Dane A. Crossley

Cardiovascular development in embryos of the American alligator Alligator mississippiensis: effects of chronic and acute hypoxia.

SUMMARY Chronic hypoxic incubation is a common tool used to address the plasticity of morphological and physiological characteristics during vertebrate development. In this study chronic hypoxic incubation of embryonic American alligators resulted in both morphological (mass) and physiological changes. During normoxic incubation embryonic mass, liver mass and heart mass increased throughout the period of study, while yolk mass fell. Chronic hypoxia (10%O2) resulted in a reduced embryonic mass at 80% and 90% of incubation. This reduction in embryonic mass was accompanied by a relative enlargement of the heart at 80% and 90% of incubation, while relative embryonic liver mass was similar to the normoxic group. Normoxic incubated alligators maintained a constant heart rate during the period of study, while mean arterial pressure rose continuously. Both levels of hypoxic incubation (15% and 10%O2) resulted in a lower mean arterial pressure at 90% of incubation, while heart rate was lower in the 10%O2 group only. Acute (5 min) exposure to 10%O2 in the normoxic group resulted in a biphasic response, with a normotensive bradycardia occurring during the period of exposure and a hypertensive tachycardic response occurring during recovery. The embryos incubated under hypoxia also showed a blunted response to acute hypoxic stress. In conclusion, the main responses elicited by chronic hypoxic incubation, namely, cardiac enlargement, blunted hypoxic response and systemic vasodilation, may provide chronically hypoxic embryos with a new physiological repertoire for responding to hypoxia.

Comparative cardiovascular physiology: future trends, opportunities and challenges

The inaugural Kjell Johansen Lecture in the Zoophysiology Department of Aarhus University (Aarhus, Denmark) afforded the opportunity for a focused workshop comprising comparative cardiovascular physiologists to ponder some of the key unanswered questions in the field. Discussions were centred around three themes. The first considered function of the vertebrate heart in its various forms in extant vertebrates, with particular focus on the role of intracardiac shunts, the trabecular (‘spongy’) nature of the ventricle in many vertebrates, coronary blood supply and the building plan of the heart as revealed by molecular approaches. The second theme involved the key unanswered questions in the control of the cardiovascular system, emphasizing autonomic control, hypoxic vasoconstriction and developmental plasticity in cardiovascular control. The final theme involved poorly understood aspects of the interaction of the cardiovascular system with the lymphatic, renal and digestive systems. Having posed key questions around these three themes, it is increasingly clear that an abundance of new analytical tools and approaches will allow us to learn much about vertebrate cardiovascular systems in the coming years.

Ontogeny of baroreflex control in the American alligator Alligator mississippiensis.

SUMMARY Baroreflex regulation appears in different species at different points in embryonic development. This study was designed to understand the development of the baroreflex in embryos of the American alligator at four different points of embryonic development (60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of a total incubation period of 72 days) and in 1-week-old hatchlings. Data from a separate study on 1-year-old alligators were included for comparison. The gain of the cardiac limb of the baroreflex was calculated from heart rate changes triggered by pharmacological manipulation of arterial pressure with sodium nitroprusside and phenylephrine. The results demonstrated that a vagally mediated hypertensive baroreflex was present during the final 30% of alligator development. A hypotensive baroreflex was not present in embryos but appeared in hatchlings, mediated by a combined effect of vagal and sympathetic efferents. Absolute baroreflex gain was maximal at 80% of incubation (41.22 beats kPa–1 min–1) and dropped thereafter, reaching a minimum in 1-year-old alligators (9.69 beats kPa–1 min–1). When the baroreflex gain was normalized to resting arterial pressure and heart rate, the maximum gain was observed in 1-year-old alligators (normalized index of 2.12 versus 0.75 in hatchlings and 0.69 as the highest gain in embryos). In conclusion, baroreflex regulation appeared during embryonic development with a substantial gain. These findings indicate that embryonic development is a period of preparation for cardiovascular regulatory mechanisms that will be necessary in adult life and that the baroreflex control mechanism is required for cardiovascular control during ontogeny.

Maturation of Cardiovascular Control Mechanisms in the Embryonic Emu (Dromiceius Novaehollandiae)

SUMMARY Our understanding of avian embryonic cardiovascular regulation has been based on studies in chickens. The present study was undertaken to determine if the patterns established in chickens are generally applicable to the emu, a ratite bird species. We studied cardiovascular physiology over the interval from 60% to 90% of the emus 50-day incubation period. During this period, embryonic emus exhibit a slight fall in resting heart rate (from 171 beats min-1 to 154 beats min-1) and a doubling of mean arterial pressure (from 1.2 kPa to 2.6 kPa). Exposures to 15% or 10% O2 initially decreased heart rate during the first period of emu incubation studied [60% of incubation (60%I)] but increased heart rate in the 90%I group. Arterial pressure responded to hypoxia with an initial depression (-1.6 kPa) at 60%I and 70%I but showed no response during the later periods of incubation (80%I and 90%I). In addition, tonic stimulation of both cholinergic and adrenergic (α and β) receptors was present on heart rate at 70%I, with the cholinergic and β-adrenergic tone increasing in strength by 90%I. Arterial pressure was dependent on a constant β-adrenergic and constant α-adrenergic tone from 60%I to 90%I. A comparison with embryonic white leghorn chickens over a similar window of incubation revealed that emus and white leghorn chickens both possess an adrenergic tone on heart rate and pressure but that only emus possess a cholinergic tone on heart rate. Collectively, these data indicate that the maturation of cardiovascular control systems differs between white leghorn chickens and emus, inviting investigation of additional avian species to determine other patterns.

