G. Bryden

Debris Disk Evolution Around A Stars

We report 24 and/or 70 μm measurements of ~160 A-type main-sequence stars using the Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer (MIPS). Their ages range from 5 to 850 Myr, based on estimates from the literature (cluster or moving group associations) or from the H-R diagram and isochrones. The thermal infrared excess is identified by comparing the deviation (~3% and ~15% at the 1 σ level at 24 and 70 μm, respectively) between the measurements and the synthetic Kurucz photospheric predictions. Stars showing excess infrared emission due to strong emission lines or extended nebulosity seen at 24 μm are excluded from our sample; therefore, the remaining infrared excesses are likely to arise from circumstellar debris disks. At the 3 σ confidence level, the excess rate at 24 and 70 μm is 32% and ≥33% (with an uncertainty of 5%), considerably higher than what has been found for old solar analogs and M dwarfs. Our measurements place constraints on the fractional dust luminosities and temperatures in the disks. We find that older stars tend to have lower fractional dust luminosity than younger ones. While the fractional luminosity from the excess infrared emission follows a general 1/t relationship, the values at a given stellar age vary by at least 2 orders of magnitude. We also find that (1) older stars possess a narrow range of temperature distribution peaking at colder temperatures, and (2) the disk emission at 70 μm persists longer than that at 24 μm. Both results suggest that the debris disk clearing process is more effective in the inner regions.

Decay of Planetary Debris Disks

We report new Spitzer 24 � m photometry of 76 main-sequence A-type stars. We combine these results with previously reportedSpitzer24 � m data and 24 and 25 � m photometry from theInfrared Space Observatoryand the InfraredAstronomySatellite.Theresultisasampleof266starswithmasscloseto2.5M� ,alldetectedtoatleastthe � 7 � level relative to their photospheric emission. We culled ages for the entire sample from the literature and/or estimated them using the H-R diagram and isochrones; they range from 5 to 850 Myr. We identified excess thermal emission using an internally derived K � 24 (or 25) � m photospheric color and then compared all stars in the sample tothatcolor.Becausewehaveexcludedstarswithstrongemissionlinesorextendedemission(associatedwithnearby interstellar gas), these excesses are likely to be generated by debris disks. Younger stars in the sample exhibit excess thermal emissionmore frequently andwithhigher fractional excess thandothe olderstars. However,asmanyas 50% oftheyoungerstarsdonotshowexcessemission.Thedeclineinthemagnitudeofexcessemission,forthosestarsthat show it, has a roughly t0/time dependence, with t0 � 150 Myr. If anything, stars in binary systems (including Algoltype stars) and k Boo stars show less excess emission than the other members of the sample. Our results indicate that (1) there is substantial variety among debris disks, including that a significant number of stars emerge from the protoplanetary stage of evolution with little remaining disk in the 10‐60 AU region and (2) in addition, it is likely that much of the dust we detect is generated episodically by collisions of large planetesimals during the planet accretion endgame,andthatindividualeventsoftendominatetheradiometricpropertiesofadebrissystem.Thislatterbehavior agrees generally withwhat weknowabouttheevolution of thesolar system, andalsowiththeoretical models ofplanetary system formation. Subject headingg circumstellar matter — infrared: stars — planetary systems: formation Online material: machine-readable table

FREQUENCY OF DEBRIS DISKS AROUND SOLAR-TYPE STARS: FIRST RESULTS FROM A SPITZER MIPS SURVEY

We have searched for infrared excesses around a well-defined sample of 69 FGK main-sequence field stars. These starswereselectedwithoutregardto theirage,metallicity,oranypreviousdetectionof IRexcess; they have amedian ageof � 4Gyr.Wehavedetected70 � mexcessesaroundsevenstarsatthe3 � confidencelevel.Thisextraemissionis produced by cool material (<100 K) located beyond 10 AU, well outside the ‘‘habitable zones’’ of these systems and consistent with the presence of Kuiper Belt analogs with � 100 times more emitting surface area than in our own planetary system. Only one star, HD 69830, shows excess emission at 24 � m, corresponding to dust with temperaturesk300Klocatedinsideof1AU.WhiledebrisdiskswithLdust/L? � 10 � 3 arerarearoundoldFGKstars,wefind that thediskfrequencyincreasesfrom2% � 2%forLdust/L? � 10 � 4 to12% � 5%forLdust/L? � 10 � 5 .Thistrendin the disk luminosity distribution is consistent with the estimated dust in our solar system being within an order of magnitude greater or less than the typical level around similar nearby stars. Although there is no correlation of IR excesswithmetallicity orspectraltype,there isaweak correlationwithstellarage,withstarsyoungerthanagigayear more likely to have excess emission.

