Denise Donlon

The first archaeological evidence for death by spearing in Australia

An Aboriginal man done to death on the dunes 4000 years ago was recently discovered during excavations beneath a bus shelter in Narrabeen on Sydneys northern beaches. The presence of backed microliths and the evidence for trauma in the bones showed that he had been killed with stone-tipped spears. Now we know how these backed points were used. A punishment ritual is implied by analogies with contact-period observations made in the eighteenth century AD.

A comparison of cortical bone thickness in the femoral midshaft of humans and two non-human mammals

Fragments of bone shafts that lack diagnostic features can be difficult to identify as human or non-human-an important task in forensic science and archaeology. Some workers have found the thickness of cortical bone in the shaft to be a useful distinction, although the sparse literature in the field is contradictory in how this may be applied. The aim of the present study was to determine whether any difference is discernible between humans, kangaroos and sheep (mammals whose remains are commonly confused with those of humans in Australia) at the femoral midshaft, with a view to a larger-scale analysis if differences were discovered. Cross-sections at the midpoint of the shaft were measured to determine the diameter of the whole shaft and the medullary cavity on each bone; an index describing cortical thickness relative to shaft diameter was calculated. Statistically significant differences were found between all three groups, with humans showing the thickest cortical bone, and sheep the thinnest. These differences may be linked to a higher load on the human femur, due to a larger body mass carried on two legs, as opposed to the sheeps four. Further work now needs to be carried out to determine if differences are present when comparing multiple sites on the skeleton, and between non-human mammals of different sizes.

Sexual dimorphism in deciduous crown traits of a European derived Australian sample

Sex determination of juvenile skeletal remains is a problematic area affecting physical anthropology, forensic science and archaeology. Sexual dimorphism in the morphometric crown traits of the deciduous dentition may be used to help resolve this issue. Dental stone casts from a European derived Australian sample (n=151) were used to investigate variation within crown traits of the deciduous canine and molars. The metric traits investigated were crown size, trigonid size and talonid size. The morphological features included Carabellis trait and molar cusp number. Metric crown traits were significantly larger in males (p<0.05). The morphological crown traits were not significantly different between the sexes. The largest degree of sexual dimorphism was 11.11% in the trigonid mesiodistal diameter of the first deciduous molar. This is the first recording of the measurement in a European derived sample. Two multivariate statistics, linear functional discriminant analysis and binary logistic regression, were used to determine the success rate of sex classification from the crown traits. The most suitable was linear functional discriminant analysis, however similar results were found when using binary logistic regression. When using all variables investigated in this study, sex could be classified with accuracy of 70.2% from linear functional discriminant analysis (cross validated). The mandibular teeth had greater sexual dimorphism, classifying sex correctly 74.8% of the time compared to maxillary variables that had a success rate of 55.6%. Our results have shown that morphometric crown traits in the deciduous dentition can be used to classify sex of juvenile skeletons (11 months to 12 years) of European descent from linear functional discriminant analysis with accuracy between 70.2% and 74.8%.

Patterns in dental enamel hypoplasia by sex and age at death in two archaeological populations

AIMS Levels of enamel hypoplasia in past populations are frequently used to study health. However, few studies have looked at patterning in the occurrence of different types of hypoplasia. In this pilot study, skeletal remains from an Iron Age tomb at Pella in Jordan were analysed for the presence of linear and pit enamel hypoplasia, to investigate enamel hypoplasia aetiology by comparison of the results obtained for adults and juveniles, and females and males. METHODS AND RESULTS The proportion of individuals with enamel hypoplasia was determined for males and females and for adults and juveniles using the F.D.I. Developmental Defects of Enamel (DDE) Index. Although males and females had a similar percentage of individuals affected, females had a higher prevalence of enamel hypoplasia per tooth than males. Adults had a higher prevalence of enamel hypoplasia than juveniles. In particular, adults had a higher prevalence of linear enamel hypoplasias and pit enamel hypoplasia arrays, but a similar prevalence of single pit enamel hypoplasia when both the permanent and deciduous dentitions were considered. These differences were largely due to different patterns and frequencies of enamel hypoplasia in deciduous teeth compared to permanent teeth. CONCLUSIONS The different patterns of occurrence of the various forms of hypoplasia observed in this study imply that single pits may have a different aetiology to linear enamel hypoplasias and pit arrays. By investigating similar patterns in other archaeological populations, we may develop a better understanding of the specific causes of particular types of enamel hypoplasia, and may be able to more meaningfully interpret enamel hypoplasia data from past populations.

Aboriginal Skeletal Collections and Research in Physical Anthropology: An Historical Perspective

The research in physical anthropology is limited to Aboriginal skeletal remains in Australia and it has excluded Torres Strait Islander skeletal remains. The progress in some important aspects of physical anthropology of the Australian Aborigines are limited by the reburial and requirement for community permission for access to Aboriginal skeletal collections, but the research into regional anthropology and individual burials is increasing.

