Elena Yago

Electrical responses reveal the temporal dynamics of brain events during involuntary attention switching

Surviving in the natural environment requires the rapid switching of attention among potentially relevant stimuli. We studied electrophysiologically the involuntary switching time in humans performing a task designed to study brain mechanisms of involuntary attention and distraction (C. Escera et al., 1998, J. Cogn. Neurosci., 10, 590–604). Ten subjects were instructed to discriminate visual stimuli preceded by a task‐irrelevant sound, this being either a repetitive tone (P = 0.8) or a distracting sound, i.e. a slightly higher deviant tone (P = 0.1) or an environmental novel sound (P = 0.1). In different conditions, the sounds preceded the visual stimuli by 245 or 355 ms. Deviant tones and novel sounds prolonged reaction times significantly to subsequent visual stimuli by 7.4 (P < 0.02) and 15.2 ms (P < 0.003), respectively. In addition to a mismatch negativity (MMN) and a positive‐polarity, 320‐ms latency, P3a event‐related potential associated, respectively, with detection of the distracting sound and the subsequent orienting of attention to it, a late frontal negative deflection was observed in distracting trials. The peak latency of this brain response from sound onset was 580 ms in the 245‐ms condition and 115 ms longer in the 355‐ms condition (P < 0.001), peaking consequently at 340 ms from visual stimulus onset, irrespective of the onset of the distracting sound. We suggest that this late frontal negative response may signal over the scalp the process of reallocating attention back to the original task after momentary distraction, and therefore that recovering from distraction may take a similar shifting time as orienting attention involuntarily towards unexpected novelty.

Attention capture by auditory significant stimuli: semantic analysis follows attention switching.

Event‐related potentials (ERPs) were recorded from the scalp to investigate a long‐standing controversy in auditory attention research, namely when the ‘breakthrough of the unattended’ takes place in the human brain. Nine subjects classified visual stimuli appearing 300 ms after task‐irrelevant standard tones (80%, i.e. P = 0.8) or novel sounds (20%, i.e. P = 0.2) into odd/even categories. After the recording session, subjects scored the novel sounds as to whether they had any particular meaning (identifiable) or were perceived as a burst of noise (non‐identifiable), and performance and ERPs were analysed according to this classification. A control condition, in which the visual stimuli were presented with no sounds, showed that subjects covertly monitored the task‐irrelevant sounds during visual task‐performance, and a further condition, in which the auditory and visual stimuli appeared regardless of each other, made it possible to trace the processing of the distracters during allocation of attention outside the auditory environment. Results yielded identical N1‐enhancement for the two types of novel sounds, indicating similar attention switching triggered to these two types of unexpected sounds. However, there was a stronger orientating of attention towards identifiable novel sounds, as indicated both by behavioural distraction and by larger novelty‐P3. Furthermore, this stronger orientating of attention was due to the sounds being contingent on the visual stimuli, as no increase in novelty‐P3 to identifiable novel sounds was observed in the control condition, in which the sounds occurred outside the attentional set. Therefore, provided that the N1‐enhancement reflects a call for focal attention, and novelty‐P3 the effective orientating of attention towards the eliciting sounds, the present results suggest that semantic analysis of significant sounds occurs after a transitory switch of attention towards the eliciting stimuli. Moreover, as the novelty‐P3 increase in amplitude was observed only when subjects covertly monitored the sounds, the present data suggest that semantic analysis of irrelevant sounds depends on the top‐down cognitive influences of the attentional set.

Effects of involuntary auditory attention on visual task performance and brain activity

INVOLUNTARY attention to auditory stimulus changes during a visual discrimination task was studied with event-related potentials (ERPs) recorded from the human scalp. A repetitive standard tone or an infrequent, slightly higher deviant tone preceded each visual target stimulus. Deviant tones elicited the mismatch negativity and P3a ERP components and caused increases in reaction time and error rate in the visual task indicating involuntary attention to an auditory stimulus change. These effects were observed even when the tones occurred simultaneously with a visual warning stimulus introduced to keep attention focused on the visual task. In the latter condition, involuntary switching of attention away from the visual task also attenuated the N1 ERP component to visual target stimuli preceded by the deviant tone.

