Francesca Leonori

Crossed molecular beam reactive scattering: from simple triatomic to multichannel polyatomic reactions

In our laboratory a recent series of experiments by means of the crossed molecular beam (CMB) scattering technique with mass-spectrometric detection and time-of-flight analysis has been instrumental in fostering progress in the understanding of the dynamics of both simple triatomic insertion reactions and complex polyatomic addition–elimination reactions exhibiting competing channels. In the first part of this review we survey the advances made in the comprehension of the dynamics of the insertion reactions involving excited carbon, nitrogen and oxygen atoms – C(1D), N(2D), O(1D) – with H2(D2), as made possible by synergistic comparisons of experimental reactive differential cross-sections with the results of exact quantum, quasiclassical trajectory and statistical calculations on reliable ab initio potential energy surfaces. Related experimental and theoretical work from other laboratories is noted throughout. In the second part, we review the progress made in the understanding of the dynamics of polyatomic multichannel reactions, such as those of ground state oxygen and carbon atoms, O(3P) and C(3P), with the simplest alkyne, acetylene, and alkene, ethylene, as made possible by the gained capability of identifying virtually all primary reaction channels, characterising their dynamics, and determining their branching ratios. Such a capability is based on an improved crossed molecular beam instrument which features product detection by low-energy electron soft-ionisation for increased sensitivity and universal detection power, and variable beam crossing angle for a larger collision energy range and increased angular and velocity resolution. The scattering results are rationalised with the assistance of theoretical information from other laboratories on the stationary points and product energetics of the relevant ab initio potential energy surfaces. These detailed studies on polyatomic multichannel reactions provide an important bridge between crossed beam dynamics and thermal kinetics research. Contents PAGE 1. Introduction 110 2. Experimental: improved crossed molecular beams apparatus 113  2.1. Soft electron-ionisation detection 114  2.2. Product angular and velocity distributions 116  2.3. Crossed molecular beam experiments with variable beam crossing angle 118  2.4. Supersonic sources of radical beams 120 3. Triatomic insertion reactions 120  3.1. Reaction C(1D) + H2 122  3.2. Reaction N(2D) + H2 126  3.3. Reaction O(1D) + H2 129 4. Polyatomic multichannel reactions 133  4.1. Reaction O(3P) + C2H2 134   4.1.1. Product angular and TOF distributions 135   4.1.2. Determination of branching ratios 138   4.1.3. Determination of product ionisation energies 138  4.2. Reaction C(3P) + C2H2 138   4.2.1. H and H2 elimination channels, and branching ratios 140   4.2.2. Ionisation energy of c/l-C3H radicals 145  4.3. Reaction O(3P) + C2H4 145   4.3.1. Observation of all product channels and branching ratios 146  4.4. Reaction C(3P) + C2H4 151   4.4.1. H-elimination channels 151   4.4.2. C–C bond fission channels 154 5. Summary and outlook 154 Acknowledgements 157 References 158

Intersystem crossing and dynamics in O(3P) + C2H4 multichannel reaction: Experiment validates theory

The O(3P) + C2H4 reaction, of importance in combustion and atmospheric chemistry, stands out as a paradigm reaction involving triplet- and singlet-state potential energy surfaces (PESs) interconnected by intersystem crossing (ISC). This reaction poses challenges for theory and experiments owing to the ruggedness and high dimensionality of these potentials, as well as the long lifetimes of the collision complexes. Primary products from five competing channels (H + CH2CHO, H + CH3CO, H2 + CH2CO, CH3 + HCO, CH2 + CH2O) and branching ratios (BRs) are determined in crossed molecular beam experiments with soft electron-ionization mass-spectrometric detection at a collision energy of 8.4 kcal/mol. As some of the observed products can only be formed via ISC from triplet to singlet PESs, from the product BRs the extent of ISC is inferred. A new full-dimensional PES for the triplet state as well as spin-orbit coupling to the singlet PES are reported, and roughly half a million surface hopping trajectories are run on the coupled singlet-triplet PESs to compare with the experimental BRs and differential cross-sections. Both theory and experiment find almost equal contributions from the two PESs to the reaction, posing the question of how important is it to consider the ISC as one of the nonadiabatic effects for this and similar systems involved in combustion chemistry. Detailed comparisons at the level of angular and translational energy distributions between theory and experiment are presented for the two primary channel products, CH3 + HCO and H + CH2CHO. The agreement between experimental and theoretical functions is excellent, implying that theory has reached the capability of describing complex multichannel nonadiabatic reactions.

Soft electron impact ionization in crossed molecular beam reactive scattering: The dynamics of the O(3P)+C2H2 reaction

Soft ionization by low-energy, tunable electrons is implemented for the first time in crossed molecular beam reactive scattering experiments with mass-spectrometric detection. The power of the method, which permits the suppression of the dissociative ionization of interfering species, is exemplified with the study of the O((3)P)+C(2)H(2) multichannel reaction.

