Fabian Runge

Identity of the downy mildew pathogens of basil, coleus, and sage with implications for quarantine measures

The downy mildew pathogen of basil (Ocimum spp.) has caused considerable damage throughout the past five years, and an end to the epidemics is not in sight. The downy mildew of coleus (Solenostemon spp.) is just emerging and here we report that it was very recently introduced into Germany. Although it has been recognised that these pathogens are a major threat, the identity of the pathogens is still unresolved, and so it is difficult to devise quarantine measures against them. Using morphological comparison and molecular phylogenetic reconstructions we confirmed in this study that the downy mildews of basil and coleus are unrelated to Peronospora lamii, which is a common pathogen of the weed Lamium purpureum. In addition, we conclude by the investigation of the type specimen of P. swingleii and downy mildew specimens on Salvia officinalis that the newly occurring pathogens are not identical to P. swingleii on Salvia reflexa. The taxonomy of the downy mildew pathogens of hosts from the Lamiaceae and, in particular, from the tribes Mentheae and Elsholtzieae, is discussed, and a new species is described to accommodate the downy mildew pathogen of basil and coleus, which is the first downy mildew pathogen known to be parasitic to hosts of the tribe Ocimeae.

Phylogenetic investigations in the genus Pseudoperonospora reveal overlooked species and cryptic diversity in the P. cubensis species cluster

Pseudoperonospora cubensis is one of the most devastating diseases of cucurbitaceous crops. The pathogen has a worldwide distribution and occurs in all major cucurbit growing areas. It had been noticed for the first time at the end of the 19th century, but it became a globally severe disease as recently as 1984 in Europe and 2004 in North America. Despite its economic importance, species concepts in Pseudoperonospora are debated. Here, we report that the genus Pseudoperonospora contains cryptic species distinct from the currently accepted ones. Pseudoperonospora on Celtis is split into two phylogenetic lineages and Pseudoperonospora humuli is confirmed as a species distinct from the Cucurbitaceae-infecting lineages. A cryptic species occupying a basal position within the Pseudoperonospora cubensis complex is revealed to be present on Humulus japonicus, thus providing evidence that the host jump that gave rise to Pseudoperonospora cubensis likely occurred from hops. Notably, Cucurbitaceae infecting pathogens are present in two cryptic sister species or subspecies. Clade 1 contains primarily specimens from North America and likely represents Pseudoperonospora cubensis s.str.. Pre-epidemic isolates in clade 2 originate from Japan and Korea, suggesting this cryptic species or subspecies is indigenous to East Asia. Recent samples of this lineage from epidemics in Europe and the United States cluster together with clade 2. It thus seems possible that this lineage is associated with the recent severe epidemics of cucurbit downy mildew and is now naturalised in North America and Europe.

Gene Loss Rather Than Gene Gain Is Associated with a Host Jump from Monocots to Dicots in the Smut Fungus Melanopsichium pennsylvanicum

Smut fungi are well-suited to investigate the ecology and evolution of plant pathogens, as they are strictly biotrophic, yet cultivable on media. Here we report the genome sequence of Melanopsichium pennsylvanicum, closely related to Ustilago maydis and other Poaceae-infecting smuts, but parasitic to a dicot plant. To explore the evolutionary patterns resulting from host adaptation after this huge host jump, the genome of Me. pennsylvanicum was sequenced and compared with the genomes of U. maydis, Sporisorium reilianum, and U. hordei. Although all four genomes had a similar completeness in CEGMA (Core Eukaryotic Genes Mapping Approach) analysis, gene absence was highest in Me. pennsylvanicum, and most pronounced in putative secreted proteins, which are often considered as effector candidates. In contrast, the amount of private genes was similar among the species, highlighting that gene loss rather than gene gain is the hallmark of adaptation after the host jump to the dicot host. Our analyses revealed a trend of putative effectors to be next to another putative effector, but the majority of these are not in clusters and thus the focus on pathogenicity clusters might not be appropriate for all smut genomes. Positive selection studies revealed that Me. pennsylvanicum has the highest number and proportion of genes under positive selection. In general, putative effectors showed a higher proportion of positively selected genes than noneffector candidates. The 248 putative secreted effectors found in all four smut genomes might constitute a core set needed for pathogenicity, whereas those 92 that are found in all grass-parasitic smuts but have no ortholog in Me. pennsylvanicum might constitute a set of effectors important for successful colonization of grass hosts.

