Cristina Bombieri

Consensus on the use and interpretation of cystic fibrosis mutation analysis in clinical practice

It is often challenging for the clinician interested in cystic fibrosis (CF) to interpret molecular genetic results, and to integrate them in the diagnostic process. The limitations of genotyping technology, the choice of mutations to be tested, and the clinical context in which the test is administered can all influence how genetic information is interpreted. This paper describes the conclusions of a consensus conference to address the use and interpretation of CF mutation analysis in clinical settings. Although the diagnosis of CF is usually straightforward, care needs to be exercised in the use and interpretation of genetic tests: genotype information is not the final arbiter of a clinical diagnosis of CF or CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein related disorders. The diagnosis of these conditions is primarily based on the clinical presentation, and is supported by evaluation of CFTR function (sweat testing, nasal potential difference) and genetic analysis. None of these features are sufficient on their own to make a diagnosis of CF or CFTR-related disorders. Broad genotype/phenotype associations are useful in epidemiological studies, but CFTR genotype does not accurately predict individual outcome. The use of CFTR genotype for prediction of prognosis in people with CF at the time of their diagnosis is not recommended. The importance of communication between clinicians and medical genetic laboratories is emphasized. The results of testing and their implications should be reported in a manner understandable to the clinicians caring for CF patients.

Variation in a Repeat Sequence Determines Whether a Common Variant of the Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator Gene Is Pathogenic or Benign

An abbreviated tract of five thymidines (5T) in intron 8 of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene is found in approximately 10% of individuals in the general population. When found in trans with a severe CFTR mutation, 5T can result in male infertility, nonclassic cystic fibrosis, or a normal phenotype. To test whether the number of TG repeats adjacent to 5T influences disease penetrance, we determined TG repeat number in 98 patients with male infertility due to congenital absence of the vas deferens, 9 patients with nonclassic CF, and 27 unaffected individuals (fertile men). Each of the individuals in this study had a severe CFTR mutation on one CFTR gene and 5T on the other. Of the unaffected individuals, 78% (21 of 27) had 5T adjacent to 11 TG repeats, compared with 9% (10 of 107) of affected individuals. Conversely, 91% (97 of 107) of affected individuals had 12 or 13 TG repeats, versus only 22% (6 of 27) of unaffected individuals (P<.00001). Those individuals with 5T adjacent to either 12 or 13 TG repeats were substantially more likely to exhibit an abnormal phenotype than those with 5T adjacent to 11 TG repeats (odds ratio 34.0, 95% CI 11.1-103.7, P<.00001). Thus, determination of TG repeat number will allow for more accurate prediction of benign versus pathogenic 5T alleles.

Complete mutational screening of the CFTR gene in 120 patients with pulmonary disease

In order to determine the possible role of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR) gene in pulmonary diseases not due to cystic fibrosis, a complete screening of the CFTR gene was performed in 120 Italian patients with disseminated bronchiectasis of unknown cause (DBE), chronic bronchitis (CB), pulmonary emphysema (E), lung cancer (LC), sarcoidosis (S) and other forms of pulmonary disease. The 27 exons of the CFTR gene and their intronic flanking regions were analyzed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and automatic sequencing. Mutations were detected in 11/23 DBE (P=0.009), 7/25 E, 5/27 CB, 5/26 LC, 5/8 S (P=0.013), 1/4 tuberculosis, and 1/5 pneumonia patients, and in 5/33 controls. Moreover, the IVS8–5T allele was detected in 6/25 E patients (P=0.038). Four new mutations were identified: D651N, 2377C/T, E826K, and P1072L. These results confirm the involvement of the CFTR gene in disseminated bronchiectasis of unknown origin, and suggest a possible role for CFTR gene mutations in sarcoidosis, and for the 5T allele in pulmonary emphysema.

A quarter of men with idiopathic oligo-azoospermia display chromosomal abnormalities and microdeletions of different types in interval 6 of Yq11.

