZA has been investigated in more detail and compared with high-energy ball milling of sublimation-grown γ-PZA crystals. Co-ball milling of PZA and DMU is found to extend the lifetime of the high temperature form of PZA to a few months, while separate ball milling leads to an extension of merely a few weeks. DMU acts as an additive that most likely stabilizes the surface of γ-PZA, which would reduce the vapor pressure of PZA, thereby reducing the transition rate. Alternatively, DMU could prevent nucleation of low temperature forms of PZA.

Time and space resolved methods: General discussion

Jim De Yoreo presented some slides on in situ AFM, TEM, dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS) and optical spectroscopy investigations of nucleation in the calcium carbonate system: The free energy barrier to homogeneous nucleation of calcite calculated within the framework of classical nucleation theory (CNT) is prohibitive, even at concentrations exceeding the solubility limits of the amorphous phases. Consistent with this analysis, during nucleation in pure solutions, in our in situ TEM experiments we observed direct formation of all phases, including amorphous calcium carbonate (ACC), as well as the three predominant crystalline phases: calcite, vaterite, and aragonite, even under conditions in which ACC readily forms. In addition to direct formation pathways, we observed indirect pathways in which ACC transforms to aragonite and vaterite through nucleation within or on the precursors, rather than via dissolution and reprecipitation. We also observed aragonate transformation to calcite, but never recorded an instance in which ACC transforms into calcite, except via dissolution–reprecipitation reactions.