Eviatar Natan

Structural evolution of p53, p63, and p73: Implication for heterotetramer formation

Oligomerization of members of the p53 family of transcription factors (p53, p63, and p73) is essential for their distinct functions in cell-cycle control and development. To elucidate the molecular basis for tetramer formation of the various family members, we solved the crystal structure of the human p73 tetramerization domain (residues 351–399). Similarly to the canonical p53 tetramer, p73 forms a tetramer with D2 symmetry that can be described as a dimer of dimers. The most striking difference between the p53 and p73 tetramerization domain is the presence of an additional C-terminal helix in p73. This helix, which is conserved in p63, is essential for stabilizing the overall architecture of the tetramer, as evidenced by the different oligomeric structures observed for a shortened variant lacking this helix. The helices act as clamps, wrapping around the neighboring dimer and holding it in place. In addition, we show by mass spectrometry that the tetramerization domains of p63 and p73, but not p53, fully exchange, with different mixed tetramers present at equilibrium, albeit at a relatively slow rate. Taken together, these data provide intriguing insights into the divergent evolution of the oligomerization domain within the p53 family, from the ancestral p63/p73-like protein toward smaller, less promiscuous monomeric building blocks in human p53, allowing functional separation of the p53 pathway from that of its family members.

Intrinsically Disordered p53 and Its Complexes Populate Compact Conformations in the Gas Phase

Spontaneous shrinking: the intrinsically disordered tumor suppressor protein p53 was analyzed by using a combination of ion mobility mass spectrometry and molecular dynamics simulations. Structured p53 subdomains retain their overall topology upon transfer into the gas phase. When intrinsically disordered segments are introduced into the protein sequence, however, the complex spontaneously collapses in the gas phase to a compact conformation.

Acetylation of lysine 120 of p53 endows DNA-binding specificity at effective physiological salt concentration

Lys120 in the DNA-binding domain (DBD) of p53 becomes acetylated in response to DNA damage. But, the role and effects of acetylation are obscure. We prepared p53 specifically acetylated at Lys120, AcK120p53, by in vivo incorporation of acetylated lysine to study biophysical and structural consequences of acetylation that may shed light on its biological role. Acetylation had no affect on the overall crystal structure of the DBD at 1.9-Å resolution, but significantly altered the effects of salt concentration on specificity of DNA binding. p53 binds DNA randomly in vitro at effective physiological salt concentration and does not bind specifically to DNA or distinguish among its different response elements until higher salt concentrations. But, on acetylation, AcK120p53 exhibited specific DNA binding and discriminated among response elements at effective physiological salt concentration. AcK120p53 and p53 had the highest affinity to the same DNA sequence, although acetylation reduced the importance of the consensus C and G at positions 4 and 7, respectively. Mass spectrometry of p53 and AcK120p53 DBDs bound to DNA showed they preferentially segregated into complexes that were either DNA(p53DBD)4 or DNA(AcK120DBD)4, indicating that the different DBDs prefer different quaternary structures. These results are consistent with electron microscopy observations that p53 binds to nonspecific DNA in different, relaxed, quaternary states from those bound to specific sequences. Evidence is accumulating that p53 can be sequestered by random DNA, and target search requires acetylation of Lys120 and/or interaction with other factors to impose specificity of binding via modulating changes in quaternary structure.

The emergence of protein complexes: quaternary structure, dynamics and allostery

All proteins require physical interactions with other proteins in order to perform their functions. Most of them oligomerize into homomers, and a vast majority of these homomers interact with other proteins, at least part of the time, forming transient or obligate heteromers. In the present paper, we review the structural, biophysical and evolutionary aspects of these protein interactions. We discuss how protein function and stability benefit from oligomerization, as well as evolutionary pathways by which oligomers emerge, mostly from the perspective of homomers. Finally, we emphasize the specificities of heteromeric complexes and their structure and evolution. We also discuss two analytical approaches increasingly being used to study protein structures as well as their interactions. First, we review the use of the biological networks and graph theory for analysis of protein interactions and structure. Secondly, we discuss recent advances in techniques for detecting correlated mutations, with the emphasis on their role in identifying pathways of allosteric communication.

Ultraslow oligomerization equilibria of p53 and its implications.

The tumor suppressor p53 is in equilibrium at cellular concentrations between dimers and tetramers. Oncogenic mutant p53 (mut) exerts a dominant-negative effect on co-expression of p53 wild-type (wt) and mut alleles in cancer cells. It is believed that wt and mut form hetero-tetramers of attenuated activity, via their tetramerization domains. Using electrospray mass spectrometry on isotopically labeled samples, we measured directly the composition and rates of formation of p53 complexes in the presence and absence of response element DNA. The dissociation of tetramers was unexpectedly very slow (t1/2 = 40 min) at 37 °C, matched by slow association of dimers, which is approximately four times longer than the half-life of spontaneous denaturation of wt p53. On mixing wt tetramers with the oncogenic contact mutant R273H of low DNA affinity, we observed the same slow formation of only wt4, wt2mut2, and mut4, in the ratio 1:2:1, on a cellular time scale. On mixing wt and mut with response element DNAs P21 and BAX, we observed only the complexes wt4.DNA, wt2mut2.DNA, and mut4.DNA, with relative dissociation constants 1:4:71 and 1:13:85, respectively, accounting for the dominant-negative effect by weakened affinity. p53 dimers assemble rapidly to tetramers on binding to response element DNA, initiated by the p53 DNA binding domains. The slow oligomerization of free p53, competing with spontaneous denaturation, has implications for the possible regulation of p53 by binding proteins and DNA that affect tetramerization kinetics as well as equilibria.

