Daniel M. Gordon

Protection of Humans against Malaria by Immunization with Radiation-Attenuated Plasmodium falciparum Sporozoites

During 1989-1999, 11 volunteers were immunized by the bites of 1001-2927 irradiated mosquitoes harboring infectious sporozoites of Plasmodium falciparum (Pf) strain NF54 or clone 3D7/NF54. Ten volunteers were first challenged by the bites of Pf-infected mosquitoes 2-9 weeks after the last immunization, and all were protected. A volunteer challenged 10 weeks after the last immunization was not protected. Five previously protected volunteers were rechallenged 23-42 weeks after a secondary immunization, and 4 were protected. Two volunteers were protected when rechallenged with a heterologous Pf strain (7G8). In total, there was protection in 24 of 26 challenges. These results expand published findings demonstrating that immunization by exposure to thousands of mosquitoes carrying radiation-attenuated Pf sporozoites is safe and well tolerated and elicits strain-transcendent protective immunity that persists for at least 42 weeks.

Degenerate cytotoxic T cell epitopes from P. falciparum restricted by multiple HLA-A and HLA-B supertype alleles.

We recently described human leukocyte antigen (HLA) A2, A3 and B7 supertypes, characterized by largely overlapping peptide-binding specificities and represented in a high percentage of different populations. Here, we identified 17 Plasmodium falciparum peptides capable of binding these supertypes and assessed antigenicity in both vaccinated and naturally exposed populations. Positive cytotoxic T lymphocyte recall and cytokine (interferon-gamma and tumor necrosis factor alpha) responses were detected for all peptides; all were recognized in the context of more than one HLA class I molecule; and at least 12 of the 17 were recognized in the context of all HLA alleles studied. These data validate the concept of HLA supertypes at the biological level, show that highly degenerate peptides are almost always recognized as epitopes, and demonstrate the feasibility of developing a universally effective vaccine by focusing on a limited number of peptide specificities.

Randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial of SPf66 malaria vaccine in children in northwestern Thailand

Summary Background Previous efficacy trials of SPf66 malaria vaccine have produced conflicting results in different populations. We report a randomised double-blind trial of the SPf66 vaccine conducted in Karen children aged 2–15 living in a malarious region of northwestern Thailand. Recombinant hepatitis B vaccine was used as a comparator. Methods The study had a power of 90% to detect an efficacy of 30%, defined as a reduction in the incidence of first cases of symptomatic falciparum malaria after three doses of vaccine. 1221 children received three immunisations and were eligible for the primary efficacy analysis. Intense active and passive case detection continued over 15 months of follow-up. Findings The SPf66 vaccine was well tolerated, although 26 children had mild or moderately severe local or systemic allergic reactions, compared with none in the comparator group. The vaccine was immunogenic; after three doses, 73% of recipients had seroconverted. There were no deaths due to malaria during the study. During the 15-month period of evaluation there were 379 first cases of symptomatic falciparum malaria (195 in the SPf66 recipients, 184 in the comparator group); an SPf66 efficacy of −9% (95% Cl -33 to 14, p=0·41). No significant differences between the two study groups in parasite density or any other measure of malaria-related morbidity were detected. Interpretation These findings are consistent with a recent study showing lack of efficacy of SPf66 among Gambian infants and differ from earlier positive reports from South America and evidence of borderline efficacy from Tanzania. We conclude that SPf66 does not protect against clinical falciparum malaria and that further efficacy trials are not warranted.

Phase 2a Trial of 0, 1, and 3 Month and 0, 7, and 28 Day Immunization Schedules of Malaria Vaccine RTS,S/AS02 in Malaria-Naive Adults at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research

