Derek W. R. Gray

Delayed graft function: risk factors and the relative effects of early function and acute rejection on long‐term survival in cadaveric renal transplantation

Delayed graft function (DGF) and acute rejection have both been associated with reduced renal allograft survival. In some studies, they have been shown to have an interactive effect. We studied the risk factors for DGF and the relative impact of DGF and rejection on both short‐ and long‐term survival in recipients of cadaveric renal transplants.Data from the Oxford Transplant Centre Database were assessed on 710 cadaver allografts over a 10‐yr period, during which time all recipients received cyclosporin‐based immunosuppressive protocols. The interaction between DGF and acute rejection was examined using logistic and Cox multivariate regression.Long cold ischaemia time (CIT), sensitisation and older donor age were found to be independent predictors of DGF. The occurrence of DGF resulted in a reduced 5‐yr survival (56 vs. 75%). However, the effect of DGF was confined to the first year post‐transplant, as there was no significant difference in survival, as measured by half‐life (t1/2) of grafts functioning at 1 yr, with DGF alone and a group with good early function (t1/2=21.3 vs. 20.0 yr). There was no increase in acute rejection in grafts with DGF. However, the combination of DGF and acute rejection resulted in the worst short‐term graft survival (68% at 1 yr, compared to 92.3% in those grafts with no DGF or acute rejection) and this continued over the long term (t1/2=10.5 yr).These data suggest that early function is critical to the success of renal transplantation. The effects of DGF are limited to the first year post‐transplant. Long‐term graft survival may be improved by efforts to limit CITs, particularly for grafts from older donors and sensitised recipients.

Variation in expression of endothelial adhesion molecules in pretransplant and transplanted kidneys--correlation with intragraft events.

Endothelial adhesion molecules are directly involved in the localization and migration of leukocytes from the circulation into tissues at sites of inflammation. We have compared the expression of PECAM-1 (CD31), ELAM-1, ICAM-1 (CD54), and VCAM-1 in pretransplant (n=20) and needle-core biopsies from renal transplants obtained during different clinical circumstances (n=42). PECAM-1 was consistently expressed on all endothelium in both pretransplant and transplant biopsies. In contrast, there was variation in endothelial expression of ELAM-1 and in proximal tubular expression of ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 between pretransplant biopsies. After transplantation induced expression of endothelial ELAM-1 and VCAM-1 and tubular induction of ICAM- 1 and VCAM-1 was detected. Induced adhesion molecule expression was frequently associated with focal leukocyte infiltration, and there was a significantly higher level of CD45 and CD25 positive cell infiltration in biopsies with induced adhesion molecule expression. The induction of adhesion molecule expression is evidence of endothelial activation in these transplant biopsies. Comparison of adhesion molecule expression and HLA-class II antigen expression revealed that induced tubular class II antigens may be detected in the absence of induced adhesion molecule expression.

A Method for Isolation of Islets of Langerhans from the Human Pancreas

A method has been developed for the isolation of islets of Langerhans from the human pancreas. The average number of islets isolated was 1011 islets per gram of pancreas (SD 475, range 752–2111), and the purity of the preparation as defined by histologie examination and specific staining for insulin varied from 10% to 40%. Islet structure was well preserved and the islets were shown to be viable by supravital staining, demonstration of insulin response to glucose, and by transplantation of isolated islets beneath the renal capsule of nude mice. The essential features of this technique for isolation of human islets include injection of a high concentration of collagenase (6 mg/ml) into the pancreatic duct under pressure, followed by a short incubation (23 min) at 39°C. The gland is then dispersed by a process of teasing and shaking, and the islets are separated by a two-stage process of filtration on a nylon mesh to remove the larger islets and centrifugation on a preformed Ficoll density gradient to separate the small islets.

Exocrine contamination impairs implantation of pancreatic islets transplanted beneath the kidney capsule

The effect of exocrine contamination on islets implanted under the kidney capsule has been studied by histological examination of pure or exocrine-contamination human, monkey, or rat islets transplanted to the kidney capsule of the nude rat, monkey, or rat, respectively. Exocrine contamination resulted in an appearance suggestive of impaired islet implantation, due to tissue necrosis and subsequent fibrosis. The effect of exocrine contamination was examined quantitatively in a rat islet isograft model in which handpicked DA rat islets were transplanted under the kidney capsule of normal DA rats. The islets were either pure or deliberately recontaminated with exocrine tissue (50 or 90% contamination). Four hundred pure islets were placed under one kidney capsule and 400 islets (of similar size and from the same islet preparation) were contaminated and then placed under the contralateral kidney capsule. After 2 weeks the kidneys were removed and extracted for insulin content. The insulin content of kidneys bearing islets contaminated by either 50 or 90% exocrine tissue was significantly reduced when compared to the contralateral kidney bearing pure islets. These findings support the view that exocrine contamination of islets resulted in impaired islet implantation when transplanted to a confined site such as the kidney subcapsule.

