G.C.H. Sanderink

Accuracy of three-dimensional measurements obtained from cone beam computed tomography surface-rendered images for cephalometric analysis: influence of patient scanning position.

The aims of this study were to assess the accuracy of linear measurements on three-dimensional (3D) surface-rendered images generated from cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) in comparison with two-dimensional (2D) slices and 2D lateral and postero-anterior (PA) cephalometric projections, and to investigate the influence of patient head position in the scanner on measurement accuracy. Eight dry human skulls were scanned twice using NewTom 3G CBCT in an ideal and a rotated position and the resulting datasets were used to create 3D surface-rendered images, 2D tomographic slices, and 2D lateral and PA projections. Ten linear distances were defined for cephalometric measurements. The physical and radiographic measurements were repeated twice by three independent observers and were compared using repeated measures analysis of variance (P=0.05). The radiographic measurements were also compared between the ideal and the rotated scan positions. The radiographic measurements of the 3D images were closer to the physical measurements than the 2D slices and 2D projection images. No statistically significant difference was found between the ideal and the rotated scan measurements for the 3D images and the 2D tomographic slices. A statistically significant difference (P<0.001) was observed between the ideal and rotated scan positions for the 2D projection images. The findings indicate that measurements based on 3D CBCT surface images are accurate and that small variations in the patients head position do not influence measurement accuracy.

Efficacy of digital intra-oral radiography in clinical dentistry

OBJECTIVES This article emphasizes the comparison of intra-oral digital imaging to film-based imaging. Additional possibilities of digital imaging that may contribute to system efficacy are discussed as well. STUDY SELECTION The main subjects for research in digital imaging are image quality, image acquisition, diagnostic quality, image manipulation, automated analysis, and application software. DATA SOURCES Representative articles on these subjects from the international literature are used for this review. Indirect digital imaging still requires film processing, sophisticated film digitizers, and time to digitize film. Although it is not an efficient method for the dental practice, digitization can be very useful for quantitative analysis of radiographs. Direct digital imaging is more efficient than indirect digital imaging. The main advantages are (semi) real time imaging, low X-ray dose requirements, and no need for chemical processing. In spite of a more limited resolution of the images, direct imaging may perform as accurately as film-based imaging. Direct image plate systems can well be used, for instance, for full-mouth series. The main application of direct sensor systems appears to be endodontology and implantology. In summary, direct digital imaging may be as efficient as film-based imaging in clinical dentistry. The computer provides for many additional options in digital imaging, such as the digital storage, compression, and exchange of radiographic information. Image manipulation (e.g. image enhancement, subtraction radiography and image reconstruction) and automated analysis may benefit radiodiagnosis. CONCLUSION It can be concluded that digital imaging certainly has great potential, especially with respect to improvement of diagnostic quality and automated image analysis.

Image quality of direct digital intraoral x-ray sensors in assessing root canal length: The RadioVisioGraphy, Visualix/VIXA, Sens-A-Ray, and Flash Dent systems compared with Ektaspeed films

The Trophy RadioVisioGraphy model 32000 system in Normal Mode, the Trophy RVG-PC in Normal and Archive Mode, the Gendex VIXA/Visualix, the Regam Sens-A-Ray, and the Villa Flash Dent in High-Resolution Mode and Normal Mode were compared with respect to the visibility of endodontic files. Kodak Ektaspeed film served as the reference. An acrylic embedded human skull was prepared for taking radiographs with endodontic files (Kerr files size 10 and size 15) on full root length and 1.5 mm short in upper and lower premolars and molars. Possibilities for enhancement of the digital images were not studied. Receiver operating characteristics curves were derived and the areas under the curves were averaged and compared using Students t test statistic (p < 0.05). Kodak Ektaspeed film gave acceptable results for both file sizes. Both Trophy RVG units in Normal Mode and the Regam Sens-A-Ray system gave results above the areas under the curves equals 0.95 for the size 15 files. For the size 10 files the values of the areas under the curves of all sensors systems were below this threshold. It is concluded that both RVG units in Normal Mode and the Sens-A-Ray system render a comparable result with conventional radiography in determining root canal length with the use of a size 15 files. All sensor systems were unacceptably inferior to film images when size 10 files were used.

