Elizabeth Anne Ouellette

Compartment Syndromes of the Hand

We retrospectively reviewed the records of nineteen patients who had been managed with fasciotomy because of compartment syndrome of the hand. The patients were five months to sixty-seven years old and included ten adults and nine children. Seventeen patients were followed for an average of twenty-one months (range, one to fifty-eight months), one patient was lost to follow-up after discharge, and one patient died four days postoperatively. All of the patients had a tense, swollen hand and elevated pressure in at least one interosseous compartment. Eight patients also had a compartment syndrome of the forearm. The compartment syndromes developed after intravenous injections (eleven patients); after a gunshot wound, a crush injury, or a complication related to the use of an arterial line (two patients each); and after a complication related to an arthrodesis of the wrist or a crush injury due to prolonged pressure on the upper extremity secondary to a drug overdose (one patient each). Fifteen patients had an obtunded sensorium—either because of a serious illness or injury or secondary to prolonged anesthesia—when the compartment syndrome was recognized. In thirteen of these patients, including eight children and five adults, the compartment syndrome developed because of a complication related to the intravenous or intra-arterial administration of drugs. Carpal tunnel release and decompression of the involved compartments led to a satisfactory result for thirteen of the seventeen patients who were followed. The remaining four patients (including two children who had an amputation, one child who had impaired function of the hand secondary to brain damage, and one adult who had extensive involvement of the forearm and complete loss of function of the hand) had a poor result. All four of these patients had been obtunded when the compartment syndrome developed. The treating physician should maintain a high index of suspicion for a compartment syndrome of the hand when managing seriously ill, obtunded patients—particularly children—who are receiving multiple intravenous or intra-arterial injections.

Acute compartment syndrome of the upper extremity.

&NA; Acute compartment syndrome occurs when pressure within a fibroosseous space increases to a level that results in a decreased perfusion gradient across tissue capillary beds. Compartment syndromes of the hand, forearm, and upper arm can result in tissue necrosis, which can lead to devastating loss of function. The etiology of acute compartment syndrome in the upper extremity is diverse, and a high index of suspicion must be maintained. Pain out of proportion to injury is the most reliable early symptom of impending compartment syndrome. Diagnosis is particularly difficult in obtunded patients and in young children. Early recognition and expeditious surgical treatment are essential to obtain a good clinical outcome and prevent permanent disability.

Acute pediatric upper extremity compartment syndrome in the absence of fracture.

Background: To determine the etiologies and outcomes associated with acute pediatric upper extremity compartment syndrome in the absence of fracture. Methods: A retrospective review was performed looking at children treated for acute upper extremity compartment syndrome in the absence of fracture at a major teaching hospital. Reason for admission, age, etiology, sensorium, time to fasciotomy, involved compartments, secondary procedures, and functional outcome were recorded. Results: A total of 14 extremities in 13 children with acute compartment syndrome in the absence of fracture were identified over a 22-year period at this single institution. There were 8 boys and 5 girls, with an average age of 7.2 years. Average follow-up was 22 months. Ten patients were being managed in the intensive care unit and had an obtunded sensorium. The cause was iatrogenic in 8 patients, and 2 of these resulted in loss of the involved limb. Six patients required 9 secondary procedures, including 4 amputations, 3 contracture releases, and 2 skin grafts. Of the 3 patients who required a total of 4 amputations, 2 of the patients were in the intensive care unit, and all were younger than 3 years. Only 7 patients had normal hand function. Upon comparing patients with a normal outcome versus those with an abnormal outcome, there was a statistically significant difference if surgery was performed in shorter than 6 hours (P = 0.033). Conclusions: This problem is often iatrogenic in etiology and can be diagnosed late in this population. An increased level of vigilance should be adopted for this entity because the final outcome can be catastrophic for both the patient and the hospital and early fasciotomy is associated with improved results. Level of Evidence: Level IV Case Series