BACKGROUND Immunization with RTS,S/AS02 consistently protects some vaccinees against malaria infection in experimental challenges and in field trials. A brief immunization schedule against falciparum malaria would be compatible with the Expanded Programme on Immunization, or in combination with other prevention measures, interrupt epidemic malaria or protect individuals upon sudden travel to an endemic area. METHODS We conducted an open label, Phase 2a trial of two different full dose schedules of RTS,S/AS02 in 40 healthy malaria-naïve adults. Cohort 1 (n=20) was immunized on a 0, 1, and 3 month schedule and Cohort 2 (n=20) on a 0, 7, and 28 day schedule. Three weeks later, 38 vaccinees and 12 unimmunized infectivity controls underwent malaria challenge. RESULTS Both regimens had a good safety and tolerability profile. Peak GMCs of antibody to the circumsporozoite protein (CSP) were similar in Cohort 1 (78 microg/mL; 95% CI: 45-134) and Cohort 2 (65 microg/mL; 95% CI: 40-104). Vaccine efficacy for Cohort 1 was 45% (95% CI: 18-62%) and for Cohort 2, 39% (95% CI: 11-56%). Protected volunteers had a higher GMC of anti-CSP antibody (114 microg/mL) than did volunteers with a 2-day delay (70 microg/mL) or no delay (30 microg/mL) in the time to onset of parasitemia (Kruskal-Wallis, p=0.019). A trend was seen for higher CSP-specific IFN-gamma responses in PBMC from protected volunteers only in Cohort 1, but not in Cohort 2, for ex vivo and for cultured ELISPOT assays. CONCLUSION In malaria-naïve adults, the efficacy of three-dose RTS,S/AS02 regimens on either a 0, 1, and 3 month schedule or an abbreviated 0, 7, and 28 day schedule was not discernibly different from two previously reported trials of two-dose regimens given at 0, 1 month that conferred 47% (95% CI: -19 to 76%) protection and in another trial 42% (95% CI: 5-63%). A strong association of CSP-specific antibody with protection against malaria challenge is observed and confirms similar observations made in other studies. Subsequent trials of adjuvanted RTS,S in African children and infants on a 0, 1, and 2 month schedule have demonstrated a favorable safety and efficacy profile.

Clinical Manifestations of Plasmodium falciparum Malaria Experimentally Induced by Mosquito Challenge

To determine the characteristics of clinical illness accompanying Plasmodium falciparum infection induced by controlled exposure to infected mosquitoes, records of 118 volunteers participating in studies conducted between 1985 and 1992 were reviewed. One hundred fourteen volunteers (97%) reported at least one symptom attributable to malaria, with fatigue, myalgias or arthralgias, headache, and chills most commonly reported. The median duration of symptoms was 3 days. Fever was recorded in 61% of volunteers; 4 volunteers had temperatures >40 degrees C. Neutropenia and thrombocytopenia were present in 9% and 12% of volunteers, respectively. Despite counts as low as 658/microL (neutrophils) or 73,000/microL (platelets), no secondary infectious or hemorrhagic complications occurred. In all cases, volunteers recovered completely and laboratory values returned to baseline after specific antimalarial therapy. Recrudescence did not occur in any volunteer. In this model, mosquito inoculation of P. falciparum is a reliable, safe, and well-tolerated method of experimental challenge.

Use of adjuvant containing mycobacterial cell-wall skeleton, monophosphoryl lipid A, and squalane in malaria circumsporozoite protein vaccine

Human immune responses to modern synthetic and recombinant peptide vaccines administered with the standard adjuvant, aluminum hydroxide, tend to be poor, hence the search for better adjuvants. Antibody responses to a Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite (CS) protein vaccine, R32NS1(81), administered with an adjuvant containing cell-wall skeleton of mycobacteria and monophosphoryl lipid A in squalane (MPL/CWS) have been compared to responses to the same immunogen administered with aluminum hydroxide. 2 weeks after the third dose the following indices were greater in the 5 patients who received MPL/CWS than in controls (p less than 0.05): the geometric mean concentration (2.0 vs 25.4 microgram/ml) and avidity index of antibodies to the P falciparum CS protein by ELISA, the geometric mean titre to P falciparum sporozoites by IFAT (1/115 vs 1/1600), and the geometric mean inhibition of sporozoite invasion of hepatoma cells in vitro (37.6 vs 90.3%). For R32NS1(81) MPL/CWS is superior to aluminum hydroxide as an adjuvant, and the data support the evaluation of this complex as an adjuvant for other vaccines.

Safety, immunogenicity and limited efficacy study of a recombinant Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite vaccine in Thai soldiers

Thai soldiers were vaccinated with a recombinant protein derived from the central repeat region of the circumsporozoite (CS) protein of Plasmodium falciparum conjugated to Toxin A (detoxified) of Pseudomonas aeruginosa (R32Tox-A) to evaluate its safety, immunogenicity and efficacy. In a randomized, double-blind manner, 199 volunteers received either R32Tox-A or a control vaccine at 0, 8 and 16 weeks. Immunization was performed in a malaria non-transmission area, after completion of which volunteers were deployed to an endemic border area and monitored closely to allow early detection and treatment of infection. The vaccine was found to be safe and to elicit antibody responses in all vaccinees. Peak CS antibody (IgG) concentrations in malaria-experienced vaccinees exceeded those in malaria-naive vaccinees (mean 40.6 versus 16.1 micrograms ml-1; p = 0.005) as well as those induced by previous CS protein-derived vaccines and observed in association with natural infections. A log-rank comparison of time to falciparum malaria revealed no differences between vaccinated and non-vaccinated subjects. Secondary analyses revealed that CS antibody levels were lower in vaccinee malaria cases than in non-cases, 3 and 5 months after the third dose of vaccine (p = 0.06 and p = 0.014, respectively). Because antibody levels had fallen substantially before peak malaria transmission occurred, the question of whether high levels of CS antibody are protective remains to be resolved.