Dose reduction of two digital sensor systems measuring file lengths

OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to determine the effect of dose reduction on the image quality of two sensor systems with automatic greyscale adjustment. STUDY DESIGN Two digital sensor systems, Sidexis (Siemens, Bensheim, Germany) and Digora (Soredex, Helsinki, Finland), were tested. The image quality of the systems was determined by comparing lengths of endodontic files (025, 020, 015, and 010 files) and a premolar root in the digital images with lengths on conventional radiographic films. For the experiments the exposure was changed to 100%, 50%, 25%, 12.5%, 6.25%, and 3.125% of that for Ektaspeed films. RESULTS The lengths of 025 and 020 files and the premolar root in the digital images were comparable with the lengths on films even if the exposure was reduced to 6% of that used for Ektaspeed films. The lengths of 015 files reduced as the exposure was reduced. The lengths of 010 files were significantly shorter than the lengths on films. CONCLUSIONS With the systems tested, a dose reduction of approximately 95% compared with Ektaspeed films is possible to determine the lengths of a premolar root and 025 and 020 files. For thinner objects a dose reduction is questionable.

In vivo study of approximal caries depth on storage phosphor plate images compared with dental x-ray film

The aim of this in vivo study was to compare approximal caries depth on storage phosphor plate images to conventional film. A Soredex Digora imaging plate was placed in a film bite-wing positioner behind a Kodak Ektaspeed Plus film package without lead foil. The effect of scattered radiation on film without lead foil with a storage phosphor plate at the back was studied in a separate in vitro experiment. Compared with film protected by lead foil, the film showed higher density, but comparable contrast. For the in vivo study, clinical bite-wing exposures were made with the setup described above, with exposure settings for Ektaspeed Plus film. A four-point scale was chosen for approximal caries depth: 0 = no caries; 1 = caries in enamel; 2 = caries reaching dentino-enamel junction; 3 = caries into dentin. The bite-wing film images were shown to a panel of four experts. Sixty surfaces were selected for observer performance, based on identical scorings of the experts consensus classification. Next, six dentists evaluated both film and storage phosphor plate images with the same four point scale. Analysis of variance revealed a significant observer and image modality effect without an interaction effect. In conclusion, caries depth on storage phosphor plate images was underestimated compared with film-based images.

Effects of dose reduction on the detectability of standardized radiolucent lesions in digital panoramic radiography

Dose reduction in digital panoramic radiography was studied. Intentional underexposure was performed with the Orthophos DS while six different human mandibles were radiographed. Exposure settings were 69 kV/15 mA (standard), 64 kV/16 mA, and 60 kV/16 mA. Standardized spherical defects, each either 1 or 1.25 mm in diameter, were simulated in 288 of 432 images, and seven observers decided whether defects were present or not. Areas under the receiver operating characteristics curves were calculated. They showed no significant differences in the detectability of the 1-mm defect at 69, 64, or 60 kV. For the 1.25-mm defect, no difference was found between the 69 and 60 kV images, but a statistically significant different detectability was found for 64 kV images in comparison with both 69 and 60 kV images. A dose reduction of up to 43% was ascertained with a Pedo-RT-Humanoid phantom when panoramic radiography was performed at 60 kV/16 mA. The conclusion is that with the Orthophos DS, it seems possible to reduce the dose rate of x-rays without loss of diagnostic quality in the case of radiolucent changes.

Detection of in vitro proximal caries in storage phosphor plate radiographs scanned with different resolutions

OBJECTIVES To investigate the effect of the scanning resolution of storage phosphor plate (SPP) radiographs on the detection of proximal caries lesions. METHODS 10 dentists evaluated 72 proximal surfaces of premolars with respect to caries from SPP radiographs scanned with theoretical spatial resolutions of: (1) the Digora FMX at 7.8 lp mm(-1); (2) the Digora Optime at both 7.8 lp mm(-1) and 12.5 lp mm(-1); and (3) the Dürr VistaScan at 10 lp mm(-1) and 20 lp mm(-1), respectively. The lesions were validated by histological examination. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was employed. RESULTS The A(z) value for the radiographs scanned with the Dürr VistaScan at 10 lp mm(-1) is significantly lower than those for the other series of radiographs (P = 0.000). CONCLUSIONS For SPP radiographs, an increased theoretical spatial resolution per se is not related to an improved detection of proximal caries.

