Fred Stormshak

The effect of aromatase inhibition on the sexual differentiation of the sheep brain

This study tested the hypothesis that aromatization of testosterone to estradiol is necessary for sexual differentiation of the sheep brain. Pregnant ewes (n=10) were treated with the aromatase inhibitor 1,4,6-androstatriene-3,17-dione (ATD) during the period of gestation when the sheep brain is maximally sensitive to the behavior-modifying effects of exogenous testosterone (embryonic d 50–80; 147 d is term). Control (n=10) ewes received vehicle injections. Fifteen control lambs (7 males and 8 females) and 17 ATD-exposed lambs (7 males and 10 females) were evaluated for sexually dimorphic behavioral and neuroendocrine traits as adults. Prenatal ATD exposure had no significant effect on serum concentrations of androgen at birth, growth rates, expression of juvenile play behaviors, or the onset of puberty in male and female lambs. Rams exposed to ATD prenatally exhibited a modest, but significant, decrease in mounting behavior at 18 mo of age. However, prenatal ATD exposure did not interfere with defeminization of adult sexual partner preferences, receptive behavior, or the LH surge mechanism. In summary, our results indicate that aromatization is necessary for complete behavioral masculinization in sheep. However, before we can conclude that aromatization does not play a role in defeminization of the sheep brain, it will be necessary to evaluate whether intrauterine exposure of male fetuses to higher doses of ATD for a more extended period of time can disrupt normal neuroendocrine and behavioral development.

Separate critical periods exist for testosterone-induced differentiation of the brain and genitals in sheep.

Sheep exposed to testosterone during a critical period from gestational day (GD) 30 to GD 90 develop masculine genitals and an enlarged male-typical ovine sexually dimorphic nucleus of the preoptic area (oSDN). The present study tested the hypothesis that separate critical periods exist for masculinization of these two anatomical end points. Pregnant ewes were treated with testosterone propionate (TP) either from GD 30 to GD 60 (early TP) or GD 60 to GD 90 (late TP). Control (C) pregnant ewes were treated with corn oil. Fetuses were delivered at GD 135 and the volume of the oSDN was measured. Early TP females possessed a penis and a scrotum devoid of testes, whereas late TP and C females had normal female genitals. Neither period of TP exposure grossly affected the genitals of male fetuses. Despite masculinized genitals, the mean volume of the oSDN in early TP females (0.32 ± 0.06 mm³) was not different from C females (0.24 ± 0.02 mm³) but was significantly enlarged in late TP females (0.49 ± 0.04 mm³; P < 0.05 vs. C) when the genitals appeared normal. In contrast, the volume of the oSDN in late TP males (0.51 ± 0.02 mm³) was not different from C males (0.51 ± 0.04 mm³) but was significantly smaller in the early TP males (0.35 ± 0.04 mm³; P < 0.05 vs. C). These results demonstrate that the prenatal critical period for androgen-dependent differentiation of the oSDN occurs later than, and can be separated temporally from, the period for development of masculine genitals.

Expression of steroid hormone receptors in the fetal sheep brain during the critical period for sexual differentiation

The objective of this study was to examine the expression of receptors for androgen, estrogen, and progesterone in the fetal sheep brain during the critical period for sexual differentiation. We isolated mRNA from the hypothalamus-preoptic area (HPOA), amygdala (AMYG), medulla (MD), frontal cortex (FCTX) and olfactory bulbs (OB) of fetal sheep that were delivered on day 64 of gestation. Using a ribonuclease protection assay and species-specific cRNA probes, we measured mRNA expression levels of androgen receptor (AR), estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) and progesterone receptor (PR). ERalpha and AR mRNA were expressed in all of the tissues tested and highest in the HPOA. PR mRNA was measured in HPOA and AMYG only and was significantly higher in male than in female fetuses. We conclude that the fetal brain is a target site for circulating steroid hormones. These data have implications for the steroid dependent development of sexually dimorphic brain functions in sheep.

