Frederick J. Kummer

Biomechanics of locked plates and screws

Objective: To review the biomechanical principles that guide fracture fixation with plates and screws; specifically to compare and contrast the function and roles of conventional unlocked plates to locked plates in fracture fixation. We review basic plate and screw function, discuss the design rationale for the new implants, and examine the biomechanical evidence that supports the use of such implants. Data Sources: Systematic review of the per reviewed English language orthopaedic literature listed on PubMed (National Library of Medicine online service). Study Selection: Papers selected for this review were drawn from peer review orthopaedic journals. All selected papers specifically discussed plate and screw biomechanics with regard to fracture fixation. PubMed search terms were: plates and screws, biomechanics, locked plates, PC-Fix, LISS, LCP, MIPO, and fracture fixation. Data Synthesis: The following topics are discussed: plate and screw function—neutralization plates and buttress plates, bridge plates; fracture stability—specifically how this effects gap strain and fracture union, conventional plate biomechanics, and locking plate biomechanics. Conclusions: Locked plates and conventional plates rely on completely different mechanical principles to provide fracture fixation and in so doing they provide different biological environments for healing. Locked plates may increasingly be indicated for indirect fracture reduction, diaphyseal/metaphyseal fractures in osteoporotic bone, bridging severely comminuted fractures, and the plating of fractures where anatomical constraints prevent plating on the tension side of the bone. Conventional plates may continue to be the fixation method of choice for periarticular fractures which demand perfect anatomical reduction and to certain types of nonunions which require increased stability for union.

The use of an injectable, biodegradable calcium phosphate bone substitute for the prophylactic augmentation of osteoporotic vertebrae and the management of vertebral compression fractures.

STUDY DESIGN A biomechanical study comparing two materials for augmentation of osteoporotic vertebral bodies and vertebral bodies after compression fracture. OBJECTIVES To compare an injected, biodegradable calcium phosphate bone substitute with injected polymethylmethacrylate bone cement for strengthening osteoporotic vertebral bodies and improving the integrity of vertebral compression fractures. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA Injection of polymethylmethacrylate bone cement into fractured vertebral bodies has been used clinically. However, there is concern about thermal damage to the neural elements during polymerization of the polymethylmethacrylate bone cement as well as its negative effects on bone remodeling. Biodegradable calcium phosphate bone substitutes have been studied for enhancement of fixation in fractured vertebrae. METHODS Forty fresh osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebrae were used for two separate parts of this study: 1) injection into osteoporotic vertebrae: intact control (n = 8), calcium phosphate (n = 8), and polymethylmethacrylate bone cement (n = 8) groups. Each specimen then was loaded in anterior compression until failure; 2) injection into postfractured vertebrae: calcium phosphate (n = 8) and polymethylmethacrylate bone cement (n = 8) groups. Before and after injection, the specimens were radiographed in the lateral projection to determine changes in vertebral body height and then loaded to failure in anterior bending. RESULTS For intact osteoporotic vertebrae, the average fracture strength was 527 +/- 43 N (stiffness, 84 +/- 11 N/mm), 1063 +/- 127 N (stiffness, 157 +/- 21 N/mm) for the group injected with calcium phosphate, and 1036 +/- 100 N (stiffness, 156 +/- 8 N/mm) for the group injected with polymethylmethacrylate bone cement. The fracture strength and stiffness in the calcium phosphate bone substitute group and those in the polymethylmethacrylate bone cement group were similar and significantly stronger than those in intact control group (P < 0.05). For the compression fracture study, anterior vertebral height was increased 58.5 +/- 4.6% in the group injected with calcium phosphate and 58.0 +/- 6.5% in the group injected with polymethylmethacrylate bone cement as compared with preinjection fracture heights. No significant difference between the two groups was found in anterior vertebral height, fracture strength, or stiffness. CONCLUSION This study demonstrated that the injection of a biodegradable calcium phosphate bone substitute to strengthen osteoporotic vertebral bodies or improve vertebral compression fractures might provide an alternative to the use of polymethylmethacrylate bone cement.

