Cristina Musselli

Immunization of metastatic breast cancer patients with a fully synthetic globo H conjugate: A phase I trial

The carbohydrate antigen globo H commonly found on breast cancer cells is a potential target for vaccine therapy. The objectives of this trial were to determine the toxicity and immunogenicity of three synthetic globo H-keyhole limpet hemocyanin conjugates plus the immunologic adjuvant QS-21. Twenty-seven metastatic breast cancer patients received five vaccinations each. The vaccine was well tolerated, and no definite differences were observed among the three formulations. Serologic analyses demonstrated the generation of IgM antibody titers in most patients, with minimal IgG antibody stimulation. There was significant binding of IgM antibodies to MCF-7 tumor cells in 16 patients, whereas IgG antibody reactivity was observed in a few patients. There was evidence of complement-dependent cytotoxicity in several patients. Affinity column purification supported the specificity of IgM antibodies for globo H. On the basis of these data, globo H will constitute one component of a polyvalent vaccine for evaluation in high-risk breast cancer patients.

Fully Synthetic Carbohydrate-Based Vaccines in Biochemically Relapsed Prostate Cancer: Clinical Trial Results With α-N-Acetylgalactosamine-O-Serine/Threonine Conjugate Vaccine

PURPOSE We report the synthesis of a mucin-related O-linked glycopeptide, alpha-N-acetylgalactosamine-O-serine/threonine (Tn), which is highly simplistic in its structure and can induce a relevant humoral response when given in a trimer or clustered (c) formation. We tested for an antitumor effect, in the form of a change in the posttreatment versus pretreatment prostate-specific antigen (PSA) slopes, that might serve as a surrogate for effectiveness of vaccines in delaying the time to radiographic progression. METHODS We compared the antibody response to immunization with two conjugates, Tn(c)-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and Tn(c)-palmitic acid (PAM) with the saponin immunologic adjuvant QS21, in a phase I clinical trial in patients with biochemically relapsed prostate cancer. Patients received Tn(c)-KLH vaccine containing either 3, 7, or 15 microg of Tn(c) per vaccination. Ten patients received 100 microg of Tn(c)-PAM. QS21 was included in all vaccines. Five vaccinations were administered subcutaneously during 26 weeks with an additional booster vaccine at week 50. RESULTS Tn(c), when given with the carrier molecule KLH and QS21, stimulated the production of high-titer immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgG antibodies. Inferior antibody responses were seen with T(c)-PAM. There was no evidence of enhanced immunogenicity with increasing doses of vaccine. An antitumor effect in the form of a decline in posttreatment versus pretreatment PSA slopes was also observed. CONCLUSION A safe synthetic conjugate vaccine in a trimer formation was developed that can break immunologic tolerance by inducing specific humoral responses. It seemed to affect the biochemical progression of the disease as determined by a change in PSA log slope.

Comparison of the effect of different immunological adjuvants on the antibody and T-cell response to immunization with MUC1-KLH and GD3-KLH conjugate cancer vaccines

While the importance of immunological adjuvants for optimal induction of antibody and T-cell responses against tumor antigens is clear, the relevant potency of different adjuvants is not clear. We have screened 19 different immunological adjuvants with KLH conjugate vaccines containing the two human cancer antigens (MUC1 peptide and GD3 ganglioside) in the mouse. ELISA assays for IgM and IgG antibody responses as well as proliferation and cytokine release (IFN-gamma and IL-4) for T-cell responses were performed. Six adjuvants stood out as being especially effective for induction of IgM and IgG antibodies against both MUC1 and GD3: QS-21, TiterMax, MoGM-CSF, MPL/DETOX and CpG ODN. Of these QS-21, MPL/DETOX and MoGM-CSF were uniformly effective at inducing potent proliferation and potent IFN-gamma and IL-4 responses against KLH while TiterMax and CpG ODN generated potent IFN-gamma responses but less potent proliferation or IL-4 release. Overall, as in our previous experience, QS-21 was the most effective adjuvant. There was no clear evidence for induction of T-cell immunity against either GD3 or MUC1 with any of the adjuvants. There was a strong correlation between the antibodies induced against MUC1 and GD3 with different immunological adjuvants and the strength of the IFN-gamma release against KLH. This suggests that the primary role of adjuvants in the context of these conjugate vaccines may be induction of higher levels of T-cell immunity against KLH, which then leads to higher levels antibody against the conjugated antigens.

Induction of antibodies against GD3 ganglioside in melanoma patients by vaccination with GD3-lactone-KLH conjugate plus immunological adjuvant QS-21.

