Diana Bachran

Saponins in Tumor Therapy

Saponins are plant glycosides with favorable anti-tumorigenic properties. Several saponins inhibit tumor cell growth by cell cycle arrest and apoptosis with IC50 values of up to 0.2 microM. We discuss diverse groups of saponins (dioscins, saikosaponins, julibrosides, soy saponins, ginseng saponins and avicins) investigated in relation to tumor therapy and focus on cellular and systemic mechanisms of tumor cell growth inhibition both in vitro and in vivo. The review also describes saponins in combination with conventional tumor treatment strategies, which result in improved therapeutic success. Some combinations of saponins and anti-tumorigenic drugs induce synergistic effects with potentiated growth inhibition.

Targeted Enzyme Prodrug Therapies

The cure of cancer is still a formidable challenge in medical science. Long-known modalities including surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy are successful in a number of cases; however, invasive, metastasized and inaccessible tumors still pose an unresolved and ongoing problem. Targeted therapies designed to locate, detect and specifically kill tumor cells have been developed in the past three decades as an alternative to treat troublesome cancers. Most of these therapies are either based on antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, targeted delivery of cytotoxic drugs or tumor site-specific activation of prodrugs. The latter is a two-step procedure. In the first step, a selected enzyme is accumulated in the tumor by guiding the enzyme or its gene to the neoplastic cells. In the second step, a harmless prodrug is applied and specifically converted by this enzyme into a cytotoxic drug only at the tumor site. A number of targeting systems, enzymes and prodrugs were investigated and improved since the concept was first envisioned in 1974. This review presents a concise overview on the history and latest developments in targeted therapies for cancer treatment. We cover the relevant technologies such as antibody-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (ADEPT), gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT) as well as related therapies such as clostridial- (CDEPT) and polymer-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (PDEPT) with emphasis on prodrug-converting enzymes, prodrugs and drugs.

Inhibition of Tumor Growth by Targeted Toxins in Mice is Dramatically Improved by Saponinum Album in a Synergistic Way

The application of targeted toxins in cancer therapy remains a challenge due to the severe side effects as a consequence of the high systemic doses required. Here, we describe the combined application of a glycosylated triterpenoid (Spn) and epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR)-targeted chimeric toxins (SA2E). The cytotoxicity of SA2E on murine TSA tumor cells transfected with human EGFR was enhanced 20,000-fold by low nonpermeabilizing Spn concentrations in a synergistic manner. Subcutaneous application of Spn and SA2E in BALB/c mice bearing a solid TSA cells transfected with epidermal growth factor receptor tumor resulted in 94% tumor volume reduction with a 50-fold lower chimeric toxin concentration compared with pure SA2E treatment. Side effects as monitored by observable complications, body weight, blood parameters; histologic analyses and antibody responses were only moderate and usually reversible.

Real time monitoring of the cell viability during treatment with tumor-targeted toxins and saponins using impedance measurement.

This work describes the application of an impedance-based measurement for the real time evaluation of targeted tumor therapies in cell culture (HeLa cells). We used a treatment procedure that is well established in cells and mice. Therein, tumor cells are treated with a combination of an epidermal growth factor-based targeted toxin named SE and particular plant glycosides called saponins. In the present study HeLa cells were seeded in different numbers onto interdigitated electrode structures integrated into the bottom of a 96 well plate. The cells were treated with SE in the presence and absence of the saponin SpnS-1 (isolated from Saponaria officinalis roots). The impedance was directly correlated with the viability of the cells. As expected from known end point measurements, a concentration dependent enhancement of toxicity was observed; however, with the impedance measurement we were for the first time able to trace the temporal changes of cell death during the combination treatment. This substantially added to the understanding of initial cellular mechanisms in the augmentation of the toxicity of targeted toxins by saponins and indicated the superiority of real time monitoring over end point assays. The method is less labor intensive and label-free with ease of monitoring the effects at each time point.

The toxin component of targeted anti-tumor toxins determines their efficacy increase by saponins.

Tumor‐targeting protein toxins are composed of a toxic enzyme coupled to a specific cell binding domain that targets cancer‐associated antigens. The anti‐tumor treatment by targeted toxins is accompanied by dose‐limiting side effects. The future prospects of targeted toxins for therapeutic use in humans will be determined by reduce side effects. Certain plant secondary metabolites (saponins) were shown to increase the efficacy of a particular epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR)‐targeted toxin, paralleled by a tremendous decrease of side effects.

