D. De Leon

The DYT1 phenotype and guidelines for diagnostic testing

Objective: To develop diagnostic testing guidelines for the DYT1 GAG deletion in the Ashkenazi Jewish (AJ) and non-Jewish (NJ) primary torsion dystonia (PTD) populations and to determine the range of dystonic features in affected DYT1 deletion carriers. Methods: The authors screened 267 individuals with PTD; 170 were clinically ascertained for diagnosis and treatment, 87 were affected family members ascertained for genetic studies, and 10 were clinically and genetically ascertained and included in both groups. We used published primers and PCR amplification across the critical DYT1 region to determine GAG deletion status. Features of dystonia in clinically ascertained (affected) DYT1 GAG deletion carriers and noncarriers were compared to determine a classification scheme that optimized prediction of carriers. The authors assessed the range of clinical features in the genetically ascertained (affected) DYT1 deletion carriers and tested for differences between AJ and NJ patients. Results: The optimal algorithm for classification of clinically ascertained carriers was disease onset before age 24 years in a limb (misclassification, 16.5%; sensitivity, 95%; specificity, 80%). Although application of this classification scheme provided good separation in the AJ group (sensitivity, 96%; specificity, 88%), as well as in the group overall, it was less specific in discriminating NJ carriers from noncarriers (sensitivity, 94%; specificity, 69%). Using age 26 years as the cut-off and any site at onset gave a sensitivity of 100%, but specificity decreased to 54% (63% in AJ and 43% in NJ). Among genetically ascertained carriers, onset up to age 44 years occurred, although the great majority displayed early limb onset. There were no significant differences between AJ and NJ genetically ascertained carriers, except that a higher proportion of NJ carriers had onset in a leg, rather than an arm, and widespread disease. Conclusions: Diagnostic DYT1 testing in conjunction with genetic counseling is recommended for patients with PTD with onset before age 26 years, as this single criterion detected 100% of clinically ascertained carriers, with specificities of 43% to 63%. Testing patients with onset after age 26 years also may be warranted in those having an affected relative with early onset, as the only carriers we observed with onset at age 26 or later were genetically ascertained relatives of individuals whose symptoms started before age 26 years.

Phenotypic features of myoclonus-dystonia in three kindreds

Background Myoclonus-dystonia (M-D) is a movement disorder with involuntary jerks and dystonic contractions. Autosomal dominant alcohol-responsive M-D is associated with mutations in the &egr;-sarcoglycan gene (SGCE) (six families) and with a missense change in the D2 dopamine receptor (DRD2) gene (one family). Objective To investigate the clinical phenotype associated with M-D including motor symptoms, psychiatric disorders, and neuropsychological deficits. Methods Fifty individuals in three M-D families were evaluated and a standardized neurologic examination and DNA analysis were performed. Psychiatric profiles were established with the Diagnostic Interviews for Genetic Studies (DIGS) and the Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale (YBOCS). Cognition was evaluated with standardized neuropsychological tests. Results Distinct truncating mutations in the SGCE gene were identified in each family. Additionally, a missense alteration in the DRD2 gene was previously found in one family. Motor expression was variable, with onset of myoclonus or dystonia or both affecting the upper body and progression to myoclonus and dystonia in most cases. Psychiatric profiles revealed depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder, substance abuse, anxiety/panic/phobic disorders, and psychosis in two families, and depression only in the third family. Averaged scores from cognitive testing showed impaired verbal learning and memory in one family, impaired memory in the second family, and no cognitive deficits in the third family. Conclusions Cognitive deficits may be associated with M-D. Psychiatric abnormalities correlate with the motor symptoms in affected individuals. Assessment of additional M-D families with known mutations is needed to determine whether these are characteristic phenotypic manifestations of M-D.

Diagnostic criteria for dystonia in DYT1 families

Family studies of primary torsion dystonia have used the diagnostic categories of definite, probable, and possible dystonia for gene mapping and identification, but the validity of this hierarchical classification is not known. The authors assessed 147 DYT1 GAG deletion carriers and 113 blood-related noncarriers from 43 families. Only the category of definite dystonia was 100% specific. Probable dystonia, but not possible, was increased in carriers compared with noncarriers. The authors recommend that only those with definite signs of dystonia be considered affected in linkage and other genetic studies.

A study of idiopathic torsion dystonia in a non–jewish family: Evidence for genetic heterogeneity

A gene (DYT1) for idiopathic torsion dystonia (ITD) was mapped to chromosome 9q34 in non-Jewish and Jewish families; the dystonia in these families usually began in childhood, with the limb muscles affected first. The role of the DYT1 gene in adult-onset and cervical- or cranial-onset ITD is unknown. We examined 53 individuals from four generations of a non-Jewish North American family with adult-onset ITD. There were seven affected family members, with a mean age at onset of 28.4 years (range, 7 to 50 years). In six of the seven, the neck was affected first. All seven developed cervical dystonia, and dysarthria or dysphonia occurred in five. Linkage data excluded the region containing the DYT1 locus, indicating that DYT1 was not responsible for ITD in this family. This study provides evidence that a gene other than DYT1 is responsible for some cases of adult cervical-onset dystonia.

Clinical findings of a myoclonus-dystonia family with two distinct mutations

Myoclonus-dystonia has recently been associated with mutations in the epsilon-sarcoglycan gene (SCGE) on 7q21. Previously, the authors reported a patient with myoclonus-dystonia and an 18-bp deletion in the DYT1 gene on 9q34. The authors have now re-evaluated the patient harboring this deletion for mutations in the SGCE gene and identified a missense change. In the current study, the authors describe the clinical details of this family carrying mutations in two different dystonia genes. Further analysis of these mutations separately and together in cell culture and in animal models should clarify their functional consequences.

Genetic analysis of three patients with an 18p− syndrome and dystonia

Article abstract Some patients with an 18p− syndrome show dystonia, and a focal dystonia gene has been mapped to chromosome 18p. The authors evaluated the extent of the deletion in three patients with an 18p− syndrome and dystonia using 14 DNA markers on 18p. A common deleted area, covering the DYT7 locus, places the putative dystonia gene between the telomere of 18p and D18S1104 (49.6 cM). Dystonia in these patients may be caused by haploinsufficiency of the DYT7 gene, a new dystonia gene on 18p, or may result from developmental brain anomalies.

Secondary dystonia and the DYTI gene

Early-onset (<28 years) primary dystonia in most Ashkenazi Jews is due to a single founder mutation in the DYT1 gene on chromosome 9q34, as determined by very strong linkage disequilibrium with a haplotype of 9q34 alleles at surrounding marker loci. The role of this mutation in individuals with secondary causes for dystonia has never been tested, although environmental insults, such as neuroleptic exposure or perinatal asphyxia, are proposed to precipitate dystonia in genetically predisposed individuals. We assessed 9q34 haplotypes in 40 Ashkenazi patients with secondary dystonia; 25 had early onset of symptoms, including 15 with exposure to neuroleptic medication or perinatal asphyxia. Of the 25 patients with early onset, 9 were considered phenocopies of DYT1 having normal examinations except for dystonia, normal radiographic and other laboratory studies, and onset in a limb or the neck. Only one individual whose dystonia developed in the setting of a measles infection carried the associated haplotype. Our findings indicate that clinical diagnostic criteria that include historical information to detect tardive dystonia and perinatal asphyxia discriminate primary dystonia due to the DYT1 founder mutation. We found no evidence that the DYT1 founder mutation contributes to secondary dystonia.