Spatiotemporal dynamics of the auditory novelty-P3 event-related brain potential

The spatiotemporal dynamics of the cerebral network involved in novelty processing was studied by means of scalp current density (SCD) analysis of the novelty P3 (nP3) event-related brain potential (ERP). ERPs were recorded from 30 scalp electrodes at the occurrence of novel unpredictable environmental sounds during the performance of a visual discrimination task. Increased SCD was observed at left frontotemporal (FT3), bilateral temporoparietal (TP3 and TP4) and prefrontal locations (F8-F4 and F7-F3), suggesting novelty-P3 generators located in the left auditory cortex, and bilaterally in temporoparietal and prefrontal association regions. Additional increased SCD was found at a central location (Cz) and at superior parietal locations (P3-Pz-P4). The SCD of the nP3 was therefore generated at three successive, partially overlapping, stages of neuroelectric activation. At the central location, SCD started to be significant before the onset of the nP3 waveform, contributing solely to its early phase. At temporoparietal and left frontotemporal locations, nP3 electrophysiological activity was characterized by sustained current density, starting at about 210 ms and continuing during the full latency range of the response, including its early and late phases. At its late phase, the nP3 was characterized by sharp phasic current density at prefrontal and superior parietal locations, starting at about 290 ms and vanishing at around 385 ms. Taken together, these results provide the first evidence of the cerebral spatio-temporal dynamics underlying novelty processing.

Activation of brain mechanisms of attention switching as a function of auditory frequency change

The activation of the cerebral network underlying involuntary attention switching was studied as a function of the magnitude of auditory change. Event-related brain potentials (ERPs) were recorded during the performance of a visual discrimination task in which task-irrelevant auditory frequency changes of six different levels (5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 40% and 80%) occurred randomly within the same stimulus sequence. All the frequency changes elicited a typical ERP waveform, characterized by MMN, P3a and RON, their respective amplitudes increasing linearly as a function of the magnitude of change. The results indicate that attentional processes in the brain may follow a linear function of activation, contrasting with the well-established logarithmic functions underlying perceptual and psychophysical processes.

Cerebral mechanisms underlying orienting of attention towards auditory frequency changes

Brain mechanisms underlying detection of auditory frequency changes were studied with event-related potentials (ERPs) in 14 human subjects discriminating visual stimuli. Scalp-current density mapping revealed bilateral components of mismatch negativity (MMN) in frontal and auditory cortices. Deviance-related activations in frontal and temporal cortex began to be significant at 94 ms and 154 ms in the right hemisphere, and at 128 ms and 132 ms in the left hemisphere. The magnitude of MMN-neuroelectric currents from the left temporal cortex correlated significantly (r = −0.56, p < 0.05) with distraction caused by MMN-eliciting deviant tones. These results suggest a complex cerebral circuitry involved in frequency change detection and strongly support the role of this circuitry in driving attention involuntarily towards potentially relevant frequency changes in the acoustic environment.

An electrophysiological and behavioral investigation of involuntary attention towards auditory frequency, duration and intensity changes