A biomechanical evaluation of the Gamma nail

We examined the effect of the Gamma nail on strain distribution in the proximal femur, using ten cadaver femora instrumented with six unidirectional strain gauges along the medial and lateral cortices. The femora were loaded to 1800 N and strains were determined with or without distal interlocking screws before and after experimentally created two-part and four-part fractures. Motion of the sliding screw and the nail was also determined. Strain patterns and screw motion were compared with previously obtained values for a sliding hip screw device (SHS). The Gamma nail was shown to transmit decreasing load to the calcar with decreasing fracture stability, such that virtually no strain on the bone was seen in four-part fractures with the posteromedial fragment removed; increasing compression was noted, however, at the proximal lateral cortex. Conversely, the SHS showed increased calcar compression with decreasing fracture stability. The insertion of distal interlocking screws did not change the pattern of proximal femoral strain. The Gamma nail imparts non-physiological strains to the proximal femur, probably because of its inherent stiffness. These strains may alter bone remodelling and interfere with healing. Distal interlocking screws may not be necessary for stable intertrochanteric fractures.

The Effect of Acetabular Cup Orientations on Limiting Hip Rotation

The orientation of the acetabular cup and position of lip augmentation (if present) may improve postoperative total hip replacement stability by decreasing dislocation caused by hip prosthesis impingement during rotation. To determine how these cup parameters affect dislocation, the range and amount of rotation for two standard femoral components was determined in a Sawbones hemipelvis model. The parameters that allowed for maximal range of rotation were a cup angle of inclination between 35 degrees and 45 degrees and cup anteversion between 0 degrees and 10 degrees. Cup anteversion angles greater than 20 degrees and cup angles of inclination greater than 45 degrees significantly limited internal and external rotation, particularly for hip flexion greater than 60 degrees. The position of the cup lip augmentation did not affect the amount of rotation except when the hip was flexed and the lip superiorly oriented. Although there are currently devices to facilitate a particular cup position, hip stem type and orientation are other important factors affecting range of rotation that must be considered.

Distal femoral fixation: a biomechanical comparison of the standard condylar buttress plate, a locked buttress plate, and the 95-degree blade plate.

OBJECTIVES This biomechanical cadaver study was performed to compare the fixation stability of a standard lateral condylar buttress plate with a similar condylar buttress plate with the distal screws locked to the plate. Then the study was repeated with six additional matched femoral pairs to compare the locked plate with a standard 95-degree blade plate. DESIGN Six matched pairs of mildly osteopenic femurs were selected, and each side was assigned randomly to fixation with either a standard lateral condylar buttress plate or a modified lateral condylar buttress plate with locked distal screws. The experiment was repeated with six additional matched pairs of femurs instrumented with either a modified lateral condylar buttress plate with locked distal screws or a standard 95-degree blade plate. INTERVENTION The femurs were instrumented, and a gap osteotomy was created at the distal femoral metaphysis. The instrumented femurs were then mechanically tested in axial compression and bending/torsional loading to determine fixation stability; then they were loaded at 1,000 newtons for 10(5) cycles and retested for stability. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENT The displacement across the osteotomy gap at 100-newton and 1,000-newton axial loads was measured directly for each specimen before and after cycling. In addition, resistance to displacement in bending/torsional loading (newtons/centimeter) was determined from load/displacement curves, before and after cycling. RESULTS The locked buttress plate provided significantly greater fixation stability than the standard plate both before and after cycling in axial loading. The locked buttress plate also proved significantly more stable in axial loading than the blade plate both before and after cycling. CONCLUSION A condylar buttress plate with locked screws is a valid concept for improving fixation stability.

Kinematics of the first metatarsophalangeal joint.

The kinematics of both the first metatarsophalangeal joint and the articulation of the hallux sesamoid bones with the metatarsal head were investigated with fifteen fresh-frozen below-the-knee amputation specimens using a radiographic technique. Six feet were of normal structural anatomy, six displayed hallux valgus, and three had hallux rigidus. Normal specimens demonstrated an average total range of motion in the sagittal plane of 111 degrees, with about 76 degrees of dorsiflexion and 34 degrees of plantar flexion. The abnormal specimens revealed a decreased total arc of motion, with a limitation of plantar flexion in feet with hallux valgus and a loss of dorsiflexion in feet with hallux rigidus. Motion analysis of the normal metatarsophalangeal joints demonstrated minimum scattering of instant centers of rotation. This was in contrast to the diseased articulations, which displayed markedly displaced instant centers of rotation located eccentrically about the metatarsal head. Surface motion in the normal joints was characterized as tangential sliding from maximum plantar flexion to moderate dorsiflexion, with some compression at maximum dorsiflexion. The feet with hallux valgus and the feet with hallux rigidus displayed distinctive patterns of distraction and jamming throughout specific portions of the range of motion in the sagittal plane. Motion of the metatarsophalangeal joint in the transverse plane concomitant with motion in the sagittal plane, which has been hypothesized by other investigators, was confirmed and quantified in this study. The feet with hallux rigidus displayed a reduction in this motion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The influence of coracoacromial arch anatomy on rotator cuff tears