The phylogeny and ontogeny of autonomic control of the heart and cardiorespiratory interactions in vertebrates

Heart rate in vertebrates is controlled by activity in the autonomic nervous system. In spontaneously active or experimentally prepared animals, inhibitory parasympathetic control is predominant and is responsible for instantaneous changes in heart rate, such as occur at the first air breath following a period of apnoea in discontinuous breathers like inactive reptiles or species that surface to air breathe after a period of submersion. Parasympathetic control, exerted via fast-conducting, myelinated efferent fibres in the vagus nerve, is also responsible for beat-to-beat changes in heart rate such as the high frequency components observed in spectral analysis of heart rate variability. These include respiratory modulation of the heartbeat that can generate cardiorespiratory synchrony in fish and respiratory sinus arrhythmia in mammals. Both may increase the effectiveness of respiratory gas exchange. Although the central interactions generating respiratory modulation of the heartbeat seem to be highly conserved through vertebrate phylogeny, they are different in kind and location, and in most species are as yet little understood. The heart in vertebrate embryos possesses both muscarinic cholinergic and β-adrenergic receptors very early in development. Adrenergic control by circulating catecholamines seems important throughout development. However, innervation of the cardiac receptors is delayed and first evidence of a functional cholinergic tonus on the heart, exerted via the vagus nerve, is often seen shortly before or immediately after hatching or birth, suggesting that it may be coordinated with the onset of central respiratory rhythmicity and subsequent breathing.

Development of cardiac form and function in ectothermic sauropsids

Evolutionary morphologists and physiologists have long recognized the phylogenetic significance of the ectothermic sauropsids. Sauropids have been classically considered to bridge between early tetrapods, ectotherms, and the evolution of endotherms. This transition has been associated with many modifications in cardiovascular form and function, which have changed dramatically during the course of vertebrate evolution. Most cardiovascular studies have focused upon adults, leaving the development of this critical system largely unexplored. In this essay, we attempt a synthesis of sauropsid cardiovascular development based on the limited literature and indicate fertile regions for future studies. Early morphological cardiovascular development, i.e., the basic formation of the tube heart and the major pulmonary and systemic vessels, is similar across tetrapods. Subsequent cardiac chamber development, however, varies considerably between developing chelonians, squamates, crocodilians, and birds, reflected in the diversity of adult ventricular structure across these taxa. The details of how these differences in morphology develop, including the molecular regulation of cardiac and vascular growth and differentiation, are still poorly understood. In terms of the functional maturation of the cardiovascular system, reflected in physiological mechanisms for regulating heart rate and cardiac output, recent work has illustrated that changes during ontogeny in parameters such as heart rate and arterial blood pressure are somewhat species‐dependent. However, there are commonalities, such as a β‐adrenergic receptor tone on the embryonic heart appearing prior to 60% of development. Differential gross morphological responses to environmental stressors (oxygen, hydration, temperature) have been investigated interspecifically, revealing that cardiac development is relatively plastic, especially, with respect to change in heart growth. Collectively, the data assembled here reflects the current limited morphological and physiological understanding of cardiovascular development in sauropsids and identifies key areas for future studies of this diverse vertebrate lineage. J. Morphol., 2009.

Role of nitric oxide in the systemic and pulmonary circulation of anesthetized turtles (Trachemys scripta)

In reptiles the influence of local vascular factors on blood flow regulation is vaguely understood. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of nitric oxide (NO) on vascular function in anesthetized Trachemys scripta. The experimental protocol consisted of serial injections of sodium nitroprusside (SNP; 25 microg. kg(-1)), L-arginine (185 mg. kg(-1)) and L-NAME (50 mg. kg(-1)). SNP induced a systemic vasodilation (0.05 to 0.02 kPa. min. kg. mL(-1), P = 0.015), with no change in pulmonary vascular resistance (0.07 versus 0.08 kPa. min. kg. mL(-1), P > 0.05). L-Arg had no effect on resistances but increased cardiac output by 17%. L-NAME increased systemic resistance (33% increase; P = 0.01) while pulmonary resistance was unchanged. These effects are consistent with in vivo and in vitro studies on the systemic vasculature of different reptilian species, suggesting that NO has an important role in maintaining systemic vascular tone. The pulmonary vasculature did not respond to NO due to either a lack of an endogenous NO tone or a relaxed state of the pulmonary vasculature. The importance of NO-based mechanisms versus other neuro-humoral modulators in the reptilian circulation remains uncertain. However, as established in prior studies, cholinergic control of the proximal pulmonary artery is the main regulator of pulmonary resistance while systemic resistance depends on a more complex suite of neural, humoral and local effectors that include NO.