Unraveling the dynamics of the C(3P,1D) + C2H2 reactions by the crossed molecular beam scattering technique

A detailed investigation of the dynamics of the reactions of ground- and excited-state carbon atoms, C(3P) and C(1D), with acetylene is reported over a wide collision energy range (3.6-49.1 kJ mol-1) using the crossed molecular beam (CMB) scattering technique with electron ionization mass spectrometric detection and time-of-flight (TOF) analysis. We have exploited the capability of (a) generating continuous intense supersonic beams of C(3P, 1D), (b) crossing the two reactant beams at different intersection angles (45, 90, and 135 degrees ) to attain a wide range of collision energies, and (c) tuning the energy of the ionizing electrons to low values (soft ionization) to suppress interferences from dissociative ionization processes. From angular and TOF distribution measurements of products at m/z=37 and 36, the primary reaction products of the C(3P) and C(1D) reactions with C2H2 have been identified to be cyclic (c)-C3H + H, linear (l)-C3H + H, and C3 + H2. From the data analysis, product angular and translational energy distributions in the center-of-mass (CM) system for both the linear and cyclic C3H isomers as well as the C3 product from C(3P) and for l/c-C3H and C3 from C(1D) have been derived as a function of collision energy from 3.6 to 49.1 kJ mol-1. The cyclic/linear C3H ratio and the C3/(C3 + c/l-C3H) branching ratios for the C(3P) reaction have been determined as a function of collision energy. The present findings have been compared with those from previous CMB studies using pulsed beams; here, a marked contrast is noted in the CM angular distributions for both C3H- and C3-forming channels from C(3P) and their trend with collision energy. Consequently, the interpretation of the reaction dynamics derived in the present work contradicts that previously proposed from the pulsed CMB studies. The results have been discussed in the light of the available theoretical information on the relevant triplet and singlet C3H2 ab initio potential energy surfaces (PESs). In particular, the branching ratios for the C(3P) + C2H2 reaction have been compared with the available theoretical predictions (approximate quantum scattering calculations and quasiclassical trajectory calculations on ab initio triplet PESs and, very recent, statistical calculations on ab initio triplet PESs as well as on ab initio triplet/singlet PESs including nonadiabatic effects, that is, intersystem crossing). While the experimental branching ratios have been corroborated by the statistical predictions, strong disagreement has been found with the results of the dynamical calculations. The astrophysical implications of the present results have been noted.

Crossed-beam universal-detection reactive scattering of radical beams characterized by laser-induced-fluorescence: the case of C2 and CN

Continuous supersonic beams of dicarbon (C2) and cyano (CN) radicals have been generated by a high-pressure radio-frequency discharge beam source starting from dilute mixtures in rare gases of suitable precursor molecules. Their internal quantum state distributions have been characterized by laser-induced-fluorescence (LIF) in a new crossed molecular beam-laser apparatus. These supersonic beams have been used to study the reactive scattering of C2 and CN radicals with unsaturated hydrocarbons. This paper reports here on the C2 and CN radical beam characterization by LIF and on dynamics studies of the reactions CN + C2H2 (acetylene) and CN + CH3CCH (methylacetylene) by the crossed molecular beam scattering technique with universal mass spectrometric detection and time-of-flight analysis. The role of CN rovibrational excitation on the dynamics of the CN + C2H2 reaction is discussed with reference to previous dynamics and kinetics studies. These reactions are of interest in the chemistry of planetary atmospheres (Titan) and the interstellar medium as well as in combustion.

Experimental and theoretical studies of the O(3P) + C2H4 reaction dynamics: collision energy dependence of branching ratios and extent of intersystem crossing.

The reaction of O((3)P) with C(2)H(4), of importance in combustion and atmospheric chemistry, stands out as paradigm reaction involving not only the indicated triplet state potential energy surface (PES) but also an interleaved singlet PES that is coupled to the triplet surface. This reaction poses great challenges for theory and experiment, owing to the ruggedness and high dimensionality of these potentials, as well as the long lifetimes of the collision complexes. Crossed molecular beam (CMB) scattering experiments with soft electron ionization detection are used to disentangle the dynamics of this polyatomic multichannel reaction at a collision energy E(c) of 8.4 kcal∕mol. Five different primary products have been identified and characterized, which correspond to the five exothermic competing channels leading to H + CH(2)CHO, H + CH(3)CO, CH(3) + HCO, CH(2) + H(2)CO, and H(2) + CH(2)CO. These experiments extend our previous CMB work at higher collision energy (E(c) ∼ 13 kcal∕mol) and when the results are combined with the literature branching ratios from kinetics experiments at room temperature (E(c) ∼ 1 kcal∕mol), permit to explore the variation of the branching ratios over a wide range of collision energies. In a synergistic fashion, full-dimensional, QCT surface hopping calculations of the O((3)P) + C(2)H(4) reaction using ab initio PESs for the singlet and triplet states and their coupling, are reported at collision energies corresponding to the CMB and the kinetics ones. Both theory and experiment find almost an equal contribution from the triplet and singlet surfaces to the reaction, as seen from the collision energy dependence of branching ratios of product channels and extent of intersystem crossing (ISC). Further detailed comparisons at the level of angular distributions and translational energy distributions are made between theory and experiment for the three primary radical channel products, H + CH(2)CHO, CH(3) + HCO, and CH(2) + H(2)CO. The very good agreement between theory and experiment indicates that QCT surface-hopping calculations, using reliable coupled multidimensional PESs, can yield accurate dynamical information for polyatomic multichannel reactions in which ISC plays an important role.

