Eric Cottington

Acute mortality associated with injuries to the pelvic ring: the role of early patient mobilization and external fixation.

PURPOSE To analyze the effect on mortality of a protocol for early mobilization with external fixation of patients with pelvic ring injuries. METHODS From 1981 through 1988, 605 patients with pelvic ring fractures and dislocations were treated. In 1982, a protocol for early external fixation of hemodynamically unstable patients and those with structurally unstable pelvic fracture patterns to achieve early mobilization to an upright chest position was initiated. Mortality rates were compared between 1981 (pre-protocol), 1982 (transitional), and 1983 through 1988, after initiation of a protocol of care that included external fixation of the pelvic injury. No statistical changes occurred from 1983 through 1988. RESULTS Mortality rates in pelvic ring injury patients fell from 26% in 1981, to 6% in 1983 through 1988 (p < 0.001), whereas during the study period the mean injury Severity Score (ISS), 23, did not change. The mortality rate of a group of consecutive patients with comparable ISSs, but without pelvic ring injuries did not change. The mortality rate in patients with systolic blood pressure < 100 mm Hg at admission fell from 41% in 1981 to 21% 1983 through 1988 (p = 0.0001). Mortality in patients with closed head injuries associated with pelvic ring injuries fell from 43% in 1981 to 7% from 1983 through 1988 (p = 0.0001). The proportion of patients undergoing external fixation rose from 3% in 1981 to 31% in 1983 through 1988 (p = 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS An organized protocol including external fixation and early patient mobilization to an upright chest position reduced mortality associated with injuries of the pelvic ring. Orthopedic stabilization of major skeletal injuries should be viewed as part of patient resuscitation, not reconstruction.

The utility of physiological status, injury site, and injury mechanism in identifying patients with major trauma.

It has been suggested that if triage criteria are to identify accurately patients with major trauma, not only physiologic status, but also anatomic site and injury mechanism must be assessed. This study examined the influence of physiologic, injury site, and injury mechanism criteria on the diagnosis of major trauma in 2,057 trauma patients. Because the Trauma Score was found to be a highly specific indicator of major trauma (98.7%), the strategy adopted for isolating the factors that minimize inappropriate triage was to determine which, alone or in combination, are the most effective in identifying patients with major trauma among those with high Trauma Scores (greater than 12). Based on this analysis, a set of triage guidelines was developed. The application of these guidelines to the study population indicated an undertriage rate of 4.1 to 6.3% and an overtriage rate of 16.8 to 21.3%, depending on the definition of major trauma.

EFFECT OF ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION ON OUTCOME OF PEDESTRIAN VICTIMS

The influence of alcohol consumption on the severity of pedestrian injuries has not been studied extensively. In this retrospective study, we reviewed the cases of 143 pedestrian accident victims admitted to our trauma center during 1982 and 1983. Alcohol consumption was present in 30% of patients; 74% of them had blood alcohol levels of more than 100 mg/dL. There was a significant difference in age distribution (P less than .001); the alcohol-related accidents peaked in the 25- to 34-year-old age group, and the nonalcohol-related accidents peaked in the less than 18- and more than 55-year-old groups. Mean Injury Severity Score (25.0 vs 17.8, P less than .01) and mean length of stay (30.9 vs 17.2 days, P less than .005) were significantly greater in the patients who had consumed alcohol. Those patients with ethanol in their blood had significantly more frequent injuries to the spine (25.6% vs 10%, P less than .05) and the chest (32.6% vs 13%, P = .01). Overall mortality (11.6% vs 20%, P = .23) and mortality excluding emergency department deaths (11.6% vs 11.1%, P = .93) were not significantly different between the drinking and nondrinking groups. However, the ED mortality was higher in the nonalcohol group (0% vs 10%, P = .03). We conclude that pedestrian victims are commonly intoxicated and that chest and spine injuries are more common in this population.

