Fanny M. Ebling

Tolerogenic Treatment of Lupus Mice with Consensus Peptide Induces Foxp3-Expressing, Apoptosis-Resistant, TGFβ-Secreting CD8+ T Cell Suppressors

Lupus-prone (NZB × NZW)F1 mice spontaneously develop elevated titers of anti-DNA Abs that contain T cell determinants in their VH regions. We have previously shown that tolerization with an artificial peptide based on these T cell determinants (pConsensus (pCons)) can block production of anti-DNA Abs and prolong survival of the mice. In this study, we show that this protection depends in part on the generation of peripheral TGFβ- and Foxp3-expressing inhibitory CD8+ (Ti) cells. These CD8+ Ti cells suppress anti-DNA IgG production both in vitro and in vivo and require up-regulated expression of both Foxp3 and TGFβ to exert their suppressive function, as indicated by microarray analyses, small interfering RNA inhibition studies, and blocking experiments. Additionally, CD8+ Ti cells from pCons-tolerized mice were longer-lived suppressors that up-regulated expression of Bcl-2 and were more resistant to apoptosis than similar cells from naive mice. These data indicate that clinical suppression of autoimmunity after administration of pCons depends in part on the generation of CD8+ Ti cells that suppress secretion of anti-DNA Ig using mechanisms that include Foxp3, TGFβ, and resistance to apoptosis.

Structural characteristics of the variable regions of immunoglobulin genes encoding a pathogenic autoantibody in murine lupus.

We have studied several monoclonal anti-double-stranded (ds) DNA antibodies for their ability to accelerate lupus nephritis in young NZB X NZW F1 female mice and to induce it in BALB/c mice. Two identified as pathogens in both strains have characteristics previously associated with nephritogenicity: expression of IgG2a isotype and IdGN2 idiotype. Both pathogenic antibodies used the combination of genes from the VHJ558 and VK9 subfamilies. Two weak pathogens failed to accelerate nephritis in young BW mice, but induced lupus nephritis in BALB/c mice. They both express IdGN2; one is cationic and an IgG3, the other is an IgG2a. Additional MAbs (some IgG2a, one IdGN2-positive) did not accelerate or induce nephritis. We have cloned and sequenced the variable regions of the immunoglobulin genes of one pathogenic autoantibody. No unique V, D, or J gene segments and no evidence of unusual mechanisms in generating diversity were used to construct this antibody. These data argue against use of unique abnormal Ig genes by systemic lupus erythematosus individuals to construct pathogenic autoantibody subsets. Instead, the major abnormality may be immunoregulatory.

Treatment with a consensus peptide based on amino acid sequences in autoantibodies prevents T cell activation by autoantigens and delays disease onset in murine lupus.

OBJECTIVE To test the hypothesis that an artificial peptide, based on an algorithm describing T cell stimulatory sequences from the VH regions of murine IgG antibodies to DNA, is an effective tolerogen in vivo in the (NZB/NZW)F1 (BWF1) mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus. METHODS Using proliferative T cell responses to 439 Ig peptides, an algorithm was constructed that describes the amino acid sequences likely to stimulate BWF1 T cells. Stimulatory (pConsensus [pCONS]) or nonstimulatory (pNegative [pNEG]) peptides were synthesized. Groups of 10-week-old (healthy) or 20-week-old (diseased) BWF1 mice received monthly intravenous injections of 1,000 microg of peptide or saline. Ex vivo splenic T cell responses and in vivo clinical effects were measured. RESULTS Tolerance was induced by pCONS, but not by pNEG, with respect to ex vivo T cell proliferation and T cell help for antibodies to DNA. T cell help for IgG anti-DNA was impaired not only after T cell stimulation by pCONS but also after stimulation by some peptides from nucleosomal and Ro antigens. Treatment with pCONS significantly delayed the onset of nephritis and inhibited increases in the plasma levels of total IgG, IgG antibodies to DNA, nucleosome, cardiolipin, interferon-gamma, and interleukin-4. In contrast, antibody responses to an exogenous antigen were not impaired. Survival was significantly prolonged in both healthy and diseased mice treated with pCONS. CONCLUSION Induction of immune tolerance in response to treatment with pCONS in autoreactive T cell helper populations is highly effective in delaying the appearance of multiple autoantibodies, cytokine increases, and nephritis in BWF1 mice, and dramatically prolongs survival. A striking effect is the ability of the peptide to tolerize T cell help for anti-DNA that is induced by multiple, structurally unrelated self antigens.

Ig-reactive CD4+CD25+ T cells from tolerized (New Zealand Black x New Zealand White)F1 mice suppress in vitro production of antibodies to DNA.