Variations of the paranasal sinuses in Melanesians as observed by CT.

Studies have reported the incidence of anatomical variants of the paranasal sinuses for specific populations with a view to helping surgeons avoid possible complications during functional endoscopic sinus surgery. Some have found significant variation when comparing different populations. The current study has used computed tomography (CT) scans to observe variations in the paranasal sinuses in a non-random sample of museum skulls of Melanesians, a racial group that has not previously been studied in this respect. The incidence of variants found were: agger nasi cells 59.5%, concha bullosa 41.5%/o, Hallers air cells 31.7%, internal carotid artery bulge in the sphenoid sinus 23.8%/, supraorbital cells 16. 7%, paradoxical curvature of the mid-dle turbinate 7.5% and pneumatization of crista galli 7.1%.Because of contradictory findings in the literature as to the incidence of such variations between racial groups the authors are able to make only limited meaningful comparisons between their subjects and other such groups.

Comparative cortical bone thickness between the long bones of humans and five common non-human mammal taxa.

The task of identifying fragments of long bone shafts as human or non-human is difficult but necessary, for both forensic and archaeological cases, and a fast simple method is particularly useful. Previous literature suggests there may be differences in the thickness of the cortical bone between these two groups, but this has not been tested thoroughly. The aim of this study was not only to test this suggestion, but also to provide data that could be of practical assistance for future comparisons. The major limb bones (humerus, radius, femur and tibia) of 50 Caucasoid adult skeletons of known age and sex were radiographed, along with corresponding skeletal elements from sheep, pigs, cattle, large dogs and kangaroos. Measurements were taken from the radiographs at five points along the bone shaft, of shaft diameter, cortical bone thickness, and a cortical thickness index (sum of cortices divided by shaft diameter) in both anteroposterior and mediolateral orientations. Each variable for actual cortical bone thickness as well as cortical thickness indices were compared between the human group (split by sex) and each of the non-human groups in turn, using Students t-tests. Results showed that while significant differences did exist between the human groups and many of the non-human groups, these were not all in the same direction. That is, some variables in the human groups were significantly greater than, and others were significantly less than, the corresponding variable in the non-human groups, depending on the particular non-human group, sex of the human group, or variable under comparison. This was the case for measurements of both actual cortical bone thickness and cortical thickness index. Therefore, for bone shaft fragments for which the skeletal element is unknown, the overlap in cortical bone thickness between different areas of different bones is too great to allow identification using this method alone. However, by providing extensive cortical bone thickness data for a range of bones, this study may be able to assist in the identification of some bone fragments by providing another piece of evidence that, used in conjunction with other clues, can provide a likely determination of the origin of a bone fragment.

Strontium in 19th century Australian children's teeth

The enamel of teeth from 57 children, who died in the mid to late 1800s, were analysed to investigate strontium (Sr) concentrations in historic teeth. Teeth were analysed using proton induced X-ray emission at the Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation (ANSTO). Where available, multiple teeth were analysed for each individual including permanent (molars and premolars) and deciduous teeth (molars). Preliminary results show that Sr does not appear to be affected by the postmortem environment. Sr levels in permanent molars strongly correlate with levels in the premolars but not with the deciduous molars. Concerns are raised over the large variation seen in Sr levels and the effect it would have on the interpretation of Sr levels in studies with small sample sizes.

Fundamentals of Forensic Anthropology

descendents or descendent communities. As the series editors state ‘this volume has certainly provided an interesting case of practical application of the Accord.’ This is indeed an example of defining what is reasonable and appropriate in the context of forensic application. The Series Editors and the Editors are to be congratulated for displaying a practical yet ethically based approach to this volume. The use of images throughout the book is sparing, in black and white and lacks any sense of sensationalism. That sense of professionalism is further emphasised in the concluding chapter on global perspectives by the books excellent editors, Soren Blau and Douglas Ubelaker. It is pleasing to note that Soren makes special mention of the establishment of a Medical Sciences Specialist Advisory Group under the auspices of the Senior Managers of Australian and New Zealand Forensic Laboratories (SMANZFL) umbrella. This group includes forensic anthropology and is the first time forensic anthropology has had an ‘official home’ in Australia. This volume has much to offer readers who have no special interest in the specific disciplines of forensic archaeology and anthropology. In today’s complex world, scientists from many disciplines need to work together as a team. This is best achieved when everyone appreciates, understands and respects each others roles. This book will help many understand the work of these two interrelated disciplines. Readers in Australia should be proud of the significant number of Australian contributors, which reflects well on the role being played by these disciplines in our country and region. The Editors should be congratulated on an excellent book, which should be on the bookshelf of any serious practitioner and library. The Editors state that the ‘methodologies summarised in this volume are state of the art but hardly the last word.’ However, this book should remain highly relevant for many years to come. Highly recommended!!