We performed an anatomic study of 140 cadaver shoulders to correlate the influence of the coracoacromial arch anatomy on full-thickness rotator cuff tears (RCTs). The presence, location, and size of RCTs were initially documented. After dissection was complete 14 dimensional parameters, including humeral head size, glenoid size, and location of bony landmarks, were obtained by direct measurement. These data were entered into a computerized data base and 24 additional parameters (lengths, angles, areas) were calculated. The data were then subjected to analysis of variance and paired and unpaired t tests to determine correlation between the multiple parameters, age, sex, and left-to-right variance with RCTs. Three-dimensional computer modeling was then used to investigate the role of humeral head position in defining the available space within the coracoacromial arch (supraspinatus outlet). Overall 20% of the cadaver group exhibited full-thickness RCTs. The age group 60 years and older had a 29% incidence of RCTs compared with 5% in the group less than 60 years of age. The RCT group had a significantly greater anterior projection of the acromion than had the intact group (difference = 3.8 mm, p < 0.007). Acromial tilt was 28.5° in the RCT group and 33.5° in the intact group (p < 0.007). The supraspinatus outlet area was calculated by determining the total coracoacromial arch area and subtracting the area of the humeral head within the coracoacromial arch. The supraspinatus outlet was 22.5% smaller in the RCT group (p < 0.07). By using a series of measured and calculated parameters, we were able to characterize the anatomy of the coracoacromial arch and its relationship with the humeral head and to correlate variations in structure with the presence of RCTs. These findings may aid in our understanding of outlet impingement as a factor in the cause of RCTs.

Surgical neck fractures of the proximal humerus : A laboratory evaluation of ten fixation techniques

OBJECTIVE A biomechanical cadaver study was performed to compare the stability and ultimate strength of ten standard fixation techniques used for the treatment of surgical neck fractures of the proximal humerus. DESIGN One hundred twenty (60 fresh frozen, 60 embalmed) proximal humerus specimens were selected and divided into two groups: fresh frozen specimens represented a nonosteopenic group and embalmed specimens an osteopenic group. Simulated fractures were created at the level of the surgical neck, reduced, and randomly assigned to one of ten methods of fixation (six fresh frozen and six embalmed specimens per fixation group). These constructs were then mechanically tested with the humeri oriented to create primarily shear loading of the fixation. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS The T-plate and screws provided significantly stronger fixation (p < 0.005) in the fresh frozen specimens than all other methods. The Ender nails/tension band construct was the second strongest fixation technique, providing significantly stronger fixation (p < 0.01) than all the remaining techniques. Four Schanz pins with one pin placed through the greater tuberosity followed by the T-plate and screws provided the strongest fixation in embalmed specimens. Tension band fixation in both humeral groups was shown to provide the least effective fixation.

Vascular Anatomy of the Fifth Metatarsal

The extraosseous and intraosseous vascular anatomy to the fifth metatarsal as visualized in a group of below-the- knee amputation specimens has been described. The extrinsic circulation to the area is provided by the dorsal metatarsal artery, the plantar metatarsal arteries, and the fibular plantar marginal artery. These three source arteries supply branches to the metatarsal and adjacent joints. The intraosseous vascularity consists of a periosteal plexus, a nutrient artery, and a system of metaphyseal and capital vessels.

Stress Fractures of the Femoral Neck

Stress fractures of the femoral neck are uncommon injuries. In general these injuries are seen in two distinct populations: (1) young, healthy, active individuals such as recreational runners, endurance athletes, or military recruits; and (2) the elderly who have osteoporosis. Stress fractures can be classified as either fatigue or insufficiency fractures and result from untoward cyclic loading or impaired bone quality. The key to treatment is early diagnosis, which may require scintigraphy or magnetic resonance imaging. Nondisplaced compression type stress fractures can be treated nonoperatively with protected weight-bearing and frequent radiographic followup. Tension type stress fractures should be stabilized internally to prevent the adverse consequences of fracture displacement.