The Role of Soft Tissues in Plate Fixation of Proximal Phalanx Fractures

The tension band effect of plate fixation and the contribution of soft tissues to that effect was examined biomechanically in human proximal phalanges. Forty-six proximal phalanges in whole cadaver hands with all soft tissues in place (intact) and 43 proximal phalanges stripped of soft tissues (denuded) were tested. After midshaft osteotomy, each proximal phalanx was fixed internally with a dorsal minicondylar plate, a lateral minicondylar plate, a dorsal straight plate, or a lateral straight plate. Specimens were tested in three-point apex dorsal bending to clinical failure, defined as 30° angulation. Ultimate moment (stability) at this angulation was similar among the four fixation methods in the specimens with all soft tissues intact. Stability also was similar among these methods in the denuded specimens. There were no significant differences in stability between minicondylar and straight plates or between dorsal and lateral plates in the specimens with soft tissues, nor were there significant differences between these groups in the denuded specimens. The stability of the four fixation methods was significantly greater in the specimens with soft tissues than in the denuded specimens. Soft tissues increased the stability of lateral minicondylar plates by 163%, lateral straight plates by 157%, dorsal minicondylar plates by 126%, and dorsal straight plates by 104%, providing a dorsal tension band effect that counteracted the buttress (compression) of the volar fracture surfaces of the phalanx. The results suggest that in the clinical setting a laterally placed straight or minicondylar plate may provide as much stability to a phalanx with a midshaft fracture as does the traditional, more invasive dorsally placed minicondylar or straight plate. These findings must be evaluated with caution, however, because all specimens were from embalmed cadavers, and the formalin fixation may have augmented the stability and stiffness of the soft tissues in the intact specimens. A subsequent pilot study comparing intact proximal phalangeal specimens that were formalin-fixed with those that were fresh-frozen showed a significant increase in stability and stiffness of formalin-fixed specimens.

Reverse Radial Forearm Fascial Flap for Soft Tissue Coverage of Hand and Forearm Wounds

Six patients with severe hand and forearm injuries involving open wounds and exposed structures were treated with reverse radial forearm fascial flaps and split-thickness skin grafts for soft tissue cover. There were five men and one woman aged between 16 and 36 years. Injuries included soft tissue avulsion on the dorsum of the hand and fingers, extensive flexor and extensor tendon damage, multiple phalangeal fractures, a grade IIIB open dislocation of the index to little carpometacarpal joints, a grade III open metacarpal fracture and a finger amputation. The average wound size was 9 cm in length and 7 cm in width. The mean duration of follow-up was 12 months (range, 5–20 months). All flaps healed well, and all patients were satisfied.

Extensor retinaculum capsulorrhaphy for ulnocarpal and distal radioulnar instability: the Herbert sling.

Wrist pain and instability are challenging problems that may be the result of pathology at the distal radioulnar (DRUJ) or ulnocarpal joints or both. Instability of the wrist can often be attributed to a compromise of the integrity of the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC), a key soft tissue stabilizer of the DRUJ and ulnocarpal articulations. Subsequently, when surgical reconstruction is indicated, techniques should strive to restore the biarthrodial function of the TFCC. Although anatomic reconstruction of the DRUJ ligaments provides successful stabilization of the radioulnar articulation, those patients who present with concomitant ulnocarpal instability require an alternative technique that addresses both the DRUJ- and ulnocarpal-stabilizing functions of the TFCC. The Herbert sling, which is an extensor retinaculum capsulorrhaphy, is an effective method of creating a strong tether among the distal radius, ulna, and ulnar carpus. Preliminary biomechanical and clinical results have been encouraging.

The Injury Distress Index: Development and Validation

OBJECTIVE To develop and validate a new measurement tool designed to assess self-reported distress responses after traumatic physical injury. DESIGN A mixed-methods study design was used. Development of the Injury Distress Index (IDI) included input from patients and experts and a comprehensive literature review. The IDI and validity measures were administered by a trained research assistant at bedside within 1 week of admission. The internal structure (exploratory factor analyses [EFAs]), reliability (internal consistency), and associations with other variables (construct and criterion validity) were examined. SETTING Hand, multiple trauma, and burn services at a large southeastern level-1 trauma center. PARTICIPANTS Multicultural cohort of 169 traumatically injured adults (31% hand, 21% burn, 48% multiple trauma). INTERVENTIONS Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES IDI, Trauma Symptom Checklist-40, Short-Form McGill Pain Questionnaire, Perceived Stress Scale-10, Life Orientation Test-Revised, General Perceived Self-Efficacy Scale, Drug Abuse Screening Test-10, Brief Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test, Abbreviated Injury Scale, hospital length of stay (LOS), postdischarge emergency department visits, and days readmitted to hospital postdischarge. RESULTS An item pool was developed from patient, expert, and literature review data. EFAs extracted 3 separate factors for posttraumatic stress (avoidance and numbing, re-experience, and hyperarousal: coefficient range, .31-.98), which is consistent with conceptual and diagnostic criteria. EFAs also produced single factors of depression (coefficient range, .44-.72), anxiety (coefficient range, .50-.75), and pain (coefficient range, .57-.79). Most IDI scales (except anxiety) could be differentiated between different levels of injury severity. IDI scales and subscales correlated highly and in a convergent pattern with validity measures of posttraumatic stress (r range, .18-.50), depression (r range, .24-.52), anxiety (r range, .30-.57), and pain (r range, .10-.42), as well as theoretically related variables, such as general distress (r range, .32-.56), self-efficacy (r range, -.15 to -.39), and optimism (r range, -.21 to -.45). IDI scales correlated in a discriminant pattern with measures of drug and alcohol abuse (r range, .02-.07; r range, .09-.21, respectfully). Concurrent and predictive validity evidence was also supported with small associations with injury severity (r range, .16-.30), hospital LOS (r range, .05-.21), number of emergency department visits postdischarge (r range, -.05 to .27), and number of days readmitted to the hospital postdischarge (r range, .05-.21). Cronbach alpha coefficients were within the acceptable range (alpha range, .75-.92). CONCLUSIONS A new tool to examine injury-related distress after traumatic physical injury has been developed. Results suggest that IDI scores showed acceptable reliability and validity coefficients with this multicultural sample. Additional validation studies are recommended with larger sample sizes using similar populations to confirm these findings.

