David M. J. Lilley

Nucleic acids and molecular biology

A wide range of topics are covered, including articles on nucleic acid structure, through their interactions with proteins to the control of gene expressions. A number of authors address the subject of RNA, including the difficult but important subject of its chemical synthesis, the complexities of its structures and the mechanisms of transcript splicing. The probing of DNA structure is reviewed in papers on the applications of dydroxyl radical and 1,10 phenanthroline copper cleavages. A number of important DNA-protein interactions are discussed, including DNA polymerase, the tryptophan and deoR repressors, and the resolvase enzymes which cleave Holliday junctions in recombination. Gene transcription is also covered, from the points of view of DNA methylation, mammalian ribosomal and avian lysozyme genes, and the control of transcription in the proto-oncogene c-fos. Finally, the plant kingdom has not been forgotten with articles on development and transposition in plants.

The structure of the Holliday junction, and its resolution.

The Holliday (four-way) junction is a critical intermediate in homologous genetic recombination. We have studied the structure of a series of four-way junctions, constructed by hybridization of four 80 nucleotide synthetic oligonucleotides. These molecules migrate anomalously slowly in gel electrophoresis. Each arm of any junction could be selectively shortened by cleavage at a unique restriction site, and we have studied the relative gel mobilities of species in which two arms were cleaved. The pattern of fragments observed argues strongly for a structure with two-fold symmetry, based on an X shape, the long arms of which are made from pairwise colinear association of helical arms. The choice of partners is governed by the base sequence at the junction, allowing a potential isomerization between equivalent structural forms. Resolvase enzymes can distinguish between these structures, and the resolution products are determined by the structure adopted, i.e., by the sequence at the junction. In the absence of cations, the helical arms of the junction are fully extended in a square configuration, and unstacking results in junction thymines becoming reactive to osmium tetroxide.

Structures of helical junctions in nucleic acids.

Our knowledge of the architectural principles of nucleic acid junctions has seen significant recent advances. The conformation of DNA junctions is now well understood, and this provides a new basis for the analysis of important structural elements in RNA. The most significant new data have come from X-ray crystallography of four-way DNA junctions; incidentally showing the great importance of serendipity in science, since none of the three groups had deliberately set out to crystallise a junction. Fortunately the results confirm, and of course extend, the earlier conformational studies of DNA junctions in almost every detail. This is important, because it means that these methods can be applied with greater confidence to new systems, especially in RNA. Methods like FRET, chemical probing and even the humble polyacrylamide gel can be rapid and very powerful, allowing the examination of a large number of sequence variants relatively quickly. Molecular modelling in conjunction with experiments is also a very important component of the general approach. Ultimately crystallography provides the gold standard for structural analysis, but the other, simple approaches have considerable value along the way. At the beginning of this review I suggested two simple folding principles for branched nucleic acids, and it is instructive to review these in the light of recent data. In brief, these were the tendency for pairwise coaxial stacking of helical arms, and the importance of metal ion interactions in the induction of folding. We see that both are important in a wide range of systems, both in DNA and RNA. The premier example is the four-way DNA junction, which undergoes metal ion-induced folding into the stacked X-structure that is based on coaxial stacking of arms. As in many systems, there are two alternative ways to achieve this depending on the choice of stacking partners. Recent data reveal that both forms often exist in a dynamic equilibrium, and that the relative stability of the two conformers depends upon base sequence extending a significant distance from the junction. The three-way junction has provided a good test of the folding principles. Perfect three-way (3H) DNA junctions seem to defy these principles in that they appear reluctant to undergo coaxial stacking of arms, and exhibit little change in conformation with addition of metal ions. Modelling suggests that such a junction is stereochemically constrained in an extended conformation. However, upon inclusion of a few additional base pairs at the centre (to create a 3HS2 junction for example) the additional stereochemical flexibility allows two arms to undergo coaxial stacking. Such a junction exhibits all the properties consistent with the general folding principles, with ion-induced folding into a form based on pairwise coaxial stacking of arms in one of two different conformers. The three-way junction is therefore very much the exception that proves the rule. It is instructive to compare the folding of corresponding species in DNA and RNA, where we find both similarities and differences. The RNA four-way junction can adopt a structure that is globally similar to the stacked X-structure (Duckett et al. 1995a), and the crystal structure of the DNAzyme shows that the stacked X-conformation can include one helical pair in the A-conformation (Nowakowski et al. 1999). However, modelling suggests that the juxtaposition of strands and grooves will be less satisfactory in RNA, and the higher magnesium ion concentration required to fold the RNA junction indicates a lower stability of the antiparallel form. Perhaps the biggest difference between the properties of the DNA and RNA four-way junctions is the lack of an unstacked structure at low salt concentrations for the RNA species. This clearly reflects a major difference in the electrostatic interactions in the RNA junction. In general the folding of branched DNA provides some good indications on the likely folding of the corresponding RNA species, but caution is required in making the extrapolation because the two polymers are significantly different. A number of studies point to the flexibility and malleability of branched nucleic acids, and this turns out to have particular significance in their interactions with proteins. Proteins such as the DNA junction-resolving enzymes exhibit considerable selectivity for the structure of their substrates, which is still not understood at a molecular level. Despite this, it appears to be universally true that these proteins distort the global, and in some cases at least the local, structure of the junctions. The somewhat perplexing result is that the proteins appear to distort the very property that they recognise. In general it seems that four-way DNA junctions are opened to one extent or another by interaction with proteins. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Generation of Superhelical Torsion by ATP-Dependent Chromatin Remodeling Activities

ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling activities participate in the alteration of chromatin structure during gene regulation. All have DNA- or chromatin-stimulated ATPase activity and many can alter the structure of chromatin; however, the means by which they do this have remained unclear. Here we describe a novel activity for ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling activities, the ability to generate unconstrained negative superhelical torsion in DNA and chromatin. We find that the ability to distort DNA is shared by the yeast SWI/SNF complex, Xenopus Mi-2 complex, recombinant ISWI, and recombinant BRG1, suggesting that the generation of superhelical torsion represents a primary biomechanical activity shared by all Snf2p-related ATPase motors. The generation of superhelical torque provides a potent means by which ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling activities can manipulate chromatin structure.

Orientation dependence in fluorescent energy transfer between Cy3 and Cy5 terminally attached to double-stranded nucleic acids

We have found that the efficiency of fluorescence resonance energy transfer between Cy3 and Cy5 terminally attached to the 5′ ends of a DNA duplex is significantly affected by the relative orientation of the two fluorophores. The cyanine fluorophores are predominantly stacked on the ends of the helix in the manner of an additional base pair, and thus their relative orientation depends on the length of the helix. Observed fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) efficiency depends on the length of the helix, as well as its helical periodicity. By changing the helical geometry from B form double-stranded DNA to A form hybrid RNA/DNA, a marked phase shift occurs in the modulation of FRET efficiency with helix length. Both curves are well explained by the standard geometry of B and A form helices. The observed modulation for both polymers is less than that calculated for a fully rigid attachment of the fluorophores. However, a model involving lateral mobility of the fluorophores on the ends of the helix explains the observed experimental data. This has been further modified to take account of a minor fraction of unstacked fluorophore observed by fluorescent lifetime measurements. Our data unequivocally establish that Förster transfer obeys the orientation dependence as expected for a dipole–dipole interaction.

Structural dynamics of individual Holliday junctions

The four-way DNA (Holliday) junction is the central intermediate of genetic recombination, but the dynamic aspects of this important structure are presently unclear. Although transitions between alternative stacking conformers have been predicted, conventional kinetic studies are precluded by the inability to synchronize the junction in a single conformer in bulk solution. Using single-molecule fluorescence methodology we have been able to detect these transitions. The sequence dependence, the influence of counterions and measured energetic barriers indicate that the conformer transition and branch migration processes share the unstacked, open structure as the common intermediate but have different rate-limiting steps. Relative rates indicate that multiple conformer transitions occur at each intermediate step of branch migration, allowing the junction to reach conformational equilibrium. This provides a mechanism whereby the sequence-dependent conformational bias could determine the extent of genetic exchange upon junction resolution.

The DNA binding site of HMG1 protein is composed of two similar segments (HMG boxes), both of which have counterparts in other eukaryotic regulatory proteins.

