D. Macias

Analysis of the molecular cascade responsible for mesodermal limb chondrogenesis: sox genes and BMP signaling

Here, we have studied how Sox genes and BMP signaling are functionally coupled during limb chondrogenesis. Using the experimental model of TGFbeta1-induced interdigital digits, we dissect the sequence of morphological and molecular events during in vivo chondrogenesis. Our results show that Sox8 and Sox9 are the most precocious markers of limb cartilage, and their induction is independent and precedes the activation of BMP signaling. Sox10 appears also to cooperate with Sox9 and Sox8 in the establishment of the digit cartilages. In addition, we show that experimental induction of Sox gene expression in the interdigital mesoderm is accompanied by loss of the apoptotic response to exogenous BMPs. L-Sox5 and Sox6 are respectively induced coincident and after the expression of Bmpr1b in the prechondrogenic aggregate, and their activation correlates with the induction of Type II Collagen and Aggrecan genes in the differentiating cartilages. The expression of Bmpr1b precedes the appearance of morphological changes in the prechondrogenic aggregate and establishes a landmark from which the maintenance of the expression of all Sox genes and the progress of cartilage differentiation becomes dependent on BMPs. Moreover, we show that Ventroptin precedes Noggin in the modulation of BMP activity in the developing cartilages. In summary, our findings suggest that Sox8, Sox9, and Sox10 have a cooperative function conferring chondrogenic competence to limb mesoderm in response to BMP signals. In turn, BMPs in concert with Sox9, Sox6, and L-Sox5 would be responsible for the execution and maintenance of the cartilage differentiation program.

Retinoic acid regulates programmed cell death through BMP signalling

rogrammed cell death by apoptosis is one of the major driving forces that shape and pattern the organs and tissues of a developing embryo. One of the best model systems for the study of apoptosis is the interdigital cell death (INZ) that occurs during the outgrowth of the vertebrate limb. However, although much has been learned about the cells involved in this process, the molecular mechanisms underlying INZ remain unclear. Retinoic acid (RA) and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) are two of the signalling components known to be involved in INZ. However, the exact relationships between these two factors in controlling cell death remain unknown. Here we show that RA can control INZ by promoting BMP gene expression and simultaneously repressing the chondrogenic potential of BMPs. We found that RA-soaked beads implanted in the interdigital regions of the chick limb bud promoted apoptosis before the onset of physiological INZ (assessed by neutral red vital staining and TUNEL assay; Fig. 1a–c). Furthermore, interdigital web regression was accelerated (Fig. 1d,e). These effects were preceded by upregulation of different members of the BMP gene family (bmp-7, Fig. 1f,g and bmp-4, not shown). In accordance with these findings, the P

Bone Morphogenetic Proteins Regulate Interdigital Cell Death in the Avian Embryo

The embryonic limb bud provides an excellent model for analyzing the mechanisms that regulate programmed cell death during development. At the time of digit formation in the developing autopod, the undifferentiated distal mesodermal cells may undergo or chondrogenic differentiation or apoptosis depending whether they are incorporated into the future digital rays or into the interdigital spaces. Both chondrogenesis or apoptosis are induced by local BMPS. However, whereas the chondrogenic‐promoting activity of BMPs appears to be regulated through the BMPR‐ 1b receptor, the mechanism by which the BMPs execute the death program remains unknown. The BMP proapoptotic activity requires the expression of members of the msx family of closely related homeobox‐containing genes and is finally mediated by caspase activation, but the nature of the caspase(s) directly responsible for the cell death is also unknown. Finally, other growth factors present in the developing autopod at the stages of digit formation such as members of the FGF and TGFβ families modulate the ability of BMPs to induce cell death or chondrogenesis.

