David P. Desmond

Development and validation of a brief screening version of the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire

OBJECTIVE The goal of this study was to develop and validate a short form of the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire (the CTQ-SF) as a screening measure for maltreatment histories in both clinical and nonreferred groups. METHOD Exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses of the 70 original CTQ items were used to create a 28-item version of the scale (25 clinical items and three validity items) and test the measurement invariance of the 25 clinical items across four samples: 378 adult substance abusing patients from New York City, 396 adolescent psychiatric inpatients, 625 substance abusing individuals from southwest Texas, and 579 individuals from a normative community sample (combined N=1978). RESULTS Results showed that the CTQ-SFs items held essentially the same meaning across all four samples (i.e., measurement invariance). Moreover, the scale demonstrated good criterion-related validity in a subsample of adolescents on whom corroborative data were available. CONCLUSIONS These findings support the viability of the CTQ-SF across diverse clinical and nonreferred populations.

Obtaining follow-up interviews for treatment evaluation☆

Studies of the outcomes of substance abuse treatment are often handicapped because of subjects lost to follow-up. While follow-up data may be obtained from several sources, the follow-up interview often serves as the principal source of data. Difficulties are regularly encountered in locating and interviewing subjects not in treatment. From review of the literature on follow-up methodology and our own experience, we identified 10 procedures for effective follow-up. Application of these procedures is illustrated in a follow-up study of illicit opioid users treated in a methadone maintenance program. Follow-up interviews were obtained with 98% of the subjects. We recommend use of the 10 procedures by follow-up researchers, and we also recommend review of several previous publications on follow-up methodology.

An Ethnographic Comparison of HIV Risk Behaviors Among Heroin and Methamphetamine Injectors

Drug injection and other practices affecting the risk of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection were studied among 154 heroin users and 45 methamphetamine users in San Antonio, Texas. Amphetamine users were younger, mostly white, and had less-severe drug dependence. Heroin users had significantly higher levels of needle risk, as indicated by frequency of injection, number of persons sharing equipment, and place of injection. Methamphetamine users tended to buy syringes in lots of 10 or more from pharmacies and to use a syringe less than 5 times before discarding it. Heroin users tended to buy 1 needle at a time from an illicit source and to use it more than 20 times. Of methamphetamine users, 71% had more than one sex partner, compared to 39% of heroin users. Partners of methamphetamine users were more likely to be drug injectors than were partners of heroin users. Fewer methamphetamine users reported a behavior change in response to the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) epidemic, and fewer had been contacted by AIDS Education/Outreach. We suggest that efforts to promote risk reduction among methamphetamine users be stepped up because this population has been underserved and because less-sweeping behavior changes are needed to reduce needle-related risks to acceptable levels.

RELIABILITY AND VALIDITY OF INFORMATION FROM CHRONIC HEROIN USERS

Abstract Data on 12 life history variables obtained by interviews with 34 chronic heroin users at the time of admission to a treatment program were compared with data on the same variables obtained by later research interviews with the same subjects, and from other sources. The principal findings included: 1. (1) High percentages, 71 per cent or higher, of exact or approximate agreement between the two sources of information were found on nine of the 12 variables studied. This finding is consistent with reports of most previous studies by other investigators. 2. (2) With the exception of two variables, remarkably close agreement between the two sources was found in the estimates of central tendency and variability on the variables measured by interval scales. 3. (3) Noteworthy systematic discrepancy between the two sources was found on two variables: number of treatment interactions and number of arrests. The subjects underreported frequency of treatment and of arrest. 4. (4) Conditions which seemed to affect reliability of information included: refinement of measurement, misunderstanding of terms, elapsed time, repeated use, consequences of disclosure, the psychological defense of denial, and features of the interview 5. (5) Although the results of this study and of most previous studies show that chronic heroin users offen give reliable and valid life history information, uncritical acceptance seems as unwise as rejection of their statements.

Psychological distress in childhood trauma survivors who abuse drugs

The relationships between the level of childhood maltreatment and current psychological distress were examined in a community sample of 676 substance abusing men and women using a validated self-report instrument (the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire) designed to measure physical, emotional, and sexual abuse and physical and emotional neglect. Current levels of self-reported psychological distress/symptoms were measured using a 53-item Brief Symptom Inventory. Prevalence of early trauma ranged from 44% for emotional neglect to 65% for sexual abuse. The severity of all forms of childhood maltreatment were directly associated with current psychological distress.

