Elke D. Reissing

Etiological Correlates of Vaginismus: Sexual and Physical Abuse, Sexual Knowledge, Sexual Self-Schema, and Relationship Adjustment

This study investigated the role of sexual and physical abuse, sexual self-schema, sexual functioning, sexual knowledge, relationship adjustment, and psychological distress in 87 women matched on age, relationship status, and parity and assigned to 3 groups- vaginismus, dyspareunia/vulvar vestibulitis syndrome (VVS), and no pain. More women with vaginismus reported a history of childhood sexual interference, and women in both the vaginismus and VVS groups reported lower levels of sexual functioning and a less positive sexual self-schema. Lack of support for traditionally held hypotheses concerning etiological correlates of vaginismus and the relationship between vaginismus and dyspareunia are discussed.

Does vaginismus exist? A critical review of the literature.

The basic strategies and methods for assessing and treating vaginismus were proposed by the early 20th century and have not essentially changed. Etiological theories have changed over time but are not supported by controlled empirical studies. This critical review of the literature disputes the widely held belief that vaginismus is an easily diagnosed and easily treated sexual dysfunction. We propose a reconceptualization of vaginismus as either an aversion/phobia of vaginal penetration or a genital pain disorder.

The female sexual pain disorders: genital pain or sexual dysfunction?

Vaginismus and dyspareunia have been typically classified as sexual dysfunctions. In practice and research, this conceptualization has led to a focus on sexual and interpersonal issues after biological causes were excluded. Although this approach has been very useful, it has not led to significant theoretical or therapeutic progress in the last 20 years. We propose a reconceptualization of vaginismus and dyspareunia as pain disorders that interfere with sexuality rather than as sexual disorders characterized by pain. This reconceptualization focuses the clinician and researcher on the central phenomenon—pain. It also suggests new approaches to research and treatment. Data from diagnostic, etiologic, and therapeutic studies will be presented to illustrate these points.

Premenstrual dysphoric disorder: Prevalence, diagnostic considerations, and controversies

Premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) has been included as a formal diagnosis of a mood disorder in the appendix of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition in 1994. The ensuing, critical attention has resulted in increased research productivity and clinical recognition of this neglected womens health problem. A decade later, this paper will review the current literature on PMDD focusing on prevalence, biopsychosocial etiological correlates, history of the development of a formal DSM diagnosis, and the controversies surrounding the current classification of PMDD. The authors conclude that PMDD presents a distinct diagnostic entity and that recognition through formal diagnostic criteria serves the important minority of women who suffer from this cyclical mood disorder distinct from premenstrual symptoms and major depression.

A comparative study of sexual function, behavior, and cognitions of women with lifelong vaginismus.

Vaginismus is classified as a sexual dysfunction, yet limited research is available on the sexual function and behavior of women with this condition. Comparing women with lifelong vaginismus to women with lifelong dyspareunia and women with no pain during intercourse, this study explored sexual function, anxiety, and behavior along with cognitions related to vaginal penetration. A total of 152 women completed an online survey that included a series of validated questionnaires. Main findings indicated that, relative to both comparison groups, women in the vaginismus group reported a more limited range of sexual behavior across the lifespan and more maladaptive cognitions related to fear of losing control of one’s body and the situation during penetration. Compared to the no-pain group, both symptomatic groups reported more difficulties across several indicators of sexual function, more limited sexual behavior in the past year and past month, and more maladaptive cognitions related to vaginal penetration. However, women with vaginismus reported more sexual desire and less difficulty with lubrication compared to women with dyspareunia. Numerous sexual problems extending beyond vaginal penetration difficulties were confirmed, suggesting a need for broader treatment approaches not limited to the experience of vaginal penetration. Results were discussed as they relate to the fear-avoidance model of vaginismus.

A Psychophysiological Investigation of Sexual Arousal in Women with Lifelong Vaginismus

INTRODUCTION Relatively little is known about the subjective reactions of women with lifelong vaginismus to erotic stimuli and genital arousal has never been investigated. Reports of maladaptive cognitions and fears regarding sexuality and intercourse suggest that anxiety may interfere with sexual arousal in women with vaginismus. AIMS To examine the genital and subjective responses to sexually explicit film stimuli of women with lifelong vaginismus compared with women with lifelong dyspareunia and women with no pain. METHODS Forty-five women (15 vaginismus, 15 dyspareunia, and 15 no pain) viewed two neutral and two erotic film sets, one depicting sexual activity without vaginal penetration and the other depicting intercourse, over two testing sessions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Vulvar temperature was recorded using an infrared camera. Participants completed a measure of subjective responses after viewing each film. RESULTS All groups experienced increased vulvar temperature during the erotic films regardless of activity depicted. In response to the erotic films, the vaginismus group reported less mental arousal than the no-pain group and a range of negative subjective responses, including threat and disgust. Overall, participants showed concordance between peak subjective sexual arousal and temperature change from baseline to peak arousal. CONCLUSION Despite negative subjective responses, women with vaginismus responded with increased genital sexual arousal to erotic films. The resilience of genital arousal may have resulted from moderate levels of anxiety experienced in the laboratory setting facilitating sexual response regardless of subjective appraisal; however, anxiety experienced in a dyadic context may interfere more substantially.

