D. M. Juriloff

An update to the list of mouse mutants with neural tube closure defects and advances toward a complete genetic perspective of neural tube closure

The number of mouse mutants and strains with neural tube defects (NTDs) now exceeds 240, including 205 representing specific genes, 30 for unidentified genes, and 9 multifactorial strains. These mutants identify genes needed for embryonic neural tube closure. Reports of 50 new NTD mutants since our 2007 review (Harris and Juriloff, 2007) were considered in relation to the previously reviewed mutants to obtain new insights into mechanisms of NTD etiology. In addition to null mutations, some are hypomorphs or conditional mutants. Some mutations do not cause NTDs on their own, but do so in digenic, trigenic, and oligogenic combinations, an etiology that likely parallels the nature of genetic etiology of human NTDs. Mutants that have only exencephaly are fourfold more frequent than those that have spina bifida aperta with or without exencephaly. Many diverse cellular functions and biochemical pathways are involved; the NTD mutants draw new attention to chromatin modification (epigenetics), the protease-activated receptor cascade, and the ciliopathies. Few mutants directly involve folate metabolism. Prevention of NTDs by maternal folate supplementation has been tested in 13 mutants and reduces NTD frequency in six diverse mutants. Inositol reduces spina bifida aperta frequency in the curly tail mutant, and three new mutants involve inositol metabolism. The many NTD mutants are the foundation for a future complete genetic understanding of the processes of neural fold elevation and fusion along mechanistically distinct cranial-caudal segments of the neural tube, and they point to several candidate processes for study in human NTD etiology.

A consideration of the evidence that genetic defects in planar cell polarity contribute to the etiology of human neural tube defects

A variety of human birth defects originate in failure of closure of the embryonic neural tube. The genetic cause of the most common nonsyndromic defects, spina bifida (SB) or anencephaly, is considered to be combinations of variants at multiple genes. The genes contributing to the etiology of neural tube closure defects (NTDs) are unknown. Mutations in planar cell polarity (PCP) genes in mice cause a variety of defects including the NTD, craniorachischisis, and sometimes SB or exencephaly (EX); they also demonstrate the role of digenic combinations of PCP mutants in NTDs. Recent studies have sought rare predicted-to-be-deleterious alterations (putative mutations) in coding sequence of PCP genes in human cases with various anomalies of the neural tube. This review summarizes the cumulative results of these studies according to a framework based on the embryopathogenesis of NTDs, and considers some of the insights from the approaches used and the limitations. Rare putative mutations in the PCP genes VANGL2, SCRIB, DACT1, and CELSR1 cumulatively contributed to over 20% of cases with craniorachischisis, a rare defect; no contributing variants were found for PRICKLE1 or PTK7. PCP rare putative mutations had a weaker role in myelomeningocele (SB), being found in approximately 6% of cases and cumulated across CELSR1, FUZ, FZD6, PRICKLE1, VANGL1, and VANGL2. These results demonstrate that PCP gene alterations contribute to the etiology of human NTDs. We recommend that future research should explore other types of PCP gene variant such as regulatory mutations and low frequency (1 to 5%) deleterious polymorphisms.

Genetic landmarks for defects in mouse neural tube closure

Many mutations cause neural tube closure defects (NTDs, exencephaly or spina bifida) in mice and the gene loci are widely distributed in the mouse genome. This compilation summarizes the map position of 40 mouse NTD mutations and the corresponding human linkage homology of each. It includes the nature of the gene product where known, and whether the NTD is part of a syndrome involving other developmental systems. Also listed are the several mouse strains known to have genetic susceptibility to exencephaly, with multifactorial genetic cause in at least one case. The purposes of this mouse NTD compilation are to enable recognition of patterns in genetic causes of NTDs, of molecular pathways essential for closure of specific regions of the mammalian neural tube, and of candidate regions for mapping loci contributing to human multifactorial NTDs.

Structure and Expression of Mobile ETnII Retroelements and Their Coding-Competent MusD Relatives in the Mouse

ABSTRACT ETnII elements are mobile members of the repetitive early transposon family of mouse long terminal repeat (LTR) retroelements and have caused a number of mutations by inserting into genes. ETnII sequences lack retroviral genes, but the recent discovery of related MusD retroviral elements with regions similar to gag, pro, and pol suggests that MusD provides the proteins necessary for ETnII transposition in trans. For this study, we analyzed all ETnII elements in the draft sequence of the C57BL/6J genome and classified them into three subtypes (α, β, and γ) based on structural differences. We then used database searches and quantitative real-time PCR to determine the copy number and expression of ETnII and MusD elements in various mouse strains. In 7.5-day-old embryos of a mouse strain in which two mutations due to ETnII-β insertions have been identified (SELH/Bc), we detected a three- to sixfold higher level of ETnII-β and MusD transcripts than in control strains (C57BL/6J and LM/Bc). The increased ETnII transcription level can in part be attributed to a higher number of ETnII-β elements, but 70% of the MusD transcripts appear to have been derived from one or a few MusD elements that are not detectable in C57BL/6J mice. This element belongs to a young MusD subgroup with intact open reading frames and identical LTRs, suggesting that the overexpressed element(s) in SELH/Bc mice might provide the proteins for the retrotransposition of ETnII and MusD elements. We also show that ETnII is expressed up to 30-fold more than MusD, which could explain why only ETnII, but not MusD, elements have been positively identified as new insertions.