Trauma and the full moon: A waning theory

There exists a popular belief in the causal relationship between the moons phase and the incidence of major trauma. In this retrospective study we reviewed 1,444 trauma victims admitted to the hospital during one calendar year. Full moons were defined as three-day periods in the 29.531-day lunar cycle, with the middle day being described in the world almanac as the full moon. Victims of violence included those patients sustaining blunt assault, gunshot wounds, and stabbings. There was no statistical difference in number of trauma admissions between the full moon, 129 patients per 36 days (mean, 3.58), and nonfull moon days, 1,315 patients per 330 days (mean, 3.98). Mortality rate, 5.4% versus 10.3%; mean Injury Severity Score, 13 versus 15; and mean length of stay, ten versus 12 days, were not significantly different during the full moon and nonfull moon days. Victims of violence were admitted at a similar frequency on full moon, 16 patients per 36 days (mean, 0.444), and nonfull moon days, 183 patients per 330 days (mean, 0.555). We conclude that the belief in the deleterious effects of the full moon on major trauma is statistically unfounded.

Facilitated intravenous access through local application of nitroglycerin ointment

Thirty-four patients with diminutive peripheral veins requiring peripheral IV access (PIVA) in the emergency department setting were randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups. One group of patients (Group A) received application of a bland ointment to the dorsum of the hand prior to attempts at cannulation, while the other group (Group B) received application of 2% nitroglycerin ointment to the dorsum of the hand prior to cannulation attempts. Cannulation was achieved in all 34 patients in the study, but required significantly fewer attempts in Group B patients (P = .04). No side effects of the drug were observed in any patient or any staff member applying the ointments. We conclude that application of 2% nitroglycerin ointment to the dorsum of the hand is a safe, effective method of inducing local venodilation that will ensure PIVA with significantly fewer attempts at cannulation.

The power of the Z statistic: implications for trauma research and quality assurance review.

The Z statistic can be used to test whether the observed number of survivors in a specific trauma population is significantly different from what would be expected based on the Major Trauma Outcome Study (MTOS) norms. However, as with any statistic, inferences based on the Z statistic should be made with care. This is particularly true when a non-significant Z statistic is observed. The purpose of this paper, using data from a large, urban trauma registry, is to illustrate how the power of the Z statistic, or its ability to detect a difference between observed and expected survival, is influenced by the magnitude of the difference, the direction of the difference, the survival probability distribution of the study population, and the sample size. The implications for trauma research and quality assurance review are discussed.

Acoustic otoscopy in the diagnosis of otitis media

Acoustic otoscopy detects middle ear pathology by measuring the ability of the tympanic membrane to reflect sound. Fluid or thickening of the tympanic membrane increases sound reflection. We conducted a study to compare acoustic otoscopy with pneumatic otoscopy in identifying middle ear pathology in 80 children (160 ears) presenting to the emergency department with ear or upper respiratory complaints. We then evaluated the use of acoustic otoscopy in 34 adults (68 ears) with and without ear complaints. Using a reflectivity of 5 or more units to signify acute pathology in children, the sensitivity was 82%, and the specificity was 100%. Using a reflectivity of 6 or more units to indicate acute suppurative pathology in adults, the sensitivity was 83%, and the specificity was 95%. We found acoustic otoscopy to be objective, practical, and reproducible. We conclude that acoustic otoscopy is a valuable adjunct in the diagnosis of otitis media in children and adults.

Transconjunctival Oxygen Monitoring as a Predictor of Hypoxemia During Helicopter Transport

As the use of helicopters for air transport of critically ill patients increases, the availability of monitoring devices for physiological parameters during flight becomes important. It has long been known that arterial PO2 (PaO2) decreases during unsupplemented, non-pressurized flight. In this study, the authors examined the use of the transconjunctival oxygen (cjO2) monitor for assessing the adequacy of arterial oxygenation during helicopter flight in four healthy volunteers. Arterial PaO2 as measured by conventional blood gas analysis was compared with cjO2 at ground level, 5,000 feet, and 10,000 feet altitude. Mean PaO2 dropped significantly from 93.5 to 81.5 to 58.5 mm Hg, respectively (P less than 0.001, analysis of variance with repeated measures). Mean cjO2 also decreased significantly from 63.8 to 52.0 to 34.8 mm Hg, respectively (P less than 0.001, analysis of variance with repeated measures). Within individual subjects, cjO2 was an accurate predictor of PaO2 (P less than 0.001, multiple regression analysis). The relationship between cjO2 and PaO2 was linear with a regression coefficient of 1.147. The authors conclude that the transconjunctival O2 monitor may be useful for monitoring the adequacy of arterial oxygenation during helicopter flight in hemodynamically stable patients. The results of study also support the use of supplemental oxygen in all patients subjected to helicopter transport.