The gangliosides GD3, GD2 and GM2 are expressed on the cell surface of malignant melanomas, GD3 being the most abundant. We have shown that immunization of melanoma patients with GM2 adherent to Bacillus Calmette‐Guerin (GM2/BCG) induced an IgM antibody response. Vaccines containing GM2‐keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) conjugate and the immunological adjuvant QS‐21 induced a higher titer IgM response and consistent IgG antibodies. Patients with antibodies against GM2 survived longer than patients without antibody. On the other hand, our previous trials with GD3/BCG, GD3 derivatives including GD3‐lactone (GD3‐L)/BCG failed to induce antibodies against GD3. In our continuing efforts to induce antibody against GD3, we have immunized groups of 6 melanoma patients with GD3‐KLH or GD3‐L‐KLH conjugates containing 30 μg of ganglioside plus 100 μg of QS‐21 at 0, 1, 2, 3, 7 and 19 weeks. Prior to vaccination, no serological reactivity against GD3 or GD3‐L was detected. After immunization, IgM and IgG antibodies were detected against both GD3 and GD3‐L in the GD3‐L group exclusively. The GD3‐L‐KLH vaccine induced IgM titers against GD3‐L of 1:40–1/1,280 in all patients and IgG titers of 1/160–1/1,280 in 4 patients. These antibodies also strongly cross‐reacted with GD3. ELISA reactivity was confirmed by immune thin‐layer chromatography on GD3 and melanoma extracts. Sera obtained from 4 of these 6 patients showed cell surface reactivity by FACS and from 2 showed strong cell surface reactivity by immune adherence (IA) assay and complement lysis against the GD3 positive cell line SK‐Mel‐28. Int. J. Cancer 85:659–666, 2000.

Reevaluation of the cellular immune response in breast cancer patients vaccinated with MUC1.

Conjugation of antigens to a carrier protein like keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) has proven effective in clinical trials for inducing antibodies against selected tumor antigens. The impact of this approach on T‐cell immunity has not been previously tested. We utilized peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) obtained at leukapheresis from 6 breast cancer patients vaccinated 4 times each with a 106‐amino acid‐long MUC1 peptide conjugated with KLH plus immune adjuvant QS‐21. Proliferation after 6 days of in vitro culture and an interferon gamma ELISPOT assay with and without 6 days of in vitro sensitization with the immunizing antigen were used. Parallel experiments employed the use of the cytokine IL2. Our results indicate that despite a high response to KLH in all patients with precursor frequencies as high as 1/120 peripheral blood lymphocytes and augmentation of proliferation in excess of 200‐fold after vaccination, the T‐cell response against MUC1 peptide was minimal and inconsistent. The strength and consistency of the vaccine‐induced T‐cell response against KLH in these patients excludes general immune incompetence and assay insensitivity or inconsistency as explanations for the weak and inconsistent response against MUC1. We conclude that for any report of augmented T‐cell responses against MUC1 to be convincing, one or more postimmunization blood samples will be needed to demonstrate augmented MUC1‐specific immunity consistently on multiple occasions. Assuming this criteria, convincing induction of T‐cell immunity against MUC1 by vaccination has yet to be described.

Antibodies against Tumor Cell Glycolipids and Proteins, but Not Mucins, Mediate Complement-Dependent Cytotoxicity

One of several effector mechanisms thought to contribute to Ab efficacy against cancer is complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC). Serological analysis of a series of clinical trials conducted over a 10-year period suggested that six vaccines containing different glycolipids induced Abs mediating CDC whereas four vaccines containing carbohydrate or peptide epitopes carried almost exclusively by mucin molecules induced Abs that did not mediate CDC. To explore this further, we have now compared cell surface reactivity using flow cytometry assays (FACS), complement-fixing ability, and CDC activity of a panel of mAbs and immune sera from these trials on the same two tumor cell lines. Abs against glycolipids GM2, globo H and Lewis Y, protein KSA (epithelial cell adhesion molecule, also known as EpCAM) and mucin Ags Tn, sialylated Tn, Thomsen Friedenreich (TF), and MUC1 all reacted comparably by FACS with tumor cells expressing these Ags. Compared with the strong complement binding and CDC with Abs against glycolipids and KSA, complement binding was diminished with Abs against mucin Ags and no CDC was detected. A major difference between these two groups of Ags is proximity to the cell membrane. Glycolipids and globular glycoproteins extend less than 100 Å from the cell membrane while mucins extend up to 5000 Å. Although complement activation at sites remote from the cell membrane has long been known as a mechanism for resistance from complement lysis in bacteria, it is identified here for the first time as a factor which may contribute to resistance from CDC against cancer cells.