The major locus for multifactorial nonsyndromic cleft lip maps to mouse chromosome 11.

Cleft lip with or without cleft palate, CL(P), a common human birth defect, has a genetically complex etiology. An animal model with a similarly complex genetic basis is established in the A/WySn mouse strain, in which 20% of newborn have CL(P). Using a newly created congenic strain, AEJ.A, and SSLP markers, we have mapped a major CL(P)-causing gene derived from the A/WySn strain. This locus, here named clf1 (cleft lip) maps to Chromosome (Chr) 11 to a region having linkage homology with human 17q21-24, supporting reports of association of human CL(P) with the retinoic acid receptor alpha (RARA) locus.

Effect of multifactorial genetic liability to exencephaly on the teratogenic effect of valproic acid in mice

The present study shows that the multifactorial genetic liability to spontaneous exencephaly in the SELH/Bc mouse strain (10-20% of embryos) also confers an elevated risk of exencephaly induced by valproic acid. Treatment of pregnant dams (600 mg/kg sodium valproate in distilled water, i.p.) during the critical period on day 8 (D8) of gestation resulted in D14 exencephaly frequencies of 69% in SELH/Bc contrasted with 39% in each of the SWV/Bc and ICR/Bc strains. Analysis of these data under the assumptions of the threshold model indicated that the valproic acid-induced-shift in mean liability was similar for all three strains, and therefore the effects of genotype and teratogen were additive, not synergistic. A similar exencephaly response pattern for the same three strains was observed previously with retinoic acid [Tom et al. (1991) Teratology 43:27-40], a pattern that, combined with the data of Finnell et al. [(1988) Teratology 38:313-320], argues that strain differences in exencephaly response are not due to strain differences in teratogen metabolism. SWV/Bc and ICR/Bc embryos differ in location of the Closure 2 initiation site of cranial neural tube closure [Juriloff et al. (1991) Teratology 44:225-233], but the observation that they do not differ in risk of exencephaly produced by either valproic acid or retinoic acid contradicts the hypothesis that this particular morphological difference underlies strain differences in exencephaly risk. The high exencephaly response of SELH/Bc to two teratogens predicts that human conceptuses with a genetically determined elevated risk for neural tube defects could be easily tipped into high risk by mild teratogens.

exma: an X-linked insertional mutation that disrupts forebrain and eye development.

Abstract. Formation of the neural tube plays a primary role in establishing the body plan of the vertebrate embryo. Here we describe the phenotype and physical mapping of a highly penetrant X-linked male-lethal murine mutation, exma (exencephaly, microphthalmia/anophthalmia), that specifically disrupts development of the rostral neural tube and eye. The mutation arose from the random insertion of a transgene into the mouse X Chromosome (Chr). Eighty-three percent of transgenic male embryos display an open, disorganized forebrain and lack optic vesicles. No transgenic males survive beyond birth. Hemizygous females show a variable phenotype, including reduced viability and occasional exencephaly and/or microphthalmia. Altered or reduced expression patterns of Otx2, Pax6, Six3, and Mrx, known markers of early forebrain and eye development, confirmed the highly disorganized structure of the forebrain and lack of eye development in affected exma male embryos. Physical mapping of the transgene by FISH localized a single insertion site to the interval between Dmd and Zfx on the X Chr. A 1-Mb contig of BAC clones was assembled by using sequences flanking the transgene and revealed that the insertion lies close to Pola1 and Arx, a gene encoding a highly conserved homeobox protein known to be expressed in the developing forebrain of the mouse. Data from Southern blots of normal and transgenic DNA demonstrated that a large segment of DNA encompassing Arx and including part of Pola1 was duplicated as a result of the transgene insertion. From the physical mapping results, we propose a model of the gross rearrangements that accompanied transgene integration and discuss its implications for evaluating candidate genes for exma.