The factor V Leiden (R506Q) mutation and risk of thrombosis in renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND Renal transplantation and chronic renal failure are associated with an increased risk of venous thrombosis and myocardial infarction (MI). We investigated whether resistance to activated protein C due to a mutation in the factor V gene (FV Leiden/FV506Q) may predispose patients to thrombosis. METHODS Three hundred patients who had undergone renal transplantation were genotyped for the FV mutation. Seventy-seven patients who had suffered thrombotic complications (42 venous, 28 arterial, and 7 both) were compared with 223 patients free of thrombosis. RESULTS Thirty-two patients had suffered early renal allograft thrombosis (30 venous), and 33 patients had suffered MI. A higher proportion of the patients with thrombosis, compared to those without, had a family history of arterial cardiovascular disease (42% vs. 26%, P=0.04). Eighteen (6%) patients were heterozygous for FV506Q and seven (39%) of these had suffered venous thrombosis (including four primary allograft thromboses), compared with 15% of the patients without the mutation (P<0.05). The odds ratio for risk of venous thrombosis for FV506Q carriers was 3.6 (95% confidence interval: 1.3-9.9) or 4.0 (1.2-13.8) for primary allograft thrombosis. Only one of the FV506Q carriers had suffered an MI. CONCLUSIONS Carriers of the factor V 506Q mutation with chronic renal failure who have undergone transplantation are at an increased risk of venous but not arterial thrombosis. This mutation explained 14% of all venous and 20% of primary allograft thrombosis, suggesting that other unidentified genetic and environmental factors contribute to the risk of thrombosis in renal transplant recipients.

Patterns of graft infiltration and cytokine gene expression during the first 10 days of kidney transplantation.

Understanding of the events preceding acute cellular rejection of kidney transplants would be useful in the development of immunosuppressive strategies to prevent rejection. Information about these events in humans has been scarce, because of the lack of early, serial, biopsy samples. We took daily fine needle aspirates from kidney allografts for the first 10 days after transplant. Samples were analyzed by morphological cytology of graft-infiltrating cells, and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction for detection of interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, and gamma-interferon gene expression. During the first 4 days, all of the grafts developed a low-grade monocyte-rich mononuclear cell infiltrate, accompanied by IL-10 gene expression. Thereafter, the infiltrates either remained stable or intensified. Of the 13 grafts with dense infiltrates, seven developed graft dysfunction. The remaining six did not, despite significant interstitial infiltrates. Both rejecting and nonrejecting dense infiltrates were associated with a biphasic pattern of IL-2 and gamma-interferon gene expression, preceding and accompanying lymphocytic graft infiltration. Grafts that did not develop dense infiltrates had no detectable IL-2 or gamma-interferon gene expression and did not suffer cellular rejection during the study period. The development of both rejecting and nonrejecting infiltrates was strongly associated with DR mismatches between donor and recipient. IL-2 and gamma-interferon gene expression are necessary, but not sufficient, for the development of acute cellular rejection in the first 10 days of kidney transplantation, and are more closely associated with the period leading up to rejection than with the period of graft dysfunction.

Characterisation of collagen VI within the islet-exocrine interface of the human pancreas: implications for clinical islet isolation?

Background. To optimize the methods used for human islet isolation for transplantation, it is important to improve our understanding of the structure of the islet-exocrine interface. In this study, the composition of collagen subtypes in the interface have been characterized and quantified in human pancreas. Methods. Human adult pancreases were retrieved from older (mean age 55.7±3.0 yrs) and young donors (mean age 21.8±3.2 yrs). Tissue from the body of each pancreas was examined by quantitative immunohistochemistry. Collagen within the islet-exocrine interface was identified by immunolabeling for collagen I, IV, V or VI and islets identified either morphologically or by immunolabeling for insulin. Collagen subtypes were quantified and data expressed as collagen area at the interface relative to the islet area. Statistical analysis was by ANOVA or Mann Whitney U test. Results. In older pancreases, collagen IV, V and VI were present throughout the islet-exocrine interface, whereas collagen I was more variable. The mean peri-islet collagen VI proportion was significantly greater than that of collagen I or IV. Mean islet area and the proportional collagen VI content in specimens from younger subjects were not significantly different to those in older subjects. Conclusions. Collagen VI is a major component of the islet-exocrine interface of the adult pancreas, the content being more than double that of collagen I or IV. However, the proportional collagen VI content was not dependent on the age of the donor. These data may facilitate the design of new collagenases, targeting major substrates such as collagen VI in order to improve clinical islet isolation.