Safety and immunogenicity of long HSV-2 peptides complexed with rhHsc70 in HSV-2 seropositive persons

HSV-2, the primary causative agent of genital herpes, establishes latency in sensory ganglia and reactivates causing recurrent lesions and viral shedding. Induction or expansion of CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell responses are expected to be important for a successful therapeutic vaccine against HSV-2. A candidate vaccine consisting of 32 synthetic 35mer HSV-2 peptides non-covalently complexed with recombinant human Hsc70 protein (named HerpV, formerly AG-707) was tested for safety and immunogenicity in a Phase I study. These peptides are derived from 22 HSV-2 proteins representative of all phases of viral replication. Thirty-five HSV-2 infected participants were randomized and treated in one of four groups: HerpV+QS-21 (saponin adjuvant), HerpV, QS-21, or vehicle. The vaccine was well tolerated and safe. All seven participants with evaluable samples who were administered HerpV with QS-21 demonstrated a statistically significant CD4(+) T cell response to HSV-2 antigens, and the majority of such participants demonstrated a statistically significant CD8(+) T cell response as well. To our knowledge, this is the first candidate vaccine against HSV-2 to demonstrate a broad CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell response in HSV-2(+) participants, and the first HSP-based vaccine to show immune responses against viral antigens in humans.

A heat shock protein based polyvalent vaccine targeting HSV-2: CD4(+) and CD8(+) cellular immunity and protective efficacy.

Efforts to develop a subunit vaccine against genital herpes have been hampered by lack of knowledge of the protective antigens of HSV-2, the causative agent of the disease. Vaccines based either on selected antigens or attenuated live virus approaches have not demonstrated meaningful clinical activity. We present here results of a therapeutic vaccine candidate, HerpV (formerly called AG-707), consisting of 32 HSV-2 peptides derived from 22 HSV-2 proteins, complexed non-covalently to the HSP70 chaperone and formulated with QS-21 saponin adjuvant. HerpV is observed to be immunogenic, generating CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell responses in three mouse strains including HLA-A2 transgenic mice. Optimal T cell stimulation was dependent on the synergistic adjuvant properties of QS-21 with hsp70. The vaccine provided significant protection from viral challenge in a mouse prophylaxis model and showed signals of activity in a guinea pig therapeutic model of existing infection. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from human HSV-2(+) subjects also showed reactivity in vitro to a subset of individual peptides and to the pool of all 32 peptides. Recombinant human Hsc70 complexed with the 32 peptides also stimulated the expansion of CD8(+) T cells from HSV-2(+) subjects in vitro. These studies demonstrate that HerpV is a promising immunotherapy candidate for genital herpes, and provide a foundation for evaluating HerpV in human HSV-2(+) subjects with the intent of eliciting CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell responses to a broad array of viral antigens.

Autoimmune and Antitumor Consequences of Antibodies Against Antigens Shared by Normal and Malignant Tissues

There is now a considerable body of information documenting the autoimmune consequences of antibodies induced by growing malignancies, or by passively administered and actively induced antibodies, in cancer patients against antigens shared by normal and malignant tissues. This provides a rich source of information addressing the consequences of autoantibodies against a range of antigens. Antibodies against cell-surface or intracellular antigens in the central nervous system (CNS) or on epithelial surfaces of normal tissues do not generally result in autoimmunity, but the same types and titers of antibodies against cell surface antigens in the subepidermal skin, peripheral nerves, blood, or vascular sites such as the spleen and bone marrow readily induce autoimmunity. The blood brain barrier of the CNS and apical antigen expression and the basement membrane in epithelial tissues, may protect these sites from antibody induced damage. Cancer cells, however, are protected by neither unidirectional antigen expression nor basement membranes. Vaccine induced antibodies against a variety of cancer cell surface antigens have been associated with prevention of tumor recurrence in preclinical models and in vaccinated cancer patients, in the absence of demonstrable autoimmunity. This forms the basis for a series of ongoing Phase III trials with single or polyvalent antigen cancer vaccines designed for optimal antibody induction.

Immunization of mice with fucosyl-GM1 conjugated with keyhole limpet hemocyanin results in antibodies against human small-cell lung cancer cells

Abstract Fucosyl-GM1 (Fuc-GM1) [Fucα1 → 2Galβ1 → 3GalNAcβ1 → 4(NeuAcα2-3)Galβ1 → 4Glcβ1 → O-Cer] is a small-cell-lung-cancer (SCLC)-associated ganglioside initially defined by the murine monoclonal antibody F12. On the basis of its known distribution, Fuc-GM1 is a potential target for active immunotherapy in SCLC patients. Fuc-GM1 has been extracted and purified from bovine thyroid. The immunogenicity of Fuc-GM1 was tested in mice either alone, mixed with carrier protein keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) or covalently linked with KLH, plus immunological adjuvant QS-21. The Fuc-GM1-KLH conjugate plus QS-21 adjuvant was found to be optimal. It induced consistent IgM and IgG enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) titers against Fuc-GM1. These antibodies were strongly reactive with the strongly Fuc-GM1-positive rat hepatoma cell line H4-II-E, and they were moderately reactive with the moderately positive human SCLC cell line H146 by flow cytometry and complement-mediated lysis. Both ELISA and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) reactions were inhibited with Fuc-GM1or H4-II-E but not with the structurally related ganglioside GM1 or Fuc-GM1-negative colon cancer cell line LS-C. On the basis of these results, a vaccine comprising Fuc-GM1-KLH plus QS-21 is being prepared for testing in patients with SCLC.