Dmitri V. Voronine

Coherent Multidimensional Optical Spectroscopy of Excitons in Molecular Aggregates; Quasiparticle versus Supermolecule Perspectives

Molecular aggregates are abundant in nature; they form spontaneously in concentrated solutions and on surfaces and can be synthesized by supramolecular chemistry techniques.1-3 Assemblies of chromophores play important roles in many biological processes such as light-harvesting and primary * To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: smukamel@uci.edu. † University of California Irvine. ‡ Universität Würzburg. § Charles University. Chem. Rev. 2009, 109, 2350–2408 2350

Direct evidence of quantum transport in photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes

The photosynthetic light-harvesting apparatus moves energy from absorbed photons to the reaction center with remarkable quantum efficiency. Recently, long-lived quantum coherence has been proposed to influence efficiency and robustness of photosynthetic energy transfer in light-harvesting antennae. The quantum aspect of these dynamics has generated great interest both because of the possibility for efficient long-range energy transfer and because biology is typically considered to operate entirely in the classical regime. Yet, experiments to date show only that coherence persists long enough that it can influence dynamics, but they have not directly shown that coherence does influence energy transfer. Here, we provide experimental evidence that interaction between the bacteriochlorophyll chromophores and the protein environment surrounding them not only prolongs quantum coherence, but also spawns reversible, oscillatory energy transfer among excited states. Using two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy, we observe oscillatory excited-state populations demonstrating that quantum transport of energy occurs in biological systems. The observed population oscillation suggests that these light-harvesting antennae trade energy reversibly between the protein and the chromophores. Resolving design principles evident in this biological antenna could provide inspiration for new solar energy applications.

Coherent Two-Dimensional Nanoscopy

Coherent electronic states excited by ultrafast laser pulses were imaged at subwavelength resolution with photoelectrons. We introduce a spectroscopic method that determines nonlinear quantum mechanical response functions beyond the optical diffraction limit and allows direct imaging of nanoscale coherence. In established coherent two-dimensional (2D) spectroscopy, four-wave–mixing responses are measured using three ingoing waves and one outgoing wave; thus, the method is diffraction-limited in spatial resolution. In coherent 2D nanoscopy, we use four ingoing waves and detect the final state via photoemission electron microscopy, which has 50-nanometer spatial resolution. We recorded local nanospectra from a corrugated silver surface and observed subwavelength 2D line shape variations. Plasmonic phase coherence of localized excitations persisted for about 100 femtoseconds and exhibited coherent beats. The observations are best explained by a model in which coupled oscillators lead to Fano-like resonances in the hybridized dark- and bright-mode response.

Spatiotemporal control of nanooptical excitations

The most general investigation and exploitation of light-induced processes require simultaneous control over spatial and temporal properties of the electromagnetic field on a femtosecond time and nanometer length scale. Based on the combination of polarization pulse shaping and time-resolved two-photon photoemission electron microscopy, we demonstrate such control over nanoscale spatial and ultrafast temporal degrees of freedom of an electromagnetic excitation in the vicinity of a nanostructure. The time-resolved cross-correlation measurement of the local photoemission yield reveals the switching of the nanolocalized optical near-field distribution with a lateral resolution well below the diffraction limit and a temporal resolution on the femtosecond time scale. In addition, successful adaptive spatiotemporal control demonstrates the flexibility of the method. This flexible simultaneous control of temporal and spatial properties of nanophotonic excitations opens new possibilities to tailor and optimize the light–matter interaction in spectroscopic methods as well as in nanophotonic applications.

Photosynthetic reaction center as a quantum heat engine

Two seemingly unrelated effects attributed to quantum coherence have been reported recently in natural and artificial light-harvesting systems. First, an enhanced solar cell efficiency was predicted and second, population oscillations were measured in photosynthetic antennae excited by sequences of coherent ultrashort laser pulses. Because both systems operate as quantum heat engines (QHEs) that convert the solar photon energy to useful work (electric currents or chemical energy, respectively), the question arises whether coherence could also enhance the photosynthetic yield. Here, we show that both effects arise from the same population–coherence coupling term which is induced by noise, does not require coherent light, and will therefore work for incoherent excitation under natural conditions of solar excitation. Charge separation in light-harvesting complexes occurs in a pair of tightly coupled chlorophylls (the special pair) at the heart of photosynthetic reaction centers of both plants and bacteria. We show the analogy between the energy level schemes of the special pair and of the laser/photocell QHEs, and that both population oscillations and enhanced yield have a common origin and are expected to coexist for typical parameters. We predict an enhanced yield of 27% in a QHE motivated by the reaction center. This suggests nature-mimicking architectures for artificial solar energy devices.

