David Bushek

Evaluation of methods using ray's fluid thioglycollate medium for diagnosis of Perkinsus marinus infection in the eastern oyster, Crassostrea virginica

Abstract Accurate detection and quantification of parasite body burden are critical for understanding many aspects of host-parasite interactions. The standard assay for diagnosing Perkinsus marinus infections in Crassostrea virginica involves incubation of oyster tissue in Rays fluid thioglycollate medium (RFTM), followed by iodine staining and microscopic examination for parasites. The original RFTM tissue assay is destructive and provides only a ranked level of infection intensity. A recent modification provides a technique to enumerate P. marinus after incubation in RFTM and determines total body burden. Application of this technique to hemolymph samples has provided a nondestructive assay. We provide a critical evaluation of these three assays. Data from previous studies were not adequate to critically evaluate performance of the tissue and hemolymph assays. Sensitivity and accuracy of these assays were therefore compared against weight-standardized body burden in Delaware Bay oysters over the course of a year. Determination of total body burden was significantly more sensitive than the other assays. Neither tissue nor hemolymph assays provided accurate estimates of individual infection intensities and were insensitive at low infection levels. The tissue assay was easier to use and slightly more accurate than the hemolymph assay, and both provided reasonable estimates of average infection level in the population. In summary, total body burden assessment is recommended when highly accurate measures of infection intensity or prevalence are necessary, the tissue assay is recommended for monitoring epizootics because of its simplicity and accuracy at the population level, and the hemolymph assay is only recommended when oysters must be kept alive.

Large-scale production of triploid oysters, Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin), using “stripped” gametes

Abstract Successful production of triploid oysters requires precise control of the timing of fertilization of eggs. Logistically, using stripped gametes is the most practical method for producing triploids because the time of fertilization can be easily controlled. We examined several factors that may affect the survival and yield of triploid C. virginica from stripped gametes in large scale spawnings. Triploidy was induced by inhibiting polar body II with cytochalasin B. Fourteen replicates containing from 17 to 49 million (M) eggs were treated. Survival and percent triploidy of 48-h-old larvae were not correlated; mean survival was 22% and mean triploidy was 79%. About 72% of 138 spat examined were triploid, indicating that the estimate of triploidy at 48 h was accurate. Overall, 400.8 M eggs yielded about 17.8 triploid spat, an efficiency of 4.4%. All linear regression models incorporating the treatment variables were non-significant. Variability may be random, a reflection of egg quality, or both.

Long-term Trends in Oyster Population Dynamics in Delaware Bay: Regime Shifts and Response to Disease

Abstract We evaluate a 54-y survey time series for the Delaware Bay oyster beds in New Jersey waters to identify the characteristics of regime shifts in oyster populations and the influence of MSX and Dermo diseases on population stability. Oyster abundance was high during the 1970s through 1985. Oyster abundance was low at the inception of the time series in 1953, remained low through 1969, and has been low since 1985 and very low since 2000. Natural mortality was low in most years prior to the appearance of MSX in 1957. From 1957 through 1966, natural mortality generally remained above 10% annually and twice exceeded 20%. Natural mortality remained well below 15% during the 1970s and into the early 1980s when oyster abundance was continuously high. The largest mortality event in the time series, an MSX epizootic that resulted in the death of 47% of the stock, occurred in 1985. Mortality rose again with the incursion of Dermo in 1990 and has remained above 15% for most years since that time and frequently has exceeded 20%. The primary impact of MSX and Dermo diseases has been to raise natural mortality and ultimately to cause a dispersed stock to retreat into its habitat of refuge in the moderately low salinity reach of the bay. The time series of oyster abundance on the New Jersey oyster beds of Delaware Bay is dominated by two regime shifts, the 1970 abundance increase that was maintained for about 15 y thereafter, and the 1985 abundance decrease that continues through today. These two regime shifts ushered in long-term periods of apparent constancy in population dynamics. The 1985 regime shift was induced by the largest MSX epizootic on record that produced high mortalities throughout a population distributed broadly throughout its habitat range after 15 y of high abundance. A putative new regime commenced circa 2000 as a consequence of a series of Dermo epizootics. Mortalities routinely exceeded 20% of the population annually during this period, with the consequence of a greater degree of stock consolidation than any previous time in the 54-y record. Extreme consolidation of the stock would appear to be a characteristic of the populations response to Dermo disease. The 1970–1984 and post-1985 regimes each were ushered in by a confluence of events unique in the 54-y time series. Each was characterized by a period of relative stability in population abundance. However, the stability in total population abundance belies a more dynamic process of stock redistribution during both time intervals, demonstrating that the appearance of constancy in stock abundance is not necessarily a result of invariant stock dynamics. Rather, the Delaware Bay oyster time series suggests that regime shifts delimit periods during which differential, often offsetting, local trends impart similar abundance levels, and thus constancy at the level of the stock masks substantive changes in local population dynamics potentially fostering future catastrophic changes in population-level attributes. Understanding such regime shifts will likely determine the success of decadal management goals more so than measures designed to influence population abundance.

