Doris Bonnet

Ethical aspects of neonatal screening for sickle cell disease in Western European countries: Sickle cell neonatal screening and ethics

Sickle cell disease raises some important ethical questions regarding neonatal screening in Western European countries such as France, England or Belgium, which have already introduced either universal or selective screening. Such screening is aimed at benefiting children affected with major sickle cell syndrome. It also detects heterozygous babies and, in doing so, heterozygous parents. The latter information, which is ignored most of the time, risks making parents feel guilty and can raise fears of stigmatization. Whether it would change their future reproductive decisions requires further studies, for cultural and religious reasons may have a strong negative influence on the request for prenatal diagnosis. Disclosure of the childs illness may oblige the family to remain in the country they have emigrated to because it offers the best chance of treatment. As a result, links between the family and its original community are modified. Parents must more or less sever links with their family in Africa and try to trust and adapt to the public health services in Europe.