Relationship of Serum Testosterone Concentrations to Mate Preferences in Rams

Abstract This study examined systemic testosterone concentrations in rams that were classified according to their sexual behavior and partner preference as either female-oriented (FOR), male-oriented (MOR), or asexual (NOR). For this purpose, we measured testosterone concentrations under three separate conditions: in conscious rams during the nonbreeding season (June) and breeding season (November), and in anesthetized rams during the breeding season. Basal testosterone concentrations in conscious rams were not different among the three groups (P > 0.05) in either season. However, when rams were anesthetized, mean systemic concentrations of testosterone in FORs (mean ± SEM, 13.9 ± 7.4 ng/ml serum) were greater (P < 0.05) than in NORs (0.9 ± 0.1 ng/ml), but not in MORs (2.2 ± 6.2 ng/ml), whereas testosterone concentrations were not different between MORs and NORs (P > 0.05). Concentrations of testosterone in the spermatic vein of FORs (127 ± 66 ng/ml) were greater (P < 0.05) than in MORs (41 ± 10 ng/ml) and NORs (19 ± 7 ng/ml). Serum LH concentrations were not different. Cortisol was higher (P < 0.05) in anesthetized MORs (25.1 ± 4.2 ng/ml) and NORs (27.2 ± 4.4 ng/ml) than in FORs (10.9 ± 1.8 ng/ml). These results demonstrate that circulating testosterone concentrations are related to sexual behavior only when rams are bled under anesthesia. Thus, differences in basal androgen concentrations in adulthood cannot be responsible for expression of male-oriented preferences or low libido in sheep. Instead, functional differences must exist between the brains of rams that differ in sexual preference expression.

The Neurobiology of Sexual Partner Preferences in Rams

The question of what causes a male animal to seek out and choose a female as opposed to another male mating partner is unresolved and remains an issue of considerable debate. The most developed biologic theory is the perinatal organizational hypothesis, which states that perinatal hormone exposure mediates sexual differentiation of the brain. Numerous animal experiments have assessed the contribution of perinatal testosterone and/or estradiol exposure to the development of a male-typical mate preference, but almost all have used hormonally manipulated animals. In contrast, variations in sexual partner preferences occur spontaneously in domestic rams, with as many as 8% of the population exhibiting a preference for same-sex mating partners (male-oriented rams). Thus, the domestic ram is an excellent experimental model to study possible links between fetal neuroendocrine programming of neural mechanisms and adult sexual partner preferences. In this review, we present an overview of sexual differentiation in relation to sexual partner preferences. We then summarize results that test the relevance of the organizational hypothesis to expression of same-sex sexual partner preferences in rams. Finally, we demonstrate that the sexual differentiation of brain and behavior in sheep does not depend critically on aromatization of testosterone to estradiol.

Prolactin expression in the sheep brain.

Accumulating evidence in rodents suggests that a prolactin locally synthesized and released within the brain can act together with that taken up from the circulation to modulate neuroendocrine responses. The present study was designed to identify the regional patterns of prolactin expression in the adult and developing sheep brain. Specifically, we tested the hypothesis that prolactin is expressed in regions of the adult and fetal sheep brain that are critical in the development of neuroendocrine homeostatic and behavioral functions. The expression of prolactin protein in sheep brain was demonstrated by Western blot analysis and brain prolactin mRNA was detected and sequenced using RT-PCR. In situ hybridization histochemistry revealed that prolactin mRNA was expressed in the medial preoptic area, periventricular preoptic nucleus, bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, and in the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus, particularly the ventral region. The neuroanatomical distribution of prolactin mRNA was best visualized in the fetus and prolactin-immunoreactive neurons could also be identified in late gestation fetuses. Brain prolactin mRNA was expressed as early as day 60 of gestation and increased as the fetus aged and peaked at day 135 (term = 147 days). Prolactin mRNA expression did not exhibit a sex difference in the preoptic area, but in the amygdala prolactin mRNA was significantly higher in females than in males at day 100 of gestation. We conclude that prolactin expressed in adult and fetal sheep brain could be involved in neurodevelopment and/or modulation of the neuroendocrine stress axis, although it is too early to rule out other possibilities given the diverse actions that have been attributed to prolactin.

The Ovine Sexually Dimorphic Nucleus, Aromatase, and Sexual Partner Preferences in Sheep

We are using the domestic ram as an experimental model to examine the role of aromatase in the development of sexual partner preferences. This interest has arisen because of the observation that as many as 8% of domestic rams are sexually attracted to other rams (male-oriented) in contrast to the majority of rams that are attracted to estrous ewes (female-oriented). Our findings demonstrate that aromatase expression is enriched in a cluster of neurons in the medial preoptic nucleus called the ovine sexually dimorphic nucleus (oSDN). The size of the oSDN is associated with a rams sexual partner preference, such that the nucleus is 2-3 times larger in rams that are attracted to females (female-oriented) than in rams that are attracted to other rams (male-oriented). Moreover, the volume of the oSDN in male-oriented rams is similar to the volume in ewes. These volume differences are not influenced by adult concentrations of serum testosterone. Instead, we found that the oSDN is already present in late gestation lamb fetuses (approximately day 135 of gestation) when it is approximately 2-fold greater in males than in females. Exposure of genetic female fetuses to exogenous testosterone during the critical period for sexual differentiation masculinizes oSDN volume and aromatase expression when examined subsequently on day 135. The demonstration that the oSDN is organized prenatally by testosterone exposure suggests that the brain of the male-oriented ram may be under-androgenized during development.