Activin/TGFβ and BMP crosstalk determines digit chondrogenesis

The progress zone (PZ) is a specialized area at the distal margin of the developing limb where mesodermal cells are kept in proliferation and undifferentiated, allowing limb outgrowth. At stages of digit morphogenesis the PZ cells can undergo two possible fates, either aggregate initiating chondrogenic differentiation to configure the digit blastemas, or to die by apoptosis if they are incorporated in the interdigital mesenchyme. While both processes are controlled by bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) the molecular basis for such contrasting differential behavior of the autopodial mesoderm remains unknown. Here we show that a well-defined crescent domain of high BMP activity located at the tip of the forming digits, which we termed the digit crescent (DC), directs incorporation and differentiation of the PZ mesenchymal cells into the digit aggregates. The presence of this domain does not correlate with an exclusive expression domain of BMP receptors and its abrogation by surgical approaches or by local application of BMP antagonists is followed by digit truncation and cell death. We further show that establishment of the DC is directed by Activin/TGFbeta signaling, which inhibits Smad 6 and Bambi, two specific BMP antagonists expressed in the interdigits and progress zone mesoderm. The interaction between Activin/TGFbeta and BMP pathways at the level of DC promotes the expression of the chondrogenic factor SOX9 accompanied by a local decrease in cell proliferation. Characteristically, the DC domain is asymmetric, it being extended towards the posterior interdigit. The presence of the DC is transitorily dependent of the adjacent posterior interdigit and its maintenance requires also the integrity of the AER.

IN VIVO INHIBITION OF PROGRAMMED CELL DEATH BY LOCAL ADMINISTRATION OF FGF-2 AND FGF-4 IN THE INTERDIGITAL AREAS OF THE EMBRYONIC CHICK LEG BUD

The formation of the digits in amniote vertebrates is accompanied by a massive degeneration process that accounts for the disappearance of the interdigital mesenchyme. The establishment of these areas of interdigital cell death (INZs) is concomitant with the flattening of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), but a possible causal relationship between these processes has not been demonstrated. Recent studies have shown that the function of the AER can be substituted for by implantation of beads bearing either FGF-2 or FGF-4 into the apical mesoderm of the early limb bud. According to these observations, if the onset of INZs is triggered by the cessation of the AER function, local administration of FGFs to the interdigital tissue prior to cell death should delay or inhibit interdigit degeneration. In the present study we have confirmed this prediction. Implanting Affi-gel blue or heparin beads pre-absorbed with either FGF-2 or FGF-4 into the interdigital tissue of the chick leg bud in the stages prior to cell death stimulates cell proliferation and causes the formation of webbed digits. Vital staining with neutral red confirmed an intense temporal inhibition of interdigital cell death after FGF treatment. This inhibition of interdigital cell death was not accompanied by modifications in the pattern of expression of Msx-1 or Msx-2 genes, which in normal development display a domain of expression in the interdigital tissue preceding the onset of degeneration.

Experimental analysis of the in vivo chondrogenic potential of the interdigital mesenchyme of the chick leg bud subjected to local ectodermal removal

Current in vitro investigations suggest that ectoderm plays a major role in limb morphogenesis by producing a diffusible factor which inhibits the chondrogenesis of the underlying mesenchyme. In the present work we report evidence supporting such an ectodermal role in vivo. Surgical removal of the marginal ectoderm from the third interdigit of chick leg buds at stages 27 to 30 induces the formation of PNA-positive prechondrogenic mesenchymal condensations 15 hr after the operation. The incidence of prechondrogenic condensations achieved 47, 95.2, and 92.8 of the experimental embryos of stages 27, 28, and 29, respectively. This high rate of prechondrogenic aggregate formation contrasted with a lower incidence of ectopic cartilage formation detectable by Alcian blue staining 40 hr after the operation. The sequential analysis of the experimental interdigits by means of peanut lectin labeling suggests that a number of prechondrogenic condensations undergo disaggregation 20 and 30 hr after the operation failing to form fully differentiated cartilages. When ectoderm removal was accompanied by the elimination of a variable amount of interdigital mesenchyme the incidence of prechondrogenic aggregates showed little differences but the formation of fully differentiated cartilages was reduced at a rate proportional to the amount of interdigital mesenchyme removed. From this study it can be concluded that the ectoderm in vivo appears to inhibit the process of aggregation of the mesenchymal cells to form prechondrogenic condensations. Furthermore our results suggest that as observed in vitro (C. P. Cotrill, C. Archer, and L. Wolpert, 1987, Dev. Biol. 122, 503-515) the transformation of prechondrogenic aggregates into fully differentiated cartilage requires the involvement of a critical amount of mesenchymal cells.

Regulation by members of the transforming growth factor beta superfamily of the digital and interdigital fates of the autopodial limb mesoderm.

