Elsa Wagner-Rousset

Trends in Glycosylation, Glycoanalysis and Glycoengineering of Therapeutic Antibodies and Fc-Fusion Proteins

Monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) are the fastest growing class of human pharmaceuticals. More than 20 MAbs have been approved and several hundreds are in clinical trials in various therapeutic indications including oncology, inflammatory diseases, organ transplantation, cardiology, viral infection, allergy, and tissue growth and repair. Most of the current therapeutic antibodies are humanized or human Immunoglobulins (IgGs) and are produced as recombinant glycoproteins in eukaryotic cells. Many alternative production systems and improved constructs are also being actively investigated. IgGs glycans represent only an average of around 3% of the total mass of the molecule. Despite this low percentage, particular glycoforms are involved in essential immune effector functions. On the other hand, glycoforms that are not commonly biosynthesized in human may be allergenic, immunogenic and accelerate the plasmatic clearance of the linked antibody. These glyco-variants have to be identified, controlled and limited for therapeutic uses. Glycosylation depends on multiple factors like production system, selected clonal population, manufacturing process and may be genetically or chemically engineered. The present account reviews the glycosylation patterns observed for the current approved therapeutic antibodies produced in mammalian cell lines, details classical and state-of-the-art analytical methods used for the characterization of glycoforms and discusses the expected benefits of manipulating the carbohydrate components of antibodies by bio- or chemical engineering as well as the expected advantages of alternative biotechnological production systems developed for new generation of therapeutic antibodies and Fc-fusion proteins.

Identification and characterization of asparagine deamidation in the light chain CDR1 of a humanized IgG1 antibody

Despite technological advances, detection of deamidation in large proteins remains a challenge and the use of orthogonal methods is needed for unequivocal assignment. By a combination of cation-exchange separation, papain digestion, and a panel of mass spectrometry techniques we identified asparagine deamidation in light chain complementarity determining region 1 (CDR1) of a humanized IgG1 monoclonal antibody. The reaction yields both Asp and isoAsp, which were assigned by Edman degradation and by isoAsp detection using protein isoaspartate methyltransferase. The deamidated antibody variants were less potent in antigen binding compared to the nondegraded antibody. Changes in near-UV CD spectra, susceptibility to papain cleavage in an adjacent CDR2 loop, and the tendency of the newly formed isoAsp to undergo isomerization suggest local perturbations in the structure of the isoAsp-containing antibody.

Correct primary structure assessment and extensive glyco-profiling of cetuximab by a combination of intact, middle-up, middle-down and bottom-up ESI and MALDI mass spectrometry techniques

The European Medicines Agency received recently the first marketing authorization application for a biosimilar monoclonal antibody (mAb) and adopted the final guidelines on biosimilar mAbs and Fc-fusion proteins. The agency requires high similarity between biosimilar and reference products for approval. Specifically, the amino acid sequences must be identical. The glycosylation pattern of the antibody is also often considered to be a very important quality attribute due to its strong effect on quality, safety, immunogenicity, pharmacokinetics and potency. Here, we describe a case study of cetuximab, which has been marketed since 2004. Biosimilar versions of the product are now in the pipelines of numerous therapeutic antibody biosimilar developers. We applied a combination of intact, middle-down, middle-up and bottom-up electrospray ionization and matrix assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry techniques to characterize the amino acid sequence and major post-translational modifications of the marketed cetuximab product, with special emphasis on glycosylation. Our results revealed a sequence error in the reported sequence of the light chain in databases and in publications, thus highlighting the potency of mass spectrometry to establish correct antibody sequences. We were also able to achieve a comprehensive identification of cetuximab’s glycoforms and glycosylation profile assessment on both Fab and Fc domains. Taken together, the reported approaches and data form a solid framework for the comparability of antibodies and their biosimilar candidates that could be further applied to routine structural assessments of these and other antibody-based products.

Innovative Native MS Methodologies for Antibody Drug Conjugate Characterization: High Resolution Native MS and IM-MS for Average DAR and DAR Distribution Assessment