Transience of Hot Dust around Sun-like Stars

In this paper a simple model for the steady state evolution of debris disks due to collisions is developed and confronted with the properties of the emerging population of seven Sun-like stars that have hot dust at 10 AU (η Corvi and HD 72905); one has three Neptune mass planets at <1 AU (HD 69830); all exhibit strong mid-IR silicate features. We consider the most likely origin for this transient dust to be a dynamical instability that scattered planetesimals inward from a more distant planetesimal belt in an event akin to the late heavy bombardment in our own system, the dust being released from such planetesimals in collisions and sublimation.

Debris disks around Sun-like stars

We have observed nearly 200 FGK stars at 24 and 70 ?m with the Spitzer Space Telescope. We identify excess infrared emission, including a number of cases where the observed flux is more than 10 times brighter than the predicted photospheric flux, and interpret these signatures as evidence of debris disks in those systems. We combine this sample of FGK stars with similar published results to produce a sample of more than 350 main sequence AFGKM stars. The incidence of debris disks is -->4.2+ 2.0?1.1% at 24 ?m for a sample of 213 Sun-like (FG) stars and -->16.4+ 2.8?2.9% at 70 ?m for 225 Sun-like (FG) stars. We find that the excess rates for A, F, G, and K stars are statistically indistinguishable, but with a suggestion of decreasing excess rate toward the later spectral types; this may be an age effect. The lack of strong trend among FGK stars of comparable ages is surprising, given the factor of 50 change in stellar luminosity across this spectral range. We also find that the incidence of debris disks declines very slowly beyond ages of 1 billion years.

Steady-state evolution of debris disks around A stars

In this paper a simple analytical model for the steady-state evolution of debris disks due to collisions is confronted with Spitzer observations of dust around main sequence A stars. All stars are assumed to have planetesimal belts with a distribution of initial masses and radii. In the model disk mass is constant until the largest planetesimals reach collisional equilibrium whereupon the mass falls off ∝ t −1 age. Using parameters that are reasonable within the context of planet formation models and observations of proto-planetary disks, the detection statistics and trends seen at both 24 and 70 µm can be fitted well by the model. While there is no need to invoke stochastic evolution or delayed stirring to explain the detection statistics of dust around A stars, the model is also consistent with a moderate rate of stochastic events. Potentially anomalous systems are identified by their high ratio of observed dust luminosity to the maximum permissible in the model given their radii and ages, f/fmax; these are HD3003, HD38678, HD115892, and HD172555. It is not clear if their planetesimals have unusual properties (e.g., high strength or low eccentricity), or if their dust is a transient phenomenon. There are also well-studied examples from the literature where transient phenomena are favored (e.g., Vega, HD69830). However, the overall success of our model, which assumes planetesimals in all belts have the same strength, eccentricity and maximum size, suggests there is a large degree of uniformity in the outcome of planet formation. The distribution of the radii of the planetesimal belts, once corrected for detection bias, is found to follow N(r) ∝ r −0.8±0.3 in the range 3-120 AU. Since the inner edge of a belt is often attributed to an unseen planet, this provides a unique constraint on the planetary systems of A stars. It is also shown that the effect of P-R drag on the inner edge of A star disks may need to be considered for those close to the Spitzer detection threshold, such as HD2262, HD19356, HD106591, and HD115892. Predictions are made for the upcoming SCUBA-2 survey, including that at least 17 of the 100 A stars should be detectable above 2 mJy at 850 µm, illustrating how this model can be readily applied to the interpretation of future surveys. Subject headings: circumstellar matter – planetary systems: formation

The Debris Disk Around HR 8799

We have obtained a full suite of Spitzer observations to characterize the debris disk around HR 8799 and to explore how its properties are related to the recently discovered set of three massive planets orbiting the star. We distinguish three components to the debris system: (1) warm dust (T ~150 K) orbiting within the innermost planet; (2) a broad zone of cold dust (T ~45 K) with a sharp inner edge, orbiting just outside the outermost planet and presumably sculpted by it; and (3) a dramatic halo of small grains originating in the cold dust component. The high level of dynamical activity implied by this halo may arise due to enhanced gravitational stirring by the massive planets. The relatively young age of HR 8799 places it in an important early stage of development and may provide some help in understanding the interaction of planets and planetary debris, an important process in the evolution of our own solar system.

