David W. Baker

Nanomaterial cytotoxicity is composition, size, and cell type dependent

BackgroundDespite intensive research efforts, reports of cellular responses to nanomaterials are often inconsistent and even contradictory. Additionally, relationships between the responding cell type and nanomaterial properties are not well understood. Using three model cell lines representing different physiological compartments and nanomaterials of different compositions and sizes, we have systematically investigated the influence of nanomaterial properties on the degrees and pathways of cytotoxicity. In this study, we selected nanomaterials of different compositions (TiO2 and SiO2 nanoparticles, and multi-wall carbon nanotubes [MWCNTs]) with differing size (MWCNTs of different diameters < 8 nm, 20-30 nm, > 50 nm; but same length 0.5-2 μm) to analyze the effects of composition and size on toxicity to 3T3 fibroblasts, RAW 264.7 macrophages, and telomerase-immortalized (hT) bronchiolar epithelial cells.ResultsFollowing characterization of nanomaterial properties in PBS and serum containing solutions, cells were exposed to nanomaterials of differing compositions and sizes, with cytotoxicity monitored through reduction in mitochondrial activity. In addition to cytotoxicity, the cellular response to nanomaterials was characterized by quantifying generation of reactive oxygen species, lysosomal membrane destabilization and mitochondrial permeability. The effect of these responses on cellular fate - apoptosis or necrosis - was then analyzed. Nanomaterial toxicity was variable based on exposed cell type and dependent on nanomaterial composition and size. In addition, nanomaterial exposure led to cell type dependent intracellular responses resulting in unique breakdown of cellular functions for each nanomaterial: cell combination.ConclusionsNanomaterials induce cell specific responses resulting in variable toxicity and subsequent cell fate based on the type of exposed cell. Our results indicate that the composition and size of nanomaterials as well as the target cell type are critical determinants of intracellular responses, degree of cytotoxicity and potential mechanisms of toxicity.

The pivotal role of fibrocytes and mast cells in mediating fibrotic reactions to biomaterials

Almost all biomaterial implants are surrounded by a fibrotic capsule, although the mechanism of biomaterial-mediated fibrotic reactions is mostly unclear. To search for the types of cells responsible for triggering the tissue responses, we used poly-L glycolic acid polymers capable of releasing various reagents. We first identified that CD45(+)/Collagen 1(+) fibrocytes are recruited and resided within the fibrotic capsule at the implant interface. Interestingly, we found that the recruitment of fibrocytes and the extent of fibrotic tissue formation (collagen type I production) were substantially enhanced and reduced by the localized release of compound 48/80 and cromolyn, respectively. Since it is well established that compound 48/80 and cromolyn alter mast cell reactions, we hypothesized that mast cells are responsible for triggering fibrocyte recruitment and subsequent fibrotic capsule formation surrounding biomaterial implants. To directly test this hypothesis, similar studies were carried out using mast cell deficient mice, WBB6F1/J-Kit(W)/Kit(W-v)/, and their congenic controls. Indeed, mast cell deficient mice prompted substantially less fibrocyte and myofibroblast responses in comparison to C57 wild type mice controls. Most interestingly, subcutaneous mast cell reconstitution of WBB6F1/J-Kit(W)/Kit(W-v)/J mice almost completely restored the fibrocyte response in comparison to the C57 wild type response. These results indicate that the initial biomaterial interaction resulting in the stimulation of mast cells and degranulation byproducts not only stimulates the inflammatory cascade but significantly alters the downstream fibrocyte response and degree of fibrosis.

Fibroblast/fibrocyte: surface interaction dictates tissue reactions to micropillar implants.

Micropillar technology has shown great promise for medical implants or sensors in recent years. To study the influence of surface topography on cellular responses, polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) micropillar arrays with pillar spacing (20-70 μm) and height (14-25 μm) have been fabricated. The influence of micropillar arrays on cellular behavior was tested both in vitro and in vivo. Interestingly, in vitro, we observe a distinct response for 3T3 fibroblasts and RAW 264.7 macrophages to the topographical cues tested. Attachment and proliferation of fibroblasts was substantially enhanced by increasing pillar height, whereas macrophage adherence is significantly diminished by reduced pillar spacing. When implanted in the subcutaneous cavity of BALB/c mice for 14 days, we find a prevailing trend with capsule cell density and capsule thickness increasing, as both pillar height and spacing rise. Collagen deposition and neoangiogenesis, two pivotal factors in granulation tissue maturation, are also observed to have a stronger response to the increase in both pillar height and spacing. In contradiction to our original hypothesis, we observed that fibroblasts rather than macrophages are a key contributor to the in vivo outcome of micropillar arrays. Investigation into fibroblast activation, however, revealed that recruited fibrocytes, rather than resident fibroblasts, correspond to the in vivo outcome. The results from this work support the critical and often overlooked role of fibrocytes in tissue response to biomaterial implants with varying topography.

Development of optical probes for in vivo imaging of polarized macrophages during foreign body reactions

Plasticity of macrophage (MΦ) phenotypes exist in a spectrum from classically activated (M1) cells, to alternatively activated (M2) cells, contributing to both the normal healing of tissues and the pathogenesis of implant failure. Here, folate- and mannose-based optical probes were fabricated to simultaneously determine the degree of MΦ polarization. In vitro tests show the ability of these probes to specifically target M1 and M2 cells. In an in vivo murine model, they were able to distinguish between the M1-dominated inflammatory response to infection and the M2-dominated regenerative response to particle implants. Finally, the probes were used to assess the inflammatory/regenerative properties of biomaterial implants. Our results show that these probes can be used to monitor and quantify the dynamic processes of MΦ polarization and their role in cellular responses in real time.

