Dominic Thompson

Revascularisation surgery for paediatric moyamoya: a review of the literature

Introduction and aimsThe role of and optimal surgical revascularisation technique for paediatric moyamoya syndrome (MMS) are controversial. In this literature review our primary aim was to evaluate the evidence base for the efficacy of surgical revascularisation for the treatment of paediatric MMS. Secondary aims were to estimate the rate of peri-operative complications and to ascertain whether direct or indirect revascularisation techniques resulted in differences in clinical or radiological outcomes.MethodsPapers describing surgical revascularisation and its outcome in the treatment of children with MMS were identified from the OVID Medline database (1966–2004). Only papers in English were reviewed. Data were abstracted using a standardised form.ResultsFifty-seven studies, including data on 1,448 patients, were reviewed. Most were Japanese; 10% were from Western institutions. Indications for revascularisation were described in <15% of studies and varied between centres. Indirect procedures were most commonly performed (alone in 73% of cases, combined with direct procedures in 23%). The rates of peri-operative stroke and reversible ischaemic events were 4.4 and 6.1% respectively. Out of 1,156 (87%) patients, 1,003 derived symptomatic benefit from surgical revascularisation (complete disappearance or reduction in symptomatic cerebral ischaemia), with no significant difference between the indirect and direct/combined groups. Data on developmental and functional outcomes were limited and of uncertain significance as they were not related to pre-operative status. Good collateral formation was significantly more frequent in the direct/combined group than in the indirect group (χ2, p<0.001).ConclusionsData from the medical literature suggest that surgical revascularisation is a safe intervention for paediatric MMS and most treated patients derive some symptomatic benefit. However, paucity of data on selection criteria and more global outcome measures means that the impact of surgical revascularisation on natural history remains uncertain. Direct and/or combined procedures provide better revascularisation, but this is not associated with differences in symptomatic outcome. International standardisation of the clinical approach to the treatment of paediatric MMS is urgently needed to critically evaluate the optimal indications for and timing of surgical revascularisation.

Intracranial Pressure in Single-Suture Craniosynostosis

The indications for surgical correction of craniosynostosis in which there is involvement of only one of the cranial vault sutures have traditionally been based upon the cosmetic merits of the deformity alone. Whilst it is now appreciated that intracranial hypertension is commonly associated with the more complex forms of craniosynostosis, this aspect has not previously been addressed in detail among cases of single-suture craniosynostosis. This retrospective study reports our experience of overnight subdural intracranial pressure monitoring in 74 children with premature closure of a single cranial suture. A single coronal suture was involved in 37 patients, the sagittal suture in 25 and the metopic suture in 12. Intracranial pressure was raised in 13 (17%), borderline in 28 (38%) and normal in 33 (45%). Elevated intracranial pressure was seen more commonly where a midline suture was involved (sagittal or metopic) than when a single coronal suture was fused. We conclude that intracranial hypertension occurs in a significant proportion of children with single-suture craniosynostosis and suggest that this factor should be borne in mind during the initial assessment of these children so as to enable timely intervention where required and appropriate counselling of parents.

Subdural intracranial pressure monitoring in craniosynostosis: its role in surgical management.

In the management of craniosynostosis subdural intracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring has proved a useful and safe means of identifying those children with raised ICP who are at risk from its long-term sequelae and who would benefit from early surgical intervention. Overnight subdural ICP recordings have been obtained in 136 unoperated cases of craniosynostosis. Fifteen patients were studied both before and after cranial vault remodelling procedures. ICP was raised (>15 mmHg) in 35%, borderline (10–15 mmHg) in 27% and normal (<10 mmHg) in 27% of cases. Raised ICP was present in 28/53 of the syndromic craniofacial dysostosis cases and in 20/83 non-syndromic craniosynostosis cases investigated (P<0.001). Raised mean ICP and periodic plateaux of sustained ICP during sleep were particularly associated with the syndromic cases. Of the 15 patients studied following cranial vault surgery, 9 showed a reduction in ICP, 3 were unchanged and 3 had higher ICP postoperatively. The results of ICP monitoring can contribute significantly to formulating a rational and staged surgical management plan incorporating the need to normalise ICP and correct the frequently severe functional and cosmetic consequences of these disorders.

