Frank Riley

Supercritical fluid chromatographic resolution of water soluble isomeric carboxyl/amine terminated peptides facilitated via mobile phase water and ion pair formation

Both analytical scale and preparative scale packed column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) have found widespread applicability for chiral separations of multiple polar pharmaceutical candidates. However, SFC is rapidly becoming an achiral technique. More specifically, ion pair SFC is finding greater utility for separation of ionic analytes such as amine salts and organic sulfonates. The key to this success is, in part, the incorporation of additives such as trifluoroacetic acid and ammonium acetate into the mobile phase in association with a wide variety of both bonded silica stationary phases and high purity bare silica. Ion pairing SFC coupled with evaporative light scattering detection and mass spectrometric detection is presented here for the separation of water soluble, uncapped, isomeric peptide pairs that differ in amino acid arrangement. The separation is best achieved on either diol-bonded silica or bare silica with 1-5% (w/w) water as a significant ingredient in the mobile phase. Nitrogenous stationary phases such as 2-ethylpyridine, which had been very successful for the separation of capped peptides failed to yield the desired separation regardless of the mobile phase composition. A HILIC type retention mechanism is postulated for the separation of both isomeric uncapped peptide pairs.

Packed column supercritical fluid chromatography of isomeric polypeptide pairs.

The characterization and determination of peptides is of great importance in the pharmaceutical industry as is the ability to rapidly perform targeted determinations of bioactive peptides in complex matrices. The purpose of the presented work is to assess the feasibility of packed column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) for the separation of two-pairs of water soluble peptides of identical mass, composition and charge that differ only in amino acid sequence. Upon evaluating a variety of conditions, trifluoroacetic acid (HTFA) in conjunction with methanol as the modifier proved to be, in general, the most successful mobile phase additive for elution of the two isomeric peptide pairs from all nitrogenous stationary phases. In contrast, water and ammonium acetate gave distorted peak shapes and therefore proved to be less satisfactory as neutral additives. The basic additive, iso-propylamine (IPAm), coupled with HA-Pyridine yielded the highest resolution factor for the complete study. Aminopropyl and HA-Pyridine columns with 5 μm particle size and 60 Å pore size were found to be best for resolution of each peptide pair. Bare silica and phenyl-hexyl stationary phases did not afford any separation. The primary roles of the carbon dioxide and methanol modifier are believed to provide (a) stationary phase solvation and (b) peptide solubility and transport; while, HTFA is postulated to fully protonate each peptide and form ion pairs between its conjugate base and cationic peptide analyte. The separation process, therefore, is best viewed as ion pair supercritical fluid chromatography (IP-SFC). For the case where IPAm gave good resolution on the HA-Pyridine column, the peptides are probably in the neutral state.

On the method development of immobilized polysaccharide chiral stationary phases in supercritical fluid chromatography using an extended range of modifiers.

Polysaccharide-derived selectors are often used in the separation of enantiomers by supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). Their recognition patterns are normally investigated with alcohols and acetonitrile as modifiers. The present paper describes the results of a research program designed by Pfizer and Chiral Technologies Inc. to explore the potential of other solvents (i.e. ethyl acetate, tetrahydrofuran, dichloromethane) in SFC by using a series of polysaccharide-derived supports with broad solvent versatility (CHIRALPAK IA, IB, IC, ID, IE and IF). The contribution of such extended solvent range to the overall success rate, as well as to overcome racemization, solubility and stability issues was confirmed by using standard non-proprietary samples and research molecules. Elution patterns with such lower polarity solvents, compared to alcohols, and the role of the different additives were also investigated.

Evolution of strategies to achieve baseline separation of ten anionic, water-soluble sulfated estrogens via achiral packed column supercritical fluid chromatography.