Interaction of the P53 DNA-Binding Domain with its N-Terminal Extension Modulates the Stability of the P53 Tetramer.

The tetrameric tumor suppressor p53 plays a pivotal role in the control of the cell cycle and provides a paradigm for an emerging class of oligomeric, multidomain proteins with structured and intrinsically disordered regions. Many of its biophysical and functional properties have been extrapolated from truncated variants, yet the exact structural and functional role of certain segments of the protein is unclear. We found from NMR and X-ray crystallography that the DNA-binding domain (DBD) of human p53, usually defined as residues 94–292, extends beyond these domain boundaries. Trp91, in the hinge region between the disordered proline-rich N-terminal domain and the DBD, folds back onto the latter and has a cation–π interaction with Arg174. These additional interactions increase the melting temperature of the DBD by up to 2 °C and inhibit aggregation of the p53 tetramer. They also modulate the dissociation of the p53 tetramer. The absence of the Trp91/Arg174 packing presumably allows nonnative DBD–DBD interactions that both nucleate aggregation and stabilize the interface. These data have important implications for studies of multidomain proteins in general, highlighting the fact that weak ordered–disordered domain interactions can modulate the properties of proteins of complex structure.

Structure and Kinetic Stability of the p63 Tetramerization Domain

The p53 family of transcription factors—comprising p53, p63 and p73—plays an important role in tumor prevention and development. Essential to their function is the formation of tetramers, allowing cooperative binding to their DNA response elements. We solved crystal structures of the human p63 tetramerization domain, showing that p63 forms a dimer of dimers with D2 symmetry composed of highly intertwined monomers. The primary dimers are formed via an intramolecular β-sheet and hydrophobic helix packing (H1), a hallmark of all p53 family members. Like p73, but unlike p53, p63 requires a second helix (H2) to stabilize the architecture of the tetramer. In order to investigate the impact of structural differences on tetramer stability, we measured the subunit exchange reaction of p53 family homotetramers by nanoflow electrospray mass spectrometry. There were differences in both the kinetics and the pattern of the exchange reaction, with the p53 and p63 tetramers exhibiting much faster exchange kinetics than p73. The structural similarity between p63 and p73 rationalizes previous observations that p63 and p73 form mixed tetramers, and the kinetic data reveal the dissociation of the p73 homotetramers as the rate-limiting step for heterotetramer formation. Differential stability of the tetramers may play an important role in the cross talk between different isoforms and regulation of p53, p63 and p73 function in the cell cycle.

Regulation, evolution and consequences of cotranslational protein complex assembly

Most proteins assemble into complexes, which are involved in almost all cellular processes. Thus it is crucial for cell viability that mechanisms for correct assembly exist. The timing of assembly plays a key role in determining the fate of the protein: if the protein is allowed to diffuse into the crowded cellular milieu, it runs the risk of forming non-specific interactions, potentially leading to aggregation or other deleterious outcomes. It is therefore expected that strong regulatory mechanisms should exist to ensure efficient assembly. In this review we discuss the cotranslational assembly of protein complexes and discuss how it occurs, ways in which it is regulated, potential disadvantages of cotranslational interactions between proteins and the implications for the inheritance of dominant-negative genetic disorders.

The novel p53 isoform ''delta p53'' is a misfolded protein and does not bind the p21 promoter site

The tumor suppressor p53 can be expressed as different isoforms because of promoter selection and mRNA editing. One isoform, “delta p53” (Δp53), results from what would be an unusual alternative splicing of exons 7/8 of the p53 gene, conserving the reading frame and generating a novel protein with proposed transcriptional activity essential for the intra S‐phase checkpoint. Here, we show that the deletion of the 66 residues that correspond to strand β10 and the C‐terminal helix of the core domain and the interconnecting linker to the tetramerization domain occurring in the Δp53 isoform leads to a misfolded and unstable protein, prone to form soluble aggregates, which does not bind the p21 promoter site. The complex of coexpressed Δp53 and flp53 is soluble in vitro and binds poorly to DNA. Our results provide a structural explanation for the dominant‐negative effect of Δp53 and its lack of transcriptional activity.

Cotranslational protein assembly imposes evolutionary constraints on homomeric proteins

Cotranslational protein folding can facilitate rapid formation of functional structures. However, it can also cause premature assembly of protein complexes, if two interacting nascent chains are in close proximity. By analyzing known protein structures, we show that homomeric protein contacts are enriched toward the C termini of polypeptide chains across diverse proteomes. We hypothesize that this is the result of evolutionary constraints for folding to occur before assembly. Using high-throughput imaging of protein homomers in Escherichia coli and engineered protein constructs with N- and C-terminal oligomerization domains, we show that, indeed, proteins with C-terminal homomeric interface residues consistently assemble more efficiently than those with N-terminal interface residues. Using in vivo, in vitro and in silico experiments, we identify features that govern successful assembly of homomers, which have implications for protein design and expression optimization.In vivo, in vitro and in silico experiments demonstrate that interface residues of homomeric proteins are enriched toward protein C termini to avoid premature assembly and aggregation.