Throwing the Baby Out with the Bathwater: The Demise of Vaginismus in Favor of Genito-Pelvic Pain/Penetration Disorder

Over the past 15 years, there has been ongoing debate about whether vaginismus can be differentiated from dyspareunia categorically, dimensionally, or not at all (Reissing, Binik, & Khalifé, 1999). Despite the fact that the debate on diagnostic distinction continues, a significant change was made in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5; American Psychiatric Association, 2013). The diagnosis of Genito-Pelvic Pain/Penetration Disorder (GPPPD) was introduced to replace the hitherto separate diagnosesofDyspareuniaandVaginismus,previouslyunder thesubcategory of sexual pain disorders (DSM-IV-TR; American Psychiatric Association, 2000). Binik (2005a) argued that the sexual pain disorders were the onlypainconditionsthatwereclassifiedaccordingtotheactivity they interfered with and argued for their removal from the classification of sexual dysfunctions. This was received with broad skepticism from clinicians and researchers alike (Binik, 2005b). The introduction of GPPPD may represent an apparent compromise. The diagnostic criteria for this new category have focused on symptomatology related to pain during sexual activity and/or pain with (anticipated) vaginal penetration. The multidimensional diagnosis of GPPPD is clearly more in line with the outcomes of scientific research and clinical practice than the original categorical classification in DSM-IV-TR as outlined elegantly by Binik’s (2010a, 2010b) summary of the literature. However, GPPPD fails to capture the complexity of sexual difficulties in women who have never been able to experience intercourse (for the purpose of this commentary referred tobythepreviousdiagnostic labelof lifelongvaginismus). Inour opinion, we run the risk that the baby (lifelong vaginismus) is thrown out with the bathwater (sexual pain disorders). By summarizing different aspects of lifelong vaginismus based on the results of recent studies, we will underscore this and offer a temporary solution to assist clinicians and researchers to mediate the omission of lifelong vaginismus from the DSM-5. Vaginismus was first mentioned as a sexual/reproductive problem by the Italian physician Trotula of Salerno in the eleventh century:‘‘On the tightening of the vulva so that even a woman who has been seduced may appear a virgin’’(1940; p. 37). The diagnostic term ‘‘vaginismus’’was coined by the English gynecologist, J. Marion Sims, in 1861. Even in the first description of vaginismus, the confusion between pelvic Charmaine Borg and Symon K. Spoelstra are both second authors.

Women who have sex with women: a comprehensive review of the literature and conceptual model of sexual function

Women who have sex with women (WSW) have been underrepresented in studies on sexual function. Consequently, much of what is known of female sexual function may not be representative of, or generalizable to, the experiences of WSW. The purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive and critical review of the literature on the sexual function of WSW, followed by an integration of the literature in a conceptual model to guide and stimulate research. Twenty-six articles are reviewed and 15 factors are identified as contributing to sexual functioning in WSW and are subsequently included in the conceptual model. Of these, it is suggested that eight factors may contribute directly to sexual function. These include: age, income, religion, cultural recognition, relationship duration, sexual satisfaction, psychological well-being, and relationship satisfaction. The literature suggests the remaining seven factors may indirectly contribute to sexual function. These include: sexual frequency, desire discrepancy between partners, internalized homonegativity, power, social support, emotional intimacy, and a discrepancy between partners in level of being “out” as a lesbian or bisexual woman. Comparisons are made to the sexual function of women who have sex with men and the implications of having a model that recognizes similarities while also considering unique influences for WSW are discussed.

Women’s Motivations to Have Sex in Casual and Committed Relationships with Male and Female Partners

Women report a wide variety of reasons to have sex (e.g., Meston & Buss, 2010), and while it is reasonable to assume that those reasons may vary based on the context of the relationship, this assumption has not yet been tested. The purpose of this study was to explore how relationship type, sexual attraction, and the gender of one’s partner interact and affect the sexual motivations of women. A total of 510 women (361 who reported exclusively other-sex attraction and 149 who reported same-sex/bisexual attraction) completed the YSEX? questionnaire. Participants rated their sexual motivations for casual sex and sex in a committed relationship with male and/or female partners, depending on reported sexual attraction. Results showed that relationship type affected reported motivation for sex: physical motivations were more strongly endorsed for casual sex, whereas emotional motivations were more strongly endorsed for sex in committed relationships. No significant differences in motivation were reported between women who reported same-sex attraction and those who did not. Women who reported bisexual attraction and identified as being lesbian, bisexual, or another sexual minority reported no significant differences in motivation for sex with male or female partners. The results of this study highlight the importance of relationship context when discussing sexual motivation and suggest a high degree of similarity in motivation for women, regardless of sexual orientation or gender of partner.

Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy for Lifelong Vaginismus: A Retrospective Chart Review and Interview Study

Pelvic floor physical therapy is used in the treatment of sexual pain disorders; however, women with lifelong vaginismus have not yet been included in treatment studies or have not been differentiated from women with acquired vaginismus and/or dyspareunia. This retrospective chart review and interview study was intended to obtain initial information on physical therapy interventions, course, and outcome in women who have never been able to experience vaginal intercourse. The files of 53 women, consecutively treated at one physical therapy clinic, were included in the chart review; 13 of these women volunteered to be interviewed. The chart review revealed significant pelvic floor pathology and an average treatment course of 29 sessions. Internal manual techniques were found to be most effective, followed by patient education, dilatation exercises, and home exercises. Although participants were very satisfied with the physical therapy, some symptoms, such as pain, anxiety/fear, and pelvic floor tension remained and scores on the Female Sexual Distress Scale and Female Sexual Function Index indicated clinical levels of sexual distress and impaired sexual function after treatment. Although there appears to be no linear relation between symptom reduction and healthy sexual function, this initial information suggests that physical therapy may be a promising treatment option for some women with lifelong vaginismus and merits further evaluation.