AN EXCESS DUE TO SMALL GRAINS AROUND THE NEARBY K0 V STAR HD 69830: ASTEROID OR COMETARY DEBRIS?

Spitzer photometry and spectroscopy of the star HD 69830 reveal an excess of emission relative to the stellar photosphere between 8 and 35 � m dominated by strong features attributable to crystalline silicates with an emitting surface area more than 1000 times that of our zodiacal cloud. The spectrum closely resembles that of the comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp). Since no excess is detected at 70 � m, the emitting material must be quite warm, be confined within a few AU of the star, and originate in grains with low, long-wavelength emissivity, i.e., grains much smallerthan70 � m/2� � 10 � m.Thestrongmineralogicalfeaturesareevidenceforevensmaller,possiblysubmicronsized grains. This small grain size is in direct contrast to the 10‐100 � m grains that dominate the relatively featureless spectra of our zodiacal dust cloud and most other main-sequence stars with excesses. The upper limit at 70 � ma lso implies that any Kuiper Belt analog must be either very cold or less massive than � 5 times our own Kuiper Belt. WithcollisionalandPoynting-Robertsondragtimesoflessthan1000yrforsmallgrains,theemittingmaterialmust either (1) be created through continual grinding down of material in a dense asteroid belt, or (2) originate in cometary debris arising from either a single ‘‘supercomet’’ or a very large number of individual comets arriving from a distant reservoir. In the case of a cometary origin for the emission, the mass requirements for continuous generation by many individual comets are unreasonable, and we favor the capture of a single super comet into a 0.5‐1 AU orbit, where it can evolve a large number of small grains over a 2 Myr period.

New Debris Disks Around Nearby Main Sequence Stars: Impact on The Direct Detection of Planets

Using the MIPS instrument on Spitzer, we have searched for infrared excesses around a sample of 82 stars, mostly F, G, and K main-sequence field stars, along with a small number of nearby M stars. These stars were selected for their suitability for future observations by a variety of planet-finding techniques. These observations provide information on the asteroidal and cometary material orbiting these stars, data that can be correlated with any planets that may eventually be found. We have found significant excess 70 μm emission toward 12 stars. Combined with an earlier study, we find an overall 70 μm excess detection rate of 13% ± 3% for mature cool stars. Unlike the trend for planets to be found preferentially toward stars with high metallicity, the incidence of debris disks is uncorrelated with metallicity. By newly identifying four of these stars as having weak 24 μm excesses (fluxes ~10% above the stellar photosphere), we confirm a trend found in earlier studies wherein a weak 24 μm excess is associated with a strong 70 μm excess. Interestingly, we find no evidence for debris disks around 23 stars cooler than K1, a result that is bolstered by a lack of excess around any of the 38 K1-M6 stars in two companion surveys. One motivation for this study is the fact that strong zodiacal emission can make it hard or impossible to detect planets directly with future observatories such as the Terrestrial Planet Finder (TPF). The observations reported here exclude a few stars with very high levels of emission, >1000 times the emission of our zodiacal cloud, from direct planet searches. For the remainder of the sample, we set relatively high limits on dust emission from asteroid belt counterparts.

Debris Disks in Main-Sequence Binary Systems

We observed 69 A3-F8 main-sequence binary star systems using the Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer on board the Spitzer Space Telescope. We find emission significantly in excess of predicted photospheric flux levels for 9 % and 40 % of these systems at 24 and 70 μm, respectively. Twenty-two systems total have excess emission, including four systems that show excess emission at both wavelengths. A very large fraction (nearly 60%) of observed binary systems with small (<3 AU) separations have excess thermal emission. We interpret the observed infrared excesses as thermal emission from dust produced by collisions in planetesimal belts. The incidence of debris disks around main-sequence A3-F8 binaries is marginally higher than that for single old AFGK stars. Whatever combination of nature (birth conditions of binary systems) and nurture (interactions between the two stars) drives the evolution of debris disks in binary systems, it is clear that planetesimal formation is not inhibited to any great degree. We model these dust disks through fitting the spectral energy distributions and derive typical dust temperatures in the range 100-200 K and typical fractional luminosities around 10-5, with both parameters similar to other Spitzer-discovered debris disks. Our calculated dust temperatures suggest that about half the excesses we observe are derived from circumbinary planetesimal belts and around one-third of the excesses clearly suggest circumstellar material. Three systems with excesses have dust in dynamically unstable regions, and we discuss possible scenarios for the origin of this short-lived dust.