Antibody drug conjugates (ADCs) are macromolecules composed of cytotoxic drugs covalently attached via a conditionally stable linker to monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). ADCs are among the most promising next generation of empowered mAbs foreseen to treat cancers. Compared to naked mAbs, ADCs have an increased level of complexity as the heterogeneity of conjugation cumulates with the inherent microvariability of the biomolecule. An increasing need underlying ADCs development and optimization is to improve its analytical and bioanalytical characterization by assessing three main ADC quality attributes: drug distribution, amount of naked antibody, and average drug to antibody ratio (DAR). Here, the analytical potential of native mass spectrometry (MS) and native ion mobility MS (IM-MS) is compared to hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC), the reference method for quality control of interchain cysteinyl-linked ADCs. Brentuximab vedotin, first in class and gold standard, was chosen for a proof of principle. High resolution native MS provided accurate mass measurement (<30 ppm) of intact ADCs together with average DAR and drug distribution, confirming the unique ability of native MS for simultaneous detection of mixtures of covalent and noncovalent products. Native IM-MS was next used for the first time to characterize an ADC. IM-MS evidenced ADC multiple drug loading, collisional cross sections measurement of each payload species attesting slight conformational changes. A semiquantitative interpretation of IM-MS data was developed to directly extrapolate average DAR and DAR distribution. Additionally, HIC fractions were collected and analyzed by native MS and IM-MS, assessing the interpretation of each HIC peak. Altogether, our results illustrate how native MS and IM-MS can rapidly assess ADC structural heterogeneity and how easily these methods can be implemented into MS workflows for in-depth ADC analytical characterization.

The way forward, enhanced characterization of therapeutic antibody glycosylation: comparison of three level mass spectrometry-based strategies.

Glycosylation which plays a crucial role in the pharmacological properties of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) is influenced by several factors like production systems, selected clonal population and manufacturing processes. Efficient analytical methods are therefore required in order to characterize glycosylation at different stages of MAbs discovery and production. Three mass spectrometry (MS)-based strategies were compared to analyze N-glycosylation of MAbs either expressed in murine myeloma (NS0) or Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell lines, the two current main production systems used for therapeutic MAbs. First a top-down approach was used on intact and reduced MAbs by liquid chromatography coupled to an electrospray ionization-time of flight mass spectrometer (LC-ESI-TOF), which provided fast and accurate profiles of MAbs glycosylation patterns for routine controls. Secondly, after digestion of the antibody with the peptide N-glycosidase F (PNGase F) enzyme, released N-linked glycans were directly analyzed by electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) without any prior derivatization, which gave precise details on the structure of the most abundant glycoforms. Finally, a bottom-up approach on tryptic glycopeptides using a nanoLC-Chip-MS/MS ion trap (IT) system equipped with a graphitized carbon column was investigated. Data were compared to those obtained with a more classical C18 reversed phase column showing that this last method is well suited to detect low abundant glycoforms and to provide in one shot information regarding both the oligosaccharide structure and the amino acid sequence of its peptide moiety.

Antibody-drug conjugate model fast characterization by LC-MS following IdeS proteolytic digestion

Here we report the design and production of an antibody-fluorophore conjugate (AFC) as a non-toxic model of an antibody-drug conjugate (ADC). This AFC is based on the conjugation of dansyl sulfonamide ethyl amine (DSEA)-linker maleimide on interchain cysteines of trastuzumab used as a reference antibody. The resulting AFC was first characterized by routine analytical methods (SEC, SDS-PAGE, CE-SDS, HIC and native MS), resulting in similar chromatograms, electropherograms and mass spectra to those reported for hinge Cys-linked ADCs. IdeS digestion of the AFC was then performed, followed by reduction and analysis by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry analysis. Dye loading and distribution on light chain and Fd fragments were calculated, as well as the average dye to antibody ratio (DAR) for both monomeric and multimeric species. In addition, by analyzing the Fc fragment in the same run, full glyco-profiling and demonstration of the absence of additional conjugation was easily achieved. As for naked antibodies and Fc-fusion proteins, IdeS proteolytic digestion may rapidly become a reference analytical method at all stages of ADC discovery, preclinical and clinical development. The method can be routinely used for comparability assays, formulation, process scale-up and transfer, and to define critical quality attributes in a quality-by-design approach.

Cutting-edge mass spectrometry characterization of originator, biosimilar and biobetter antibodies

The approval process for antibody biosimilars relies primarily on comprehensive analytical data to establish comparability and high similarity with the originator. Mass spectrometry (MS) in combination with liquid chromatography (LC) and electrophoretic methods are the corner stone for comparability and biosimilarity evaluation. In this special feature we report head-to-head comparison of trastuzumab and cetuximab with corresponding biosimilar and biobetter candidates based on cutting-edge mass spectrometry techniques such as native MS and ion-mobility MS at different levels (top, middle and bottom). In addition, we discuss the advantages and the limitations of sample preparation and enzymatic digestion, middle-up and -down strategies and the use of hydrogen/deuterium exchange followed by MS (HDX-MS). Last but not least, emerging separation methods combined to MS such as capillary zone electrophoresis-tandem MS (CESI-MS/MS), electron transfer dissociation (ETD), top down-sequencing (TDS) and high-resolution MS (HR-MS) that complete the panel of state-of-the-art MS-based options for comparability and biosimilarity evaluation are presented.