Detection of Proximal Caries in vitro Using Standard and Task-Specific Enhanced Images from a Storage Phosphor Plate System

Eight dentists evaluated 72 proximal surfaces of premolars with respect to all caries lesions and to lesions into dentine in digital images from a storage phosphor plate system. The images were processed in four different ways: (1) the default algorithm of the standard imaging system (DF); (2) an algorithm correcting for attenuation and visual response (AV), and two proprietary caries-specific enhancement algorithms (3) K1, and (4) K2, respectively. The lesions were validated by histological examination. There were no significant differences in the areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves between differently processed radiographs for the categories of all caries lesions and caries into dentine.

The value of thyroid shielding in intraoral radiography.

OBJECTIVES To evaluate the utility of the application of a thyroid shield in intraoral radiography when using rectangular collimation. METHODS Experimental data were obtained by measuring the absorbed dose at the position of the thyroid gland in a RANDO(®) (The Phantom Laboratory, Salem, NY) male phantom with a dosemeter. Four protocols were tested: round collimation and rectangular collimation, both with and without thyroid shield. Five exposure positions were deployed: upper incisor (Isup), upper canine (Csup), upper premolar (Psup), upper molar (Msup) and posterior bitewing (BW). Exposures were made with 70 kV and 7 mA and were repeated 10 times. The exposure times were as recommended for the exposure positions for the respective collimator type by the manufacturer for digital imaging. The data were statistically analyzed with a three-way ANOVA test. Significance was set at p < 0.01. RESULTS The ANOVA test revealed that the differences between mean doses of all protocols and geometries were statistically significant, p < 0.001. For the Isup, thyroid dose levels were comparable with both collimators at a level indicating primary beam exposure. Thyroid shield reduced this dose with circa 75%. For the Csup position, round collimation also revealed primary beam exposure, and thyroid shield yield was 70%. In Csup with rectangular collimation, the thyroid dose was reduced with a factor 4 compared with round collimation and thyroid shield yielded an additional 42% dose reduction. The thyroid dose levels for the Csup, Psup, Msup and BW exposures were lower with rectangular collimation without thyroid shield than with round collimation with thyroid shield. With rectangular collimation, the thyroid shield in Psup, Msup and BW reduced the dose 10% or less, where dose levels were already low, implying no clinical significance. CONCLUSIONS For the exposures in the upper anterior region, thyroid shield results in an important dose reduction for the thyroid. For the other exposures, thyroid shield augments little to the reduction achieved by rectangular collimation. The use of thyroid shield is to be advised, when performing upper anterior radiography.

DIMITRA pediatric skull phantoms: development of age-specific pediatric models for dentomaxillofacial radiology research

OBJECTIVES This report aims to describe the development of age-specific phantoms for use in paediatric dentomaxillofacial radiology research. These phantoms are denoted DIMITRA paediatric skull phantoms as these have been primarily developed and validated for the DIMITRA European research project (Dentomaxillofacial paediatric imaging: an investigation towards low-dose radiation induced risks). METHODS To create the DIMITRA paediatric phantoms, six human paediatric skulls with estimated ages ranging between 4 and 10 years- old were selected, protected with non-radiopaque tape and immersed in melted Mix-D soft tissue equivalent material, by means of a careful procedure (layer-by-layer). Mandibles were immersed separately and a Mix-D tongue model was also created. For validation purposes, the resulting paediatric phantoms were scanned using a cone-beam CT unit with different exposure parameter settings. RESULTS Preliminary images deriving from all scans were evaluated by two dentomaxillofacial radiologists, to check for air bubbles, artefacts and inhomogeneities of the Mix-D and a potential effect on the visualization of the jaw bone. Only skulls presenting perfect alignment of Mix-D surrounding the bone surfaces with adequate and realistic soft tissue thickness density were accepted. CONCLUSIONS The DIMITRA anthropomorphic phantoms can yield clinically equivalent images for optimization studies in dentomaxillofacial research. In addition, the layer-by-layer technique proved to be practical and reproducible, as long as recommendations are carefully followed.