Epidermal growth factor receptor expression affects the efficacy of the combined application of saponin and a targeted toxin on human cervical carcinoma cells

Cervical cancer is the second most common cancer in women worldwide. Targeting the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) is a very promising approach since it is overexpressed in about 90% of cervical tumors. Here, we quantified the toxic effect of SE, a targeted toxin consisting of epidermal growth factor (EGF) as targeting moiety and the plant toxin saporin‐3, on 3 common human cervical carcinoma cell lines (HeLa, CaSki and SiHa) and recently established lines (PHCC1 and PHCC2) from 2 different individuals. A human melanocytic and a mouse cell line served as negative control. Additionally, we combined SE with saponinum album, a saponin composite from Gypsophila paniculata, which exhibited synergistic properties in previous studies. The cell lines, except for SiHa cells, revealed high sensitivity to SE with 50% cell survival in the range of 5–24.5 nM. The combination with saponin resulted in a remarkable enhancement of cytotoxicity with enhancement factors ranging from 9,000‐fold to 2,500,000‐fold. The cytotoxicity of SE was clearly target receptor specific since free EGF blocks the effect and saporin‐3 alone was considerably less toxic. For all cervical carcinoma cell lines, we evinced a clear correlation between EGFR expression and SE sensitivity. Our data indicate a potential use of targeted toxins for the treatment of cervical cancer. In particular, the combination with saponins is a promising approach since efficacy is drastically improved.

A convenient method for saponin isolation in tumour therapy.

Saponinum album (Merck), which is a crude mixture of saponins from Gypsophila paniculata L., was shown to improve the anti cancer therapy when used in vivo in combination with saporin-based targeted toxins. Unfortunately saponinum album cannot be used for further development since Merck has ceased its production in the 1990s. As pure saponins are mandatory for use in medical purposes we developed a convenient method for saponin isolation directly from the roots of Gypsophila paniculata L. The developed method is rapid, cheap and scaling up is also possible. By combining dialysis and HPLC three saponins were isolated in a one-step procedure. Chemical structures of the purified saponins were characterized by extensive one and two-dimensional NMR-spectroscopy and by using ESI-TOF-MS. The biological activities of the purified saponins were also investigated. The method presented herein enabled a rapid and cheap isolation of saponins for tumour therapy.

Chimeric toxins inhibit growth of primary oral squamous cell carcinoma cells

Treatment of oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) is currently based on surgery and radiotherapy. Prolongation of the survival time of patients with progressing tumors is infrequently achieved. To improve the therapeutic options, targeted therapies are a favorable alternative. Therefore, we analyzed the effect of a chimeric toxin (CT) named SE consisting of the epidermal growth factor and the plant protein toxin saporin from Saponaria officinalis. A second construct (SA2E) additionally contains a peptidic adapter designed to enhance efficacy of the CT in vivo and to reduce side effects. The IC50 values for an oral squamous cell carcinoma cell line (BHY) were 0.27 nM and 0.73 nM for SE and SA2E, respectively, while fibroblasts remained unaffected. To investigate primary tumor cells, we developed a technique to analyze freshly prepared OSCC cells of 28 patients in a stem cell assay directly after surgery. Cells were treated for 1 h with the CTs, subsequently seeded into soft agar and colony growth determined after 1–2 weeks. In spite of the short time of CT incubation, the amount of colonies was reduced to about 78% by 10 nM and to 69% by 100 nM of either toxin. A combined application of 10 nM SA2E with a saponin from Gypsophila paniculata reduced the amount of surviving cells to 68%. The results demonstrate the impact of the CTs on OSCC cells and depict that the stem cell assay is suitable to determine the potential of anti-tumor drugs before studies in vivo will be initiated.

The distribution of saponins in vivo affects their synergy with chimeric toxins against tumours expressing human epidermal growth factor receptors in mice.

Background and purpose:  Certain saponins synergize with antitumour drugs to enhance their efficacy, but the mechanisms underlying this synergy in vivo are not well studied. Here, we describe the distribution of Saponinum album (Spn) from Gypsophila paniculata L. in mice after subcutaneous injection.

Electrophoretic isolation of saponin fractions from Saponinum album and their evaluation in synergistically enhancing the receptor-specific cytotoxicity of targeted toxins.

Saponinum album (SA) is a commercial mixture of saponins isolated from Gypsophila species. In the previously published work, we reported that SA dramatically improves the inhibition of tumor growth by targeted toxins in mice in a synergistic way. Here we report a simplified electrophoretic method for the isolation of a highly effective fraction of SA with a relative electrophoretic mobility to the dye front (Rf) of 0.63 from the mixture. In total, four different fractions were separated at a preparative scale, and evaluated by ESI‐MS, HPLC and TLC analysis. Electrophoretic mobility and electrochemical properties of the different fractions of saponins from SA were set into relation to their ability to enhance the cytotoxicity of epidermal growth factor (EGF)‐based targeted toxins. We here treated HER‐14 cells, which are NIH‐3T3 Swiss mouse embryo cells transfected with the human EGF receptor. Untransfected NIH‐3T3 cells served as control. The major bulk of SA (72.3%) (Rf=0.78) migrated the farthest and was found to be significantly ineffective (p<0.05) in enhancing the cytotoxicity of the targeted toxin, while the second fraction (Rf=0.63) showed an enhancement of 9800‐fold. The third (Rf=0.56) had an enhancement factor of 3200, the fourth (Rf=0.08) was again significantly ineffective (p<0.05) in exhibiting any enhancement of cytotoxicity.