Microarray analysis of gene expression in eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica) reveals a novel combination of antimicrobial and oxidative stress host responses after dermo (Perkinsus marinus) challenge

Dermo disease, caused by Perkinsus marinus, is one of the most severe diseases of eastern oysters, Crassostrea virginica. It causes serious mortalities in both wild and aquacultured oysters. Using existing expressed sequence tag (EST) resources, we developed a 12K in situ oligonucleotide microarray and used it for the analysis of gene expression profiles of oysters during the interactions between P. marinus and its oyster host. Significant gene expression regulation was found at day 30 post-challenge in the eastern oyster. Putative identities of the differentially expressed genes revealed a set of genes involved in several processes including putative antimicrobial defenses, pathogen recognition and uptake, anti-oxidation and apoptosis. Consistent with results obtained from previous, smaller-scale experiments, expression profiles revealed a large set of genes likely involved in an active mitigating response to oxidative stress and apoptosis induced by P. marinus. Additionally, a unique galectin from C. virginica, CvGal, which serves as a preferential receptor for P. marinus trophozoites, was found to be significantly down-regulated in gill tissue of oysters with both light and heavy infection, suggesting an attempt to control parasite uptake and proliferation in the later stages of infection. Potential histone-derived antimicrobial responses to P. marinus were also revealed in the gene expression profiles.

Ecosystem response to bivalve density reduction: management implications

Coastal ecosystems are easily overexploited and changed by physical and biological factors. In this paper, we discuss current ideas and arguments for coastal ecosystem management with an emphasis on systems that have large bivalve filter feeder components. For centuries the species or population approach has been utilized in fisheries management. With the growing knowledge base on specific environmental effects and relationships, it has become increasingly evident that a broad or holistic approach to fisheries management in these systems is usually more appropriate. An ongoing ecosystem scale experiment in which oysters are completely removed from tidal creeks is described and used as a case study. The experimental design takes estimates of the systems carrying capacity into account. Using the population or species approach to monitor the oysters, the only observable change after the experimental manipulation was a slight increase in summer somatic growth and elevated recruitment of oysters in creeks with oyster reefs removed. These data are interpreted as an indication that the creeks with oysters present are below or near carrying capacity. However, when nekton, plankton and water chemistry data are also examined a much more complicated picture emerges. During the summer growing season, nekton biomass in all creeks is often greater than oyster biomass. Also, our calculations show that oysters do not produce enough ammonium to satisfy phytoplankton productivity, but nekton, water column remineralization and sediments can account for most of the deficit. Finally, microflagellates, which are a preferred food for the oysters, dominate the phytoplankton during the summer growing season and diatoms dominate the colder months. The timing of the change in phase of phytoplankton dominance seems to mirror the seasonal arrival and departure times of nekton in the creeks. We argue that dense bivalve reefs and beds are indicative of intense positive feedback loops that make their ecosystems susceptible to dramatic changes in structure. Such changes have not been reported for natural systems, but are found in systems influenced by over-fishing, nutrient loading and pollution. Thus, the management of sustainable fisheries in coastal ecosystems requires an understanding of the ecosystem science and the realization that systems dominated by bivalves exhibit complex responses that are not easily explained by linear dynamics.

Long-term patterns of an estuarine pathogen along a salinity gradient

Parasitic, disease-causing pathogens can exert strong control over marine populations yet few long-term studies exist that describe these relationships. Understanding the connections to longterm large-scale processes relative to local short-term processes should facilitate better planning for disease impacts in the management of marine resources. We describe a 21-yr dataset of dermo disease (Perkinsus marinus) in eastern oysters (Crassostrea virginica) in Delaware Bay, USA. Analyses indicated (1) a strong positive association between disease and mortality that was non-linear and defined by thresholds, (2) a clear spatial gradient of increasing disease and mortality with increasing salinity, (3) an apparent 7-year cycle in which peaks were associated with strong positive anomalies of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), (4) an inverse relationship with freshwater inflow, and (5) no obvious response to natural selection from persistent disease pressure. These data quantify the impact of environmental variables on the disease in a wild population and provide new insight into how disease interacts with host populations by linking disease patterns with larger climate controlling processes. Understanding these connections will facilitate prediction of and response to disease outbreaks.

