Eric S. Rountree

Evaluation of homogeneous electrocatalysts by cyclic voltammetry.

The pursuit of solar fuels has motivated extensive research on molecular electrocatalysts capable of evolving hydrogen from protic solutions, reducing CO2, and oxidizing water. Determining accurate figures of merit for these catalysts requires the careful and appropriate application of electroanalytical techniques. This Viewpoint first briefly presents the fundamentals of cyclic voltammetry and highlights practical experimental considerations before focusing on the application of cyclic voltammetry for the characterization of electrocatalysts. Key metrics for comparing catalysts, including the overpotential (η), potential for catalysis (E(cat)), observed rate constant (k(obs)), and potential-dependent turnover frequency, are discussed. The cyclic voltammetric responses for a general electrocatalytic one-electron reduction of a substrate are presented along with methods to extract figures of merit from these data. The extension of this analysis to more complex electrocatalytic schemes, such as those responsible for H2 evolution and CO2 reduction, is then discussed.

Electrochemical reduction of Brønsted acids by glassy carbon in acetonitrile-implications for electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution.

Molecular catalysts for electrochemically driven hydrogen evolution are often studied in acetonitrile with glassy carbon working electrodes and Brønsted acids. Surprisingly, little information is available regarding the potentials at which acids are directly reduced on glassy carbon. This work examines acid electroreduction in acetonitrile on glassy carbon electrodes by cyclic voltammetry. Reduction potentials, spanning a range exceeding 2 V, were found for 20 acids. The addition of 100 mM water was not found to shift the reduction potential of any acid studied, although current enhancement was observed for some acids. The data reported provides a guide for selecting acids to use in electrocatalysis experiments such that direct electrode reduction is avoided.

Potential-Dependent Electrocatalytic Pathways: Controlling Reactivity with pKa for Mechanistic Investigation of a Nickel-Based Hydrogen Evolution Catalyst.

A detailed mechanistic analysis is presented for the hydrogen evolution catalyst [Ni(P2(Ph)N2(Ph))2(CH2CN)][BF4]2 in acetonitrile (P2(Ph)N2(Ph) = 1,3,5,7-tetraphenyl-1,5-diaza-3,7-diphosphacyclooctane). This complex has a Ni(II/I) redox couple at −0.83 V and a Ni(I/0) redox couple at −1.03 V versus Fc(+/0). These two closely spaced redox events both promote proton reduction catalysis, each via a distinct mechanism: an electrochemical ECEC pathway and an EECC route. The EECC mechanism, operative at more negative potentials, was isolated through use of a weak acid (anilinium, pKa = 10.6 in CH3CN) to avert protonation of the singly reduced species. Electroanalytical methods and time-resolved spectroscopy were used to analyze the kinetics of the elementary steps of hydrogen evolution catalysis. The rate constant for the formation of a nickel(II)–hydride intermediate was determined via measurements of peak shift (k1 = 1.2 × 106 M(-1) s(-1)) and through foot-of-the-wave analysis (k1 = 6.5 × 106 M(-1) s(-1)). Reactivity of the isolated hydride with acid to release hydrogen and regenerate the nickel(II) complex was monitored by stopped-flow spectroscopy. Kinetics obtained from stopped-flow measurements are corroborated by current plateau analysis of the catalytic cyclic voltammograms. These kinetic data suggest the presence of an off-cycle intermediate in the reaction.

Reactivity of Proton Sources with a Nickel Hydride Complex in Acetonitrile: Implications for the Study of Fuel-Forming Catalysts

The reactivity of the nickel hydride complex [HNi(P2PhN2Ph)2]+ (P2PhN2Ph = 1,3,5,7-tetraphenyl-1,5-diaza-3,7-diphosphacyclooctane) with a variety of acids to form hydrogen in acetonitrile was evaluated using stopped-flow spectroscopy in order to gain a better understanding of how the proton source influences the reaction kinetics when evaluating fuel-forming catalysts in acetonitrile. This reaction is initiated by the rate-determining step in the catalytic cycle for the hydrogen-evolving catalyst [Ni(P2PhN2Ph)2]2+. Proton sources were evaluated with respect to pKa, homoconjugation, dimerization, heteroconjugation, and aggregation (for water). The effects of water and conjugate base were also studied. A linear free energy relationship between rate constant and pKa was revealed; rate constants increased with the magnitude of the homoconjugation constant for acids prone to homoconjugation, and second-order reactivity was observed for trifluoroacetic and trichloroacetic acid, suggesting dimerization. Upon the...

Identification of an Electrode-Adsorbed Intermediate in the Catalytic Hydrogen Evolution Mechanism of a Cobalt Dithiolene Complex

Analysis of a cobalt bis(dithiolate) complex reported to mediate hydrogen evolution under electrocatalytic conditions in acetonitrile revealed that the cobalt complex transforms into an electrode-adsorbed film upon addition of acid prior to application of a potential. Subsequent application of a reducing potential to the film results in desorption of the film and regeneration of the molecular cobalt complex in solution, suggesting that the adsorbed species is an intermediate in catalytic H2 evolution. The electroanalytical techniques used to examine the pathway by which H2 is generated, as well as the methods used to probe the electrode-adsorbed species, are discussed. Tentative mechanisms for catalytic H2 evolution via an electrode-adsorbed intermediate are proposed.

Switching between Stepwise and Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer Pathways in Tungsten Hydride Activation

Catalytic processes to generate (or oxidize) fuels such as hydrogen are underpinned by multiple proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) steps that are associated with the formation or activation of metal-hydride bonds. Fully understanding the detailed PCET mechanisms of metal hydride transformations holds promise for the rational design of energy-efficient catalysis. Here we investigate the detailed PCET mechanisms for the activation of the transition metal hydride complex CpW(CO)2(PMe3)H (Cp = cyclopentadienyl) using stopped-flow rapid mixing coupled with time-resolved optical spectroscopy. We reveal that all three limiting PCET pathways can be accessed by changing the free energy for elementary proton, electron, and proton-electron transfers through the choice of base and oxidant, with the concerted pathway occurring exclusively as a secondary parallel route. Through detailed kinetics analysis, we define free energy relationships for the kinetics of elementary reaction steps, which provide insight into the factors influencing reaction mechanism. Rate constants for proton transfer processes in the limiting stepwise pathways reveal a large reorganization energy associated with protonation/deprotonation of the metal center (λ = 1.59 eV) and suggest that sluggish proton transfer kinetics hinder access to a concerted route. Rate constants for concerted PCET indicate that the concerted routes are asynchronous. Additionally, through quantification of the relative contributions of parallel stepwise and concerted mechanisms toward net product formation, the influence of various reaction parameters on reactivity are identified. This work underscores the importance of understanding the PCET mechanism for controlling metal hydride reactivity, which could lead to superior catalyst design for fuel production and oxidation.