THE VOLUME OF THE OVINE SEXUALLY DIMORPHIC NUCLEUS OF THE PREOPTIC AREA IS INDEPENDENT OF ADULT TESTOSTERONE CONCENTRATIONS

The ovine sexually dimorphic nucleus (oSDN) is characterized by high levels of aromatase mRNA expression which can be used to delineate its boundaries. The volume of the oSDN is approximately 2 to 3-fold larger in rams that mate with ewes (female-oriented rams) than in rams that mate with other rams (male-oriented rams) and ewes. The sex difference in oSDN volume is present in late gestation fetuses and can be eliminated before birth by exposing genetic females to exogenous testosterone during midgestation, suggesting that early exposure to androgen masculinizes volume of the oSDN. The present study was performed to determine whether differences in oSDN volume are influenced by the adult hormonal environment. Adult rams, behaviorally characterized as female-oriented or male-oriented, and ewes were gonadectomized and treated with subcutaneous implants of testosterone to achieve physiologic concentrations of serum testosterone. Three weeks after implant placement brain tissue was prepared for histological assessment of oSDN volume using in situ hybridization for detection of aromatase mRNA expression. Quantitative analysis revealed that despite similar serum testosterone levels among the groups, the volume of the oSDN was greater in female-oriented rams than in male-oriented rams and ewes (P<0.05). Differences in oSDN volume were specific and not reflective of differences in preoptic area height or brain size. These results suggest that differences in the size of the oSDN in adult sheep were not influenced by adult exposure to testosterone.

Hormonal influences on sexual partner preference in rams.

Domestic rams display a naturally occurring variation in sexual partner preference, such that 6–10% of range-bred populations prefer male sexual partners (male-oriented) in contrast to the majority of rams that prefer female sexual partners (female-oriented). Male-oriented rams exhibit hormone profiles and stress responses distinctly different from their heterosexual counterparts. These differences include reduced circulating levels of testosterone that arise after anesthetization. Lower levels of aromatase activity in the medial preoptic area and estrogen receptor in the amygdala were also measured in male-oriented versus female-oriented rams and may represent an important link to sexual behavior that should be investigated. It is anticipated that the male-oriented ram model will be useful for studies aimed at identifying both the activational and organizational components and the neuronal substrates of male sexual partner preferences.

Prenatal Programming of Sexual Partner Preference: The Ram Model

In our laboratory, the domestic ram is used as an experimental model to study the early programming of neural mechanisms underlying same‐sex partner preference. This interest developed from the observation that approximately 8% of domestic rams are sexually attracted to other rams (male‐oriented) in contrast to the majority of rams that are attracted to oestrous ewes (female‐oriented). One prominent feature of sexual differentiation in many species is the presence of a sexually dimorphic nucleus (SDN) in the preoptic/anterior hypothalamus that is larger in males than in females. Lesion studies in rats and ferrets implicate the SDN in the expression of sexual preferences. We discovered an ovine SDN (oSDN) in the preoptic/anterior hypothalamus that is smaller in male‐ than in female‐oriented rams and similar in size to the oSDN of ewes. Neurones of the oSDN show abundant aromatase expression that is also reduced in male‐oriented compared to female‐oriented rams. This observation suggests that sexual partner preferences are neurologically hard‐wired and could be influenced by hormones. Aromatase‐containing neurones constitute a nascent oSDN as early as day 60 of gestation, which becomes sexually dimorphic by day 135 of gestation when it is two‐fold larger in males than in females. Exposure of fetal female lambs to exogenous testosterone from days 30–90 of gestation resulted in a masculinised oSDN. These data demonstrate that the oSDN develops prenatally and may influence adult sexual preferences. Surprisingly, inhibition of aromatase activity in the brain of ram foetuses during the critical period did not interfere with defeminisation of adult sexual partner preference or oSDN volume. These results fail to support an essential role for neural aromatase in the sexual differentiation of sheep brain and behaviour. Thus, we propose that oSDN morphology and male‐typical partner preferences may instead be programmed through an androgen receptor mechanism not involving aromatisation.