Filip Claerhout

The biology behind fascial defects and the use of implants in pelvic organ prolapse repair

Implant materials are increasingly being used in an effort to reduce recurrence after prolapse repair with native tissues. Surgeons should be aware of the biology behind both the disease as well as the host response to various implants. We will discuss insights into the biology behind hernia and abdominal fascial defects. Those lessons from “herniology” will, wherever possible, be applied to pelvic organ prolapse (POP) problems. Then we will deal with available animal models, for both the underlying disease and surgical repair. Then we will go over the features of implants and describe how the host responds to implantation. Methodology of such experiments will be briefly explained for the clinician not involved in experimentation. As we discuss the different materials available on the market, we will summarize some results of recent experiments by our group.

Medium term outcome of laparoscopic sacrocolpopexy with xenografts compared to synthetic grafts

PURPOSE We compared the medium term anatomical and subjective outcome, and graft related complications after sacrocolpopexy for apical vaginal prolapse using xenogenic or polypropylene grafts. MATERIALS AND METHODS We prospectively studied 50 consecutive patients who underwent laparoscopic sacrocolpopexy with porcine grafts of small intestinal submucosa (21) or dermal collagen (29). We compared these patients to 100 consecutive controls in whom polypropylene was used, and underwent surgery before (50) or after (50) the cases. The primary outcome was anatomical cure (stage I or less at any compartment). Secondary outcomes were graft related complications, subjective cure and quality of life evaluated by clinical examination, standardized interview and prolapse specific questionnaire, respectively. RESULTS At study closure 129 (86%) patients were available for functional evaluation and 104 (67%) were available for anatomical evaluation. Mean postoperative followup (+/-33 months) and baseline characteristics except age were comparable. The overall anatomical failure rate was comparable (49% vs 34%, p = 0.053) but failures at the vault (21% vs 3%, p <0.01) and posterior compartment (36% vs 19%, p <0.05) were more frequent in the xenograft group. There were 6 reoperations including secondary laparoscopic sacrocolpopexy (5) and cystocele repair (1), all confined to the xenograft group (p <0.01). Graft related complications were equally frequent (11%) in the xenograft and polypropylene groups. The reoperation rate for graft related complications was not different (xenograft 3% vs controls 11%, p = 0.20). There were no differences in functional outcome and quality of life between xenografts and controls. CONCLUSIONS While overall anatomical failure was comparable, sacrocolpopexy using xenograft was associated with more apical failures and reoperations for prolapse than with polypropylene without differences in functional outcome. The use of xenografts did not decrease the number of graft related complications.

Fate of collagen-based implants used in pelvic floor surgery: A 2-year follow-up study in a rabbit model

OBJECTIVE The purpose of this study was to compare the long-term host response to 2 different collagen matrices versus macroporous polypropylene mesh. STUDY DESIGN Four full-thickness abdominal wall defects in 35 rabbits were reconstructed with either polypropylene (Prolene), porcine dermal (Pelvicol), or small intestine submucosal collagen matrix (SIS). Animals were sacrificed on day 30, 60, 90, 180, 365, 540, and 720 days to evaluate morphologic and biomechanical properties of explants. RESULTS Prolene provoked a fibrotic reaction within 30 days. SIS was entirely replaced by a thin fibrotic layer within 60 days. Pelvicol was encapsulated, remaining structurally unchanged up to 180 days. Thereafter, half underwent degradation by a foreign body reaction. CONCLUSION Prolene was integrated by an increasingly organised fibrotic scar while SIS was entirely remodelled within 60 days. Pelvicol implants underwent late onset (> or = 180 days) degradation. After 2 years of implantation there were no differences in tensiometric strength between the 3 different materials.

Sacrocolpopexy using xenogenic acellular collagen in patients at increased risk for graft‐related complications

We studied the long‐term anatomical and functional outcome following sacrocolpopexy for apical vaginal prolapse using xenogenic grafts in a population at increased risk for graft‐related complications (GRCs).