The genetic structure of Pseudoperonospora cubensis populations

Pseudoperonospora cubensis is a destructive foliar pathogen of economically important cucurbitaceous crops in the United States and worldwide. In this study, we investigated the genetic structure of 465 P. cubensis isolates from three continents, 13 countries, 19 states of the United States, and five host species using five nuclear and two mitochondrial loci. Bayesian clustering resolved six genetic clusters and suggested some population structure by geographic origin and host, because some clusters occurred more or less frequently in particular categories. All of the genetic clusters were present in the sampling from North America and Europe. Differences in cluster occurrence were observed by country and state. Isolates from cucumber had different cluster composition and lower genetic diversity than isolates from other cucurbits. Because genetic structuring was detected, isolates that represent the genetic variation in P. cubensis should be used when developing diagnostic tools, fungicides, and resistant host varieties. Although this study provides an initial map of global population structure of P. cubensis, future genotyping of isolates could reveal population structure within specific geographic regions, across a wider range of hosts, or during different time points during the growing season.

The Genetic Structure of Pseudoperonospora cubensis Populations

Pseudoperonospora cubensis is a destructive foliar pathogen of economically important cucurbitaceous crops in the United States and worldwide. In this study, we investigated the genetic structure of 465 P. cubensis isolates from three continents, 13 countries, 19 states of the United States, and five host species using five nuclear and two mitochondrial loci. Bayesian clustering resolved six genetic clusters and suggested some population structure by geographic origin and host, because some clusters occurred more or less frequently in particular categories. All of the genetic clusters were present in the sampling from North America and Europe. Differences in cluster occurrence were observed by country and state. Isolates from cucumber had different cluster composition and lower genetic diversity than isolates from other cucurbits. Because genetic structuring was detected, isolates that represent the genetic variation in P. cubensis should be used when developing diagnostic tools, fungicides, and resistant host varieties. Although this study provides an initial map of global population structure of P. cubensis, future genotyping of isolates could reveal population structure within specific geographic regions, across a wider range of hosts, or during different time points during the growing season.

A potential perennial host for Pseudoperonospora cubensis in temperate regions

Pseudoperonospora cubensis causes great losses in cucurbitaceous crops worldwide. In cool temperate climates of northern Europe or North America overwintering as active mycelium is not possible, because all hosts so far reported there are summer annuals. Oospores have not yet been found in these regions under field conditions. The only perennial member of the Cucurbitaceae found naturally in central and northern Europe is Bryonia dioica. To date this plant has not been recorded as a host for downy mildews, but our infection trials demonstrate that P. cubensis is able to infest this plant. Amplification and sequencing of the ITS rDNA confirmed the observed downy mildew disease on B. dioica as P. cubensis. From these findings, the possibility that P. cubensis may be able to overwinter on this perennial host cannot be excluded. Whether or not B. dioica plays a part in the epidemology of P. cubensis in Europe requires evaluation by further studies.

The inclusion of downy mildews in a multi-locus-dataset and its reanalysis reveals a high degree of paraphyly in Phytophthora.

Pathogens belonging to the Oomycota, a group of heterokont, fungal-like organisms, are amongst the most notorious pathogens in agriculture. In particular, the obligate biotrophic downy mildews and the hemibiotrophic members of the genus Phytophthora are responsible for a huge variety of destructive diseases, including sudden oak death caused by P. ramorum, potato late blight caused by P. infestans, cucurbit downy mildew caused by Pseudoperonospora cubensis, and grape downy mildew caused by Plasmopara viticola. About 800 species of downy mildews and roughly 100 species of Phytophthora are currently accepted, and recent studies have revealed that these groups are closely related. However, the degree to which Phytophthora is paraphyletic and where exactly the downy mildews insert into this genus in relation to other clades could not be inferred with certainty to date. Here we present a molecular phylogeny encompassing all clades of Phytophthora as represented in a multi-locus dataset and two representatives of the monophyletic downy mildews from divergent genera. Our results demonstrate that Phytophthora is at least six times paraphyletic with respect to the downy mildews. The downy mildew representatives are consistently nested within clade 4 (contains Phytophthora palmivora), which is placed sister to clade 1 (contains Phytophthora infestans). This finding would either necessitate placing all downy mildews and Phytopthora species in a single genus, either under the oldest generic name Peronospora or by conservation the later name Phytophthora, or the description of at least six new genera within Phytophthora. The complications of both options are discussed, and it is concluded that the latter is preferable, as it warrants fewer name changes and is more practical.