We have recently shown that tolerogenic administration of an artificial peptide (pConsensus) that is based on sequences within the VH regions of several murine anti-dsDNA Ig delays appearance of autoantibodies in female (New Zealand Black (NZB) × New Zealand White (NZW))F1 (NZB/W F1) mice and significantly prolongs their survival. The aim of this study was to characterize the T cell population(s) involved in pConsensus-induced down-regulation of autoimmune responses in tolerized NZB/W F1 mice. Using MHC class II dimers loaded with tolerogenic peptide, we found that pCons favored expansion of peptide-reactive CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells (TR) that inhibited in vitro production of anti-dsDNA Ab-forming cells. Suppression by TR was abrogated by the presence in culture of Ab to glucocorticoid-induced TNFR family member 18 or to TGFβ latency-associated protein. These findings suggest possible relevance of Ag specificity in the mechanism of TR-mediated immune tolerance to Ig-derived peptides in NZB/W F1 mice.

Immune tolerance to autoantibody-derived peptides delays development of autoimmunity in murine lupus.

Mechanisms that initiate and maintain autoantibody (autoAb) production in individuals with autoimmune diseases like SLE are poorly understood. Inadequate suppression of autoreactive T cells and/or unusual activation of T and B cells may underlie the persistence of pathogenic autoAbs in lupus. Here, we examine the possibility that in mice with lupus, autoAb molecules may be upregulating their own production by activating self-reactive T cells via their own processed peptides; downregulation of this circuit may decrease autoAb production and delay the development of lupus. We found that before the onset of clinical disease, lupus-prone (NZB/NZW) F1 [BWF1] (but not MHC-matched nonautoimmune mice) developed spontaneous T cell autoimmunity to peptides from variable regions of heavy chains (VH) of syngeneic anti-DNA mAbs but not to peptides from the VH region of an mAb to an exogenous antigen. Tolerizing young BWF1 mice with intravenous injections of autoAb-derived determinants substantially delayed development of anti-DNA antibodies and nephritis and prolonged survival. Thus, in such an autoAb-mediated disease, the presence of autoreactive T cells against VH region determinants of autoAbs may represent an important mechanism involved in the regulation of autoimmunity. Our findings show that tolerizing such autoreactive T cells can postpone the development of an autoimmune disease like SLE.

Suppression of NZB/NZW murine nephritis by administration of a syngeneic monoclonal antibody to DNA. Possible role of anti-idiotypic antibodies.

Suppression of circulating antibodies to double-stranded DNA was achieved in NZB/NZW f1 female mice by repeated administration of an IgG2a monoclonal antibody to DNA. Deaths from nephritis were delayed; glomerular deposition of IgG and of the cationic IgG DNA antibodies characteristic of murine lupus nephritis were diminished. Quantities of circulating antibodies to single-stranded DNA were not reduced compared with untreated or IgG myeloma-treated control mice. Antibodies directed against the monoclonal anti-DNA appeared in the circulation of treated mice after three inoculations of the idiotype. Those antibodies did not react with another monoclonal anti-DNA of the same allotype. One monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody was obtained in hybridoma cultures derived from a spleen of a treated mouse. Cross-reactive or common idiotypes were found in 30-50% of NZB/NZW f1 sera and monoclonal DNA antibodies. Deletions of portions of the spectrotype of antibodies to DNA were found in sera containing anti-idiotypic antibodies, suggesting suppression of clones producing antibodies with isoelectric points similar to that of the immunizing idiotype. Deletions of some of the anti-idiotypic antibodies also occurred as the mice aged. Rheumatoid factors were not detectable in any sera. Therefore, administration of an antibody to DNA bearing an idiotype occurring with high frequency in NZB/NZW f1 females resulted in relatively specific suppression of the antibody response to double-stranded DNA, as well as suppression of nephritis. Reduction of anti-DNA synthesis by anti-idiotypic antibodies may have been an important suppressive mechanism. Experiments are in progress to test this hypothesis.

CD8+ T cell-mediated suppression of autoimmunity in a murine lupus model of peptide-induced immune tolerance depends on Foxp3 expression.

Systemic lupus erythematosus is an autoimmune disease caused by autoantibodies, including IgG anti-DNA. New Zealand Black/New Zealand White F1 female mice, a model of spontaneous polygenic systemic lupus erythematosus, tolerized with an artificial peptide (pConsensus) based on anti-DNA IgG sequences containing MHC class I and class II T cell determinants, develop regulatory CD4+CD25+ T cells and CD8+ inhibitory T cells (CD8+ Ti), both of which suppress autoantibody production. CD8+ Ti inhibit primarily via secretion of TGF-β. In the present study, we show that the inhibitory function of CD8+ T cells from tolerized mice is sustained for up to 8 wk and at all times depends on expression of Foxp3. Both CD28-positive and CD28-negative CD8+ T cells contain inhibitory cells, but the expression of mRNA for Foxp3 and for TGF-β is higher and lasts longer in the CD28− subset. In vitro addition of TGF-β (in the presence of IL-2) induces Foxp3 expression in a dose-response manner. Gene inhibition or blockade with small interfering RNA of Foxp3 abrogates the ability of the CD8+ Ti to inhibit anti-DNA production and the proliferation of CD4+ Th cells. Moreover, a significant correlation between expression of Foxp3 and ability of CD8+ Ti to secrete TGF-β is observed. Therefore, CD8+ Ti in this system of tolerance are similar to CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells in their dependence on expression of Foxp3, and there may be a bidirectional Foxp3/TGF-β autocrine loop that determines the ability of the CD8+ T cells to control autoimmunity.