Embryology and bony malformations of the craniovertebral junction

BackgroundThe embryology of the bony craniovertebral junction (CVJ) is reviewed with the purpose of explaining the genesis and unusual configurations of the numerous congenital malformations in this region. Functionally, the bony CVJ can be divided into a central pillar consisting of the basiocciput and dental pivot and a two-tiered ring revolving round the central pivot, comprising the foramen magnum rim and occipital condyles above and the atlantal ring below. Embryologically, the central pillar and the surrounding rings descend from different primordia, and accordingly, developmental anomalies at the CVJ can also be segregated into those affecting the central pillar and those affecting the surrounding rings, respectively.DiscussionA logical classification of this seemingly unwieldy group of malformations is thus possible based on their ontogenetic lineage, morbid anatomy, and clinical relevance. Representative examples of the main constituents of this classification scheme are given, and their surgical treatments are selectively discussed.

Management of choroid plexus tumours in children : 20 years experience at a Single Neurosurgical Centre

Objective: Tumours of the choroid plexus are rare tumours of neuro-ectodermal origin, accounting for less than 1% of all intracranial tumours. Most cases present in children less than 2 years of age. While choroid plexus carcinomas (CPC) are reported to have an extremely poor prognosis, choroid plexus papillomas (CPP) are generally regarded as benign tumours with a very favourable long-term outcome. Management dilemmas are associated with the choice of surgical procedure, tumour vascularity, the treatment of hydrocephalus and the value of adjuvant therapy. The objective of this study was to review our experience with this rare tumour over a 20-year period. Methods: Patients were identified from the Great Ormond Street Neurosurgical Brain Tumour Database. Over a 20-year period (1979–1999), 34 children were identified with a choroid plexus tumour. There were 25 cases of CPP and 9 cases of CPC. A retrospective review of case notes, radiological imaging, operation reports and pathology was performed. Results: The median age at presentation was 17 months (1–138) for CPP and 13 months (2–102) for CPC. There was no sex difference for CPP. However, 8 of the 9 CPCs were male (89%). A complete surgical resection was achieved in all 25 cases of CPP and in 3 cases of CPC (33%). The median survival for CPPs was 75.5 months (2–228), with a median follow-up of 73.5 months (2–228). The median survival for CPCs was 6 months (1–90), with a median follow-up of 6 months (1–90). Conclusion: With modern neurosurgical practise, a cure should be the aim for all children with CPP. There is no evidence that adjuvant therapy has any role in the primary management of these children. However, CPC still has an extremely poor prognosis, and the efficacy of adjuvant therapy remains to be established.

The beaten copper cranium: a correlation between intracranial pressure, cranial radiographs, and computed tomographic scans in children with craniosynostosis.

OBJECTIVE The beaten copper appearance of the cranium, as well as other cranial radiographic and computed tomographic findings in children with craniosynostosis, is often interpreted by clinicians as evidence of elevated intracranial pressure (ICP). However, a correlation between radiological findings and ICP measurements has not been previously demonstrated, and their usefulness in detecting elevated ICP has not been defined. METHODS To address those issues, 123 children with craniosynostosis who had cranial radiographs and ICP monitoring were studied. To assess the specificity of certain radiological findings to patients with craniosynostosis, cranial radiographs of patients with craniosynostosis were compared to those of age- and sex-matched controls. In patients with craniosynostosis, findings on cranial radiographs were compared to computed tomographic scans of the brain. Radiographic findings were then correlated with ICP measurements obtained while the patient was sleeping, which was measured using a Camino fiberoptic ICP monitor (Camino Laboratories, San Diego, CA). All radiographs were independently analyzed by two radiologists who were blinded to clinical and ICP data. RESULTS A diffuse beaten copper pattern, erosion of the dorsum sellar, and suture diastasis were seen more commonly in patients with craniosynostosis than in controls (P < 0.05), but the presence of the beaten copper pattern was no more common in children with craniosynostosis. ICP was greater when a diffuse beaten copper pattern, dorsum sellar erosion, suture diastasis, or narrowing of basal cisterns was present (P < 0.05). CONCLUSION Although this study demonstrates that some cranial radiographic and computed tomographic findings do correlate with elevated ICP, the sensitivity of radiological methods for detecting elevated ICP is universally low and they are not recommended to screen for elevated ICP in children with craniosynostosis.