Abstract Embryonic limb outgrowth is accomplished by the proliferation of mesodermal cells in the progress zone. In this region, mesodermal cells are maintained in an undifferentiated and proliferating state by the action of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER). Differentiation of these cells into individual skeletal elements occurs when the cells are displaced proximally and leave the influence of the AER as a consequence of the accumulation of cells in that region. Here we review the evidence obtained in the last few years showing that members of the transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ) subfamily and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) act as proximal signals in the autopod regulating the fate of the progress zone cells towards chondrogenesis or apoptosis. Our findings show that apoptosis is regulated by BMPs while chondrogenesis requires the interaction of TGFβs and BMPs. Fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) produced by the AER exert an opposite function to both TGFβs and BMPs, maintaining the progress zone cells in an undifferentiated state.

Comparative analysis of the expression and regulation of Wnt5a, Fz4, and Frzb1 during digit formation and in micromass cultures.

Previous studies have shown that three members of the Wnt signaling pathway, the ligand WNT5A, the receptor FZ4, and the Wnt antagonist FRZB1, are implicated in the formation and differentiation of the digits. In this study, we have attempted to establish a functional correlation between them by comparing their expression patterns and their regulation by the signals controlling proliferation and differentiation of the limb mesoderm during formation of the avian digits in vivo and in micromass cultures. In vivo Wnt5a and Fz4 are expressed in the undifferentiated mesoderm of the autopod and in the differentiating digit cartilages. In the undifferentiated mesoderm, the expression of both genes is regulated positively by FGFs and negatively by bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). As chondrogenic differentiation starts, Fz4 becomes intensely up‐regulated in the aggregate and in the developing perichondrium, whereas transcripts of Wnt5a are excluded from the core of the aggregate but maintained in the surrounding mesenchyme and perichondrium. In addition, at this stage, the expression of both genes become positively regulated by BMPs. These changes in expression and regulation are coincident with the induction of Frzb1 in the chondrogenic aggregate, which is expressed under the positive control of BMPs. Our findings fit with a role of Wnt5a/Fz4 negatively regulating in vivo the initiation and progression of cartilage differentiation. In vitro, only Frzb1 is expressed and regulated in a manner resembling that observed in vivo. Wnt5a and Fz4 are both expressed in the differentiating mesenchyme of micromass cultures, but their expression is not significantly regulated by the addition of FGF‐2 or BMP‐7 to the culture medium.

The Interdigital Spaces of the Chick Leg Bud as a Model for Analysing Limb Morphogenesis and Cell Differentiation

Normal embryonic development is not a linear process of cell and tissue growth and differentiation (Hurle, 1988). There are many examples in which an early embryonic structure undergoes a reshaping process involving a substantial phenomenon of cell death. In some cases the tissue loss affects to fully formed organs which play a transitory functional role in the developing individual. This is the case of the loss of the tail in the developing anura amphibia during metamorphosis. In other cases cell death appears closely linked to morphogenesis an appears to play an sculpturing role for the achievement of the final shape of a developing structure. This appears to be the case in “interdigital cell death” occurring during morphogenesis of the digits of the amniote embryos.

Interdigital chondrogenesis and extra digit formation in the duck leg bud subjected to local ectoderm removal

SummaryIn the chick embryo the interdigital tissue in the stages previous to cell death exhibits in vitro a high chondrogenic potential, and forms extra digits when subjected in vivo to local ectodermal removal. In the present work we have analyzed the chondrogenic potential both in vivo and in vitro of the interdigital mesenchyme of the duck leg bud. As distinct from the chick, the interdigital mesenchyme of the duck leg bud exhibits a low degree of degeneration, resulting in the formation of webbed digits. Our results show that duck interdigital mesenchyme exhibits also a high chondrogenic potential in vitro until the stages in which cell death starts. Once cell death is finished chondrogenesis becomes negative and the interdigital mesenchyme forms a fibroblastic tissue. In vivo the interdigital mesenchyme of the duck leg bud subjected to ectoderm removal forms ectopic foci of chondrogenesis with a range of incidence similar to that in the chick. Unlike those of the chick the ectopic cartilages of the duck are rounded and smaller, and appear to be located at the distal margin of the interdigital mesenchyme. Formation of extra digits in the duck occurs with a lower incidence than in the chick. It is concluded that ectopic chondrogenesis and formation of extra digits is related to the intensity of interdigital cell death. The non-degenerating interdigital mesenchymal cells destined to form the interdigital webs of the duck appear to contribute very little to the formation of interdigital cartilages.