Chronic Allograft Failure in Human Renal Transplantation: A Multivariate Risk Factor Analysis

OBJECTIVE To identify potential risk factors for the development of chronic renal allograft failure. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA Chronic allograft failure (CAF) is the leading cause of late graft loss in renal transplantation. The authors studied the risk factors for the development of CAF in a single center during a period in which a consistent baseline immunosuppression regimen (cyclosporine, azathioprine, and prednisolone) was used. METHODS Data from the Oxford Transplant Center Database were assessed on 862 renal allografts during a 10-year period. Risk factors were identified using multivariate logistic regression analysis. RESULTS Biopsy-proven CAF occurred in 77 patients (9.2%) in the entire group. Multivariate risk factor analysis revealed that early and late acute rejection episodes, proteinuria, and serum triglycerides were significant factors. Acute rejection after 3 months was more important than early acute rejection. Serum triglyceride level and proteinuria at 1 year were both elevated in the CAF group. Male sex provided a protective effect. Serum creatinine levels at 6 months after the transplant were not predictive of the risk of developing CAF. CONCLUSIONS These results from the largest single-center review to date suggest that both antigen-dependent and -independent factors are involved in the pathogenesis of CAF. Acute rejection at all time points has a significant impact on the development of CAF.

Immediate destruction of xenogeneic islets in a primate model.

Transplantation of pancreatic islets from other species to man has the potential to cure diabetes, but whether such islet grafts will be subject to damage due to natural antibody-mediated hyperacute rejection is unknown. We have examined the fate of islet xenografts in a recipient with direct relevance to man, the cynomolgus monkey. Rabbit islets were prepared by an intraductal collagenase technique and incubated in neat rabbit, human, or cynomolgus serum, with and without heat inactivation, for up to 6 days. Islets were analyzed by flow cytometry for IGG and IGM binding, and scored for viability by supravital staining. For in vivo studies, isolated islets were prepared from 4 New Zealand White rabbits (15-34 x 10(3) islets 70-85% purity) and transplanted beneath the kidney capsule of normal cynomolgus monkeys after aggregation in either a rabbit or monkey blood clot. The tissue was retrieved at various times up to 4 days after transplantation and processed for light and electron microscopy. The results showed that rabbit islets bind heterophile antibody of both IGG and IGM subtypes. There was slow loss of islet viability in vitro over 3 days of culture in neat human or cynomolgus serum. Destruction of islets in vivo was more rapid with visible damage within 6 hr associated with neutrophil infiltration. Subsequently, there was heavy mononuclear cell infiltration leading to total destruction within 4 days. The results suggest that immediate mechanisms of graft rejection, possibly compliment and neutrophil mediated, represent a major barrier to islet xenotransplantation in humans.

PREEMPTIVE CADAVERIC RENAL TRANSPLANTATION-CLINICAL OUTCOME

Preemptive cadaveric renal transplantation (PCRT) maximizes the chance of maintaining high quality of life and may avoid the morbidity of dialysis and the associated financial costs. These benefits are offset by disadvantages, which include the possibility of transplantation many months before the need for dialysis, resulting in wasted organ function; an immediate risk of graft failure with conversion to a dialysis-dependent state; and uncertainty of the safety of PCRT. Patients who underwent PCRT between June 1976 and December 1994 at the Oxford Transplant Centre were compared with a matched cohort of first cadaveric transplant recipients who were dialysis-dependent when transplanted. The 116 patients in the PCRT cohort were well matched to the control group with respect to sex, age, blood group, HLA match, degree of sensitization, donor age, immunosuppression, and year of transplantation. Patient and graft survival were significantly better in the PCRT group. The difference in graft survival did not appear to be completely explained by better patient survival, as suggested by a trend toward better graft survival after excluding death with a functioning graft as a cause of failure. Among surviving grafts there were no significant differences in graft function as assessed by 1, 2, and 3 year plasma creatinine levels. In conclusion, PCRT appears to be safe and may even be associated with superior graft survival when compared with conventional transplantation. Early inclusion on a transplant waiting list with a view to PCRT can be justified with respect to the clinical outcome but the financial costs and implications for the utilization of cadaveric donor kidneys must also be considered.