Crossed-beam dynamics, low-temperature kinetics, and theoretical studies of the reaction S(1D) + C2H4.

The reaction between sulfur atoms in the first electronically excited state, S((1)D), and ethene (C(2)H(4)) has been investigated in a complementary fashion in (a) crossed-beam dynamic experiments with mass spectrometric detection and time-of-flight (TOF) analysis at two collision energies (37.0 and 45.0 kJ mol(-1)), (b) low temperature kinetics experiments ranging from 298 K down to 23 K, and (c) electronic structure calculations of stationary points and product energetics on the C(2)H(4)S singlet and triplet potential energy surfaces. The rate coefficients for total loss of S((1)D) are found to be very large (ca. 4 x 10(-10) cm(3) molecule(-1) s(-1)) down to very low temperatures indicating that the overall reaction is barrierless. From laboratory angular and TOF distributions at different product masses, three competing reaction channels leading to H + CH(2)CHS (thiovinoxy), H(2) + CH(2)CS (thioketene), and CH(3) + HCS (thioformyl) have been unambiguously identified and their dynamics characterized. Product branching ratios have also been estimated. Interpretation of the experimental results on the reaction kinetics and dynamics is assisted by high-level theoretical calculations on the C(2)H(4)S singlet potential energy surface. RRKM (Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus) estimates of the product branching ratios using the newly developed singlet potential energy surface have also been performed and compared with the experimental determinations.

Combined crossed beam and theoretical studies of the C(1D) + CH4 reaction.

The reaction involving atomic carbon in its first electronically excited state (1)D and methane has been investigated in crossed molecular beam experiments at a collision energy of 25.3 kJ mol(-1). Electronic structure calculations of the underlying potential energy surface (PES) and Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus (RRKM) estimates of rates and branching ratios have been performed to assist the interpretation of the experimental results. The reaction proceeds via insertion of C((1)D) into one of the C-H bonds of methane leading to the formation of the intermediate HCCH(3) (methylcarbene or ethylidene), which either decomposes directly into the products C(2)H(3) + H or C(2)H(2) + H(2) or isomerizes to the more stable ethylene, which in turn dissociates into C(2)H(3) + H or H(2)CC + H(2). The experimental results indicate that the H-displacement and H(2)-elimination channels are of equal importance and that for both channels the reaction mechanism is controlled by the presence of a bound intermediate, the lifetime of which is comparable to its rotational period. On the contrary, RRKM estimates predict a very short lifetime for the insertion intermediate and the dominance of the H-displacement channel. It is concluded that the reaction C((1)D) + CH(4) cannot be described statistically and a dynamical treatment is necessary to understand its mechanism. Possibly, nonadiabatic effects are responsible for the discrepancies, as triplet and singlet PES of methylcarbene cross each other and intersystem crossing is possible. Similarities with the photodissociation of ethylene and with the related reactions N((2)D) + CH(4), O((1)D) + CH(4) and S((1)D) + CH(4) are also commented on.

Formation of nitriles and imines in the atmosphere of Titan: combined crossed-beam and theoretical studies on the reaction dynamics of excited nitrogen atoms N(2D) with ethane

The dynamics of the H-displacement channels in the reaction N(2D) + C2H6 have been investigated by the crossed molecular beam technique with mass spectrometric detection and time-of-flight analysis at two different collision energies (18.0 and 31.4 kJ mol(-1)). From the derived center-of-mass product angular and translational energy distributions the reaction micromechanisms and the product energy partitioning have been obtained. The interpretation of the scattering results is assisted by new ab initio electronic structure calculations of stationary points and product energetics for the C2H6N ground state doublet potential energy surface. C-C bond breaking and NH production channels have been theoretically characterized and the statistical branching ratio derived at the temperatures relevant for the atmosphere of Titan. Methanimine plus CH3 and ethanimine plus H are the main reaction channels. Implications for the atmospheric chemistry of Titan are discussed.

Crossed beam studies of radical-radical reactions: O(3P) + C3H5 (allyl).

The dynamics of the radical-radical reaction O((3)P) + C(3)H(5) has been investigated by means of the crossed molecular beam technique with mass spectrometric detection at a collision energy of 73.0 kJ mol(-1); the reaction mechanism of the H-displacement channel has been elucidated, while experimental evidence of the occurrence of one or more C-C bond-breaking channels at this collision energy has been obtained.