Dushyant K. Gulati

Results and Evaluations of 48 Continuous Breeding Reproduction Studies Conducted in Mice

Results of 48 continuous breeding reproduction (RACB) studies are summarized and control data from these studies are used to determine the statistical sensitivity of each endpoint from different parts of these studies. Results of testing individual chemicals compared well with results of multigeneration studies reported in the literature. Continuous breeding studies were able to discriminate reproductive toxicants from nontoxicants, and provided valuable structure-activity information. When mice in continuous cohabitation produce multiple litters, the statistical sensitivity of fertility endpoints is quite high and is comparable to that associated with other sensitive indicators of reproductive function, such as testis weight and sperm parameter measures. The principal advantages of the RACB protocol in comparison to multigeneration studies are: (1) the increased sensitivity and statistical power, (2) the ability to monitor progression of toxicity and to detect subfertility, (3) use of a battery of endpoints including sperm measures, (4) the ability to determine the affected sex(es), and (5) slightly reduced testing time.

The Effects of Feed Restriction on Reproductive Function in Sprague-Dawley Rats

Although it is known that severe feed restriction (FR) and weight reduction (to 50-60% of control values) will sharply impair rat reproduction, few data exist on the effects of less severe body weight reduction. In the present studies, adult Sprague-Dawley rats were feed restricted and maintained at 90, 80, and 70% of control body weight (CBW) for up to 17 weeks. In females, this treatment had no effect on fertility or total number of implants per dam, but transiently increased the length of the estrous cycle and decreased by 20% the number of corpora lutea in the 70% CBW females. Ovary weight at necropsy was decreased only in the 70% CBW group. Liver and kidney weights varied with body weight. In males, fertility was not affected when they were mated to nonrestricted females. While prostate and seminal vesicles weight varied with body weight, testis and epididymis weights were unchanged by any degree of FR, as were the number of sperm in the cauda epididymis and the number of homogenization-resistant spermatids in the testis. The percentage motile sperm was slightly decreased at all levels of FR. These data show that the Sprague-Dawley rat is largely resistant to adverse reproductive changes caused by feed restriction to 70% CBW. These data should be of use in interpreting changes seen in toxicity studies that produce weight-reduce Sprague-Dawley rats.

Reproductive Toxicity of Three Phthalic Acid Esters in a Continuous Breeding Protocol

A continuous breeding protocol was utilized to examine the reproductive toxicity of three phthalate esters. CD-1 mice were given diets with either di-n-propyl phthalate (DPrP: 0.0, 1.25, 2.5, or 5.0%), di-n-pentyl phthalate (DPP: 0.0, 0.5, 1.25, or 2.5%), or di-n-octyl phthalate (DOP: 0.0, 1.25, 2.5, or 5.0%). Both male and female mice (20 pairs per treatment group, 40 pairs of control animals) were dosed for 7 days prior to and during a 98-day cohabitation period. Reproductive function was evaluated during the cohabitation period by measuring number of litters per pair, live pups per litter, and pup weight. There was no apparent effect on reproductive function in the animals exposed to DOP at dose levels sufficient to cause a significant increase in liver weight. Both DPP and DPrP were toxic to the reproductive system as evidenced by a complete inhibition of fertility at 1.25 and 2.5% DPP or 5.0% DPrP, and reduced fertility (litters/pair and live pups/litter, 0.5% DPP; live pups/litter, 2.5% DPrP). Toxicity of DPP had a strong male component and female component, whereas DPrP was more toxic to the female than the male reproductive system. DPP and DPrP treatment was associated with decreased body weight, increased liver weight, decreased testis and epididymis weights, decreased epididymal sperm concentration, and elevated seminiferous tubule atrophy. A comparison of seven phthalate esters tested using this continuous breeding protocol indicates the relative order of reproductive toxicity as diethylhexyl, dihexyl, dipentyl, dibutyl, dipropyl; diethyl and dioctyl are nontoxic.