Near baseline separation of ten sulfated sodium salts of various structurally related estrogens employing a variety of bonded stationary phase packed columns was obtained using a conventional supercritical fluid chromatograph coupled with UV detection. Critical pairs 2/3 (8,9-dehydroestrone/17β-dihydroequilin) and 6/7 (17α-estradiol or 17α-dihydroequilin/estrone), however, failed to baseline separate. In all preliminary separations, 10mM ammonium acetate and variable percentages of H2O were initially used as co-additives in conjunction with methanol as a modifier. Different modifier programs and temperatures were employed to optimize the separation in a timely manner. A 2-ethylpyridine column provided the best separation compared to bare silica, diol, and cyano-based bonded phase columns. The employment of both salt and water as additives to the methanol-modified CO2 mobile phase suggested a mixed mode separation mechanism involving both ion pairing of each anionic sulfated estrogen with ammonium ion and hydrophilic interaction facilitated by partitioning of analyte between the aqueous solvated stationary phase and the aqueous component of the mobile phase. Upon more extensive study with either iso-propylamine or formic acid-ammonium formate buffer, the critical anionic pairs were 95% baseline resolved.

Feasibility of correlating separation of ternary mixtures of neutral analytes via thin layer chromatography with supercritical fluid chromatography in support of green flash separations.

Method development for normal phase flash liquid chromatography traditionally employs preliminary screening using thin layer chromatography (TLC) with conventional solvents on bare silica. Extension to green flash chromatography via correlation of TLC migration results, with conventional polar/nonpolar liquid mixtures, and packed column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) retention times, via gradient elution on bare silica with a suite of carbon dioxide mobile phase modifiers, is reported. Feasibility of TLC/SFC correlation is individually described for eight ternary mixtures for a total of 24 neutral analytes. The experimental criteria for TLC/SFC correlation was assumed to be as follows: SFC/UV/MS retention (tR) increases among each of the three resolved mixture components; while, TLC migration (Rf) decreases among the same resolved mixture components. Successful correlation of TLC to SFC was observed for most of the polar organic solvents tested, with the best results observed via SFC on bare silica with methanol as the CO2 modifier and TLC on bare silica with a methanol/dichloromethane mixture.

Semi-preparative high-resolution recycling liquid chromatography

A semi-preparative high-resolution system based on twin column recycling liquid chromatography was built. The integrated system includes a binary pump mixer, a sample manager, a two-column oven compartment, two low-dispersion detection cells, and a fraction manager (analytical). It addresses challenges in drug/impurity purification, which involve several constraints simultaneously: (1) small selectivity factors (α < 1.2, poor resolution), (2) mismatch of elution strength between the sample diluent and the eluent causing severe band fronting or tailing, (3) diluent-to-eluent mismatch of viscosity causing viscous fingering and unpredictable band deformation, (4) low abundance of the impurity relative to the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) (<1/100), and (5) yield and purity levels to be larger than 99% and 90%, respectively. The prototype system was tested for the preparation of a trace impurity present in a concentrated solution of an API, estradiol. The ultimate goal was to collect ∼1 mg of impurity (>90% purity) for unambiguous structure elucidation by liquid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR 600 MHz and above). First, the particle size (3.5 μm) used to pack the 4.6 mm × 150 mm long twin columns is selected so that the speed-resolution of the recycling process is maximized at 4000 psi pressure drop. Next, the production rate of the process is also maximized by determining the optimum number (7) of cycles and the corresponding largest sample volume (160 μL) to be injected. Finally, the process is fully automated by programming the time events related to (1) sample cleaning, (2) transfer of the targeted impurity from one to the second twin column, and (3) impurity collection. The process was tested without interruption during one week for the collection of a trace impurity (α = 1.166, strong acetonitrile-methanol sample diluent, concentration ∼2 mg/L) from a concentrated (10 g/L) stock solution (60 mL total) of estradiol. The process enriches the impurity content relative to the API by about a factor ∼5000. For the lack of a sufficient collected amount (∼120 μg only) of the pure impurity (purity 50% only), NMR experiments could not provide reliable results. Instead, the combination of LC-MS (single ion monitoring) and UV absorption spectra (λmax shift) revealed that the targeted impurity was likely the low-abundant enol tautomeric form of the ketone estrone, a possible intermediate or by-product of the synthesis reaction of estradiol.