Methadone Maintenance and Recovery from Opioid Dependence

While maintained on methadone, heroin users reduce their heroin use and related criminal activity and increase their legitimate employment. These benefits are obtained at the cost of continued opioid dependence. Furthermore, as a consequence of neural adaptation and conditioning, methadone maintenance may impede eventual recovery from opioid dependence. The authors attempt to assess such a possible effect by comparing long-term outcomes after methadone maintenance with those after drug-free treatment. In five long-term follow-up studies of methadone maintenance, the percentages found voluntarily abstinent ranged from 9 to 21. In six long-term follow-up studies of drug-free treatment, the percentages found voluntarily abstinent ranged from 10 to 19. These rates seem remarkably similar. They do not suggest that methadone maintenance impedes eventual recovery from opioid dependence, but they do not clearly exclude such an effect.

Factors Predicting Entry of Injecting Drug Users into Substance Abuse Treatment

A prospective study of 823 injecting drug users (IDUs) was made to identify baseline variables differentiating those who entered treatment during the study from those who did not enter. Variables independently associated with entering treatment in a multiple logistic regression model included (a) expressed desire for treatment, (b) being eligible for methadone maintenance, (c) two or more previous treatment admissions, (d) frequency of injection, (e) heroin use in the past 30 days, (e) being human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) positive, (f) giving money or drugs for sex, and (g) level of injection-related risk for HIV infection.

Reaching and enrolling drug users for HIV prevention : a multi-site analysis

Since 1994, several sites have participated in a NIDA Cooperative Agreement for AIDS Community-based Outreach/Intervention Research Program to examine rates of HIV risk behaviors and evaluate HIV risk reduction interventions among out-of-treatment drug injection and crack cocaine and heroin smokers. We studied the process and outcome of community outreach for recruitment of drug users in AIDS research and education projects in three metropolitan areas: St. Louis, MO; San Antonio, TX, and Durham and Wake Counties, NC. There were two primary areas of focus: (1) the level of accuracy among community health outreach workers (CHOWs) in identifying potentially eligible persons for HIV prevention, and (2) overall effectiveness in recruiting and enrolling persons in formal assessment and intervention studies. We found cross-site and within-site differences in levels of accuracy and in recruitment and enrollment yields. Drug users who had never been in treatment and drug users who had never been tested for HIV infection were underrepresented at all sites. We discuss the factors which may have contributed to cross-site and within-site differences. The findings suggest a need for continued study, refinement, and evaluation of community outreach strategies in order to enroll a broad spectrum of vulnerable groups in HIV prevention activities.

Attitudes toward methadone maintenance: implications for HIV prevention.

Attitudes of opioid users toward methadone maintenance were studied using semi-structured field interviews. One hundred and sixty-one heroin and speedball users in San Antonio, Texas, were interviewed between 1989 and 1992. Users were classified according to whether or not they had ever been on methadone maintenance. Opioid users who had never been on methadone maintenance were more likely to express a negative attitude toward methadone maintenance than users who had been on it (50% versus 30%). Sources of negative attitudes fell into the following categories: (1) general societal disapproval of addictive drugs, including methadone; (2) prior experience with 12 Step groups or abstinence-based treatment programs; (3) previous forced rapid detoxification from methadone in jail; and (4) observation of methadone maintained peers who continued to use drugs. Very few respondents reported adverse effects from methadone itself as a source of negative attitudes. Sources of positive attitudes included: (1) prior successful treatment with methadone; and (2) observation of methadone patients who stopped using drugs.

Ten-Year Follow-up after Admission to Methadone Maintenance

To assess the long-term effects of methadone maintenance, we compared the 10-year outcomes of 95 chronic opioid users who spent at least one cumulative year on methadone with those of 77 chronic opioid users who spent less than one cumulative year on methadone. All subjects were men and 90% were Mexican-American. The two groups were similar on 12 of 15 background variables. During the 10-year period, the methadone group had a cumulative mean of 54 months on methadone, while the comparison group had a cumulative mean of only 2 months on methadone. On social performance, as measured by months employed and months institutionalized, the methadone group did significantly better than did the comparison group. On months of voluntary abstinence, however, the comparison group did significantly better than did the methadone group. The mean of the comparison group, 36 months, was three times greater than that, 12 months, of the methadone group. At the end of the 10-year period, 26% of the comparison group but only 7% of the methadone group had been in continuous voluntary abstinence for 3 years or longer. Methadone maintenance for 1 year or longer was inversely related to abstinence during and at the end of the 10 years. This finding seems consistent with the hypothesis that methadone maintenance for 1 year or longer impedes eventual recovery from opioid dependence. For many patients, however, the benefits of prolonged maintenance could outweigh the possible cost of diminished likelihood of eventual recovery.