The mammalian nuclear protein HMG1 contains two segments that show a high sequence similarity to each other. Each of the segments, produced separately from the rest of the protein in Escherichia coli, binds to DNA with high specificity: four‐way junction DNA of various sequences is bound efficiently, but linear duplex DNA is not. Both isolated segments exists as dimers in solution, as shown by gel filtration and chemical crosslinking experiments. HMG1‐like proteins are present in yeast and in protozoa: they consist of a single repetition of a motif extremely similar to the DNA binding segments of HMG1, suggesting that they too might form dimers with structural specificity in DNA binding. Sequences with recognizable similarity to either of the two DNA binding segments of HMG1, called HMG boxes, also occur in a few eukaryotic regulatory proteins. However, these proteins are reported to bind to specific sequences, suggesting that the HMG box of proteins distantly related to HMG1 might differ significantly from the HMG box of HMG1‐like proteins.

A four-way junction accelerates hairpin ribozyme folding via a discrete intermediate

The natural form of the hairpin ribozyme comprises two major structural elements: a four-way RNA junction and two internal loops carried by adjacent arms of the junction. The ribozyme folds into its active conformation by an intimate association between the loops, and the efficiency of this process is greatly enhanced by the presence of the junction. We have used single-molecule spectroscopy to show that the natural form fluctuates among three distinct states: the folded state and two additional, rapidly interconverting states (proximal and distal) that are inherited from the junction. The proximal state juxtaposes the two loop elements, thereby increasing the probability of their interaction and thus accelerating folding by nearly three orders of magnitude and allowing the ribozyme to fold rapidly in physiological conditions. Therefore, the hairpin ribozyme exploits the dynamics of the junction to facilitate the formation of the active site from its other elements. Dynamic interplay between structural elements, as we demonstrate for the hairpin ribozyme, may be a general theme for other functional RNA molecules.

The role of metal ions in the conformation of the four-way DNA junction.

Metal ions fold DNA junctions into a compact conformation that confers protection of all thymine bases to modification by osmium tetroxide. In the absence of the cation the arms of the junction are fully extended in an approximately square‐planar configuration. Group IIa cations are effective in achieving a folded conformation of the junction at 80‐100 microM, and there is an excellent agreement between the ionic concentrations that fold the junctions as deduced from gel electrophoretic experiments, and those that prevent osmium tetroxide reaction at the junction. Hexamminecobalt(III) achieves full folding at 2 microM, while spermine and spermidine are effective at 25 microM. Some transition metal ions such as Ni(II) may replace the group IIA cations. Monovalent ions of group IA are only partially effective in folding the junctions. Very much higher concentrations are necessary, gel electrophoretic mobilities suggest that a less symmetrical conformation is adopted and thymine bases at the junction remain reactive to osmium tetroxide. Charge‐charge interactions at the centre of the junction are structurally extremely important. Substitution of junction phosphate groups by uncharged methyl phosphonates severely perturbs the structure of the junction. If just two phosphates are substituted, diametrically facing across the junction, the structure always folds in order to place the electrically neutral phosphate on the exchanging strands. We suggest that folding of the junction into the stacked X‐structure generates electronegative clefts that can selectively bind metal ions, depending on the chemistry, size and charge of the ion. Moreover, occupation of these cavities is essential for junction folding, in order to reduce electrostatic repulsion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Ion-induced folding of the hammerhead ribozyme: a fluorescence resonance energy transfer study.

The ion‐induced folding transitions of the hammerhead ribozyme have been analysed by fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The hammerhead ribozyme may be regarded as a special example of a three‐way RNA junction, the global structure of which has been studied by comparing the distances (as energy transfer efficiencies) between the ends of pairs of labelled arms for the three possible end‐to‐end vectors as a function of magnesium ion concentration. The data support two sequential ion‐dependent transitions, which can be interpreted in the light of the crystal structures of the hammerhead ribozyme. The first transition corresponds to the formation of a coaxial stacking between helices II and III; the data can be fully explained by a model in which the transition is induced by a single magnesium ion which binds with an apparent association constant of 8000–10 000 M−1. The second structural transition corresponds to the formation of the catalytic domain of the ribozyme, induced by a single magnesium ion with an apparent association constant of ∼1100 M−1. The hammerhead ribozyme provides a well‐defined example of ion‐dependent folding in RNA.