Dalibor Breznan

Cytotoxicity of carbon nanotube variants: a comparative in vitro exposure study with A549 epithelial and J774 macrophage cells.

Abstract While production of engineered carbon nanotubes (CNTs) has escalated in recent years, knowledge of risk associated with exposure to these materials remains unclear. We report on the cytotoxicity of four CNT variants in human lung epithelial cells (A549) and murine macrophages (J774). Morphology, metal content, aggregation/agglomeration state, pore volume, surface area and modifications were determined for the pristine and oxidized single-walled (SW) and multi-walled (MW) CNTs. Cytotoxicity was evaluated by cellular ATP content, BrdU incorporation, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release, and CellTiter-Blue (CTB) reduction assays. All CNTs were more cytotoxic than respirable TiO2 and SiO2 reference particles. Oxidation of CNTs removed most metallic impurities but introduced surface polar functionalities. Although slopes of fold changes for cytotoxicity endpoints were steeper with J774 compared to A549 cells, CNT cytotoxicity ranking in both cell types was assay-dependent. Based on CTB reduction and BrdU incorporation, the cytotoxicity of the polar oxidized CNTs was higher compared to the pristine CNTs. In contrast, pristine CNTs were more cytotoxic than oxidized CNTs when assessed for cellular ATP and LDH. Correlation analyses between CNTs’ physico–chemical properties and average relative potency revealed the impact of metal content and surface area on the potency values estimated using ATP and LDH assays, while surface polarity affected the potency values estimated from CTB and BrdU assays. We show that in order to reliably estimate the risk posed by these materials, in vitro toxicity assessment of CNTs should be conducted with well characterized materials, in multiple cellular models using several cytotoxicity assays that report on distinct cellular processes.

Cytotoxic and inflammatory potential of size-fractionated particulate matter collected repeatedly within a small urban area.

BackgroundExposure to coarse, fine, and ultrafine particles is associated with adverse population health impacts. We investigated whether size-fractionated particles collected repeatedly in the vicinity of industrial (steel mills and associated coking operations, wastewater treatment), high traffic, and residential areas display systematic differences in biological potency.MethodsParticulate matter (PM<0.1, PM0.1–0.5, PM0.5–2.5, PM2.5–10, PM>10) samples collected at sites within Windsor, Ontario, were screened for biological potency in human A549 lung epithelial and murine J774A.1 macrophage-like cells using cytotoxicity bioassays (cellular ATP, resazurin reduction, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release), cytokine production, and transcript profiles. Potency was determined from the slope of each dose-effect relationship.ResultsCytotoxic potency varied across size fractions and within a fraction across sites and sampling periods, suggesting that particle composition, in addition to size and mass, affected particle toxicity. While ATP and LDH profiles showed some similarity, resazurin reduction (a measure of metabolic activity) exhibited a unique pattern of response, indicating that the cytotoxicity assays were sensitive to distinct particle characteristics. Chemical speciation varied in relation to prevailing winds, consistent with enrichment of source emissions (e.g. higher metal and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon content downwind of the industrial site). Notwithstanding this variability, site-dependent differences in particle toxicity were evident, including greater potency of coarse fractions at the industrial site and of ultrafine particles at the traffic site (Site × Size interactions, p < 0.05). Regression of potency against particle constituents revealed correlations between resazurin reduction, induction of metal-responsive genes, and metal content, which were particularly strong for the coarse fraction, and between cytokine release and endotoxin, suggesting that these factors were important drivers of biological effects that explain, at least in part, the contrasting potencies of particles compared on an equivalent mass basis.ConclusionsThe data show that 1) particle potency and composition can exhibit significant temporal variation in relation to source contributions; 2) sources may differentially impact the potency of specific size fractions; and 3) particle constituents, notably metals and endotoxin, may elicit distinct biological responses. Together, the data are consistent with the notion that sources and composition, in addition to size and mass concentration, are relevant to particle toxicity.