Phylogenetic investigations in the downy mildew genus Bremia reveal several distinct lineages and a species with a presumably exceptional wide host range

Bremia lactucae is one of the most devastating and widespread pathogens in lettuce production worldwide. Despite its economical importance, uncertainty prevails about the species delimitation in the genus Bremia. Commonly, Bremia is considered to be monotypic, containing only Bremia lactucae, while taxonomists have described additional species, and molecular phylogenetic studies have shown significant sequence divergence between accessions from different hosts. Here, we report that several previously described species are genetically highly distinct from Bremia lactucae parasitic to Lactuca sativa. These include Bremia lapsanae, Bremia sonchicola, and Bremia taraxaci. In addition to these host-specific species, a plurivorous species is revealed, which infects hosts from three different tribes in the Asteraceae subfamilies Asteroideae and Carduoideae. The broad host range of clade 1 is exceptional for downy mildews and only paralleled by Pseudoperonospora cubensis, which infects a broad range of Cucurbitaceae. The taxonomic status of Bremia cirsii and of Bremia centaureae remains unresolved, as the accessions from Cirsium and Centaurea, respectively, did not form a monophylum but were partly contained in the plurivorous clade 1. Bremia lactucae was found to be restricted to Lactuca sativa and Lactuca serriola. Thus, it can be assumed that Bremia infections on weeds apart from Lactuca species do not pose a significant risk for lettuce production. However, it is unlikely that breeding resistance genes from Lactuca serriola into Lactuca sativa will result in durable resistance of lettuce to downy mildew disease, because the current study provides additional evidence that Bremia accessions from both hosts form a population continuum.

Reevaluation of Host Specificity of the Closely Related Species Pseudoperonospora humuli and P. cubensis

Pseudoperonospora cubensis causes some of the most devastating diseases of cucurbitaceous crops, while P. humuli is an important pathogen of hop (Cannabaceae). Although parasitic to different Angiosperm orders, these pathogens are highly similar, both in morphology and based on molecular comparisons. Considering the close relationship of P. humuli and P. cubensis, it was hypothesized that cross infectivity of the pathogens between their optimum hosts might be possible. Two strains of P. humuli and one of P. cubensis used in this study were able to reproduce on the two wild cucurbit relatives Bryonia dioica and Sicyos angulatus. Interestingly, limited infectivity of the P. cubensis strain to hop was also observed, and the P. humuli strain was also able to infest Cucumis sativus. The cross infections were verified by comparing the nuclear ribosomal-internal transcribed spacer sequences of newly produced sporangiophores from the different hosts. Morphologically the two pathogens could be distinguished by statistical analyses on their original hosts but these differences diminished on some alternate hosts. The ability of P. cubensis to infest the perennial Bryonia dioica and Humulus lupulus might offer a limited possibility for overwintering in temperate regions and needs to be evaluated in future studies. The ability of P. humuli to complete its life cycle on all the tested cucurbits provides evidence that the host jump across orders may continue and points to the high virulence potential of this pathogen.

Host matrix has major impact on the morphology of Pseudoperonospora cubensis

Oomycetes contain some of the economically most important pathogens of flowering plants. Most have a rather narrow host range, often being restricted to single host species. In downy mildews and other obligate biotrophic plant parasites, like powdery mildews and rusts, delimitating species on grounds of morphological characteristics is often hardly possible and thus often based on only subtle differences. This has led to the widespread application of a broad species concept for these organisms. Consequently, despite the fact that morphological differences were reported for Pseudoperonospora cubensis from different host species, the corresponding new pathogen species were not accepted as being independent, and the host range of Pseudoperonospora cubensis is reported to encompass more than 50 host species in the Cucurbitaceae in temperate to tropical climates. However, recent studies have reported narrow host ranges for other downy mildew genera and advocated a narrow species concept. Here, we report successful colonisation of five different tribes of the Cucurbitaceae by a strain of Pseudoperonospora cubensis and demonstrate that the host matrix has a major impact on the morphology of the pathogen. On the basis of five morphological criteria significant differences could be found for all hosts. These differences were more pronounced in phylogenetically unrelated than in related hosts. Our results provide evidence for a broad host range of Pseudoperonospora cubensis and demonstrate that species delimitation based on morphological characters is not feasible in Pseudoperonospora on Cucurbitaceae. Also in other biotrophic plant pathogens, the situation could be similar, thus necessitating thorough morphological, molecular phylogenetic and cross inoculation experiments for species recognition.