Methods for assessing rat sperm motility

Computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) systems are becoming more widely used. With this spread of technology come more data from toxicology studies, designed to determine if treatment with putative toxicants affects sperm motion parameters. While these CASA methods provide us with more ways to evaluate toxicity and thus perhaps increase our chances of successfully protecting human health, there is also a greater likelihood that different laboratories will use different methods of collecting data on sperm motility. Different systems used with different methods in different laboratories will inevitably generate data that are difficult to compare. In a prospective attempt to address this issue of comparability and limit the problems, a group of individuals using CASA systems to analyze rat sperm motility convened to discuss methodologic issues, share data, and try to reach a consensus about methods for performing these studies. This article shares those meetings and data in the hope that common methods will enhance interlaboratory comparisons.

Assessment of the reproductive and developmental toxicity of pesticide/fertilizer mixtures based on confirmed pesticide contamination in California and Iowa groundwater.

Pesticides and fertilizers, as used in modern agriculture, contribute to the overall low-level contamination of groundwater sources. In order to determine the potential of pesticide and fertilizer mixtures to produce reproductive or developmental toxicity at concentrations up to 100 x the median level found in groundwater, we prepared and studied two mixtures of pesticides and a fertilizer (ammonium nitrate). One mixture containing aldicarb, atrazine, dibromochloropropane, 1,2-dichloropropane, ethylene dibromide, and simazine plus ammonium nitrate was considered to be a representative of groundwater contamination in California (CAL). The other, containing alachlor, atrazine, cyanazine, metolachlor, metribuzin, and ammonium nitrate, simulated groundwater contamination in Iowa (IOWA). Each mixture was administered in the drinking water of either Swiss CD-1 mice during a Reproductive Assessment by Continuous Breeding study or pregnant Sprague-Dawley rats (gd 6-20) at three dose levels (1x, 10x, and 100x) where 1x was the median concentration of each pesticide component as determined in the groundwater surveys in California or Iowa. Unlike conventional toxicology studies, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the health effects of realistic human concentrations. Thus, the testing concentrations are probably well below the maximally tolerated dose. Propylene glycol was used as the solubilizer for the pesticides in drinking water formulations in both studies. In the reproductive study, neither mixture caused any clinical signs of toxicity, changes in food or water consumption, or body weight in either F0 or F1 mice at doses up to 100x the median groundwater concentrations. There were no treatment-related effects on fertility or any measures of reproductive performance of either the F0 or the F1 generation mice exposed to either CAL or IOWA at up to 100x. Similarly, measures of spermatogenesis, epididymal sperm concentration, percentage motile sperm, percentage abnormal sperm, and testicular and epididymal histology were normal. In the developmental study, CAL- or IOWA-exposed females did not exhibit any significant treatment-related clinical signs of toxicity. No adverse effects of CAL or IOWA were observed for measures of embryo/fetal toxicity, including resorptions per litter, live litter size, or fetal body weight. CAL or IOWA did not cause an increased incidence of fetal malformations or variations. In summary, administration of these pesticide/fertilizer mixtures at levels up to 100-fold greater than the median concentrations in groundwater supplies in California or Iowa did not cause any detectable reproductive (mice), general, or developmental toxicity (rats).

Reproductive and developmental toxicity of ethylene glycol in the mouse

The effects of ethylene glycol on reproduction of CD-1 mice were tested in a protocol which permitted continuous breeding during a specified interval. The dosage amounts of 0, 0.25, 0.5, or 1% ethylene glycol by continuous administration in drinking water for male and female mice were selected from the general toxic responses observed in a 14-day pilot study. After the first week of administration, begun at 11 weeks of age, the animals were housed one male and one female per cage for 14 weeks during which time any offspring were examined, sexed, weighted, and killed to allow continuous mating of the first generation. At the end of the 14-week cohabitation period, the males and females were separated and any litters delivered after that time were kept until weaning. Those second-generation animals were mated at about 70 days of age. Slight, but statistically significant, decreases were found in the numbers of litters per fertile pair and live pups per litter in the 1% dose group and live pup weight at the 1% dose groups compared to control F0 mice. Facial anomalies were noted in a number of offspring of high-dose-treated mice and an examination for skeletal defects demonstrated a pattern including reduction in the size of bones in the skull, fused ribs, and abnormally shaped sternebrae and vertebrae in the high-dose-treated, but not the untreated, mice. Neither the 0.25 nor 0.5% dose groups were significantly affected. No clinical signs of toxicity or significant adverse effects on body weight or water consumption were seen at the doses used, but two deaths occurred at the 0.5% quantity which may have been related to oxalate crystal deposition in the kidney.

