David H. Wahl

Selective Predation by Three Esocids: The Role of Prey Behavior and Morphology

Abstract We documented differential vulnerability of fathead minnows Pimephales promelas, gizzard shad Dorosoma cepedianum, and bluegills Lepomis macrochirus to predation by muskellunge Esox masquinongy, northern pike E. lucius, and tiger muskellunge E. masquinongy × E. lucius in a 700-L tank. Individual esocids (150–225 mm in total length) were combined with singlespecies groups (N = 15) of optimal-sized prey (25–30% of predator length for bluegills, 37–43% for fathead minnows, and 30–36% for gizzard shad). Capture ability did not differ among esocids; however, mean captures per strike were higher for fathead minnow (0.67) and gizzard shad (0.78) than for bluegill (0A4). Morphology and antipredatory behavior, unique to each prey species, contributed to this differential vulnerability. In the field, we introduced equal numbers and similar sizes of these esocids into two systems, one with centrarchid prey and one with both centrarchid and gizzard shad prey. As predicted from laboratory work, esocids ate fe...

Growth and Survival of Larval Fishes: Roles of Competition and Zooplankton Abundance

Abstract -Interactions among larval gizzard shad Dorosoma cepedianum, bluegills Lepomis macrochirus, and their zooplankton prey were examined in a controlled mesocosm experiment and by field sampling. In the mesocosm experiment, gizzard shad growth and survival were negatively correlated with gizzard shad density and positively correlated with macrozooplankton prey. Bluegill growth was positively correlated with prey availability, but survival was uniformly high despite differences in zooplankton abundance and fish density. Macrozooplankton and copepod biomasses were negatively correlated with fish density. In Lake Shelbyville, co-occurrence of larval gizzard shad and bluegills in the limnetic zone was limited to a 3-week period, and the period of greatest larval gizzard shad abundance preceded the appearance of bluegills. Zooplankton abundance declined greatly after the peak in larval gizzard shad abundance and remained low when bluegills were present. Growth rates of gizzard shad were highest early and ...

Bioenergetics Modeling in the 21st Century: Reviewing New Insights and Revisiting Old Constraints

Abstract The development and application of fish bioenergetics models have flourished in recent years, due in part to the complexity of the issues being faced by fisheries biologists. As with any model, the accuracy of bioenergetics models can be hampered by uncertainty in model parameters. A review of the literature showed that field and laboratory tests of bioenergetics models often result in poor agreement between model predictions and independent data. Nonetheless, bioenergetics modeling continues to be used to make important management decisions. Recent tests of model predictions have shown that parameter uncertainty is influenced by factors such as feeding rate, physiological adaptations, and prey composition and abundance. In an attempt to reduce the uncertainty in modeling applications, we propose a framework that highlights the importance of (1) model evaluation, (2) hypothesis-based parameter testing, and (3) improved communication between model developers and model users. Adherence to this fram...

Physiological and Behavioral Consequences of Long‐Term Artificial Selection for Vulnerability to Recreational Angling in a Teleost Fish

Few studies have examined the physiological and behavioral consequences of fisheries‐induced selection. We evaluated how four generations of artificial truncation selection for vulnerability to recreational angling (i.e., stocks selected for high and low vulnerability [HVF and LVF, respectively]) affected cardiovascular physiology and parental care behavior in the teleost fish largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides. Where possible, we compared artificially selected fish to control fish (CF) collected from the wild. Although, compared to control fish, resting cardiac activity was ∼18% lower for LVF and ∼20% higher for HVF, maximal values did not vary among treatments. As a result, the HVF had less cardiac scope than either LVF or CF. Recovery rates after exercise were similar for HVF and CF but slower for LVF. When engaged in parental care activities, nesting male HVF were captured more easily than male LVF. During parental care, HVF also had higher turning rates and pectoral and caudal fin beat rates, increased vigilance against predators, and higher in situ swimming speeds. Energetics simulations indicated that to achieve the same level of growth, the disparity in metabolic rates would require HVF to consume approximately 40% more food than LVF. Selection for angling vulnerability resulted in clear differences in physiological and energetic attributes. Not only is vulnerability to angling a heritable trait, but high vulnerability covaries with factors including higher metabolic rates, reduced metabolic scope, and increased parental care activity. Despite these energetically costly differences, HVF and LVF of the same age were of similar size, suggesting that heightened food consumption in HVF compensated for added costs in experimental ponds. Ultimately, angling vulnerability appears to be a complex interaction of numerous factors leading to selection for very different phenotypes. If HVF are selectively harvested from a population, the remaining fish in that population may be less effective in providing parental care, potentially reducing reproductive output. The strong angling pressure in many freshwater systems, and therefore the potential for this to occur in the wild, necessitate management approaches that recognize the potential evolutionary consequences of angling.