Coherent Multidimensional Optical Probes for Electron Correlations and Exciton Dynamics : From NMR to X-rays

Over the past 15 years, researchers have extended the multidimensional techniques which originated with NMR in the 1970s to infrared and visible coherent spectroscopy. These advances have dramatically enhanced the temporal resolution from the microsecond to the femtosecond regime. NMR spectroscopists have developed principles for the design of pulse sequences that enhance selected spectral features and reveal desired dynamical events. Extending these principles to the optical regime offers numerous opportunities for narrowing the line shapes in specific directions, unraveling weak cross-peaks from otherwise congested spectra, and controlling the interferences between quantum pathways. We can achieve these enhancements by shaping the spectral and temporal profiles of the pulses. Pulse polarization shaping may lead to unique probes of time-dependent chirality. In this Account, we compare two types of signals. The first, the photon echo, is generated in the direction -k(1) + k(2) + k(3), and the second, double quantum coherence, is detected at +k(1) + k(2) - k(3). Here k(1), k(2), and k(3) are the wave vectors of the three incoming pulses in chronological order. We illustrate the novel information extracted from these signals by simulations of three physical systems. In the first system, spectra of GaAs semiconductor quantum wells provide a direct look at many-body electron correlation effects. We directly observe specific projections of the many-electron wave function, which we can use to test the quality of various levels of computational techniques for electronic structure. Secondly, the spectra of photosynthetic aggregates reveal couplings between chromophores, quantum coherence signatures of chromophore entanglement, and energy-transfer pathways. Using some fundamental symmetries of pulse polarization configurations of nonlinear signals, we can construct superpositions of signals designed to better distinguish among various coherent and incoherent exciton transport pathways and amplify subtle variations among different species of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna complex. Both of the first two applications require femtosecond pulses of light in the visible range. The third application demonstrates how resonant core spectroscopy may be used to generate core excitations that are highly localized at selected atoms. Such signals can monitor the motions of valence electron wavepackets in real space with atomic spatial resolution. These future X-ray applications will require attosecond bright X-ray sources, which are currently being developed in several labs. Common principles underlie these techniques in coherent spectroscopy for spins, valence electrons, and core electronic excitations, spanning frequencies from radiowaves to hard X-rays.

Unravelling Coherent Dynamics and Energy Dissipation in Photosynthetic Complexes by 2D Spectroscopy

Spectroscopic studies of light harvesting and the subsequent energy conversion in photosynthesis can track quantum dynamics happening on the microscopic level. The Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex of the photosynthetic green sulfur bacteria Chlorobium tepidum is a prototype efficient light-harvesting antenna: it stores the captured photon energy in the form of excitons (collective excitations), which are subsequently converted to chemical energy with almost 100% efficiency. These excitons show an elaborate relaxation pattern involving coherent and incoherent pathways. We make use of the complex chirality and fundamental symmetries of multidimensional optical signals to design new sequences of ultrashort laser pulses that can distinguish between coherent quantum oscillations and incoherent energy dissipation during the exciton relaxation. The cooperative dynamical features, which reflect the coherent nature of excitations, are amplified. The extent of quantum oscillations and their timescales in photosynthesis can be readily extracted from the designed signals, showing that cooperativity is maintained during energy transport in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex. The proposed pulse sequences may also be applied to reveal information on the robustness of quantum states in the presence of fluctuating environments in other nanoscopic complexes and devices.

Analytic coherent control of plasmon propagation in nanostructures

We present general analytic solutions for optical coherent control of electromagnetic energy propagation in plasmonic nanostructures. Propagating modes are excited with tightly focused ultrashort laser pulses that are shaped in amplitude, phase, and polarization (ellipticity and orientation angle). We decouple the interplay between two main mechanisms which are essential for the control of local near-fields. First, the amplitudes and the phase difference of two laser pulse polarization components are used to guide linear flux to a desired spatial position. Second, temporal compression of the near-field at the target location is achieved using the remaining free laser pulse parameter to flatten the local spectral phase. The resulting enhancement of nonlinear signals from this intuitive analytic two-step process is compared to and confirmed by the results of an iterative adaptive learning loop in which an evolutionary algorithm performs a global optimization. Thus, we gain detailed insight into why a certain complex laser pulse shape leads to a particular control target. This analytic approach may also be useful in a number of other coherent control scenarios.

Deterministic spatiotemporal control of optical fields in nanoantennas and plasmonic circuits

We show that laser pulse shaping techniques can be applied to tailor the ultrafast temporal response of localized and propagating optical near fields in resonant optical antennas (ROAs) and plasmonic transmission lines, respectively. Using finite-difference time-domain simulations followed by Fourier transformation, we obtain the impulse response of a nanostructure in the frequency domain, which allows obtaining its temporal response to any arbitrary pulse shape. To illustrate the potential of the method we demonstrate deterministic optimal temporal pulse compression in ROAs with reduced symmetry, in a plasmonic two-wire transmission line, and in a prototype plasmonic circuit combining propagation effects and local resonances. The method described here will be of importance for the coherent control of field propagation in nanophotonic structures and light-induced processes in nanoscopic volumes.

Double-quantum resonances and exciton-scattering in coherent 2D spectroscopy of photosynthetic complexes

A simulation study demonstrates how the nonlinear optical response of the Fenna–Matthews–Olson photosynthetic light-harvesting complex may be explored by a sequence of laser pulses specifically designed to probe the correlated dynamics of double excitations. Cross peaks in the 2D correlation plots of the spectra reveal projections of the double-exciton wavefunctions onto a basis of direct products of single excitons. An alternative physical interpretation of these signals in terms of quasiparticle scattering is developed.