Cytogenetic investigations and molecular analysis of the Y chromosome by the polymerase chain reaction amplification of sequence-tagged sites (STS-PCR) technique were performed in 126 patients affected by idiopathic oligo-azoospermia following accurate selection of cases. Seventeen patients evidenced an abnormal karyotype. Fourteen patients with a normal karyotype had microdeletions of the Y chromosome within interval 6. In azo-ospermic patients microdeletions were scattered along different subintervals, while in oligozoospermic patients they were clustered in subinterval 6E. The size of the deletion was not apparently related to the severity of the disease. These results suggest that cytogenetic analysis and the STS-PCR technique can detect a genetic cause of infertility in about one-quarter of patients with idiopathic oligo-azoospermia.

Analysis of the complete coding region of the CFTR gene in a cohort of CF patients from North-Eastern Italy: identification of 90% of the mutations

A complete coding-region analysis on 225 cystic fibrosis (CF) chromosomes from a cohort that includes all the affected subjects born in two North-Eastern Italian regions over eight years was performed. In a previous study, we identified mutations on 166/225 (73.8%) CF chromosomes after screening for 62 mutations. To characterise the remaining 59 CF chromosomes, we carried out automated direct DNA sequencing (exons 9 and 13), RNA single-strand conformation polymorphism (exons 1–8 and 10–12) and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (exons 14a–24) of the 27 exons and flanking regions of the CF transmembrane conductance regulator gene. We identified 22 mutations, four of which are novel, viz. 711+5G→A, R709X, 3132delTG and 2790-2An→G, and we characterised 90.2% (203/225) of the CF chromosomes. Taking advantage of the homogeneity of the sample, an evaluation of the most important clinical parameters, assessed at the age of 12 years, is presented. We confirm some previously reported genotype-phenotype correlations and we report a new nonsense mutation (R709X) associated with a pancreatic sufficient phenotype.

Genetic history of cystic fibrosis mutations in italy. I. Regional distribution

Earlier analysis of the Italian population showed patterns of genetic differentiation that were interpreted as being the result of population settlements going back to pre‐Roman times. DNA disease mutations may be a powerful tool in further testing this hypothesis since the analysis of diseased individuals can detect variants too rare to be resolved in normal individuals. We present data on the relative frequencies of 60 cystic fibrosis (CF) mutations in Italy and the geographical distribution of the 12 most frequent CF mutations screened in 3492 CF chromosomes originating in 13 Italian regions. The 12 most frequent mutations characterize about 73% of the Italian CF chromosomes. The most common mutation, ΔF508, has an average frequency of 51%, followed by N1303K and G542X, both with average frequencies around 5%. Multivariate analyses show that the relative frequencies of CF mutations are heterogeneous among Italian regions, and that this heterogeneity is weakly correlated with the geographical pattern of non‐DNA ‘classical’ genetic markers. The northern regions are well differentiated from the central‐southern regions and within the former group the western and eastern regions are remarkably distinct. Moreover, Sardinia shows the presence of mutation T338I, which seems absent in any other European CF chromosome. The north‐western regions of Italy, characterized by the mutation 1717‐1G→A, were under Celtic influence, while the north‐east regions, characterized by the mutations R1162X, 2183AA→G and 711 + 5G→A, were under the influence of the Venetic culture.

COMPLETE DETECTION OF MUTATIONS IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS PATIENTS OF NATIVE AMERICAN ORIGIN

An increased incidence of cystic fibrosis (CF) has been reported in some populations of Native Americans of the Southwest such as the Pueblo, which is a genetic isolate. As the most common mutation found in Caucasians (ΔF508) was absent and only one chromosome carried the G542X mutation, we decided to analyze the entire coding sequence of the CFTR gene in eight Pueblo CF patients. We have identified four different mutations: G542X, R1162X, 3849+10kbC→T, and D648V that account for these 16 haplotypes. The R1162X was found on 11 chromosomes. Using intragenic microsatellites, we have compared the haplotypes of those chromosomes to those of Italian origin where the R1162X mutation was initially reported. These haplotypes turned out to be identical, suggesting a common origin and an admixture with Italian or Spanish settlers, followed by typical founder effect. In contrast the 3849+10kbC→T mutation, which was found on three chromosomes, is associated with different haplotypes than those on chromosomes carrying the same mutation in Caucasians. A novel mutation, D648V, observed on one chromosome has not been found outside the Pueblo population.

