David M. Tricoli

Comparative virus resistance and fruit yield of transgenic squash with single and multiple coat protein genes

Five transgenic squash lines expressing coat protein (CP) genes from cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV), zucchini yellow mosaic potyvirus (ZYMV), and watermelon mosaic virus 2 potyvirus (WMV 2) were analyzed in the field for their reaction to mixed infections by these three viruses and for fruit production. Test plants were exposed to natural inoculations via aphids in trials simulating the introduction of viruses by secondary spread from mechanically infected susceptible border row plants. Plants of transgenic line CZW-3 expressing the CP genes from CMV, ZYMV, and WMV 2 displayed the highest level of resistance with no systemic infection, although 64% exhibited localized chlorotic dots which were mainly confined to older leaves. CZW-3 plants had a 50-fold increase in marketable yield compared to controls and the highest predicted cash returns. Plants of transgenic line ZW-20 expressing the CP genes from ZYMV and WMV 2 displayed high levels of resistance to these two potyviruses, but 22% became infected by CMV. However, ZW-20 plants provided a 40-fold increase in marketable yield relative to controls and good estimated cash returns. Three transgenic lines expressing single CP genes from either ZYMV (line Z-33), WMV 2 (line W-164) or CMV (line C-14) developed systemic symptoms similar to those of controls but showed a delay of 2 to 4 weeks before the onset of disease. Plants of transgenic line Z-33 were highly resistant to ZYMV but not to WMV 2 and CMV. Interestingly, Z-33 plants had a 20-fold increase in marketable yield compared to controls and some predicted cash returns if market sale prices were high. This study indicates that virus-resistant transgenic lines are economically viable even if they are affected by viruses other than those to which they are resistant.

Cantaloupe line CZW-30 containing coat protein genes of cucumber mosaic virus, zucchini yellow mosaic virus, and watermelon mosaic virus-2 is resistant to these three viruses in the field

Cantaloupe line CZW-30 containing coat protein gene constructs of cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV), zucchini yellow mosaic potyvirus (ZYMV), and watermelon mosaic virus 2 potyvirus (WMV-2) was investigated in the field over two consecutive years for resistance to infections by CMV, ZYMV, and/or WMV-2. Resistance was evaluated under high disease pressure achieved by mechanical inoculations and/or natural challenge inoculations by indigenous aphid vectors. Across five different trials, homozygous plants were highly resistant in that they never developed systemic symptoms as did the nontransformed plants but showed few symptomatic leaves confined close to the vine tips. Hemizygous plants exhibited a significant delay (2–3 weeks) in the onset of disease compared to control plants but had systemic symptoms 9–10 weeks after transplanting to the field. Importantly, ELISA data revealed that transgenic plants reduced the incidence of mixed infections. Only 8% of the homozygous and 33% of the hemizygous plants were infected by two or three viruses while 99% of the nontransformed plants were mixed infected. This performance is of epidemiological significance. In addition, control plants were severely stunted (44% reduction in shoot length) and had poor fruit yield (62% loss) compared to transgenic plants, and most of their fruits (60%) were unmarketable. Remarkably, hemizygous plants yielded 7.4 times more marketable fruits than control plants, thus suggesting a potential commercial performance. This is the first report on extensive field trials designed to assess the resistance to mixed infection by CMV, ZYMV, and WMV-2, and to evaluate the yield of commercial quality cantaloupes that are genetically engineered.

Combining transgenic and natural resistance to obtain broad resistance to tospovirus infection in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum mill)

This study was undertaken to develop tomato plants with broad resistanceto tospoviruses which are a major limiting factor to tomato productionworldwide. A nontransgenic tomato line Stevens-Rodale (S-R), six transgenictomato lines expressing the nucleocapsid (N) protein gene of the lettuceisolate of tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV-BL), and progeny of the crosses between S-Rand three of the transgenic lines homozygous for the N gene were evaluated fortheir resistance to tospovirus infection in greenhouse inoculation tests. S-Rhas the Sw-5 gene that confers resistance to several TSWVisolates. The six transgenic lines showed high levels of resistance wheninoculated with either TSWV-BL or a tomato isolate from Hawaii (TSWV-H).However, these same plants were highly susceptible to the Brazilian isolate ofgroundnut ringspot virus (GRSV-BR). Plants with the Sw-5gene were resistant to TSWV-BL and GRSV-BR, but were susceptible to TSWV-H.When inoculated with any of the three viruses, the F1 progeny of thecrosses exhibited a susceptible, tolerant, or resistant phenotype with a higherproportion of the plants being either tolerant or resistant. When F2progeny from F1 resistant plants of each cross were inoculated withany of the three viruses, a higher proportion of tolerant and resistant plantswas observed compared to the F1 progeny. Our results show thepotential to obtain broad resistance to tospoviruses by combining transgenicand natural resistance in a single plant.

Evidence that resistance in squash mosaic comovirus coat protein-transgenic plants is affected by plant developmental stage and enhanced by combination of transgenes from different lines.

Three transgenic lines of squash hemizygous for the coat protein genes of squash mosaic virus (SqMV) were shown previously to have resistant (SqMV-127), susceptible (SqMV-22) or recovery (SqMV-3) phenotypes. Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) was the underlying mechanism for resistance of SqMV-127. Here, experiments conducted to determine the mechanism of the recovery phenotype and whether enhanced resistance could be obtained by combining transgenes from susceptible and recovery plants are reported. Upper leaves of SqMV-3 plants were sampled for Northern analysis at 17, 31 and 45 days after germination (DAG) and a proportion of plants were inoculated with SqMV. SqMV-3 plants inoculated at a young stage (17 DAG) showed susceptible or recovery phenotypes. However, a number of plants inoculated at later developmental stages (31 or 45 DAG) were resistant to infection. Resistance of recovery plants was due to PTGS that was activated at a later developmental stage, independent of virus infection. Similar results were observed with plants grown under field conditions. To investigate the interactions of transgenes, progeny of crosses between SqMV-127, -3 and -22 were inoculated with SqMV. Progeny with the transgene of line 127 were resistant. However, a number of plants with transgenes from the recovery and susceptible lines or the self-pollinated recovery line were resistant even when inoculated at a young stage. Northern analysis suggested that resistance was due to PTGS. The results reveal that the timing of PTGS and consequent resistance of the transgenic plants were affected by their developmental stage and the interaction of transgene inserts.