Induction of cytolytic and antibody responses using Plasmodium falciparum repeatless circumsporozoite protein encapsulated in liposomes

Plasmodium circumsporozoite (CS) protein-induced antibody and T-cell responses are considered to be important in protective immunity. Since the key repeat determinant of the CS protein may actually restrict the recognition of other potential T- and B-cell sites, a modified Plasmodium falciparum CS protein lacking the central repeat region, RLF, was expressed in Escherichia coli. On purification, RLF was encapsulated into liposomes [L(RLF)] and used for the in vivo induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) and antibodies. Immunization of B10.Br (H-2k) mice with L(RLF), but not with RLF, induced CD8+ CTL specific for the P. falciparum CS protein CTL epitope, amino acid residues 368-390. Anti-L(RLF) serum reacted with antigens on intact sporozoites and inhibited sporozoite invasion of hepatoma cells. Antibody specificity studies in New Zealand White rabbits revealed new B-cell sites localized in amino acid residues 84-94, 91-99, 97-106 and 367-375. Although the mechanisms by which liposomes enhance cellular and humoral immune responses remain unknown, liposome-formulated vaccines have been well tolerated in humans; hence, their use in vaccines, when efficacy depends on antibody and CTL responses, may be broadly applicable.

Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite vaccine immunogenicity and efficacy trial with natural challenge quantitation in an area of endemic human malaria of Kenya.

It has been hypothesized that antibody induced by Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite protein vaccine would be effective against endemic human malaria. In a malaria endemic region of Kenya, 76 volunteers, in 38 pairs sleeping adjacently, were immunized with subunit circumsporozoite protein Asn-Ala-Asn-Pro tetrapeptide repeat-pseudomonas toxin A, or hepatitis B vaccine. After quinine and doxcycycline, volunteers were followed for illness daily, parasitemia weekly, antibody, T-lymphocyte responses, and treated if indicated. Anopheles mosquitoes resting in houses were collected, and tested for P. falciparum antigen, or dissected for sporozoites and tested for blood meal ABO type and P. falciparum antigen. Vaccine was safe, with side-effects similar in both groups, and immunogenic, engendering IgG antibody as high as 600 micrograms ml-1, but did not increase the proportion of volunteers with T-lymphocyte responses. Estimation of P. falciparum challenge averaged 0.194 potentially infective Anopheles bites/volunteer/ day. Mosquito blood meals showed no difference in biting intensity between vaccine and control groups. Both groups had similar malaria-free survival curves, cumulative positive blood slides, cumulative parasites mm-3, and numbers of parasites mm-3 on first positive blood slide, during three post-vaccination observation periods. Every volunteer had P. falciparum parastemia at least once. Vaccinees had 82% and controls 89% incidences of symptomatic parasitemia (P = 0.514, efficacy 9%, statistical power 95% probability of efficacy < 50%). Vaccine-induced anti-sporozoite antibody was not protective in this study. Within designed statistical precisions the present study is in agreement with efficacy studies in Colombia, Venezuela and Tanzania.

Safety and immunogenicity in volunteers of a recombinant Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite protein malaria vaccine produced in Lepidopteran cells

A recombinant Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite (CS) antigen (rPfCSA) was produced in insect cells using a baculovirus expression vector containing the entire CS gene. This near full-length CS antigen was adsorbed onto aluminium phosphate for use as a malaria vaccine. In a study of safety and immunogenicity, 20 volunteers were divided into four groups of five each and inoculated intramuscularly with 10, 100, 500 or 1000 micrograms of vaccine. Primary vaccinations were followed by two booster immunizations at 2 and 6 months. Three volunteers developed prominent local reactions manifested as tenderness, redness and swelling at the injection site following the second or third vaccination. All symptoms resolved spontaneously within 72 h. Postimmunization sera from six of 20 volunteers showed seroconversions as measured by Western blot, using rPfCSA as antigen. However, specific anti-CS protein antibody could not be detected by indirect immunoflourescence against intact sporozoites or by ELISA using rPfCSA or peptide to the repeat region. In addition, 18 of 20 volunteers developed antibody to baculovirus proteins as determined by ELISA and/or Western blot. Antigen-driven replication studies using peripheral blood mononuclear cells from vaccinees failed to detect proliferative responses specific to CS protein. This recombinant CS protein vaccine, as formulated, was minimally immunogenic in humans.