Shewanella and Photobacterium spp. in Oysters and Seawater from the Delaware Bay

ABSTRACT Shewanella algae, S. putrefaciens, and Photobacterium damselae subsp. damselae are indigenous marine bacteria and human pathogens causing cellulitis, necrotizing fasciitis, abscesses, septicemia, and death. Infections are rare and are most often associated with the immunocompromised host. A study was performed on the microbiological flora of oysters and seawater from commercial oyster harvesting sites in the Delaware Bay, New Jersey. From 276 water and shellfish samples tested, 1,421 bacterial isolates were picked for biochemical identification and 170 (12.0%) of the isolates were presumptively identified as S. putrefaciens, 26 (1.8%) were presumptively identified as P. damselae subsp. damselae, and 665 (46.8%) could not be identified using the API 20E identification database. Sequencing of the 16S rRNA genes of 22 S. putrefaciens-like isolates identified them as S. abalonesis, S. algae, S. baltica, S. hafniensis, S. marisflavi, S. putrefaciens, Listonella anguillarum, and P. damselae. Beta-hemolysis was produced by some S. algae and P. damselae isolates, while isolates of S. baltica and L. anguillarum, species perceived as nonpathogenic, also exhibited β-hemolysis and growth at 37°C. To our knowledge, this is the first time these beta-hemolytic strains were reported from shellfish or seawater from the Delaware Bay. Pathogenic Shewanella and Photobacterium species could pose a health threat through the ingestion of contaminated seafood, by cuts or abrasions acquired in the marine environment, or by swimming and other recreational activities.

Inviable hybrids of Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin) with C. rivularis (Gould) and C. gigas (Thunberg)

Abstract Interspecific hybridization may provide important tools for selective breeding programs in oyster culture, especially for enhancement of disease resistance, and may have a bearing on debates concerning the introduction of non-native species. Factorial crosses of C. virginica with C. rivularis (C. arakiensis) and C. gigas were made, producing control and hybrid larvae. Larval survival and growth were documented. After several replicated experiments it became apparent that diploid hybrids were inviable, and so triploid hybrids were also tested and found to be equally inviable. Feeding studies with hybrids were initiated to determine if lack of growth and viability were related to capture of food. Overall, hybrids of C. virginica with C. rivularis and C. gigas can be readily produced, but are inviable after 8–10 days and grow little. With regard to the species examined here, previous reports of successful hybridization should be questioned. Introduction of C. gigas to the native range of C. virginica will not have direct genetic effects on C. virginica .

Serological Affinities of the Oyster Pathogen Perkinsus marinus (Apicomplexa) with Some Dinoflagellates (Dinophyceae)

Abstract The protozoan oyster pathogen Perkinsus marinus is classified in the phylum Apicomplexa, although molecular-genetic and ultrastructural evidence increasingly concur on its closer phylogenetic relationship with the dinoflagellates. To test for evidence of serological epitopes common to P. marinus and dinoflagellates, we probed 19 free-living and 8 parasitic dinoflagellate, or dinoflagellate-like, species for cross-reactivity with polyclonal antibodies to P. marinus. Three of 19 free-living dinoflagellates (16%), and 7 of 8 parasitic dinoflagellates (88%) were labeled by anti-P. marinus antibodies. In reciprocal immunoassays using polyclonal antibodies to the Hematodinium sp. dinoflagellate parasite of Norway lobsters, Nephrops norvegicus, P. marinus and the same 7 parasitic dinoflagellates labeled by anti-P. marinus antibodies, were again labeled. The dinoflagellate-like parasite of prawns Pandalus platyceros was not labeled by either antibody reagent. These reciprocal results confirm the presence of shared antibody-binding epitopes on cells of P. marinus and several dinoflagellates. The apparent widespread serological affinity between P. marinus and the parasitic dinoflagellates suggests a closer phylogenetic link to the syndinean dinoflagellate lineage. The consistent failure of the dinoflagellate-like prawn parasite to bind either antibody reagent shows that this parasite is serologically distinct from both P. marinus and Hematodinium-species parasitic dinoflagellates.

Circulation and Water Properties and Their Relationship to the Oyster Disease MSX in Delaware Bay

We apply a high-resolution hydro-dynamical model to investigate the role of physical factors influencing infection prevalence of Haplosporidium nelsoni, causative agent of MSX disease in the eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica), in Delaware Bay, USA. Validation studies conducted for the years 2000 and 2010–2011 confirm that the model, based upon the Regional Ocean Modeling System, has significant skill in the recovery of observed water level, temperature, salinity, and velocity. Multi-year simulations are performed for periods representing temporal and spatial variations in H. nelsoni infection prevalence (1974–76, 1979–81, 1984–86, 1990–92, and 2006–09) to assess the degree to which the variations in water properties and transport are temporally and spatially correlated with infection prevalence variations. Results show statistically significant correlations between the observed prevalence of MSX and multiple physical factors including river flow and salinity (themselves highly correlated), as well as the co-occurrence of elevated temperature and salinity values. Observed occurrences of high H. nelsoni infection prevalence at upbay locations correspond to periods of enhanced cross-bay and upbay transport together with hospitable temperature and salinity conditions.