The clf1 gene maps to a 2- to 3-cM region of distal mouse Chromosome 11

Species: Mouse Locus name: cleft lip Locus symbol: clfl Map position: Centromere-Dl lMit200, 265, 199, 146-clfl, DllMit126, 10, 166, 58-DllMit258 Method o f mapping: SSLPs differing between A/WySn and AEJ/ RkBc were typed in AEJ.A/Jur congenic strain mice (NE10-12) previously proven to be clfl/+ by progeny testing. The pedigree relationships among the animals used (Fig. 1) has been published previously [1]. Animals 923 and 992 (sire and son) shared a common ancestor with animals 976, 1006, and 1115 (sire and sons) four and three generat ions previously. Animals from other branches of the pedigree were not used because their differential chromosome segment is large (unpublished data). Molecular reagents: Primer pairs for SSLPs (simple sequence length polymorphisms) were obtained from Research Genetics, Inc. [2]. Allele detection: Polymerase chain reactions were carried out according to the instructions supplied with the primers. The amplification products were resolved on NuSieve 3:1 agarose or 3.5% Metaphor (FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, Maine), stained with ethidium bromide. Discussion: Previously clfl was mapped to a 10-cM segment of Chromosome (Chr) 11 by linked markers carried along with the cleft lip liability trait in the AEJ.A/Jur congenic strain [1,3]. With the identification of additional informative SSLPs within this region, and identification of two branches of the congenic lineage having shortened differential chromosome segments, the region containing clfl has been redefined to a 2to 3-cM segment between a proximal block of markers of unknown order that comprises Dl lMit146, 199, 200, 265, and a distal marker Dl lMit258 (Fig. 1). The informative markers contained within the current minimal differential segment are DllMitlO, 58, 126, 166. Our data concur with recent data from Kuramoto et al. [4] that indicate that DllMit58 (non-Framework on MIT Genome Center Genetic Map) is near DllMitlO and distal to DllMit59. As DllMit58 is derived from the gene Myla [2], it provides a useful anchor for clfl to the gene locus map. This reduction of the chromosomal segment containing clfl enables potential elimination of known loci in the region as candidate genes based on their map position relative to the SSLPs in the area. One of the former potential candidate loci, Rara, now seems well mapped outside the candidate region [5] and association between RARA and cleft lip _+ cleft palate in some human pedigrees [6,7] if homologous, would be owing to linkage disequilibrium with a clefting locus, not a direct effect of RARA itself.

The lidgap-Gates (lgGa) mutation for open eyelids at birth maps to mouse Chromosome 13

Complex nonadditive interactions between specific alleles at multiple loci may underlie many so-called multifactorial threshold birth defects. The open-eyelids-at-birth defect in mice is a good model for these defects, and an understanding of its genetic complexity begins with mapping the participating loci. The open-eyelids defect can be part of a syndrome or can occur with no other obvious phenotypic effects. Of the latter nonsyndromic forms, the lidgap series includes four extant mutations that are considered to be alleles based on complementation tests. All show genetic complexity in segregation ratios. None has been mapped previously. On the basis of a strategy of mapping the mutation with the simplest inheritance pattern first, we generated an extensive exclusion map for lidgap-Gates, lgGa, using morphological and protein polymorphisms. We then screened the non-excluded regions in a congenic strain, AEJ.LGG—lgGa, for SSLP markers and located the differential chromosome segment containing the lgGa locus in a region near the distal end of mouse Chromosome (Chr) 13. This linkage was confirmed and refined by typing SSLPs in 64 F2 and 74 BC1 progeny of a cross of LGG/Bc (lgGa/lgGa) to SWV/Bc. The lgGa mutation maps to a 1- to 2-cM region between D13Mit76 and D13Mit53. Integrin alpha 1 and integrin alpha 2, which map to the same general region, are possible candidate loci, based on their embryonic expression and cellular function. Evidence is also presented for a common unlinked recessive suppressor of the open eyelids trait caused by lgGa.

Accelerated embryonic development associated with increased risk of neural tube defects induced by maternal diet in offspring of SELH/Bc mice†

BACKGROUND The SELH/Bc mouse strain has a high risk of the NTD, exencephaly, caused by multifactorial genetics. All SELH/Bc embryos have delayed elevation of neural folds; some never elevate (future exencephalics). Maternal diets affect SELH/Bc exencephaly rates: 25-35% on Purina Diet 5015 versus 5-10% on Purina Diet 5001. We hypothesized that in SELH/Bc, the diets affect maternal blood glucose and embryonic developmental rate. METHODS We compared mice fed the two diets. On GD 9.4 we tested maternal blood glucose and examined embryos for developmental age (somite count) and cranial neural fold morphology. We observed GD 14 exencephaly rates. RESULTS Diet 5015 caused fivefold more exencephaly (40 vs. 7% on GD 14), significantly higher mean maternal blood glucose in replicate experiments (6.3 vs. 5.5, p < .05; 6.3 vs. 5.3 mmol/L, p < .05), and significantly higher mean litter somite count on GD 9.4 (18.4 vs. 15.0, p < .05; 16.7 vs. 14.4 somites, p < .05). Among midrange embryos (15-16 somites), embryos from Diet 5015 were significantly shifted to earlier stages of midbrain fold morphology and had significantly more distance between the tips of the folds (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS In SELH/Bc mice, the 5015 diet causes higher maternal blood glucose, a faster overall embryonic developmental rate during neural tube closure, and delayed midbrain fold elevation relative to overall development. This pattern suggests that maternal dietary effects that modestly increase embryonic growth rate may exacerbate a lack of coordination between genetically delayed neural folds and normally developing underlying tissues, increasing risk of NTD.