Assessment of Ethylene Glycol Monobutyl and Monophenyl Ether Reproductive Toxicity Using a Continuous Breeding Protocol in Swiss CD-1 Mice

A continuous breeding reproduction study design was utilized to examine the reproductive toxicity of ethylene glycol monobutyl ether (EGBE) and ethylene glycol monophenyl ether (EGPE). Swiss CD-1 mice were administered EGBE in drinking water (0, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0%, i.e., 0.7, 1.3, and 2.1 g/kg body wt/day) and EGPE was administered via the feed (0, 0.25, 1.25, and 2.5%, i.e., 0, 0.4, 2.0, and 4 g/kg body wt/day). Both male and female mice were dosed for 7 days prior to and during a 98-day cohabitation period. EGBE was toxic at the high (2%) and mid dose (1%) to adult F0 female mice: 13 out of 22 females at the high dose and 6 out of 20 at the mid dose died during the cohabitation period. Both the high- and mid-dose animals produced fewer litters/pair, fewer pups/litter, with decreased pup weight. These effects occurred in the presence of decreased body weight, decreased water consumption, and increased kidney weight. A crossover mating trial indicated that the reproductive effects could be attributed primarily to an effect on the female. This was substantiated at necropsy where testes and epididymis weights were normal as were sperm number and motility. Fertility of the offspring of the 0.5% group was normal in the presence of increased liver weights. With respect to EGPE, there was no change in the ability to produce five litters during the continuous breeding period. There was, however, a significant but small (10-15%) decrease in the number of pups/litter and in pup weight in the high-dose group. A crossover mating trial suggested a female component of the reproductive toxicity of EGPE. While fertility was only minimally compromised, severe neonatal toxicity was observed. By Day 21 there were only 8 out of 40 litters in the mid- and high-dose groups which had at least one male and female/litter. Second generation reproductive performance of the mid-dose group (1.25%) was unaffected except for a small decrease in live pup weight. In summary the reproductive toxicity of EGBE and EGPE was only evident in the female and occurred at doses which elicited general toxicity. EGBE was particularly toxic to adult female mice while EGPE was particularly toxic to immature mice of both sexes.

Are Mouse Strains Differentially Susceptible to the Reproductive Toxicity of Ethylene Glycol Monomethyl Ether? A Study of Three Strains

Most rodent reproductive toxicology studies utilize strains of high fecundity. These studies were conducted to examine the possibility that mouse strains of differing fecundity would respond differently to a known reproductive toxicant. Thirty pairs each of Swiss CD-1, C57B1, and C3H mice were cohabited for 14 weeks while consuming 0, 0.03, 0.10, or 0.30% EGME in the drinking water. Litter data were collected during cohabitation. Body and organ weights, and various sperm data, were collected at necropsy, and second-generation fertility was evaluated. The data show that the most fecund strain (Swiss) was affected the least by exposure to EGME, while the least fecund strain (C3H) suffered the greatest declines in fertility. These differences might alter interspecies extrapolation factors, or the permissible exposure levels for humans.

Reproductive Toxicity Assessment by Continuous Breeding in Sprague-Dawley Rats: A Comparison of two Study Designs

The protocol for Reproductive Assessment by Continuous Breeding (RACB) studies was originally designed to use mice as the test species. However, rats are commonly used for reproductive toxicity research and could be used in the basic RACB design. One of the studies reported below evaluated a standard murine RACB design using rats, which rears the fifth litter to test second generation fertility. The second design tested the logistics and feasibility of rearing the second litter for second generation fertility testing. The standard fifth litter design (L5) was modified slightly for rats by increasing the time allowed for gestation and delivery. Compared to rats rearing their second litter (L2), rats in this L5 design had more litters per pair during continuous breeding and maintained this fertility better over time, as evidenced by producing more pups per litter during the crossover mating segment. Both L2 and L5 rats gave sufficient pups to conduct the second generation fertility evaluation. In addition, the L5 design was easier to conduct and produced pups from gametes exposed to chemical throughout spermatogenesis, making it the preferred design for using rats in Continuous Breeding studies.