Effects of ambient air particles on the endothelin system in human pulmonary epithelial cells (A549)

Inhalation of urban particles results in higher circulating levels of the vasoconstrictor peptide endothelin-1 (ET-1), which may account for the adverse cardiovascular impacts associated with air pollution. The objective of this study was to examine the direct effects of urban particles on the production of ET-1 by human epithelial cells (A549). A549 cells were exposed to TiO2, SiO2, Ottawa urban particulate matter EHC-93, and fractions of the urban particles. The levels of ET-1, interleukin-8 (IL-8) and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) in the culture medium were detected by ELISA. The mRNA levels of preproET-1, endothelin converting enzyme (ECE-1), ETa receptor and ETb receptor, matrix metalloproteinase (MMP-2), tissue inhibitor of MMP (TIMP-2), and heat shock protein (HSP-70) were determined by quantitative real-time RT-PCR. Cluster analysis of the variables identified similarities in the patterns of effects. Cluster I comprised variables that were primarily inhibited by particles: ET-1 and MMP-2 mRNAs, ET-1 and bigET-1 peptides, and cell viability. Clusters II and III comprised variables that were either inhibited or induced, depending on the test material: HSP-70, ETaR and ECE mRNAs, and IL-8 and VEGF proteins. Cluster IV comprised variables that were mainly induced by particle preparations: ETbR and TIMP-2 mRNAs. The decreased expression of preproET-1 in A549 cells suggests that epithelial cells may not be the source of higher pulmonary ET-1 spillover in the circulation measured in vivo in response to inhaled urban particles. However, higher ECE-1 in A549 cells after exposure to particles suggests an increased ability to process bigET-1 into the mature ET-1 peptide, while increased receptor expression implies higher responsiveness. The increased release of IL-8 and VEGF by epithelial cells in response to particles could possibly upregulate ET-1 production in the adjacent pulmonary capillary endothelial cells, with concomitant increased ET-1 spillover in the systemic circulation.

Effects of ambient air particles on nitric oxide production in macrophage cell lines

We assessed thein vitro toxicity of various particles on three murine macrophage cell lines, (J774A.1, WR19M.1, RAW264.7). The cells were exposed to aqueous suspensions (0–100 μg/30 mm2 well) of urban particulate matter (SRM-1648, SRM-1649, EHC-93), fine particulate matter (PM2.5), titanium dioxide (SRM-154b), and respirable cristobalite (SRM-1879) for 2 h and were then stimulated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS, 100 ng/ml) and recombinant interferon-gamma (IFN, 100 U/ml). After overnight incubation with the particles and LPS/IFN, nitric oxide production was estimated from culture supernatant nitrite. Cell viability was determined by monitoring the rate of AlamarBlue™ reduction. The dose-effect relationships for nitrite and viability were modeled as a power function (Fold change=[Dose+1]β), where β represents the slope of the dose-response curve. Potency was defined as the rate of change in nitrite production corrected for cell viability (βPOTENCY = βNITRITE − βVIABILITY). Overall, the urban particles decreased nitric oxide production (βPOTENCY < 0), while exposure of the cells to fine particulate matter or cristobalite increased the production of nitric oxide (βPOTENCY > 0). Titanium dioxide (TiO2) was essentially inactive (βPOTENCY ≈ 0). The decrease in nitric oxide production seen in cells exposed to the urban particles was directly correlated to a decrease in the expression of inducible nitric oxide (iNOS) as determined by Western blot analysis. The results indicate that particles are modulators of nitric oxide production in murine macrophages and may directly disrupt expression of iNOS during concomitant pathogen exposure. Pathways leading to enhanced NO production causing cell injury, and to decreased NO release resulting in lower bacterial clearance, may both be relevant to the health effects of ambient particles.

Differential cytotoxic and inflammatory potency of amorphous silicon dioxide nanoparticles of similar size in multiple cell lines

Abstract The likelihood of environmental and health impacts of silicon dioxide nanoparticles (SiNPs) has risen, due to their increased use in products and applications. The biological potency of a set of similarly-sized amorphous SiNPs was investigated in a variety of cells to examine the influence of physico-chemical and biological factors on their toxicity. Cellular LDH and ATP, BrdU incorporation, resazurin reduction and cytokine release were measured in human epithelial A549, human THP-1 and mouse J774A.1 macrophage cells exposed for 24 h to suspensions of 5–15, 10–20 and 12 nm SiNPs and reference particles. The SiNPs were characterized in dry state and in suspension to determine their physico-chemical properties. The dose-response data were simplified into particle potency estimates to facilitate the comparison of multiple endpoints of biological effects in cells. Mouse macrophages were the most sensitive to SiNP exposures. Cytotoxicity of the individual cell lines was correlated while the cytokine responses differed, supported by cell type-specific differences in inflammation-associated pathways. SiNP (12 nm), the most cytotoxic and inflammogenic nanoparticle had the highest surface acidity, dry-state agglomerate size, the lowest trace metal and organics content, the smallest surface area and agglomerate size in suspension. Particle surface acidity appeared to be the most significant determinant of the overall biological activity of this set of nanoparticles. Combined with the nanoparticle characterization, integration of the biological potency estimates enabled a comprehensive determination of the cellular reactivity of the SiNPs. The approach shows promise as a useful tool for first-tier screening of SiNP toxicity.