We measured behavior and event-related brain potentials (ERPs) in 12 subjects performing on an audio-visual distraction paradigm to investigate the cerebral mechanisms of involuntary attention towards stimulus changes in the acoustic environment. Subjects classified odd/even numbers presented on a computer screen 300 ms after the occurrence of a task-irrelevant auditory stimulus, by pressing the corresponding response button. Auditory stimuli were standard tones (600 Hz, 200 ms, 85 dB; P=0.8) or deviant tones (P=0.2), these differing from the standard either in frequency (700 Hz), duration (50 ms) or intensity (79 dB), in separate blocks. In comparison to performance to visual stimuli following the standard tones, reaction time increased by 24 ms (F(1,11)=10.91, P<0.01) and hit rate decreased by 4.6% (F(1,11)=35.47, P<0.001) to visual stimuli following the deviant tones, indicating behavioral distraction. ERPs revealed the mismatch negativity (MMN) elicited to deviant tones, which was larger for the duration deviant than for the frequency and intensity deviants (F(2,22)=19.43, P<0.001, epsilon =0.83), and which had different scalp distribution for all three deviant conditions (F(16,176)=2.40, P<0.05, epsilon =0.12). As the shorter duration and softer intensity deviant tones were unlikely to engage fresh neurons responding to their specific physical features, the present results indicate that a genuine change detection mechanism is involved in triggering attention switching towards sound changes, and suggest a largely distributed neural network of the auditory cortex underlying such involuntary attention switching.

Electrophysiological evidence of abnormal activation of the cerebral network of involuntary attention in alcoholism

OBJECTIVE Increased distractibility is a common impairment in alcoholism, but objective evidence has remained elusive. Here, a task designed to investigate with event-related brain potentials (ERPs) the neural mechanism underlying distraction was used to show abnormal involuntary orienting of attention in chronic alcoholism. METHODS Fifteen alcoholics and 17 matched healthy controls were instructed to ignore auditory stimuli while concentrating in the discrimination of immediately following visual stimuli. The auditory sequences contained repetitive standard tones occasionally replaced by deviant tones of slightly higher frequency, or by complex novel sounds. RESULTS Deviant tones and novel sounds distracted visual performance, i.e. increased reaction time to visual stimuli, similarly in patients and controls. Compared to controls, however, alcoholics showed ERP abnormalities, i.e. enhanced P3a amplitudes over the left frontal region, and a positive posterior deflection instead of the frontally distributed reorienting negativity (RON). CONCLUSIONS The enhanced P3a to novelty and subsequent positive wave instead of RON in alcoholics suggests encoding into working memory of task-irrelevant auditory events and provides neurophysiological markers of impaired involuntary attention mechanisms in chronic alcoholism.

The individual replicability of mismatch negativity at short and long inter-stimulus intervals

OBJECTIVES The individual replicability of the mismatch negativity (MMN) event-related brain potential (ERP) was studied at two different inter-stimulus intervals (ISIs), to establish its potential value for routine clinical evaluation of sound discrimination and auditory sensory memory. METHODS Ten healthy young subjects were presented sequences of 3 stimulus trains, in two recording sessions approximately 1 month apart. The stimuli in the trains were delivered at an ISI of 300 ms, whereas the inter-train intervals (ITIs) were 0.4 s and 4.0 s in different blocks. ERPs were averaged to standard (75 ms) and deviant (25 ms) tones started equiprobably the stimulus trains. RESULTS Significant Pearson product-moment correlations coefficients were found between sessions at all scalp locations for the short ITI, when the MMN was quantified as the mean amplitude in the 100-200 ms latency window around its peak. However, none of the correlations reached significance for the longer ITI. CONCLUSIONS MMN appears to be a reliable measure for single-case assessment and follow-ups when obtained at short ISIs and quantified as an integrated window of neuroelectric activation over a temporal span.

Mismatch negativity and auditory sensory memory evaluation: a new faster paradigm.

A new faster paradigm to measure the duration of auditory sensory memory, as indexed by mismatch negativity (MMN) suppression to stimuli presented at increasing inter-stimulus intervals (ISI), is proposed. Trains of three stimuli were delivered at very short ISI (300 ms). The inter-train interval varied according to the memory probe interval (MPI) tested. Trains started randomly with a deviant or standard stimulus (50% each), with their event-related brain potentials subtracted to obtain the MMN. The new paradigm provided MMNs identical to the conventional one at MPIs of 0.4 and 4.0 s in young subjects, and revealed MMN suppression when the MPI was increased to 5.0 s in older subjects. The new paradigm estimates auditory sensory memory duration in one-third the time of conventional MMN.