Extending Mass Spectrometry Contribution to Therapeutic Monoclonal Antibody Lead Optimization: Characterization of Immune Complexes Using Noncovalent ESI-MS

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have taken on an increasing importance for the treatment of various diseases including cancers, immunological disorders, and other pathologies. These large biomolecules display specific structural features, which affect their efficiency and need, therefore, to be extensively characterized using sensitive and orthogonal analytical techniques. Among them, mass spectrometry (MS) has become the method of choice to study mAb amino acid sequences as well as their post-translational modifications. In the present work, recent noncovalent MS-technologies including automated chip-based nanoelectrospray MS and traveling wave ion mobility MS were used for the first time to characterize immune complexes involving both murine and humanized mAb 6F4 directed against human JAM-A, a newly identified antigenic protein (Ag) overexpressed in tumor cells. MS-based structural insights evidenced that heterogeneous disulfide bridge pairings of recombinant JAM-A alter neither its native structure nor mAbs 6F4 recognition properties. Investigations focused on mAb:Ag complexes revealed that, similarly to murine mAb, humanized mAb 6F4 binds selectively up to four antigen molecules with a similar affinity, confirming in this way the reliability of the humanization process. Noncovalent MS appears as an additional supporting technique for therapeutic mAbs lead characterization and development.

Native mass spectrometry and ion mobility characterization of trastuzumab emtansine, a lysine‐linked antibody drug conjugate

Antibody–drug conjugates (ADCs) are biochemotherapeutics consisting of a cytotoxic chemical drug linked covalently to a monoclonal antibody. Two main classes of ADCs, namely cysteine and lysine conjugates, are currently available on the market or involved in clinical trials. The complex structure and heterogeneity of ADCs makes their biophysical characterization challenging. For cysteine conjugates, hydrophobic interaction chromatography is the gold standard technique for studying drug distribution, the naked antibody content, and the average drug to antibody ratio (DAR). For lysine ADC conjugates on the other hand, which are not amenable to hydrophobic interaction chromatography because of their higher heterogeneity, denaturing mass spectrometry (MS) and UV/Vis spectroscopy are the most powerful approaches. We report here the use of native MS and ion mobility (IM‐MS) for the characterization of trastuzumab emtansine (T‐DM1, Kadcyla®). This lysine conjugate is currently being considered for the treatment of human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)‐positive breast cancer, and combines the anti‐HER2 antibody trastuzumab (Herceptin®), with the cytotoxic microtubule‐inhibiting maytansine derivative, DM1. We show that native MS combined with high‐resolution measurements and/or charge reduction is beneficial in terms of the accurate values it provides of the average DAR and the drug load profiles. The use of spectral deconvolution is discussed in detail. We report furthermore the use of native IM‐MS to directly determine DAR distribution profiles and average DAR values, as well as a molecular modeling investigation of positional isomers in T‐DM1.

Time Resolved Native Ion-Mobility Mass Spectrometry to Monitor Dynamics of IgG4 Fab Arm Exchange and “Bispecific” Monoclonal Antibody Formation

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and derivatives such as antibody-drug conjugates (ADC) and bispecific antibodies (bsAb), are the fastest growing class of human therapeutics. Most of the therapeutic antibodies currently on the market and in clinical trials are chimeric, humanized, and human immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1). An increasing number of IgG2s and IgG4s that have distinct structural and functional properties are also investigated to develop products that lack or have diminished antibody effector functions compared to IgG1. Importantly, wild type IgG4 has been shown to form half molecules (one heavy chain and one light chain) that lack interheavy chain disulfide bonds and form intrachain disulfide bonds. Moreover, IgG4 undergoes a process of Fab-arm exchange (FAE) in which the heavy chains of antibodies of different specificities can dissociate and recombine in bispecific antibodies both in vitro and in vivo. Here, native mass spectrometry (MS) and time-resolved traveling wave ion mobility MS (TWIM-MS) were used for the first time for online monitoring of FAE and bsAb formation using Hz6F4-2v3 and natalizumab, two humanized IgG4s which bind to human Junctional Adhesion Molecule-A (JAM-A) and alpha4 integrin, respectively. In addition, native MS analysis of bsAb/JAM-A immune complexes revealed that bsAb can bind up to two antigen molecules, confirming that the Hz6F4 family preferentially binds dimeric JAM-A. Our results illustrate how IM-MS can rapidly assess bsAb structural heterogeneity and be easily implemented into MS workflows for bsAb production follow up and bsAb/antigen complex characterization. Altogether, these results provide new MS-based methodologies for in-depth FAE and bsAb formation monitoring. Native MS and IM-MS will play an increasing role in next generation biopharmaceutical product characterization like bsAbs, antibody mixtures, and antibody-drug conjugates (ADC) as well as for biosimilar and biobetter antibodies.