Estelle Gaigher

Exploring the development of conceptual understanding through structured problem-solving in Physics

A study on the effect of a structured problem‐solving strategy on problem‐solving skills and conceptual understanding of physics was undertaken with 189 students in 16 disadvantaged South African schools. This paper focuses on the development of conceptual understanding. New instruments, namely a solutions map and a conceptual index, are introduced to assess conceptual understanding demonstrated in students’ written solutions to examination problems. The process of the development of conceptual understanding is then explored within the framework of Greeno’s model of scientific problem‐solving and reasoning. It was found that students who had been exposed to the structured problem‐solving strategy demonstrated better conceptual understanding of physics and tended to adopt a conceptual approach to problem‐solving.

Confidence versus performance as an indicator of the presence of alternative conceptions and inadequate problem-solving skills in mechanics

This study investigated the use of performance–confidence relationships to signal the presence of alternative conceptions and inadequate problem‐solving skills in mechanics. A group of 33 students entering physics at a South African university participated in the project. The test instrument consisted of 20 items derived from existing standardised tests from literature, each of which was followed by a self‐reported measure of confidence of students in the correctness of their answers. Data collected for this study included students’ responses to multiple‐choice questions and open‐ended explanations for their chosen answers. Fixed response physics and confidence data were logarithmically transformed according to the Rasch model to linear measures of performance and confidence. The free response explanations were carefully analysed for accuracy of conceptual understanding. Comparison of these results with raw score data and transformed measures of performance and confidence allowed a re‐evaluation of the model developed by Hasan, Bagayoko, and Kelley in 1999 for the detection of alternative conceptions in mechanics. Application of this model to raw score data leads to inaccurate conclusions. However, application of the Hasan hypothesis to transformed measures of performance and confidence resulted in the accurate identification of items plagued by alternative conceptions. This approach also holds promise for the differentiation between over‐confidence due to alternative conceptions or due to inadequate problem‐solving skills. It could become a valuable tool for instructional design in mechanics.

The effect of a structured problem solving strategy on performance in physics in disadvantaged South African schools

Abstract A quasi-experimental study was undertaken to extend first-world research on physics problem solving into disadvantaged South African classrooms. Sixteen urban high schools, involving 189 learners, participated in the study, investigating the effect of a structured problem solving strategy on performance and conceptual understanding. This article focuses on the enhancement of problem solving performance in classroom tests and the midyear examination. The treatment group outperformed the control group by 8% in the midyear examination. Using ANOVA, this increased average score was statistically significant at the.001 level, indicating enhanced problem solving skills. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that the strategy was not transferred successfully to topics studied prior to implementation of the problem solving strategy. A theory is presented to explain the results in terms of the co-development of conceptual understanding and problem solving skill.

Development of a model of effectiveness in science education to explore differential science performance : a case of South Africa

Abstract This paper reports on secondary analysis of TIMSS 2003 data, based on a sound conceptual model, aiming to explain differential science achievement in South Africa from the perspective of educational effectiveness research. The conceptual framework was developed by refining existing school effectiveness models and including factors related to science achievement. The refined model integrated psychological and sociological aspects and reflected the multilevel-structure of schools. The model added resources and climate to the quality factors at class/school level. It was applied to the South African results of TIMSS 2003. Data from the student (n=8,952), teacher (n=255) and school questionnaires (n=255) were analysed in conjunction with achievement data by means of factor, reliability, correlation and multilevel analysis. The multilevel analysis revealed that at student level the strongest predictor of science achievement is attitude towards science. At classroom/school level, the strongest predictors are resource-and climate-related factors such as the safety in school, physical resources and class size. Factors at class/school level influenced performance more than student level factors with 59% of the total variance in science achievement occurring at class/school level. Such results indicate that the model developed is well suited to science education in developing countries.

Exploring the use of Technology textbooks in medium- and well-resourced school contexts in South Africa

Abstract This study explored how Technology teachers in medium- and well-resourced schools use commercially prepared textbooks in their classrooms. A qualitative-interpretive design was used with a purposively selected sample of four schools from a city in the Gauteng province, South Africa. Data were analysed according to the conceptual framework of didactical transposition, focusing on textbook content, activities, context and teaching strategies. It was found that teachers in well-resourced schools adapt textbooks by adding content, thus expecting a higher standard from textbook content, and preferring learners to work individually, while teachers in medium-resourced schools follow textbooks without adapting them, therefore accepting the standard set by the textbooks. It is recommended that teachers in both contexts be assisted by specialists to interpret the curriculum so as to be sure how they are expected to use textbooks to improve their classroom practices.