The haemochromatosis mutations do not modify the clinical picture of thalassaemia major in patients regularly transfused and chelated

Iron overload is the main cause of morbidity and mortality in patients with thalassaemia major. In order to establish if the presence of the mutations recently described in the haemochromatosis gene affects the severity of iron overload in thalassaemia patients, we compared the prevalence of mutations C282Y and H63D in 216 young adults regularly transfused and chelated in North‐Eastern Italy with the frequency found in a group of blood donors from the same area. For each patient, mean serum ferritin over the last 3 years, liver iron concentration, and the presence of diabetes, hypogonadism and heart disease, were considered. The frequency of the C282Y allele was 1.9% in patients with thalassaemia major and 2.3% in blood donors (P = ns). The frequency of the H63D allele was 16.2% in patients with thalassaemia major and 15.3% in blood donors (P = ns). When age, liver iron concentration and mean yearly serum ferritin levels were compared in patients with and without mutations C282Y and H63D, no significant differences were found. Also, the prevalence of iron‐induced complications was not significantly different between patients carrying or not carrying the mutations. The presence of the HH mutations does not seem to influence the degree of iron overload and its consequences in regularly transfused and chelated patients with thalassaemia major.

Epidemiology and a novel procedure for large scale analysis of CFTR rearrangements in classic and atypical CF patients: A multicentric Italian study

BACKGROUND Mutation epidemiology in each ethnic group is a crucial step of strategies for cystic fibrosis (CF) diagnosis and counselling. To date, the scanning of the whole coding region of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene permits to identify about 90% of alleles from patients bearing CF and a lower percentage in patients bearing atypical CF. CFTR rearrangements in heterozygosis elude current techniques for molecular analysis, and some of them have been reported with a frequency up to 6% in various ethnic groups. METHODS Using quantitative PCR analysis of all coding regions, we assessed the occurrence of CFTR rearrangements in 130 alleles from classic CF patients and in 198 alleles from atypical CF patients (all unrelated and from Italian descent) bearing unidentified mutations after the scanning of CFTR. RESULTS Seven rearrangements (i.e., dele1, dele2, dele2_3, dele 14b_17b, dele17a_18, dele22_23, and dele22_24) were identified in 34/131 (26.0%) CF alleles bearing undetected mutations (which means about 2.5% of all CF alleles) and in none of the 198 alleles from atypical CF. The CFTR haplotype and the sequence analysis of the breakpoints confirmed the common origin of all the rearrangements. Thus, we set up a novel duplex PCR assay for the large-scale analysis of the seven rearrangements. The procedure was rapid (all PCR amplifications were obtained under the same conditions), costless and repeatable. CONCLUSIONS It is useful to select the CFTR rearrangements more frequent in specific ethnic groups and to set up procedures for large-scale analysis. Their study can be performed in cases in which a high detection rate is required (i.e., partners of CF carriers/patients). On the contrary, the analysis of rearrangement is useless in atypical CF patients.

Frequency of large CFTR gene rearrangements in Italian CF patients.

In most populations, an appreciable fraction of cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR) gene mutations in patients affected by cystic fibrosis (CF) cannot be identified, and large gene rearrangements might be missed by standard analyses. We have searched large gene rearrangements in a sample of 25 North East Italian CF patients who, after an extensive gene analysis of 188 patients, still bear one or two unidentified CF mutations. A systematic gene screening by quantitative multiplex PCR of short fluorescent fragments was performed. Overall, 5/26 (19.2%) rearranged alleles were detected, bearing mutation 3120+1Kbdel8.6Kb (three patients), and c.4_IVS1+69del119bpins299bp (two patients). These mutations were observed in compound heterozygotes with F508del or termination mutations, and a pancreatic insufficient form of CF. These findings confirm the frequency of CFTR gene rearrangements recently observed in French CF patients.