Non-specific interaction of carbon nanotubes with the resazurin assay reagent: impact on in vitro assessment of nanoparticle cytotoxicity.

In vitro cytotoxicity assays are essential tools in the screening of engineered nanomaterials (NM) for cellular toxicity. The resazurin live cell assay is widely used because it is non-destructive and is well suited for high-throughput platforms. However, NMs, in particular carbon nanotubes (CNT) can interfere in assays through quenching of transmitted light or fluorescence. We show that using the resazurin assay with time-point reading of clarified supernatants resolves this problem. Human lung epithelial (A549) and murine macrophage (J774A.1) cell lines were exposed to NMs in 96-well plates in 200 μL of media/well. After 24 h incubation, 100 μL of supernatant was removed, replaced with resazurin reagent in culture media and aliquots at 10 min and 120 min were transferred to black-wall 96-well plates. The plates were quick-spun to sediment the residual CNTs and fluorescence was top-read (λEx=540 nm, λEm=600 nm). The procedure was validated for CNTs as well as silica nanoparticles (SiNP). There was no indication of reduction of resazurin by the CNTs. Stability of resorufin, the fluorescent product of the resazurin reduction was then assessed. We found that polar CNTs could decrease the fluorescence signal for resorufin, possibly through oxidation to resazurin or hyper-reduction to hydroxyresorufin. This effect can be easily quantified for elimination of the bias. We recommend that careful consideration must be given to fluorimetric/colorimetric in vitro toxicological assessments of optically/chemically active NMs in order to relieve any potential artifacts due to the NMs themselves.

Proteomic changes in human lung epithelial cells (A549) in response to carbon black and titanium dioxide exposures.

This study combined cytotoxicity assays with proteomic analysis to characterize the unique biological responses of the A549 human lung epithelial cell line to two physicochemically distinct respirable particles titanium dioxide (TiO2) and carbon black (CB). Cellular LDH, ATP, BrdU incorporation and resazurin reduction indicated that CB was more potent than TiO2. Proteomic analysis was done using 2D-GE and MALDI-TOF-TOF-MS. Proteomic changes reflected common and particle-specific responses. Particle-specific proteomic responses were associated with cell death (necrosis and apoptosis), viability and proliferation pathways. Our results suggested that these pathways were consistent with the cytotoxicity data. For instance, increased expressions of anti-proliferative proteins LMNA and PA2G4 were in agreement with the decreased BrdU incorporation in A549 cells after exposure to CB. Similarly, increased expression of HSPA5 that is associated with ATPase activity was consistent with decreased cellular ATP levels in these cells. These findings reveal that proteomic changes can explain the cellular cytotoxicity characteristics of the particles. In essence, our results demonstrate that the in vitro toxicoproteomic approach is a promising tool to gain insight into molecular mechanisms underlying particle exposure-specific cytotoxicity. BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE In this study we have shown that toxicoproteomics is a sensitive and informative method to resolve the toxicity characteristics of particles with different physicochemical properties. This approach can be useful in the investigation of molecular mechanisms underpinning cellular cytotoxic responses elicited by particle exposures. Thus, the toxicoproteomic approach can be valuable in assessing the risk associated with particle exposures in vitro.

Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter

BackgroundAssociation of particulate matter with adverse health effects has been established in epidemiological studies and animal experiments. Epidemiological studies are difficult to undertake while animal studies are impractical for high-throughput toxicity testing. The ease and rapidity of in vitro tests emphasizes their potential for use in risk assessment of chemicals and particles. We examined the association between in vitro and in vivo responses to ambient particles, to determine the potential of cell-based assays as standalone toxicity screening tools.MethodsAssays of cytotoxicity and key inflammatory mediators were applied to determine the in vitro biological potency of a panel of urban and mineral particles in J774A.1 macrophages and A549 lung epithelial cells. The particles were also screened for the presence of AhR agonists using the Ah receptor-dependent gene induction assay and for endotoxin using the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay. A subset of the particles with a contrasting in vitro toxicity profile was delivered intratracheally in BALB/c mice to assess their in vivo biological potency. Results from various bioassays were combined within the in vitro and in vivo models. The combined potency measures were examined for associations.ResultsOverall, J774A.1 cells were more sensitive to particle effects than A549 cells. Whereas the combined cytotoxicity estimates were highly correlated between the two cell lines, the combined in vitro inflammatory potency estimates were not, emphasizing functional differences of the two cell types. Secretion of inflammatory markers by J774A.1 cells was correlated with AhR ligand binding profile and endotoxin levels of particles. Particle instillation led to an acute toxicity response in BALB/c mice, with neutrophilia and release of inflammatory mediators. While the combined toxicity estimates were not correlated between in vitro and in vivo models, the combined inflammatory and integrated potency estimates (toxicity and inflammation) approached the threshold for significance (p = 0.052) in a correlation within in vitro and in vivo models, with a ranking of fine particle (DWR1), minerals (TiO2, CRI) and coarse particles (SRM-, EHC-type) from low to high potency.ConclusionIntegration of in vitro endpoints shows promise in determining adverse outcomes of particle exposures in vivo. The devised data reduction and computational approach will prove useful in the development of models for assessment of hazard potential of particles; however, distinct models may be needed for particles of different type, such as urban particles vs. mineral particles, nanomaterials.

Chemical and toxicological evolution of carbon nanotubes during atmospherically relevant aging processes.

The toxicity of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) has received significant attention due to their usage in a wide range of commercial applications. While numerous studies exist on their impacts in water and soil ecosystems, there is a lack of information on the exposure to CNTs from the atmosphere. The transformation of CNTs in the atmosphere, resulting in their functionalization, may significantly alter their toxicity. In the current study, the chemical modification of single wall carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) via ozone and OH radical oxidation is investigated through studies that simulate a range of expected tropospheric particulate matter (PM) lifetimes, in order to link their chemical evolution to toxicological changes. The results indicate that the oxidation favors carboxylic acid functionalization, but significantly less than other studies performed under nonatmospheric conditions. Despite evidence of functionalization, neither O3 nor OH radical oxidation resulted in a change in redox activity (potentially giving rise to oxidative stress) or in cytotoxic end points. Conversely, both the redox activity and cytotoxicity of SWCNTs significantly decreased when exposed to ambient urban air, likely due to the adsorption of organic carbon vapors. These results suggest that the effect of gas-particle partitioning of organics in the atmosphere on the toxicity of SWCNTs should be investigated further.

Respiratory burst in alveolar macrophages exposed to urban particles is not a predictor of cytotoxicity

We examined the utility of respiratory burst measurements in alveolar macrophages to assess adverse cellular changes following exposure to urban particles. Cells were obtained by bronchioalveolar lavage of Fisher 344 rats and exposed (0-100 μg/well) to urban particles (EHC-93, SRM-1648, SRM-1649, PM2.5), the soluble (EHC-93sol) and insoluble (EHC-93insol) fractions of EHC-93 (EHC-93tot), mineral particles (TiO(2), SiO(2)) and metal oxides (iron III oxide, iron II/III oxide, copper II oxide, nickel II oxide). The particle-induced respiratory burst was measured by chemiluminescence for 2h after the addition of particles. The cells were then stimulated with phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), yeast Zymosan fragments (Zymosan), or lipopolysaccharide plus interferon-gamma (LPS/IFN-γ) and the stimulant-induced respiratory burst was measured. Independently of the potential of particles to induce directly a respiratory burst, exposure to most particles attenuated the subsequent stimulant-induced burst. The notable exception was SiO(2), which produced a strong respiratory burst upon contact with the macrophages and enhanced the subsequent response to PMA or LPS/IFN-γ. Based on the degree of inhibition of the stimulant-dependent respiratory burst, particles were clustered into groups of high (SRM-1649, iron III oxide), intermediate (EHC-93tot, EHC-93insol, SRM-1648, VERP, iron II/III oxide, copper II oxide), and low (EHC-93sol, SiO(2), TiO2 and nickel II oxide) potency. Across these clusters, the potency of the particles to inhibit the stimulant-dependent respiratory burst showed poor correlation with cytotoxicity determined by XTT reduction assay.