Fish Size and Prey Availability Affect Growth, Survival, Prey Selection, and Foraging Behavior of Larval Yellow Perch

Abstract Zooplankton availability is strongly linked with the growth, survival, and ultimately recruitment of fish during their early life history. We examined how different types of zooplankton affected the growth, survival, and prey selection of larval yellow perch Perca flavescens in a series of laboratory experiments. The growth and survival of newly hatched (5–7-mm) to 12-mm yellow perch larvae was greatest when feeding on adult copepods and copepod nauplii. The growth and survival of yellow perch larvae longer than 12 mm was greatest when feeding on adult copepods and small cladocerans. Prey selection patterns closely followed trends in growth and survival; smaller larvae positively selected adult and naupliar copepods, whereas larger larvae selected adult copepods and small cladocerans. Foraging behavior experiments conducted with larvae longer than 12 mm revealed that these fish derived similar energetic gains when feeding solely on adult copepods and small cladocerans. The pathway to this energet...

Recreational fishing selectively captures individuals with the highest fitness potential

Fisheries-induced evolution and its impact on the productivity of exploited fish stocks remains a highly contested research topic in applied fish evolution and fisheries science. Although many quantitative models assume that larger, more fecund fish are preferentially removed by fishing, there is no empirical evidence describing the relationship between vulnerability to capture and individual reproductive fitness in the wild. Using males from two lines of largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) selectively bred over three generations for either high (HV) or low (LV) vulnerability to angling as a model system, we show that the trait “vulnerability to angling” positively correlates with aggression, intensity of parental care, and reproductive fitness. The difference in reproductive fitness between HV and LV fish was particularly evident among larger males, which are also the preferred mating partners of females. Our study constitutes experimental evidence that recreational angling selectively captures individuals with the highest potential for reproductive fitness. Our study further suggests that selective removal of the fittest individuals likely occurs in many fisheries that target species engaged in parental care. As a result, depending on the ecological context, angling-induced selection may have negative consequences for recruitment within wild populations of largemouth bass and possibly other exploited species in which behavioral patterns that determine fitness, such as aggression or parental care, also affect their vulnerability to fishing gear.

Life in the fast lane: fish and foodweb structure in the main channel of large rivers

We studied the main channel of the lower Illinois River and of the Mississippi River just upstream and downstream of its confluence with the Illinois River to describe the abundance, composition, and/or seasonal appearance of components of the main-channel community. Abundance of fishes in the main channel was high, especially adults. Most adult fishes were present in the main channel for either 3 or 4 seasons/y, indicating that fishes regularly reside in the main channel. We documented abundant zooplankton and benthic invertebrates in the main channel, and the presence of these food types in the diets of channel catfish and freshwater drum. All trophic levels were well represented in the main channel, indicating that the main channel supports a unique food web. The main channel also serves as an important energetic link with other riverine habitats (e.g., floodplains, secondary channels, backwater lakes) because of the mobility of resident fishes and because of the varied energy sources supplying this food web. It may be more realistic to view energy flow in large-river systems as a combination of 3 existing concepts, the river continuum concept (downstream transport), the flood pulse concept (lateral transport to the floodplain), and the riverine productivity model (autochthonous production). We urge additional research to quantify the links between the main channel and other habitat types in large rivers because of the apparent importance of main-channel processes in the overall structure and function of large-river ecosystems.