Comparative cardiovascular development: improving the conceptual framework.

Immature vertebrates-either as an embryo in an egg, as free-living larva, or as an in utero fetus, are clearly not just small versions of adults. Their cardiovascular physiology (and doubtlessly other aspects of physiology) differs from that of adults both qualitatively and quantitatively. Yet, comparative cardiovascular physiologists have been relatively conservative in constructing a new (or at least modified) conceptual framework for the understanding of developmental cardiovascular physiology. We recommend that this framework rely less on the established cardiovascular truisms for adult cardiovascular physiology that are proving to be less useful and in instances even inaccurate for interpreting development of the heart and vasculature. We have suggested that three methodologies in particular be incorporated to a greater extent in studies of comparative cardiovascular development: (a) emphasis on multivariate approaches; (b) differentiation between absolute (extrinsic) and relative (intrinsic) time for development, and; (c) employment of time lines for both intra- and interspecific comparisons of the ontogeny of cardiovascular processes. While certainly none of these approaches are novel and others have previously dwelt at length on their importance in other contexts, we feel that the emerging framework for investigating cardiovascular physiological development would benefit from incorporating these and other approaches into experimental design as well as data analysis. Failing to do so results in a heavy dependence on analytical approaches typically used for adults, and thus under-appreciates the novelty and complexity of the developing vertebrate cardiovascular system.

Plasticity of cardiovascular function in snapping turtle embryos (Chelydra serpentina): Chronic hypoxia alters autonomic regulation and gene expression

Reptile embryos tolerate large decreases in the concentration of ambient oxygen. However, we do not fully understand the mechanisms that underlie embryonic cardiovascular short- or long-term responses to hypoxia in most species. We therefore measured cardiac growth and function in snapping turtle embryos incubated under normoxic (N21; 21% O₂) or chronic hypoxic conditions (H10; 10% O₂). We determined heart rate (fH) and mean arterial pressure (Pm) in acute normoxic (21% O₂) and acute hypoxic (10% O₂) conditions, as well as embryonic responses to cholinergic, adrenergic, and ganglionic pharmacological blockade. Compared with N21 embryos, chronic H10 embryos had smaller bodies and relatively larger hearts and were hypotensive, tachycardic, and following autonomic neural blockade showed reduced intrinsic fH at 90% of incubation. Unlike other reptile embryos, cholinergic and ganglionic receptor blockade both increased fH. β-Adrenergic receptor blockade with propranolol decreased fH, and α-adrenergic blockade with phentolamine decreased Pm. We also measured cardiac mRNA expression. Cholinergic tone was reduced in H10 embryos, but cholinergic receptor (Chrm2) mRNA levels were unchanged. However, expression of adrenergic receptor mRNA (Adrb1, Adra1a, Adra2c) and growth factor mRNA (Igf1, Igf2, Igf2r, Pdgfb) was lowered in H10 embryos. Hypoxia altered the balance between cholinergic receptors, α-adrenoreceptor and β-adrenoreceptor function, which was reflected in altered intrinsic fH and adrenergic receptor mRNA levels. This is the first study to link gene expression with morphological and cardioregulatory plasticity in a developing reptile embryo.

Hypotension in the chronically hypoxic chicken embryo is related to the β-adrenergic response of chorioallantoic and femoral arteries and not to bradycardia.

Prolonged fetal hypoxia leads to growth restriction and can cause detrimental prenatal and postnatal alterations. The embryonic chicken is a valuable model to study the effects of prenatal hypoxia, but little is known about its long-term effects on cardiovascular regulation. We hypothesized that chicken embryos incubated under chronic hypoxia would be hypotensive due to bradycardia and βAR-mediated relaxation of the systemic and/or the chorioallantoic (CA) arteries. We investigated heart rate, blood pressure, and plasma catecholamine levels in 19-day chicken embryos (total incubation 21 days) incubated from day 0 in normoxia or hypoxia (14-15% O(2)). Additionally, we studied α-adrenoceptor (αAR)-mediated contraction, relaxation to the β-adrenoceptor (βAR) agonist isoproterenol, and relaxation to the adenylate cyclase activator forskolin in systemic (femoral) and CA arteries (by wire myography). Arterial pressure showed a trend toward hypotension in embryos incubated under chronic hypoxic conditions compared with the controls (mean arterial pressure 3.19 ± 0.18 vs. 2.59 ± 0.13 kPa, normoxia vs. hypoxia, respectively. P = 0.056), without an accompanied bradycardia and elevation in plasma norepinephrine and lactate levels. All vessels relaxed in response to βAR stimulation with isoproterenol, but the CA arteries completely lacked an αAR response. Furthermore, hypoxia increased the sensitivity of femoral arteries (but not CA arteries) to isoproterenol. Hypoxia also increased the responsiveness of femoral arteries to forskolin. In conclusion, we suggest that hypotension in chronic hypoxic chicken embryos is the consequence of elevated levels of circulating catecholamines acting in vascular beds with exclusive (CA arteries) or exacerbated (femoral arteries) βAR-mediated relaxation, and not a consequence of bradycardia.