Ethnic and Gender Diversity in Hand Surgery Trainees

PURPOSE To evaluate whether the lack of diversity in plastic and orthopedic surgery persists into hand surgery through assessment of trainee demographics. METHODS Demographic data were obtained from compilations on graduate medical education by the Journal of the American Medical Association. Ethnic diversity was assessed using the proportions of minority trainees. We analyzed the trends in ethnic diversity in hand, orthopedic, and plastic surgery from 1995 to 2012 by evaluating changes in proportions of African American, Hispanic, and Asian trainees. In addition, we compared the proportions of minority trainees in various surgical specialties during 2009 to 2012. Trends in gender diversity were similarly analyzed using the proportions of female trainees. RESULTS During 1995 to 2012, the proportions of minority and female trainees increased significantly in the fields of orthopedic, plastic, and hand surgery. To assess the current state of diversity in various specialties, we compared minority and female population proportions using pooled 2009 to 2012 data. The percentage of non-Caucasian trainees in hand surgery was significantly higher than that in orthopedic sports medicine and orthopedic surgery and significantly lower than in general surgery. The percentage of female trainees in hand surgery was significantly higher than that in orthopedic sports medicine and orthopedic surgery and significantly lower than in plastic and general surgery. CONCLUSIONS Ethnic and gender diversity in hand surgery increased significantly between 1995 and 2012. Women constitute a fifth of hand surgery trainees. Efforts to increase diversity should be further pursued using proven strategies and innovating new ones. CLINICAL RELEVANCE Diversity in the medical field has shown to be a beneficial factor in many aspects including research productivity and patient care. Understanding how the field of hand surgery has changed with regard to the diversity of its trainees may aid in providing more equitable and effective health care.

Role of soft tissues in metacarpal fracture fixation.

The contribution of soft tissues in stabilizing fracture fixation in metacarpals is appreciated clinically, but no quantitative biomechanical study of their role has been done. All previous studies of fracture fixation in vitro have been done on metacarpals denuded of soft tissues. To quantify the role of soft tissues in metacarpal fracture fixation, the biomechanical effectiveness of four fixation devices was examined in human cadaver metacarpals with and without soft tissues. Values were compared for three nonrigid methods (expandable intramedullary fixation devices, crossed Kirschner wires, and single half-pin frames) and one rigid method (dorsal plates) in 45 disarticulated metacarpals stripped of soft tissues (denuded) and in 46 metacarpals in whole hands with all soft tissues remaining (intact). Mechanical testing to complete failure in three-point apex dorsal bending was done in all specimens. Ultimate moment (strength) of each of the four fixation methods was significantly greater in intact specimens than in denuded specimens. Crossed Kirschner wires were most stable in intact specimens, and dorsal plates were more stable in denuded specimens. The results show that soft tissues contribute to the strength of fracture fixation. Clinically, surgeons may be able to use a less invasive fixation method than plating without compromising the strength of metacarpal fixation in patients whose soft tissues are not severely disrupted and the fracture configuration allows. Plating may offer optimum stability in patients whose soft tissues are damaged severely and provide less strengthening of the fracture construct.

CORR Insights ®: Patients with greater symptom intensity and more disability are more likely to be surprised by a hand surgeon's advice.

This CORR Insights® is a commentary on the article “Patients With Greater Symptom Intensity and More Disability are More Likely to be Surprised by a Hand Surgeon’s Advice” by Strooker and colleagues available at: DOI: 10.1007/s11999-014-3971-5. The author certifies that she, or any member of her immediate family, has no funding or commercial associations (eg, consultancies, stock ownership, equity interest, patent/licensing arrangements, etc) that might pose a conflict of interest in connection with the submitted article. All ICMJE Conflict of Interest Forms for authors and Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research ® editors and board members are on file with the publication and can be viewed on request. The opinions expressed are those of the writers, and do not reflect the opinion or policy of CORR ® or the Association of Bone and Joint Surgeons®. This CORR Insights® comment refers to the article available at DOI: 10.1007/s11999-014-3971-5.