Induction of Autoantibody Production Is Limited in Nonautoimmune Mice

Many individuals develop a single or a few brief episodes of autoimmunity from which they recover. Mechanisms that quell pathologic autoimmunity following such a breakdown of self-tolerance are not clearly understood. In this study, we show that in nonautoimmune mice, dsDNA-specific autoreactive B cells exist but remain inactive. This state of inactivation in dsDNA-specific B cells could be disrupted by autoreactive Th cells; in this case T cells that react with peptides from the VH region of anti-DNA Abs (hereafter called anti-VH T cells). Immunization with anti-DNA mAb, its γ-chain or peptides derived from its VH region induced anti-VH Th cells, IgG anti-dsDNA Ab, and proteinuria. The breakdown of B cell tolerance in nonautoimmune mice, however, was short-lived: anti-DNA Ab and nephritis subsided despite subsequent immunizations. The recovery from autoimmunity temporally correlated with the appearance of T cells that inhibited anti-DNA Ab production. Such inhibitory T cells secreted TGFβ; the inhibition of anti-DNA Ab production by these cells was partly abolished by anti-TGFβ Ab. Even without immunization, nonautoimmune mice possess T cells that can inhibit autoantibody production. Thus, inhibitory T cells in nonautoimmune mice may normally inhibit T-dependent activation of autoreactive B cells and/or reverse such activation following stimulation by Th cells. The induction of such inhibitory T cells may play a role in protecting nonautoimmune mice from developing chronic autoimmunity.

Lupus autoantibodies to native DNA cross-react with the A and D SnRNP polypeptides.

Antibodies to native DNA (nDNA) in sera from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus have been found to frequently correlate with antibodies to the A and D SnRNP proteins measured in Western blot assays. 40 of 54 SLE (74.1%) sera with anti-nDNA bound to A and D proteins, while 9 of 113 sera (8%) without anti-nDNA bound the A and D proteins, P < 10(-8) by Fishers exact test. Antibodies to nDNA correlated closely with anti-A and anti-D in seven of eight patients followed sequentially, r = 0.7865. Nine human polyclonal anti-nDNA populations were isolated from DNA cellulose columns. Seven reacted equally with A and D, and two reacted predominantly with D. Two of three murine monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies isolated from NZB/NZW F1 hybrid mice bound A and D equally in Western blot with a titer > 1/40,000. These reactions were directed to the unfolded A and D proteins measurable in Western blot since these monoclonals (and several of the human anti-nDNA populations) failed to react with native U1RNP in ELISA or in RNA immunoprecipitation experiments. These newly recognized cross reactions of anti-nDNA may amplify the immune response to DNA and be part of the original immunogenic drive.

Comparison of DNA antibody idiotypes in human sera: an international collaborative study of 19 idiotypes from 11 different laboratories.

The distribution of and relationships between 18 anti-DNA antibody idiotypes and one anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody idiotype have been tested in an international collaborative study of human sera from 180 individuals. The main finding is that the serum levels of many of these idiotypes, whether of murine or human origin, show a high degree of statistical correlation. The studies in a wide range of autoimmune rheumatic diseases confirm that none of the idiotypes tested is disease specific, but 13 of 15 (87%) whose levels were recorded as OD units or cpm correlated strongly with anti-ssDNA antibody levels and 11 of 15 (73%) with total serum IgM. Expression of several idiotypes was found to fluctuate in parallel with disease activity in SLE; levels of others were also elevated in the healthy relatives of lupus patients whilst a few were also raised in the spouses of these patients. The data support the notion that there may be only a few groups of related DNA antibody idiotypes. The correlations between the idiotypes with regard to their quantities, association with disease activity, and wide distribution in different diseases and healthy individuals suggest at least two explanations. First, all of these idiotypes may be present in normal immunoglobulin repertoires and simply increase in response to poly- or oligoclonal B-cell activation in autoimmune diseases. Secondly, these idiotypes may be structurally linked to each other, so that their behaviour under conditions of specific antigenic stimulation is similar. Genetic and structural studies will be required to distinguish between these possibilities.