Validity, reliability and responsiveness of a Dutch version of the prolapse quality-of-life (P-QoL) questionnaire

Introduction and hypothesisWe aimed to test validity, reliability and responsiveness of a Dutch version of a prolapse quality-of-life questionnaire (P-QoL).MethodsP-QoL was translated into Dutch and adjusted by a panel of five experts. The scores of the final version were compared between symptomatic (n = 160) and asymptomatic (n = 80) patients and with findings on vaginal examination (pelvic organ prolapse quantification (POP-Q)). In terms of reliability, Cronbach’s alpha was calculated, and a test–retest (n = 20) was performed. Responsiveness to treatment was assessed by comparing pre- and postoperative scores in 45 patients.ResultsTotal scores for each P-QoL domain were different between symptomatic and asymptomatic women (p < 0.001). Severity according to P-QoL correlated well with POP-Q findings. Cronbach’s alphas showed internal consistency within the domains. Test–retest reliability was high. Pre- and postoperative scores for each domain were significantly different (p < 0.001).ConclusionThe Dutch version of P-QoL is valid, reliable and responsive to assess quality-of-life and symptoms in Dutch-speaking patients with urogenital prolapse.

The challenge of implementing laparoscopic sacrocolpopexy

Vaginal-vault prolapse is effectively treated using sacrocolpopexy (SCP). A randomized trial demonstrated that it can be performed as effectively via laparoscopy (LSCP) as via laparotomy and with less morbidity. This evidence begs the question of how units offering abdominal sacrocolpopexy will implement LSCP. Several limitations need to be overcome. LSCP initially requires longer operating time; however, that decreases with surgeon experience. To decrease operation time, suture training can be implemented ahead. Following a 15-h suturing lab, trainees achieved comparable operation times after 30 cases. Dissection is another critical time-consuming step and is difficult to model. Proficiency is more dependent on patient characteristics, though this component is poorly studied. One experience showed it takes 60 procedures to effectively limit complications. The large number of patients required for surgeon training for this relative infrequent operation creates a problem, thus limiting the number of centers available for training surgeons within a reasonable period.

Clinicopathological study of patients requiring reintervention after sacrocolpopexy with xenogenic acellular collagen grafts.

PURPOSE We describe the operative and histopathological findings of patients requiring reintervention because of symptomatic vault prolapse or graft related complications following sacrocolpopexy using xenografts. MATERIALS AND METHODS A total of 13 patients underwent secondary sacrocolpopexy because of failure (8) or vaginal revision (5) because of a graft related complication after the initial sacrocolpopexy with porcine dermal collagen (9) or small intestinal submucosa (4). Outcome measures were operative findings and histology of specimens obtained at reintervention. Sections were semiquantitatively scored for the presence of infection, foreign body reaction and fibrosis by a pathologist blinded to the outcome and graft type. RESULTS Reinterventions for failure and graft related complications were performed a median of 33 and 15 months, respectively, after the initial operation. Pathology of porcine dermal collagen failures (6) revealed local degradation associated with a minimal foreign body reaction. Porcine dermal collagen remnants were surrounded by minimal fibrosis and neovascularization. Small intestinal submucosa implants of failures (2) were entirely replaced by collagen rich and moderately vascularized connective tissue. Pathology of 3 erosions (all 3 porcine dermal collagen) revealed a locally degraded implant that was surrounded by histiocytes and a polymorphonuclear infiltrate. Pathology of 2 early infections, both small intestinal submucosa, revealed a massive polymorphonuclear infiltration with the implant material remodeled and replaced by loose connective tissue. CONCLUSIONS In these clinical recurrences porcine dermal collagen implants were usually locally degraded but still recognizable several years after implantation. Small intestinal submucosa implants were fully replaced by connective tissue. Therefore, the cause of recurrence remains unclear. Porcine dermal collagen erosions displayed features of infection and degradation.

The Laparoscopic Approach to Pelvic Floor Surgery

Laparoscopy offers great exposure and surgical detail, reduces blood loss and the need for excessive abdominal packing and bowel manipulation making it an excellent modality to perform pelvic floor surgery. Laparoscopic repair of level I or apical vaginal prolapse may be challenging, due to the need for extensive dissection and advanced suturing skills. However it offers the efficacy of open abdominal sacrocolpopexy, such as lower recurrence rates and less dyspareunia than sacrospinous fixation, as well as the reduced morbidity of a laparoscopic approach.