Optical imaging of fibrin deposition to elucidate participation of mast cells in foreign body responses

Mast cell activation has been shown to be an initiator and a key determinant of foreign body reactions. However, there is no non-invasive method that can quantify the degree of implant-associated mast cell activation. Taking advantage of the fact that fibrin deposition is a hallmark of mast cell activation around biomaterial implants, a near infrared probe was fabricated to have high affinity to fibrin. Subsequent in vitro testing confirmed that this probe has high affinity to fibrin. Using a subcutaneous particle implantation model, we found significant accumulation of fibrin-affinity probes at the implant sites as early as 15 min following particle implantation. The accumulation of fibrin-affinity probes at the implantation sites could also be substantially reduced if anti-coagulant - heparin was administered at the implant sites. Further studies have shown that subcutaneous administration of mast cell activator - compound 48/80 - prompted the accumulation of fibrin-affinity probes. However, implant-associated fibrin-affinity probe accumulation was substantially reduced in mice with mast cell deficiency. The results show that our fibrin-affinity probes may serve as a powerful tool to monitor and measure the extent of biomaterial-mediated fibrin deposition and mast cell activation in vivo.

Novel Thermogelling Dispersions of Polymer Nanoparticles for Controlled Protein Release

UNLABELLED A novel poly(oligo(ethylene glycol) methyl ether methacrylate-co-oligo(ethylene glycol) ethyl ether methacrylate)-poly(acrylic acid) interpenetrating network (IPN) nanoparticle was synthesized. The temperature-responsive properties of the IPN nanoparticles were investigated by a dynamic light scattering method. Atomic force microscopic images confirmed the homogenous and monodisperse morphology of the IPN nanoparticles. Both visual observation and viscosity testing demonstrated that the IPN nanoparticles exhibit thermogelling properties at body temperature, 37 °C. Subsequent studies verified that such temperature-sensitive properties of IPN nanoparticles allow their ease of injection and then slow release of model proteins, both in vitro and in vivo. Histological analysis showed that our IPN implants exerted minimal inflammation following subcutaneous implantation. Our results support the idea that, by simply mixing with proteins of interest, the novel IPN nanoparticles can be used to form in situ thermogelling devices for controlled protein release. FROM THE CLINICAL EDITOR This paper discusses a temperature responsive interpenetrating network (IPN) polymeric nanoparticle that can be used to form in situ thermogelling devices for controlled protein release by simply mixing them with proteins of interest.

Alternative strategies to manipulate fibrocyte involvement in the fibrotic tissue response: pharmacokinetic inhibition and the feasibility of directed-adipogenic differentiation.

Fibrocytes have previously been identified as important mediators in several inflammatory and fibrotic diseases. However, there is no effective treatment thus far to reduce fibrotic tissue responses without affecting wound healing reactions. Here we investigate two strategies to alleviate fibrocyte interactions at the biomaterial interface, reducing collagen production and scar tissue formation. First, in an indirect approach, TGF-β inhibitor-SB431542 and IL-1β/TNF-α inhibitor SB203580 were locally released from scaffold implants to block their respective signaling pathways. We show that the inhibition of IL-1β/TNF-α has no influence on overall fibrotic tissue reactions to the implants. However, the reduction of localized TGF-β significantly decreases the fibrocyte accumulation and myofibroblast activation while reducing the fibrotic tissue formation. Since fibrocytes can be differentiated into non-fibrotic cell types, such as adipocytes, we further sought a more direct approach to reduce fibrocyte responses by directing fibrocyte differentiation into adipocytes. Interestingly, by initiating fibrocyte-to-adipocyte differentiation through sustained differentiation cocktail release, we find that adipogenic differentiation forces incoming fibrocytes away from the traditional myofibroblast lineage, leading to a substantial reduction in the collagen formation and fibrotic response. Our results support a novel and effective strategy to improve implant safety by reducing implant-associated fibrotic tissue reactions via directing non-fibrotic differentiation of fibrocytes.

Methods Used to Evaluate the Host Responses to Medical Implants In Vivo

The ability to depict and decipher the cues and reactions which drive the host response is of utmost importance to the safety and efficacy of biomaterial implants. Although many cell culture models have been developed to decipher the molecular mechanisms of cellular responses, animal testing remains to be the most reliable system to simulate complex cellular and tissue responses to the implants. Unfortunately, traditional histological evaluation used in animal studies is unable to identify the dynamic interplay between different cell types. Here in, we present several strategies to real-time evaluate and monitor host reactions, such as fibrin deposition, production of reactive oxygen species, pH changes, and macrophage polarity. With continued development, these methods may offer rapid, diverse, noninvasive, and cost-effective options to study and improve the design of devices and treatments with minimal adverse host reactions.

Biological and chemical influence on immune and regenerative responses to joint replacements

Abstract: Intensive research efforts have been placed on the development of biomaterials with improved cell and tissue compatibility. Most of these works have focused on modifying material properties to reduce the accumulation and activation of inflammatory cells, especially macrophages. Our recent studies have revealed that circulating fibrotic cells, fibrocytes, play an important role in the formation of fibrotic tissue surrounding biomaterial implants. In addition, we have observed substantial numbers of autologous stem cells, both mesenchymal and hematopoietic stem cells, are recruited to the implant sites. Increased recruitment of stem cells was found to reduce implant-associated inflammatory responses. This review summarizes the recent information on the interactions between biomaterial implants, fibrocytes and autologous stem cells.