Dudley F. Rochester

Respiratory Muscle Failure

The diseases which are commonly complicated by hypercapnic respiratory failure also compromise the respiratory muscles in several ways. Increased work of breathing, mechanical disadvantage, neuromuscular disease, impaired nutritional status, shock, hypoxemia, acidosis, and deficiency of potassium, magnesium, and inorganic phosphorus are the major non-neurologic factors which contribute to respiratory muscle fatigue and failure. Respiratory muscle fatigue has two components. High frequency fatigue occurs rapidly with intense contractile efforts but is usually not severe. It also recovers rapidly with rest. Low frequency fatigue develops more slowly but is severe and requires hours for recovery. Since the spontaneous rate of neural stimulation is predominantly in the low frequency range, this component of fatigue is of particular clinical importance. Fatigue of the inspiratory muscles leads to acute respiratory acidosis, but before carbon dioxide retention occurs, it can be recognized from characteristic symptoms and signs. These include dyspnea which responds to mechanical ventilation, rapid shallow breathing, and asynchronous movements of the chest and abdomen. Inspiratory muscle fatigue must be treated by putting these muscles to rest, by mechanically supporting ventilation. In addition, underlying metabolic nutritional and circulatory abnormalities must be corrected and infection treated. Aminophylline and isoproterenol can restore inspiratory muscle contractility, but controlled clinical trials remain to be done regarding their application in acute and chronic respiratory failure. Inspiratory muscle training improves strength and endurance in patients with obstructive lung disease, cystic fibrosis, and spinal cord injury, but does not always improve physical exercise performance. Again, more work is needed to develop the indications for inspiratory muscle training and to determine the optimum type and duration of the training regimen.

Respiratory muscles and ventilatory failure: 1993 perspective.

Some conditions that predispose to ventilatory failure increase the work of breathing (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [COPD], obesity, kyphoscoliosis), whereas others cause severe respiratory muscle weakness. Specific reasons for muscle weakness include critical illness (electrolyte imbalance, acidemia, shock, sepsis), chronic illness (poor nutrition, cachexia), and neuromuscular diseases. Inspiratory muscle weakness from mechanical disadvantage to the diaphragm is characteristic of asthma and COPD. The increased work of breathing combined with muscle weakness increases the pressure needed to inspire a breath and decreases maximal inspiratory pressure. When this pressure exceeds 0.4, dyspnea and inspiratory muscle fatigue ensue. One way to lower this pressure and avert fatigue is to lower the tidal volume. Ventilatory drive is high, not low, in ventilatory failure. Concomitant shortening of inspiration and breath duration cause the small tidal volume and increased respiratory rate. Gas exchange is compromised by ventilation/perfusion imbalance, and the ratio of dead space to tidal volume is also increased by rapid, shallow breathing. Reduction in tidal volume minimizes dyspnea, but the small tidal volume is inadequate for gas exchange. Acute treatment of respiratory muscle failure involves respiratory muscle rest through mechanical ventilation and removal of noxious influences (infection, metabolic disarray), whereas chronic treatment involves rebuilding the contractile apparatus by nutritional repletion and training.

Steady-state response of conscious man to small expiratory resistive loads

To determine the predominant steady-state ventilatory responses to mild expiratory flow-resistive loads, we subjected 14 normal subjects to expiratory resistances of 0-10 cm H2O/L/sec (R0-R3). Breathing patterns and abdominal muscle activity (EMG) were recorded during quiet breathing, and when ventilation was augmented by dead space breathing (7 subjects) or treadmill walking (7 subjects). Expiratory loading increased expiratory time (TE), tidal volume and mean inspiratory flow rate, while decreasing inspiratory duty cycle and respiratory frequency. Minute ventilation (VI) remained constant. These load responses were most prominent during quiet breathing, and were attenuated or abolished as VI increased. Abdominal EMG was negligible during quiet breathing, increased when VI increased, but showed no consistent response to R1-R3. Thus, the principal defense against mild expiratory loads is prolongation of expiration, accompanied by enhanced inspiratory drive. Abdominal muscle expiratory activity is elicited by increasing ventilation, but occurs only sporadically with expiratory loading of the magnitude studied.

Impaired adrenergic- and corticotropic-axis outflow during exercise in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Exercise stimulates coordinated release of the sympathoadrenal hormones adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), cortisol, norepinephrine (NE), and epinephrine (Epi). The study hypothesis was that chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is marked by heightened sympathoadrenal outflow at comparable relative workloads. The location of the study was at a clinical research unit. Eight healthy men and 9 men with stable COPD (forced expiratory volume at 1 second <75% predicted) were studied. Volunteers rested (baseline) or exercised at individual submaximal (35% ± 5%) or maximal oxygen consumption. Blood was sampled every 2 minutes for 40 minutes concurrently. Two-way analysis of covariance was applied to examine group (healthy/COPD) and exercise (3 levels) effects on ACTH, cortisol, NE, and Epi release and regularity (estimable by approximate entropy). The timing of peak hormone concentrations was Epi, 14 minutes; NE, 16 minutes; ACTH, 22 minutes; and cortisol, 34 minutes in both cohorts. Type of exercise regimen influenced all 4 hormones (each P < .001), and subject group (control vs COPD) affected cortisol (P < .001) and Epi (P = .048) responses. Exercise regimen and group together controlled ACTH, cortisol, and Epi (each P < .001), but not NE, responses. In particular, endocrine responses were attenuated in COPD compared with control subjects. Approximate entropy analysis also identified loss of maximal exercise-induced ACTH-secretory regularity in COPD patients (P = .042). These outcomes demonstrate impaired rather than augmented exercise-associated sympathocorticotropic-axis outflow in patients with COPD even when outcomes are normalized to maximal oxygen consumption, suggesting that factors other than fitness are at work.