Relative Weight (Wr ) as a Field Assessment Tool: Relationships with Growth, Prey Biomass, and Environmental Conditions

We evaluated the relative weight (Wr) condition index as a field assessment tool with pumpkin seed Lepomis gibbosus and golden shiner Notemigonus crysoleucas, focusing on sources of variability and potential of Wr as a predictor of growth, prey availability, and environmental conditions in 10 southern Quebec lakes over 2 years. To allow calculation of Wr, we developed standard weight (Ws) equations for both species, using the regression-line-percentile (RLP) tech- nique. The proposed Wv equation in metric units (grams wet weight and millimeters total legnth, TL) for pumpkinseed is log|<)W; v = -5.179 + 3.237 log,0TL; for golden shiner it is Iog!0lV;v = —5.593 + 3.302 logioTL. Spatial and temporal variation in Wr was highly significant and largely asynchronous in both species, although spring values were lowest in most lakes. The Wr index frequently varied with length, prompting us to examine relationships in stock and quality length fish separately. We found little evidence for a relationship between Wr and growth in either species. Pumpkinseed Wf& were positively correlated with total benthic invertebrate biomass: stock length Wr was positively correlated with chironomid biomass, and quality length Wr was positively correlated with gastropod biomass. The relative weight of quality length golden shiners was positively correlated with chironomid biomass. Our results and those of other studies suggest that the common assumption of a relationship between Wr and growth in field populations should be reconsidered, but that Wr could be cautiously used as a working index of prey availability. We recommend empirical or experimental verification when Wr is used as an assessment tool in field populations.

ENERGETICS, PREDATION, AND RATION AFFECT SIZE‐DEPENDENT GROWTH AND MORTALITY OF FISH DURING WINTER

Winter temperatures may reduce energy costs for ectotherms. However, variable mid-temperate and low-latitude winters may interact with scaling of size, metabolism, and energy reserves to cause energy deficits and require trade-offs between foraging and predation. A dynamic optimization model explored how ration, fall fat, and both non- and size-selective predation influenced foraging (i.e., fast or forage) and energy allocation (i.e., length or fat) decisions that maximize winter survival of age-0 largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides). During a mid-latitude (38° N) winter, a pond experiment in which age-0 fish occurred with or without adult conspecific predators tested a subset of the model. In the model without predators, winter foraging occurred, with small size only reducing survival when low ration and low fall fat caused small fish to exhaust reserves. With predation, all sizes foraged to maintain mass and fat reserves when ration was sufficiently high, with small fish also growing in length. When modeled predation was nonselective, size-dependent mortality varied in complex ways. In contrast, size-selective predators consistently reduced survival of small fish. Generally consistent with the model, fish in ponds without predators gained mass and energy content, while those with predators only maintained these parameters. All small individuals grew more than large counterparts in length. Mortality in ponds never depended on size but was ∼20% higher with predators. Energy deficits often demand active foraging during mid-temperate winters, with predation rather than energy depletion influencing size-dependent survival.

The Effects of Turbidity on Prey Selection by Piscivorous Largemouth Bass

Abstract Turbidity in aquatic systems can change rapidly, affecting the visual ability of predators. Increased turbidity is known to reduce the reactive distance and foraging success of some planktivores and insectivores, leading to decreased growth rates. However, little is known about the effects of turbidity on prey selection by piscivores. We examined the interactions between largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides and their prey in 1.8-m-diameter tanks (58 cm deep) at four turbidity levels (0, 5, 10, and 40 nephelometric turbidity units [NTU]). Prey selectivity was significantly affected by turbidity. At lower turbidity levels (0 and 5 NTU), largemouth bass consumed mostly gizzard shad Dorosoma cepedianum and bluegills Lepomis macrochirus and had negative selectivity for northern crayfish Orconectes virilis. At 10 NTU, all three prey types had similar selectivity, presumably because the largemouth bass had more difficulty in capturing rapidly moving fish prey as their reactive distances decreased. At 4...