Craniopharyngioma in childhood : our evidence-based approach to management

ObjectivesIn 1996 we published our results for treatment of childhood craniopharyngioma. That study did not only reveal that there was a significant morbidity associated with our then policy of attempted radical removal followed by post-operative radiotherapy in those cases with residual disease, but also that risk factors for poor outcome could be identified based on the clinical and radiological findings at presentation. As result of that study, we redefined the role of radical surgery in the treatment of craniopharyngioma and developed a new treatment strategy in an attempt to improve the quality of outcome without compromising tumour control. Our aims in this paper were to compare the results of our current treatment strategy with that reported in the 1996 paper to assess whether we have achieved this goal.MethodsA detailed assessment of the treatment pathway and outcome was undertaken for children treated for craniopharyngioma in our unit from 1996 to 2004. This included a morbidity score based on visual, motor, cognitive, hypothalamic and endocrinological data obtained from our neuro-oncology database and review of clinical records. Where possible we have attempted to record data in the same manner as for our previous study allowing for meaningful comparison.ResultsForty-eight children with craniopharyngioma presented in the study period. On the basis of clinical presentation and radiological findings, 25 were deemed suitable for attempted radical surgery and 23 were treated with various subtotal surgical procedures. Radiotherapy was used in patients over the age of 5 years where residual tumour was present or progressed after the initial surgical intervention(s). Morbidity scores, particularly in relation to visual and cognitive outcome, are improved and there was no surgical mortality in the current series.ConclusionsA treatment paradigm for childhood craniopharyngioma is presented which improves the quality of outcome without compromising tumour control.

Aetiology of Herniation of the Hindbrain in Craniosynostosis

The occurrence and extent of herniation of the hindbrain has been evaluated in a population of children with craniosynostosis by means of magnetic resonance imaging of the craniocervical junction. The role of intracranial pressure (ICP), posterior fossa size and hydrocephalus in the development of this deformity has also been assessed. Magnetic resonance imaging (Siemens Magnetom 1.5T) was reviewed in 27 cases of craniosynostosis in whom there had been no previous cranial vault surgery. The position of the cerebellar tonsils in relation to the plane of the foramen magnum was measured and an index of the size of the posterior fossa relative to the rest of the cranial vault was also calculated for each case. The presence of hydrocephalus (requiring a cerebrospinal fluid diversion procedure) was documented. In 22 of these cases overnight, subdural ICP monitoring using the Camino fibre optic device had also been performed. Herniation of the hindbrain below the plane of the foramen magnum occurred in 10 of 27 cases (37%). The level of ICP showed a significant correlation with the extent of hindbrain herniation (p < 0.001) as did small posterior fossa size (p = 0.0035). Hydrocephalus was present in 4 patients, all of whom had hindbrain herniation. The extent of hindbrain herniation did not correlate with age (p = 0.48). We propose that herniation of the hindbrain in craniosynostosis is a consequence of brain deformation occurring in response to the physical forces imposed by a combination of the anatomical deformity at the skull base and intracranial hypertension rather than a primary malformation of brain development as commonly supposed.

Postnatal management and outcome for neural tube defects including spina bifida and encephalocoeles.

The incidence of neural tube defects (NTDs) has declined in recent decades, however myelomeningocele and encephalocele still represent one of the commoner prenatally diagnosed congenital malformations. Improved perinatal and post natal care mean that the mortality associated with these conditions has also fallen. Advances in the multidisciplinary management of children with myelomeningocele have led to significant improvements in functional outcome for many with this condition. However, there remains a substantial population of patients born with NTDs whose life expectancy is substantially reduced and who suffer significant cognitive and physical disability remaining wholly or partially dependant on the care of others into adult life.

Ventriculoperitoneal shunt block: what are the best predictive clinical indicators?

Aims: To evaluate the predictive value of symptoms, signs, and radiographic findings accompanying presumed ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt malfunction, by comparing presentation with operative findings and subsequent clinical course. Methods: Prospective study of all 53 patient referrals to a paediatric neurosurgical centre between April and November 1999 with a diagnosis of presumed shunt malfunction. Referral pattern, presenting symptoms and signs, results of computed tomography (CT) scanning, operative findings, and clinical outcome were recorded. Two patient groups were defined, one with proven shunt block, the other with presumed normal shunt function. Symptomatology, CT scan findings, and the subsequent clinical course for each group were then compared. Results: Common presenting features were headache, drowsiness, and vomiting. CT scans were performed in all patients. Thirty seven had operatively proven shunt malfunction, of whom 34 had shunt block and three shunt infection; 84% with shunt block had increased ventricle size when compared with previous imaging. For the two patient groups (with and without shunt block), odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals on their presenting symptoms were headache 1.5 (0.27 to 10.9), vomiting 0.9 (0.25 to 3.65), drowsiness 10 (0.69 to 10.7), and fever 0.19 (0.03 to 6.95). Every patient with ventricular enlargement greater than their known baseline had a proven blocked shunt. Conclusions: Drowsiness is by far the best clinical predictor of VP shunt block. Headache and vomiting were less predictive of acute shunt block in this study. Wherever possible CT scan findings should be interpreted in the context of previous imaging. We would caution that not all cases of proven shunt blockage present with an increase in ventricle size.